Assimilation: The Drawbacks Of Cross Cultural Misunderstandings

1575 words - 6 pages

The author of the book, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures, Anne Fadiman exhibits a story about the collision between two cultures and the way things affected the character’s lives. The main character, Lia, is found grasped in a dilemma within her family’s culture and the American lifestyle. Since a baby, Lia suffered form epileptic seizures, which were viewed as a positive trait for the Hmong community; those people who suffered from seizures were credited to be a twix neeb, in other words, “a person with healing spirit” (Fadiman 21). Lia’s parents Mr. and Mrs. Lee, were having a difficult time comprehending the seriousness of the epilepsies that Lia was suffering from. Her parents had never been exposed to Western medication; therefore, it was very difficult for them to understand the procedures that needed to be completed in order to save Lia’s life. Fadiman enhances her opinion in regards to the situation by stating, “I have come to believe that her [Lia’s] life was ruined by not septic shock or noncompliant parents but by cross-cultural misunderstanding.” Cross-cultural misunderstanding is indeed; the main cause for unsettled immigrant lives in new countries, such as Lia’s family. In order to enhance a successful life at a new country, the Lees needed to adapt and understand American culture into their own lives.
Adaptation is very important when trying to pursue a new living with new set of customs and beliefs. The Lee family formally arrived to America after being persecuted at their native country Laos. Living in America as refugees was not their personal decision, but was necessary in order to escape the war occurring at their native home and survive. Once living in America, the Lees were faced with a serious of cultural challenges. The language barrier and cultural customs, such as medication and technology, were two of the main obstacles that the Lee family faced. According to Derrick Jersen, an environmental activist, “if the culture moves, it must adapt itself to the will of the locality, or it will consume the locality and the locality will die, on a finite planet, that the culture will die as well” (334). Conforming to Jersen’s view, the Lee family needed to adapt to the American culture in order to maintain their values and beliefs intact. Adaptation was the most difficult thing the Lee family had to do. The Hmong background made them believe in a certain way, for example they only trusted spiritual healing, and their lifestyles were very different than the mainstream Americans. In order to adapt, the Lees would have had to first learn and speak the English language, which they were not familiar with. Unfortunately, the language barrier was one of the most imperative aspects that the Lees had to cope with. During the unfortunate times in which Lia began to suffer from seizures caused by her epilepsy, there were major misunderstandings with the doctors...

Find Another Essay On Assimilation: The Drawbacks of Cross-Cultural Misunderstandings

Determinants of Polygyny: A Cross-Cultural Analysis

2106 words - 8 pages Polygyny is a topic that existed in a great amoung of societies that are being investigated by anthropologist. In the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample (SCCS), 83.8% of societies are socially polygynous; 28% are coded as more than 40% of marriages being polygynous. However, the proportion of polygynous marriage could be small, especially in hunter-gatherer or foraging societies where people gather resources or wealth through collecting and

A cross-cultural comparison of political attack ads in Brazil and the United States.

3206 words - 13 pages A cross-cultural comparison of political attack ads in Brazil and the United States.A Brief History of Political Advertising in BrazilDuring Getulio Vargas administration, in the 1940s, Brazil saw the dawn of political marketing. His title "father of the poor" seemed to be more in the minds of the masses than their own lives. Much of his popularity came from a radio broadcast he hosted, where he addressed to "the common people". However, It was

Critique of the Theory of Assimilation

1523 words - 6 pages The scholars of the Chicago School of Sociology have presented a theory of assimilation that generally states that people of different cultures and ethnicities that come into the United States (also applies to other countries as well) will have contact with American culture which will generate conflict. These people of a different culture or ethnicity will eventually acculturate and integrate into a so called “Melting Pot” of culture in which

Relativistic Doppler Effect and the Misunderstandings of Special Theory of Relativity

998 words - 4 pages The present paper discusses the relativistic Doppler effect and tries to found misunderstandings in the present state of the Special theory of relativity. The author's conclusion that he found some “blue shift” which contradicts with time dilation is wrong. The weakest feature of the paper is that although the formulas, presented by authors, are in general correct, but they do not support the conclusions the author extract from them, and mistake

Language Choice Patterns of Young Cross-Cultural Couples

1208 words - 5 pages SUMMARY Development of transport and communications contributed to intensification of the contacts of all kind among the members of different cultures. Raising numbers of cross-cultural relationships is one of the consequences of this internationalization of life. The communication of cross-cultural couples is important for both scientific and societal reasons. The research on this kind of unions could contribute to the knowledge about the

Cross-Cultural Difference netween the United States and China

1552 words - 7 pages Task 4 A.  Cross-cultural differences between United States and China Cross-cultural differences in verbal and non-verbal communication styles The issue of verbal and non-verbal communication styles is an important cross-cultural difference to consider when seeking expansion of business in China, because it can help Company ABC facilitate successful business transactions and outperform its competitors. According to a survey by the Economist

Interracial and Cross Cultural Dating of Generation Y

2836 words - 11 pages Interracial and Cross Cultural Dating of Generation Y Interracial romance has been an issue in the United States since the first English settlers established colonies during the seventeenth century. Over the years, views toward interracial relationships in America have changed greatly. The interracial dating trend among today’s teenagers is increasing at a steady rate (Grapes 49). However, there are still many biases facing Gen-Y youth

The Eight Questions' Potential to Help Bridge Cross-Cultural Barriers

654 words - 3 pages Due to such challenges, some people have sought to provide cross-cultural solutions. One such person is Arthur Kleinman, a medical anthropologist, psychiatrist, and chair of the department of social medicine at Harvard Medical School who developed a set of eight questions that were “designed to elicit a patient’s ‘explanatory model’” (260). In other words, the Eight Questions are a set of questions to ask a patient and/or the patient’s family

Cross Cultural Exchanges on the Silk Road Networks

1996 words - 8 pages urban areas. A key component behind the development of the Silk Road is cross-cultural trade. Sea trade was linked from the Mediterranean, Black Sea, Persian Gulf and the Red Sea. The Monsoon system enabled sailors to know where the wind blows in the summer and in the winter. Religions such as Buddhism and Hinduism traveled throughout the silk roads. “The Chinese empire had extended its frontier into central Asia during the 1st century BC and

Violence Against the Elderly: a cross-cultural perspective

2262 words - 9 pages unconscious. She was taken to the hospital where she is still in critical condition. Police said that this is one of the worst cases of elder abuse that they have ever seen. From a cultural point of view, there are many Canadian immigrant victims who do not know what elder abuse is or have not reported it because they were ashamed or threatened. Cleaning the house, babysitting, obeying orders, being forced to give money away are some of these

Multi-culture Complications; Please write a 2-3 page paper identifying some of these "cultural mistakes" from the first article listed below ("The pitfalls of cross-cultural business").

983 words - 4 pages . Cultural differences can cause business plans to fold and could cost the company millions, if not more. Etiquette, manners, and cross cultural, or intercultural communication have become essential for all International and Global Businesses. As global business continues to expand, bringing people closer, the most important part of successful business may be the appreciation and respect for cultural differences. The use of cross cultural

Similar Essays

The Drawbacks Of Freedom Essay

1093 words - 4 pages The United States constitution grants many freedoms with minimal to no restrictions, which can be considered beneficial to the public. In “we are free to be you, me, stupid, and dead” by Roger Rosenblatt, he relays the disadvantages of limitless freedom. He focuses mainly on freedom of speech and the possible drawbacks to having ungoverned freedom of expression. Roger points out the public faulty rationale in the first paragraph as he says

Infanticide: Cross Cultural Analysis Of The Causes Of Infanticide

2359 words - 9 pages categories: biological (including the health of the child and twin stigmas), economical (relation to other children, women's workload, and available resources) and cultural (preferred gender, illegitimate children). This essay will examine cross-culturally the biological, economic and cultural factors for infanticide. Biological reasons for infanticide are prevalent especially in countries that lack full medical or prenatal care. Prenatal care often

Cross Cultural Connection Of The East And West

2016 words - 8 pages much of the 16th and 17th centuries, much of the West had an intense drive for exploring and dominating foreign worlds. Explorers such as Ferdinand Magellan and Francesco Carletti, dominate history as some of the first people to circumnavigate the globe in an effort to further exploration of the new world. When the East and the West met it was a collision of vastly different cultures that would eventually combine in forms of cross-cultural

A Study Of Cross Cultural Pragmatic Failure

2122 words - 8 pages Cross-cultural communication means communication between people from different cultures. We use the term cross-cultural communication instead of intercultural communication because it is too restrictive. This term implies a comparison between cultures (for example, different styles of leadership). More precisely, cross-cultural communication is communication between people whose cultural perceptions and symbol systems are distinct enough to