Assisted Suicide has been a controversial issue for some time now. It is also confused
with the term euthanasia; however the two do not mean the same thing. Euthanasia is the killing
of another to relieve their pain; whereas assisted suicide is the practice where an individual assist
the person committing suicide. The practice of both of these issues reliefs the person that is in
pain. Assisted suicide has positive and negative issues. There is a debate on whether it should be
legal or not. Some of the positive issues on assisted suicide are it reliefs a person from the pain
they are in. The person has the right to choose how they want to die because that falls under the
equal protections clause. Oncology patients don’t necessary like the idea of physician assistant
suicide. Some negative issues of assisted suicide are that it violates ethics that people may have.
Also it is compared to Euthanasia and people find that to be just as bad as assisted suicide.
Assisted nor Physician Assisted suicide should be legal in the U.S. In the following essay the
articles Technical Difficulties and National Center for Biotechnology Information will help with
support and evidence as to why there are benefits and negative issues to assisted suicide, but no
matter what it should still not be legal.
Assisted suicide has some benefits. One of those benefits is that it helps to end the
suffering of the person that is in pain. There was a case of a woman a few years ago who was in
pain and the court denied her the request that her husband help her end her life. According to
Professors Len Doyal and Lesly Doyal from National Center for Biotechnology Information state
Diane Pretty was refused the legal right to choose the circumstances of her own
death. She suffers from motor neurone disease and is experiencing the
disintegration of her body. She faces a death that she believes will entail indignity
and suffering and physically cannot kill herself. The court has denied her request
that her husband be allowed to help her. This decision may be consistent with
legal precedent but is morally wrong.
Motor neurone disease is a group of neurological disorders that affect motor neurons and these
are cells that control the muscles that allow you to speak, walk, and swallow and other body
movement. The lady Diane suffered from a disease and was not allowed to do what she wanted
to end her pain. If assisted suicide was legal this would have not have been a problem and she
would have been able to have her husband end the pain she was in. Making assisted suicide legal
would have benefited the person in this case.
Another reason why it is argued that assisted suicide should be legal is because of the
equal protections clause. This comes from the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
Originally this clause was put there for the freedom of African Americans. As time went by
however the people began to think that other government laws...