This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Athletic Scholarship Ban Essay

1302 words - 6 pages

“Its time for our college athletes to be true students on campus, not athletes on athletic stipends with sports – not education – as their top priority and obligation” (Ralph Nader in League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses, 2011)
“By eliminating the athletic scholarship, … we could de-professionalize college athletes, reestablish athletic departments as part of the educational institution, and be able to use the term student-athlete without snickering.” (Ralph Nader in League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses, 2011)
Over the past years the usefulness of athletic scholarships, and its outcomes for both the schools and athletes has been contested. Opposing parties have debated whether or not banning them will solve the problems that lay within. I believe that athletic scholarships should be interdicted because they are no guarantee of education, good academic performance or a proper lifestyle for the athletes.
Thoughts of athletic scholarships started over 20 years ago while colleges were attempting to attribute it maintaining their athletes at an amateur status (Johnson & Acquaviva, n.d.). Ralph Nader, politician, author, lawyer, and consumer advocate, has recently drawn attention upon and ignited skepticism about its effectiveness, proposing the elimination of athletic scholarships in 2011 (League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses, 2011). After the National Collegiate Athletic Association, NCAA, Professional Basketball Championship, Nader summoned higher education schools to, as he said, “…take a bold step toward restoring academic integrity in intercollegiate sports…” (League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses, 2011). His proposal is that the money assigned to athletic scholarships is redirected to need and merit based scholarships (League of Fans Proposes Eliminating Athletic Scholarships to Help Restore Integrity on College Campuses, 2011).
One reason that I agree with Nader’s proposal is that athletic scholarships can be dismissed at any point. Most scholarships are renewable, so if an athlete has an injury or can’t play for any other reason his or her scholarship may no longer be applicable, and that person may see him or herself drifting in any year of their academic life (Levin, 2012). An illustration of that is former Rice University football player Joseph Agnew, who sued NCAA for revoking his scholarship just before his senior year (Levin, 2012). The reasons were that he had been recovering from some injuries and didn’t have much playtime (Levin, 2012). Opposing views may claim that that could no longer be the case as in a recent voting including member schools of the NCAA, the ban on multi year athletic scholarships was canceled (Levin, 2012). Although not mandatory, schools can now...

Find Another Essay On Athletic Scholarship Ban

Doping in Sport and the current issues and challenges for sport management

924 words - 4 pages ) The number of athletes who abuse steroids is unknown at this day in time. Many athletic associations ban their use, including the National Football League (NFL), Major League Baseball (MLB), National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) and the Olympics. Many athletes will not admit they uses steroids until it’s too late. And even after being caught they will still fight to the end. The NFL tests its athletes for illicit use. Players who

Recent Regulation Changes in the NCAA

1267 words - 5 pages . (2011). NCAA Panel Approves Major Changes. College Sports. Retrieved from http://espn.go.com/college-sports/story/_/id/7156548/ncaa-panel-approves-major-scholarship-rules-changes. Davis, T. & Hairston, C. T. (2013). NCAA Deregulation and Reform: A Radical Shift of Governance Philosophy? Oregon Law Review, 92(77), pp. 77-128. Snyder, E. (2013). Student-Athlete Participation in Intercollegiate Athletic Decision-Making: Inclusion through Different Domains of Governance. The Sport Journal. Retrieved from http://thesportjournal.org/article/student-athlete-participation-in-intercollegiate-athletic-decision-making-inclusion-through-different-domains-of-governance/.

The Name of the Game

2284 words - 10 pages players and their living conditions at two universities known for their athletic successes: “The University of Texas football players’ fair market value is worth $513,922, but they lived $778 below the poverty line and had a $3,624 scholarship shortfall. Duke basketball players were valued at $1,025,656 while living just $732 above the poverty line and a scholarship shortfall of $1,995” (Study: “The Price” 1). Many players struggle to keep their

Pay For Play?

2178 words - 9 pages , he was a young man who received a full scholarship to USC to play football under head coach Pete Carroll. Medical staff at USC would not clear Frankie to play because they found a heart condition called hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, which is the most common cardiovascular cause of sudden death in the world. Frankie would never be able to play football ever again. However, Pete Carroll and athletic director Mike Garrett would honor Frankie’s

Sport Ethics

681 words - 3 pages University was fined $60 million, and the football team received a four-year postseason ban as well as the loss of all of their victories from 1998 to 2011. Furthermore, Penn State was forced to reduce scholarships for a four-year period, and their athletic program was forced to abide to a five-year probation period where they were forced to follow specific integrity guidelines ("ESPN College Football"). I believe that Jerry Sandusky committed a

Athletics Vs. Academics

3060 words - 12 pages to attend universities who very often have not reached the scholastic accolades to attend the specific institution; it is purely their athletic abilities that allow these people to not only study at these schools but attend at a discounted tuition or free of charge. Academic scholarships that work in the same fashion as the athletic scholarships further the goal of the university, to create academic community of excellence; athletic scholarship

Collegiate Infractions

1456 words - 6 pages Compliance 5). Being caught also suspends the athlete from all athletic involvement. This could devastate the athlete but it is deserved. They would be eligible had they not made the wrong decisions. They shouldn’t accept the gift without knowing and understanding the consequences. An apparent example is when “USC suffered a two year bowl ban and scholarship reductions” (Bryant Howard 4). This was caused by the acts of Former USC running back Reggie

Genetic Engineering

1565 words - 6 pages therefore the child will not be an identical twin.A huge step forward in genetic engineering in the Unites States was on January 23, 1993, when President Clinton lifted the Department of Health and Human Services' moratorium on funding research projects which involve transplanting tissue from selectively aborted children. The initial ban was a temporary one implemented by the Regan Administration(Quick). President Bush Sr. made the ban permanent

The Olympics: Politics, Scandal, and Corruption

3744 words - 15 pages destruction of the Olympics' golden halo. The purity of the Olympics has, since their resurrection in 1896, been politically led. Scandal, corruption, boycotts, and political disputes have smeared the Olympic innocence. The Games have always been an easy target for political protests, bitter disputes, and even acts of terrorism. The Games are no longer about sportsmanship and athletic competition, they are now about nationalism and whose country

Learning About Racism and Glory Road

2089 words - 9 pages impossible to recruit the talented white players. Initially, Haskins received a substantial amount of criticism for recruiting black players in a sport where white players were the norm. Interestingly, once the team began to win, his critics became his supporters. It was not difficult to find African-American athletes because they were more than happy to receive a scholarship to play basketball as well as get a college education. Although they were

Ethical Hazing

2759 words - 11 pages Ethical Hazing When one hears the word "hazing," the typically first impression is that of a fraternity member with a paddle in one hand, beer in another and a young "pledge" bent over being struck by the wooden paddle. This is defiantly a case of classic hazing, however many other forms have been created and made public in the recent past. Other fields such as military, sorority, high school and athletic teams have begun to come under

Similar Essays

Athletes And Anabolic Steroids Essay

991 words - 4 pages Sports and the spirit of competition have been valued by the human race for centuries. Today, sports are enjoyed globally by millions of people on amateur and professional levels. Unfortunately, the desire to win and exceed in the athletic field has led to the development and use of anabolic steroids. I believe that the use of anabolic steroids should be completely banned in order to ensure the safety of all athletes, to preserve the

Ncaa Eligibility Essay

1549 words - 7 pages the statement “academics over athletics.” Admitting students based on athletic ability also has a big impact other aspects beside the academics. The first, and arguably the most important to colleges is money. If scholarship athletes had to gain admission with the rest of the regular applicants, then college athletics would decline drastically. When athletics decline drastically, television networks do not air games, therefore causing the

Growth Hormones Or Nah? Essay

2208 words - 9 pages recovering from an injury or long periods of inactivity. This will become extremely useful for athletes who undergo surgery since after surgery, it is usually required to stay in the hospital for a while to fully recover from the surgery. This is how HGH has been used other than to increase athletic performance. Next, HGH is taken by athletes mainly for its effect on performance enhancement. Despite this reason may be enough to ban the substance

Paychecks For Playmakers? Essay

1138 words - 5 pages would go on to kick the game winning field goal to win the BCS national championship and a plentiful share of all the ticket sales, advertisements revenue, and sponsorship dollars that come with it. (Martin). Players like Dyer, do exactly what the pros do and all for the sake their team winning these things but there is one big difference however. The pros get paid a share of that income, Dyer doesn’t. Nowadays, upper echelon college athletic