Atkins And South Beach Diet Approaches

1248 words - 5 pages - kazoonuclear ✓ Expert Reviewed

Atkins and South Beach Diet Approaches

The Atkins and the South Beach diets offer different approaches to reducing insulin response levels. Both diets emphasize low carbohydrate consumption in order to avoid a high insulin response, which is thought to increase cholestrol levels and inhibit the body's ability to break down fats. Instead, the Atkins and South Beach diets attempt to achieve a lower and theoretically healthier insulin response by restricting carbohydrate consumption in different manners. Given this common objective, it is possible to compare the Atkins diet and the South Beach diet based upon their respective dietary requirements and insulinemic effects.

First, terminology important to understanding the theory behind both the Atkins and South Beach diets must be defined. Insulin response refers to the body's release of insulin as a reaction to the digestion of carbohydrates. Once carbohydrates enter the digestive process, they are broken into their constituent sugar molecules, absorbed by the small intestine, and then are transferred to the blood. These newly-absorbed sugar molecules cause the blood's sugar concentration to increase. The body responds to this increased sugar concentration by releasing insulin into the bloodstream, which carries the sugar to muscle cells to burn; excess sugar is carried to fat cells for storage1. The body uses these stored sugars for energy as needed throughout the day. Finally, metabolism refers to the overall process by which the body processes food and harvests energy.

Keeping these definitions in mind, the Atkins dietary approach might be described. It is a four-phase program that begins with an induction phase that lasts for two weeks. During induction, one eats fats and proteins liberally, consumes no more than 20 grams of good carbohydrates (i.e. fibrous vegetables) per day, and is allowed absolutely no fruit, bread, grains, starchy vegetables, or dairy products other than cheese, cream, or butter2. Phase two lasts 3-4 months and incorporates slightly more low carbohydrate foods (nuts and seeds), fibrous vegetables, and even berries3. Phase three typically last 2-3 months and introduces Atkins-acceptable fruit (identified in the Atkins diet plan) in small, controlled portions4. Phase four, which lasts for the rest of one's life, is similar to phase three, emphasizing limited, measured portions of certain carbohydrates and liberal amounts of fats and proteins5.

Basically, the Atkins dietary plan is premised on the idea that foods predominantly comprised of carbohydrates, such as bread and sugar, should be replaced by protein and fat (the other two major food groups6) and foods lower in carbohydrates, like nuts and olives. The Atkins plan holds that these latter foods, also known as good carbohydrates, produce a lower insulin response than would occur with higher carbohydrate foods7, also known as bad carbohydrates. Likewise, fibrous fruits and vegetables are...

Find Another Essay On Atkins and South Beach Diet Approaches

South Beach Diet Essay

817 words - 3 pages over bacon, cheeseburgers, and steaks. With this diet there is no calorie counting. In fact, there is no actual diet plan per se. Agatston uses sample menus to outline what you need to eat. Lists of “foods to enjoy” and “foods to avoid” round out the plan. Basically it adds up to three meals a day and three small snacks or six “eating occasions.”      Like the Atkins diet, the South Beach diet plan is divided into phases...

South Beach Diet Fanatics Essay

1830 words - 7 pages lose weight, lower their cholesterol, reduce their risk of heart disease and diabetes, and eliminate cravings without feeling hungry. Some call it the “updated version of the Atkins diet (healthyweithtforum.com).”      The South Beach Diet teaches a way of life where a person relies on the right carbohydrates and fats in their diet. This diet allows a person--according to southbeach-diet-plan.com-- “to live contently...

The South Beach Diet

2362 words - 9 pages Dieting and the South Beach DietThe nation's scales are on the rise and it is clear that American people have a serious obesity issue at their hands that needs to be turned around. The bad new is that currently only 33 percent (71 million people) of U.S. adults are dieting and are even trying to get into better shape (Calorie Control, 2006). Some of the key...

Health Benefits of the South Beach Diet

845 words - 3 pages weight loss as they encourage healthier foods lower in saturated fat. The South Beach diet thus proves to be an ideal tool when it comes to losing weight and staying healthy. Sources Cited: “2,000 Calories a Day the Easy Way” <http://www.caloriecontrol.org/menuechart.html> November 27, 2004 “Atkins vs. South Beach: How the Hottest Diets Measure Up” <http://www.atkins-diet.cc/Article36.phtml> November 10, 2004 “South Beach Diet” <http://sout-beach-diet.locolo.com/> November 28, 2004 ...

South Beach Diet

2424 words - 10 pages The crucibleThe Crucible is a 1953 play by the American Arthur Miller. It is a dramatized and partially fictionalized story of the Salem witch trials that took place in the Province of Massachusetts Bay during 1692 and 1693. Miller wrote the play as an allegory of McCarthyism, when the U.S. government blacklisted accused communists.[1] Miller...

Am I really That Fat? Response/Reaction Essay (Essay on the "South Beach Diet" in Elementary Schools)

1183 words - 5 pages "South Beach Diet" was introduced to a school's menu by replacing less wholesome foods with healthier similar choices, the children hated it at first. As Kelly a fourth grader at a school located in Orlando that is taking part in this program would put it "we had better food last year" and "I want to go back to the old menu...

Dr. Atkins diet. A short essay on the Atkins diet compared to the Hollywood diet. Plus Dr. Atkins four phase strategy and four nutritional principles to lose weight.

536 words - 2 pages As I read through the Dr. Atkins diet, I am beginning to see many excellent things. They have many ways for you to stay on track and be able to do a step-by-step weight loss. This weight loss program is unlike many other weight loss programs. Just reading over this, you are able to see that they are really trying to help you lose weight and be healthier. They have...

The Revolutionary Atkins Diet Always check my paper for misspellings and grammar but I believe this one is clean.

1992 words - 8 pages The revolutionary Atkins diet could be the miracle diet which everyone is searching to find. A diet that not only makes them drop weight fast but will also allow them to eat tasty and satisfying meals. The Atkins diet may just be this miracle diet. Although many people are questioning it since so many professionals...

A Complete Look at Fad Dieting and Your Health

1128 words - 5 pages Chapter 7 – Comparing the South Beach Diet and the Atkins Diet While the South Beach diet and the Atkins diet differ in some ways from each other, there are of course similarities in the way that the diets work. Comparing these diets from each other can be done by looking at the similarities that the diets have in common as well as the looking at the differences between the two diets. This chapter is going to show you the similarities and the...

A Complete Look at Fad Dieting and Your Health

1139 words - 5 pages Chapter 10 – Comparing the Stillman Diet and the Atkins Diet The Stillman diet is more closer to the Atkins diet than the South Beach diet is. The South Beach diet works on the bases of eating the right types of carbohydrates. Where as the Stillman diet and the Atkins diet focus on no carbohydrates to low carbohydrates. As well both the Stillman diet and the Atkins diet are high protein diets. In this they both promote the consumption of high...

The Atkins Diet

1809 words - 7 pages are going to great lengths to get their idea of the picture perfect body. Exercise and diets have always been a part of people’s lives, but now the new diet crazes such as the South Beach Diet, Atkins Diet, and the increasing use of diet pills that contain ephedrine, there is controversy as to the affects these diets will have on people’s health. The most common and advertised diet today is the Atkins Diet. It’s known as the low carbohydrate...

Similar Essays

Comparing the Atkins and South Beach Diets

1323 words - 5 pages the weight loss differs in many aspects. Both the Atkins and South Beach diets, varies in the choice of foods consumed by the dieter and the step by step process on how the diet operates. In the Atkins diet, it involves eating foods which are high in protein and fat, while limiting the amount of foods which are high in carbohydrates or foods which normally tends to raise blood sugar. The Atkins diet aims to eliminate the simple...

The Structural Differences of Atkins and South Beach Diets

1018 words - 4 pages The Structural Differences of Atkins and South Beach Diets The Atkins Diet and the South Beach Diet are both regimens that promote weight loss by increasing the intake of proteins while reducing the consumption of carbohydrates. While often grouped together under the “low-carb fad diet” label, these two diets are comparable in design, but contrasting in detail, in particular during phase one. At first glance, these diets appear to...

South Beach Diet Essay

1530 words - 6 pages History of South Beach Diet The South Beach Diet is a diet plan designed by cardiologist Arthur Agatston and dietician Marie Almon. In 1995, Dr. Agatston developed a diet to prevent heart disease for his cardiac and diabetes patients. According to the South Beach Diet website, Agatstaion knew that a low-fat diet would reduce cholesterol and prevent heart disease, but patients had a hard time sticking to the diet. Agatson wanted to find out the...

Pros and Cons of the Atkins and South Beach Diets

1166 words - 5 pages Pros and Cons of the Atkins and South Beach Diets People consider many factors when choosing a diet: what best suites their needs, how it fits with their body type, and what the diet entails, are all aspects taken into account. The Atkins and South Beach diets are plans that take different approaches in style but end up having similar results in the end. Atkins serves to eliminate carbohydrates and focus on more protein...