Attempts To Have Impaired Children Saint Mary's Univerisity Reflective Essay

1173 words - 5 pages

In the article, “Are attempts to have impaired children justifiable?”, the author discussed the issue of parents genetically selecting for impairments in their children. The article focuses on a case where a couple deliberately attempted to ensure the birth of a deaf child via artificial insemination. The couple justifies their attempt based on claims that it is not wrong to deliberately to have a child who will likely experience harm when the harm is socially imposed. Additionally, the couple argued that deaf people should be considered as a minority group, and would experience social harms much like women and people of colour. Therefore, a distinction should not be made between attempting to have a deaf child and having a girl (Anstey, 2017).
The author provides specific arguments against the couple’s claims by first acknowledging the theory behind the claims, then providing counter arguments to discuss why the validity of the claims cannot be specifically applied to this case. The author acknowledges that people tend to prefer specific gender, characteristics, and values in their children. The author agrees with the claim that having specific characteristics in their children may allow parents to form a closer bond with the child, sharing a “likeness, an affinity, of experiences, and capacities” (Anstey, 2017). The author is quick to point that selecting for impairment however is inherently unjust as it predisposes the child to avoidable harm. Additionally, selecting for impairments can encourage the selection against impairments. Among our population, selecting against impairments will be the overwhelming majority. The author ends the article with the clear statement that couples should neither select for nor against deafness.
The persuasive message in clearly stated by the author in the article. The author makes a clear statement at the end of the article that couples should not be able to select for nor against deafness, and impairment in general. The supporting evidence to the author’s statement was clearly discussed throughout the article. The author makes specific arguments against the couple’s claims, providing clear reasons why the claims are unjustifiable in this circumstance. The author’s values and beliefs are that we should not be predisposing children to avoidable harm. If we can select for impairments, there will be an overwhelming majority of parents that would select against impairments. At that point, we are approaching the controversial topic of gene selection.
I agree with author’s claims that couples should not be allowed to select for impaired children. Although the couple who were in article argue that there is not a difference between people who are preferring their infant’s sex verses those selecting for an impairment, I strongly believe that there are big differences between them. While it is understandable parents may prefer a boy or a girl, there are currently no artificial process to ensure the gender of a fetus....

Find Another Essay On Attempts to have impaired children - Saint Mary's Univerisity - Reflective Essay

This essay attempts to explain the message behind Flannery O'Connor's "A Good Man is Hard to Find"

677 words - 3 pages Du-Ewa SanabriaHonors English Composition 1101Prof. R.M. StambaughFebruary 3, 2003A Good Man's MessageAt first glance, this story is grotesque, horrifying and very disturbing. The shock value of the story is not lost even though the family's fate is quite evident quite early on.The terror is in knowing and hoping against hope that this is not so. Then you are forced to analyze why such a story is necessary and what message could the writer have

Should Parents Obtain A License To Have Children?

892 words - 4 pages Untitled Should parents obtain a license to have children? By: Rebecca Rogers I think this is a tough question to answer because how do you measure whether or not someone is capable of raising a child? I think that in some cases people you wouldn't think would be a good parent turn out to have the best children. Even if a parent tries to raise their child right and thinks they are making all the right decisions, a child still

Legal Abortion=Freedom of Choice Whenever a society attempts to outlaw abortions, it ignores the same urgent reasons for safe, legal abortions that have always existed

787 words - 3 pages Legal abortions are essential in a free society that values women and their rights. Abortion is never an easy decision, but women have been making that decision for thousands of years. Whenever a society attempts to outlaw abortions, it ignores the same urgent reasons for safe, legal abortions that have always existed.Choice is good for families. There are many programs such as family planning, sex education, and contraception which diminish the

Describe at least three forms of computer crime and outline international and Australian attempts that have been made to regulate them

1773 words - 7 pages The terms "Computer crime," "Computer-related crime," "High-tech crime" and "Cybercrime" are often used interchangeably. A difference can be made between computer specific crimes and traditional crimes performed with the aid of computer technology. Many countries have passed legislation to address computer-related crime. Under the Australian system of Government, all Australian States and Territories have a general power to enact criminal laws

Should Parents Allow Their Children Have Social Media? - English 9th - Argumentative Essay

625 words - 3 pages depressed. Social media addiction can cause short-term memory, becoming unaware of surroundings, and hard time talking; which means that children could have a hard time paying attention in class and interacting with others. When parents allow them limited access to their social media and checking it, will allow the child to not get depressed as a child that is constantly on their phone would. “The shock of post-natal depression or struggling to cope

What effects does bullying have on children? - Grand Canyon University UNV 104 - Essay

964 words - 4 pages gender ( According to the dictionary, bullying is defined as an overbearing person who badgers and intimidates smaller or weaker people. Any of these types of bullying has an effect on children. As I work within the school system I have seen bullying effect many students. I believe that children bully due to problems within themselves such as low self esteem, lack of attention, it has been done to them or they have seen it done

Delaying Childbearing: Why it is Important to Have Children While in College

1194 words - 5 pages Like many other women, I was raised in a family that repetitively told me that I needed to finish school before thinking about getting married, and definitely before having kids. This made sense when I became an adult, why not put all my focus into my schooling. Yet, for me that would mean that I would be in my early thirties when I finished school. This has become the norm for women to marry and have children in there 30s, then in years past

Adopted Children Have the Right to Know the Identities of Their Birth Parents

876 words - 4 pages Every day children are born to parent’s that give them up for adoption for one reason or another. This reason usually plays an important role in determining whether the biological parent(s) want their identities known by the child. Although the reason may be fundamental to the parents in shaping whether they choose yes or no, its value should not take precedence over the fact that adopted children have the right to know the identities of their

What does the novel "Wise Children" have to tell us about paternity and maternity?

802 words - 3 pages children to the maximum, but beneath the surface they always have a flaw that effects their children.Grandma Chance has a big influence in Dora and Nora's lives, even after her death. Carter supports the idea that mothers are what keep families together and deal with situations to help their children. When the twins' are in Hollywood and Nora is ready to get married to an Italian man called Tony, the wedding is ruined by Tony's mother who protests

Characters - Children Have to Grow Up: "Careful he might hear you" by Sumner Lock Elliot

1144 words - 5 pages Sumner Lock Elliot's novel "Careful he might hear you" introduces to the reader part of the journey made by a six-year old boy named PS, on his way to adulthood. It illustrates also the notion that growing up is a multifaceted activity, requiring not only a physical maturation, but an emotional advancement as well. He suggests that people other than children need to grow up (as indeed they do). The adults most responsible for moulding PS into an

Is It Possible To Have An Inclusive Society? - Essay

1518 words - 7 pages 1872, the first education law was passed in Victoria. This act set up central public schools but, unfortunately, Indigenous children were not allowed to attend. The first attempt to educate aboriginal children was in 1790. Indigenous students have been enrolled in Australian Government Schools from as early as the 1870?s. ?By 1882, 200 Indigenous students were enrolled in either a Government or Mission schools.? Since then, the results of

Similar Essays

Decision To Not Have Children Essay

768 words - 3 pages John SouthernMarriage and The FamilySYG 2430-BM2Project # 5The Decision to Have no ChildrenMore couples are choosing not to have children than in past generations, one of these couples is Max and Alyssa Lopez. Alyssa and Max were kind enough to let me interview them on Monday the 21st of July, to help shed some light on why, they as a couple chose to not have any children. I was able to understand the many factors behind their thought process

Reflective Essay On Writing Techniques I Have Learned

767 words - 3 pages out that, he is upset with insurance companies (Balko). This example is in my own words and is an example of a paraphrase. I quoted people and then would not write what I thought about the quote afterwards. When doing this in an essay, the teacher has no way of knowing what the student is trying to convey. A proper quote should start with an introduction. After the introduction, you have to say what the person has said, followed by what you

Was There A Trojan War? This Essay Attempts To Answer A Question That Is Very Controversial

1663 words - 7 pages The story of the Trojan War, as narrated in Homer's Iliad, has for centuries been interpreted as a literal truth or as a legend based on a conflict that really did happen. It is natural for one to believe that a story as fabulous and colorful like that of Ilios, or Troy, could not have taken place. It is very practical to believe that the great heroes, like Achilles, Odysseus, Aeneas, and the gods and goddesses were purely out of imagination

The Treatments Available To Help Infertile Couples To Have Children

1456 words - 6 pages The Treatments Available to Help Infertile Couples to Have Children There are a variety of treatments available to help infertile couples to have children as infertility is increasingly becoming a recognised problem. Infertility is the term used to describe the inability to conceive or the inability to carry a pregnancy to a live child after regular sexual intercourse without the use of contraception. If you continue to