This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Automatic Transfer Law: An Effective Policy?

1388 words - 6 pages

Researchers conducted a national study of how the juvenile court judge weighs the pertinent Kent criteria. This criterion is based on the potential risk to the community, the maturity of character and amenability to intervention. The purpose of this study is three fold, first to test the juvenile court judges' beliefs regarding the mechanics of how juveniles are transferred, second to examine the judges' beliefs about the usefulness of data presented of them and third determined how juvenile judges' weigh pertinent psychological concepts linked to transfer cases when making a decision. There were four hypothesis based on previous research and theory, one would be juvenile judges' prefer case ...view middle of the document...

For this juvenile, his level of dangerousness and sophistication-maturity were low but his amenability to treatment level was high. The judges were given a scale of one to five for how useful the Kent concepts when determining whether to transfer a juvenile to adult court. This procedure was based on random assignment; all members of the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court judges were sent one of eight versions of the survey and a letter explaining the purpose of the study. The Judges were asked to lend their expertise to help present researchers understand the transfer process better and what to consider when making such a decision.
The results of this study were that out of the 361 surveys there were similar response patterns. Geographically, the results were evenly spread across the nation, however the surveys did not provide the ultimate decision of whether judges would transfer the particular cases used in this study. Based on the data results, most judges believes that the prosecutorial direct file should be left as the last resort for offender and pinpointed things such as mental illness as a reason to retain youths in the juvenile system. These results showed the differences in the use of discretion from a judge’s point of view. For the most part, judges leaned towards keeping youth offenders in the juvenile justice system.
A third study was conducted on juvenile offending; however this study focused on the perspective of the effectiveness of the “get-tough” attitude on juvenile crime. Researchers wanted to reexamine this concept and find out if using it as a way to waive juveniles to adult court resulted in harsher punishments and if there is a difference between the two court systems. This study included 345 youths who were waived to the adult court system in Pennsylvania. Examined were the certainty, swiftness and severity of punishment for youths transferred to adult court compared to those in the juvenile system to find out the effectiveness of the juvenile legislative waiver.
This study concentrated on youths who had preliminary hearings in three Pennsylvania cities (Philadelphia, Allegheny and Dauphin) between March 1996 and December 1996. These youths met the Act 33criteria for juvenile exclusion, which are a set of guidelines that removed youth offenders from the juvenile court jurisdiction. Out of the sample of 354 youths, 144 were decertified to juvenile court and 201 were not. Random Assignment was not used possible for this study because the two groups are likely to differ in regards of other factors than the type of court system they will be placed in. The key variables in this study were conviction, target, incarceration, type of sentence and the case processing time. Other factors that may differ amongst offenders include type of attorney, race, offense severity and the type of weapon used in the crime.
The results showed that there is no significant difference in the likelihood of conviction between youth...

Find Another Essay On Automatic Transfer Law: An Effective Policy?

Constitutionality of Assault Rifles Essay

852 words - 4 pages acts of criminals could be controlled by restricting the rights of the law abiding citizenry. Now, the controversy over gun control threatens the structure and stability of the 2nd amendment and builds a prejudice against Modern Sporting Firearms. (Inert tsopic sentence) Semi-automatic firearms were introduced more than a century ago. The first semi automatic rifle was introduced in 1885, the first semi-automatic pistol in 1892, and the first


1266 words - 6 pages transfer law that is used by forty-seven states in American. Works Cited Caldwell, R. (1961). The Juvenile Court: Its Development and Some Major Problems. The Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology, and Police Science 51(5), 493-511. Fagan J.A. (1996). The comparative advantage of juvenile versus criminal court sanctions on Recidivism among adolescent felony offenders. Law and Policy 18, 77-113 Fagan, J.A (2008) Juvenile Crime and Criminal

Prison Term Policy Recommendation

1247 words - 5 pages robbery.Prison Term Policy RecommendationIt is the responsibility for members of the state legislature to thoroughly research whether a bill to double the maximum prison term for any person convicted of armed robbery will be an effective deterrent to future crimes. The data compiled will present the positive and negative aspects of the proposed bill. Therefore, the criminologist advisor will compile an unbiased study of the current laws, consequences, and

Assault Rifle Ban: Weapon Control

2068 words - 8 pages government to act swiftly and acknowledge the dangers assault rifles pose. The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines an assault rifle as any various automatic or semiautomatic rifles with large capacity magazines designed for military use. An assault weapon might have characteristics like a pistol grip, a silencer, a bayonet mount, a grenade launcher or a flash suppressor. The Violence Policy Center, a non-profit organization based in Washington D.C

Managing International Talent

1623 words - 6 pages acquire a new distributor in another country, the decision of hiring will come directly from the head office and hence there won’t be time consuming objections from the subsidiaries. This is boosted by the fact that when the central decision making organs decides on something there won’t be contradicting opinions from the organization (Sinat, 2011). Marketing It is paramount for the organization to have an effective marketing strategy in

Juvenile Justice

3128 words - 13 pages proceedings when they seek an adult sentence. Although proponents tout these measures as a sagacious solution for the vexatious problem of juvenile delinquency, abolishing the trial de novo system, providing for automatic adult trials and opening juvenile proceedings to the public when prosecutors seek an adult sentence works to the detriment, not the benefit, of juveniles and society. Therefore, the policy makers of Massachusetts should repeal most

The Importance of the Concept of Citizenship in the Development of EC Law After Maastricht

2736 words - 11 pages , because after controls were abolished at internal borders people could obviously no longer be checked for nationality. The importance of citizenship in EC law is that members are able to move anywhere within EC countries to obtain employment, by being a member you gain automatic rights. the idea is that there should be a level playing field and that if you move to a country with EC membership there is no need to

Agenda Setting Paper: Assault Weapon Bans

1080 words - 5 pages Control and Law Enforcement Act, which included the federal Assault Weapons Ban (AWB). The president at the time Bill Clinton signed it into law the same day. The Assault Weapons Ban prohibited the manufacture of certain semi-automatic firearms (those made prior to the Assault Weapons Ban could still be legally owned and sold). When the ban was passed, it had a sunset provision attached to it which gave it an expiration date of 10 years. Even

Evaluating the ACWL

1850 words - 8 pages of the WTO litigation branch based in Geneva seat of WTO. They can easily develop a strong firm relationship with the Northern groups to provide legal advice and assistance on specific issues References Mazzacano, P. J. (2004). The Estey center journal of international law and trade policy. The Problem of inclusion, developing countries and Global trade, 5(2), Keisuke Iida. 2004. Is WTO Dispute Settlement Effective? Global Governance 10(2

2718LHS Critical Review 2 - Griffith - Critical Review

710 words - 3 pages to essential health care. The cash transfer scheme section examines how it is income security for children and how most of the schemes target mothers as they are like to prioritize investments in a child well-being and looks at the both the positives and the problems that arise from these types of programs. The policy brief states that while an assumption is made that women’s empowerment is an automatic by-product of these cash transfers that is

Initial Version

2124 words - 9 pages detail some of the disputes and convictions at the root of this controversy. In 1976, the District of Columbia overwhelmed by escalating levels of violent criminality enacted one of the nation’s strongest gun control laws to ever be enforced. The effectual reality of forbidden handguns, banned automatic firearms, and prohibited semiautomatic weapons quickly became a way of life for this community. The only firearms excluded from this law were guns

Similar Essays

Conditional Cash Transfer In The Philippines: An Effective Poverty Intervention?

6459 words - 26 pages impact evaluation offers an excellent opportunity, for both policy makers and development practitioners, to learn what works and what does not work as they seek for effective poverty interventions.Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program (4Ps or CCT) is a human investment program for children through health and education and a poverty-reduction strategy that provides cash grants to extremely poor households to allow their family members to meet

An Example Of The Policy Cycle In New Zealand Using Homosexual Law Reform Act 1986 As A Case Study

2653 words - 11 pages the Homosexual Law Reform Bill had been around for quite some time. There had been in the past unsuccessful attempts to decriminalise homosexual activities between consenting males.'Various individuals and groups have a stake in the shape and management of (the agenda setting) process.' In this policy case study there were numerous individuals and groups which exerted an influence on the formation of the Bill.The first attempts to reform were

Differing Interpretation On 2nd Ammendment On Gun Control In U.S

986 words - 4 pages . (Snyder, 2014) The complexities that surround the issue of gun rights are many. Should gun laws be made stricter or should the enforcement of current laws be made stricter and no new laws created? Should all guns be banned or only semi-automatic guns? Background checks and waiting periods are just another one of the complexities in the gun control issues facing policy makers. The impact of gun control has many paradoxes. A ban on firearms could

Innovation Policy In Brazil Essay

1164 words - 5 pages the adequacy of intellectual property rights through the Brazilian Intellectual Property Law in 1996, the implementation of the “Projeto Inovar” (for the Promotion of Venture Capital Investments in Technology-based Companies in Brazil), and the creation of a set of Sectorial Funds to support innovation and mobilize complementary resources to promote knowledge generation and technological transfer. A general framework of innovation policy was