This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Automatist Utopian Themes In Acharnians & Birds

1612 words - 7 pages

During the 5th century BCE, Old Comedy was the most prevalent comedic form in Ancient Greece. This was largely due to the success of Athenian playwright, Aristophanes. His plays were frenetic, visual and personal, often containing historical figures. In particular, Aristophanes’ comedies contained automatist utopian themes that were used to satirize various aspects of 5th century Greece, often in Athens. The present essay will first define utopia and the automatist subtype. Then it will explore Aristophanes’ usage of automatist utopian themes in his plays Acharnians and Peace. Specifically, this paper will argue that Aristophanes used themes associated with automatist utopia to satirize war, ...view middle of the document...

Classicist H.C. Baldry supports this statement, emphasizing, “It is typical of Old Comedy as we know it from Aristophanes that they singled out one…topic so dear to the heart of the Athenian audience—food” (Baldry 60). This is not surprising given that Aristophanes was appealing mainly to an Athenian audience. Thus, automatist utopia focused mainly on peace, prosperity and abundance of food.
The automatist utopian theme of massive amounts of food is present throughout Aristophanes’ play, Acharnians written in 425 BCE. In an opening scene, the comedic hero, Dicaeopolis is at an assembly meeting in which Athenian ambassadors have just returned from Persia. During the meeting an ambassador exclaims, “Barbarians, you see, define a man by how much food and wine he can consume…[they feasted us with whole oxen, baked in giant ovens” (Ach. 1.77-86). In this case, Aristophanes’ description of gluttonous amounts of food being served to the ambassadors fits the automatist utopian criteria. However, it is curious that the ambassador describes “barbarians” as characterizing men by the amount of food and wine they consume. On the one hand, if taken literally, perhaps the ambassadors did not enjoy their feasts in Persia. However, Aristophanes may be satirizing the excess of the aristocracy. Given the greater context of this passage, the ambassadors seemed to have enjoyed their lives during their time in Persia even though they act as if they did not. Dicaeopolis notices this and not believing their feasting ways he responds adversely, “Who has ever seen an oven-baked ox? What absolute baloney…you’re conning all of us” (Ach. 1.87-90). In this case, Dicaeopolis’ response may serve as a satire of these aristocratic ambassadors. Specifically, he cannot believe that these men would eat oxen baked in an oven because that is considered excessive and gross. Dicaeopolis also appears to view this amount of food as so gluttonous that he cannot believe that it exists. Thus, this is a rich example of how Aristophanes use of automatist utopia can be interpreted as satirizing the excess of the aristocracy. Despite the satire, Aristophanes’ opinion is difficult to decipher. As a member of the aristocracy, it likely his opinion was equivocal by design.
In Aristophanes’ Acharnians, the absence of the automatist utopian trope of peace is used to satirize the aristocracy and their role in prolonging the Peloponnesian War. At the beginning of the play, Dicaeopolis is at an assembly meeting, expressing his discontent at the continuation of the Peloponnesian War. He exclaims, “The Magistrates aren’t even here; they’re late…and when they come…as for talk of peace, not a single moment’s thought” (Ach. 1.23-27). As seen here, Dicaeopolis is upset that the Athenian magistrates are neglecting to entertain conversations of peace. Furthermore, he views these magistrates, as a group that falls under the larger classification of the Athenian aristocracy, as culpable for the continuation of...

Find Another Essay On Automatist Utopian Themes In Acharnians & Birds

Literary Utopian Societies Essay

1715 words - 7 pages Literary Utopian Societies “The vision of one century is often the reality of the next…” (Nelson 108). Throughout time, great minds have constructed their own visions of utopia. Through the study of utopias, one finds that these “perfect” societies have many flaws. For example, most utopias tend to have an authoritarian nature (Manuel 3). Also, another obvious imperfection found in the majority of utopias is that of a faulty social class

Utopian Societies Essay

1147 words - 5 pages Republic was the model for many utopian stories. Written utopias can have many themes, such as humanistic, practical, religious, and secular, that present solutions for existing conditions. They tend to focus on liberty and extoll living a simple life. Many are satires that mock existing conditions rather than suggesting workable solutions. Gulliver’s Travels (1726) is an example of a satirical utopia story (More’s Utopia, 2013). More’s Utopia

The Use of Birds in Chronical of a Death Foretold by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

1206 words - 5 pages a “bewilderment of innocence” (101). The birds effectively convey additional sentiments and subliminal messages attached to the main themes of the novel. The use of birds in Gabriel Garcia’s figurative imagery ties into “pursuit of love” being similar to falconry. After all, Gabriel Garcia Marquez would not have implemented them into his writing had he felt that the birds did not have any relevance at all to the text.

The Birds vs

1831 words - 7 pages In the movie The Birds by Alfred Hitchcock as well as in the short story "The Birds" by Daphne du Maurier, nature wreaks havoc on human beings. The movie and the story take place in seaside towns. Hitchcock chooses the seaside town of Bodega Bay, California for the movie setting. Du Maurier selects a seaside town in England. The residents of the towns are brutally attacked by birds that increase in viciousness with every attack. The wind seems

Utopia

1168 words - 5 pages to understand and respond to the specific time. There are many ways to view the utopian society; some may view it as the result of rational thought or Humanist beliefs, others as an alternative to feudalism, a statement in favour of communal society, or an effort to promote reform according to Christian values. The book Utopia is composed of two parts – the first written last, and the second written first. The second book is the one in

Is Orwell's 1984 Utopian

792 words - 3 pages characters would describe their world as a utopian society, for technically it could be. However, Orwell's tedious tirade of mindless details, 1984, is indeed anti-utopian in nature. Through Winston and his support characters, Orwell shows the complete opposite of utopia, inevitably revealing a hint of pessimism.Utopia by nature is an extension of communism. There were several stages of communism described by Marx as to how this type of society should

How are style and structural elements used in texts to shape our meanings? Answer in referance to "Fly Away Peter."

1089 words - 4 pages the themes of the continuity of life and the brutality of war in a clearer manner. One of the symbols used throughout is the migration of the birds. The birds symbolise the specific theme of continuity of life because they continue to migrate during peace and war timesThe migration of the birds also represents how even if there is a disastrous event the cycle of life will continue, "was the presence of the birds... and to find his way back at

Utopia Vs. Dystopia

686 words - 3 pages life is extremely bad, as from deprivation, oppression, or terror." It takes quite the author to accept the formidable challenges presented when writing a utopian novel (that is, one that focuses on a utopian society), which are scarce in comparison to their opposing cousin. Some utopian novels become popular, such as Looking Backward, by Edward Bellamy. Yet, simply put, if everything is perfect, everything is boring. Attention can rarely be

The Matrix vs The Minority Report

2081 words - 9 pages The films I have chosen to focus on that could be well developed into the classes themes of Utopia vs. Dystopia societies and views are “The Matrix” (1999) and “Minority Report” (2002). As The Matrix focuses upon being an example of a dystopia society due to the variety of characteristics that it displays throughout the movie in the fact of demonstrating a totalitarian controlled system manipulated by computers controlling every minute of detail

Bird Parliment

1030 words - 4 pages annihilation represents what psychologically the Sufi's go through in their quest for God. All of these themes put together symbolize the Sufi culture and their quest for God.I found that the journey is a very important part for the birds and the Sufi's, therefore I chose to rewrite that important scene from the work in modern language.The birds had to travel for many years. A large part of their lives went by while they were traveling across mountains

The Exposed Nest

1305 words - 6 pages Throughout the poem “The Exposed Nest” by Robert Frost there were multiple themes revealed to readers. Themes that were repeatedly shown throughout this poem were duties, Nature, and Parents. Frost uses many metaphors to compare nature life to human life. In each theme revealed the message that came out was Responsibilities, protection and the misery of nature. The themes that are all portrayed in the poem comes together to show the main idea

Similar Essays

Common Themes And Elements In Psycho And The Birds

811 words - 4 pages The two films Psycho and The Birds, both directed by Alfred Hitchcock, share similar themes and elements. These recurring themes and elements are often prevalent in many of Hitchcock’s works. In Psycho and The Birds, Hitchcock uses thematic elements like the ideal blonde woman, “the motherly figure”, birds, and unusual factors that often leave the viewer thinking. Hitchcock’s works consist of melodramatic films, while also using pure cinema to

The Athenian Playwright, Aristophanes Essay

1808 words - 8 pages theme in five and politics in all 11. The five plays where Aristophanes incorporated war, Lysistrata, The Acharnians, The Birds, The Knights, and Peace, 12 In addition, Aristophanes’ notion of sex as power and human nature in Lysistrata, similar concepts were also conveyed Aristophanes’ speech in Plato’s philosophical text, Symposium. Although this was a fictional piece, Plato’s Symposium is the only source modern students of history

An Aristophanes Research Paper

559 words - 2 pages eleven survived. These eleven plays are: The Acharnians (425 BC), The Knights (424 BC), The Clouds (423 BC), The Wasps (422 BC), The Peace (421 BC), The Birds (414 BC), Lysistrata (411 BC), Thesmorphoriazusae (411 BC), The Frogs (405 BC), Ecclesiazusa (393 BC), and Plutus (388 BC). Many of Aristophanes’ plays were written as satires. The Knights is a satire about Cleon, an Athenian politician. The Clouds is a satire about Socrates. The Wasps is a

The History Of Theatre: Aristophanes Essay

996 words - 4 pages conservative, since his works show no sympathy for the aristocratic party in Athenian politics. No class, age, or profession was exempt from his satire. Aristophanes wrote more than 40 plays, of which 11 are extant. His first three plays were produced under pseudonyms, including The Acharnians (425 BC), a plea for ending the war with Sparta. The Knights (424 BC), the first of the plays of Aristophanes to be presented under his own name, is a devastating