Autonomy V Paternalism In Mental Health Treatment, Outline And Review Of The Nys Case On Jacob Gordon

2617 words - 10 pages

The assignment for this Ethics class was to review Mr. Jacob's treatment, as described by theNew York State Commission on Quality of Care for the Mentally disabled (1994). The class wasfurther asked to comment on the major issues for each of the three perspectives. The agencies,family and review board were to be included. This student will begin with a fourth perspective;that of Mr. Gordon.In the Matter of Jacob Gordon (1994), is the story of the last eight years of a psychiatricallydisabled man's life. Mr. Gordon appeared to vacillate between striving for autonomy andaccepting the support of his family. Unfortunately, it appeared by this account that the familiessupport was not synonymous with autonomy. It did not appear that Mr. Gordon had ever desiredor sought agency intervention for himself. Mr. Gordon's association with the mental healthsystem appeared to be marked by power and control issues. 'Consumers/ex-patients often report afeeling of 'invisibility'; they sense that their views and desires do not matter (Carling, 1995, p.79 ).'The commission's report (1995) spoke of several incidences where Mr. Gordon eluded to hisdesire for autonomy. Mr. Gordon did not wish to live in a supervised setting. Mr. Gordon did notwish to attend group day treatment settings. Mr. Gordon did not wish to use medication in thetreatment of his mental health disorder. Without medication his behavior was deemedunacceptable and did not permit him the opportunity to have any of these choices. 'Choice is aright-not a privilege to be afforded by good behavior (Penny, 1994, p. 29).' Mr. Gordon's right ofchoice was limited even though he lived in his apartment independently. The condition of hisapartment was scrutinized. His medication was closely monitored; sometimes to the degree that hewas directed to leave his home to receive medication that was given to him crushed, in an attemptto insure it's ingestion. 'Even peoples liberties in a highly controlled board and care home may bescarcely greater than in a hospital ward (Rubenstien, 1994, p.54).' In Mr. Gordon's case evenwithin the sanctity of his own home, his liberties were scarcely greater than in a hospital ward.Other than his autonomy the second issue for Mr. Gordon appears to be the need for safetyand support. For this, Mr. Gordon turned to his family. The report (1994) points out that Mr.Gordon requested his mother be limited in her ability to access personal information. Hecontinued to need her support and assistance although this met she continued to be overlyinvolved in his life. It was his mother he turned to when he had problems with a roommate. Itwas his mother who was utilized when Mr. Gordon was less compliant. It was Mr. Gordon'sfamily who assured that he had continued mental health counseling and services. It was also Mr.Gordon's family who appeared to be the focal point of any plans for Mr. Gordon.'......expectations, soon to be dashed by programs more devoted to servicing neurotic families thanpeople...

Find Another Essay On Autonomy v paternalism in mental health treatment, outline and review of the nys case on Jacob Gordon

Patient-Physician Relationship: The Effects of Autonomy and Paternalism

2390 words - 10 pages the practice of medicine. This ‘patient’s right’ to accept or refuse medical care changed the balance of power in the patient-physician relationship and engaged the patient more in ownership of care plans and it is viewed by patient and physician, essential for honoring the individual and his or her dignity. (4) The effect of autonomy & paternalism:- Both autonomy and paternalism and their effect on patient –physician relationship evolved

The Effects of Forgiveness on Mental Health

2471 words - 10 pages empirical evidence on the effects on mental health of forgiveness. Brown (2003) argues that longitudinal research would reinforce the previous findings. In conclusion individual difference research into forgiveness has began to give us understanding into forgiveness however there is limited findings and more research needs to be conducted. The process models has shown that we o through process and steps before we can forgive the offender. Both the

The Effects of Exercise on Mental Health

1921 words - 8 pages not being complete to date, intends on the participants taking part in one supervised exercise session and two more on their own – leading to the question of how reliable the results can be with self-reported exercise participation. The common theme woven in these five studies is the idea and motivation by the researchers to advance an alternative or concurrent treatment with traditional treatments for mental health conditions (Blumenthal et

Mental Poverty: The degradation of the mental health in America

2182 words - 9 pages outpatient treatment. A study done by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration revealed a major distinction in spending between 1986 and 2005 categorized by an increased utilization of prescription drugs and a decreased reliance on inpatient services. 10 Mental health spending is not directed to individuals in need, but rather to big pharmaceutical companies who take advantage of the blind spending. While expanding Medicaid is

Mental Health in NSW and the Illawarra

570 words - 2 pages or less as a normal person (depending on their illness severity e.t.c) in a living skills centre. All types of people with mental health problems can receive help too, with things such as, adolescent mental health services, child development centres and migrant health services.In conclusion the Illawarra's mental health facilities are fairly good and you can find help for almost any individual with mental health issues.Reference ListYellow Pages Pages

The Breakdown of Mental Health and Stability

1661 words - 7 pages and mentally? Could it be a key factor in this sudden uprising of mental ailments and the loss of many people's emotional and mental balance and stability? There are numerous studies linking stress with a multitude of health problems, many with a neurobiological connection. One of the biggest things stress takes it's toll upon is the immune system. The impact of stress on physical health is clearly evident, as it has been reported that

Legal and Ethecal Issues that impacted on the delivery of mental health care.

2214 words - 9 pages unit, under Section. Over time his wife was unable to cope with the rigors and psychological strain of his illness. Therefore during this lifetime continuum she filed for a divorce, and made an application for him to be sectioned under Section 3 (using Form 8) for treatment in accordance with part II of the Mental Health Act (1983).The legal justification for Sectioning Josh was in the interest of his safety, to protect him from harming himself

The Importance of Regular Exercise on Mental Health.

945 words - 4 pages . Physical activity can change people's perceptions of their physical self and identity in a positive way. Exercise should be promoted regardless of its impact on mental health because of its benefits in preventing and/or curing illnesses and diseases. There is also sufficient evidence to support the use of exercise in the treatment of depression, anxiety and stress (5).According to the National Institute of Mental Health, 9.5 percent of the

Exploring the Impacts of Ageism in the Mental Health and Addictions Sector

1652 words - 7 pages initiatives and by the self-reporting design of the study. However, mental health social workers ironically reported asking older adults for advice while also reporting a tendency of ignoring or dismissing individuals based on their age (Allen, Cherry and Palmore, 2009). In addition, nursing home social workers report higher tendencies of speaking slowly with older adults and attempting to assist them with movement. The authors suggest that

Summary and key notes on the case of Regents of the University of California v. Bakke

845 words - 3 pages petitioner could not take race into account in making admissions decisions, the program was held to violate the Federal and State Constitutions and Title VI. Respondent's admission was not ordered, however, for lack of proof that he would have been admitted but for the special program. A related case is DeFunis v. Odegaard (1974), in which Marco DeFunis, Jr., applied for admission as a first-year student at the University of Washington Law School

Creole Culture and the Idea of Autonomy in Martinique

2054 words - 8 pages , following further than fifty years of public service as mayor of Fort-de-France in Martinique, it is informative to review several of the prominent issues of his writing. Césaire is no outsider to us here in the United States. For the most recent forty years, with growing attention and strength, Americans have been interpretation, teaching, and translating the determining work of this Afro-French philosopher, writer, statesman, and farsighted

Similar Essays

Autonomy Vs. Paternalism In Mental Health Treatment

2577 words - 10 pages Autonomy Vs. Paternalism In Mental Health Treatment The assignment for this Ethics class was to review Mr. Jacob's treatment, as described by the New York State Commission on Quality of Care for the Mentally disabled (1994). The class was further asked to comment on the major issues for each of the three perspectives. The agencies, family and review board were to be included. This student will begin with a fourth perspective; that of Mr

Mental Health: A Literature Review

769 words - 3 pages planning in mental health care:An integrative review of the literature. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 23(9-10), 1175-1185. doi: 10.1111/jocnMachado, V., Leonidas, C., Santos, M.A., & Souza, J. (2012). Psychiatric readmission: Anintegrative review of the literature. International Nursing Review 59, 447-457. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.govMgutshini, T. (2012). Risk factors for psychiatric re-hospitalization: An exploration. International Journal of Mental

A Beautiful Mistreated Mind This Essay Concerns An Often Overlooked Aspect Of The Lives Of People With Mental Health Issues: Their Treatment. It Looks Into The Reasons Why These People Were Neglected...

1647 words - 7 pages the credits role, many people breathe a sigh of relief and murmur "Thank God that does not happen anymore." However, this movie does not incorporate some of the true horror that the mentally disabled and ill still go through to this day. Those with mental issues, a very misunderstood facet of humanity, are much mistreated, unfortunately, most of all by the people enlisted to care for them. But this problem would be easily fixed if those in power

Article Review Of What Are Child Care Social Workers Doing In Relation To Infant Mental Health? An Exploration Of Professional Ideologies And Practice Preferences Within An Inter Agency Context.

984 words - 4 pages act and it may be very hard to see through this. In baby Pete's case it wasn't the infant having mental health problems it was the parents.In conclusion to this paper I think that it worth reading, because social workers don't get as much credit as they should. Generally the public aren't aware of the frameworks and legislations that there are against infant mental health. On the face of it, mental health should not be a pursuit that social workers