This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Being A Critic Of The Arts

1792 words - 7 pages

Being a Critic of the Arts

Everyday, we act as critics, i.e., deciding which film to see or which channel to watch. Much of the time, experience guides us through the aesthetic judgments we make. Left on our own, however, we can go only so far. As Martin and Jacobus (1997) argue, in studying the essentials of criticism and in learning how to put them into practice, we develop our capacities as critics (p. 48).

1. introduction

We all resist taking on the critic's role because we value the participatory experience. Losing ourselves in a "good" film is one thing, and thinking about it critically is another. If we were to choose, we would probably prefer the former. After all, we might argue that art should be enjoyed. By the same token, we know that "good" critics help us appreciate the complexities and the subtleties of works of art. In sharing their insight into the uniqueness of a work, say, they help us appreciate what's going on. In this way, in fact, they help us become critics.

2. the critical response

Usually, the initial response is an emotional one: this can be described as the pre-critical response. What interests us as would-be critics is the critical or reflective response that follows. This reflection can intensify our appreciation of the work in question, i.e., sharpen our perception of its form and increase our understanding of its content. What is problematic for all critics is expressing in the very different medium of conceptual prose that unique, untranslatable quality that pervades a work of art in the medium of music, painting, and so on. As Martin and Jacobus argue, we can distinguish three kinds of criticism or critical activities, which go into the actual writing:

a. Descriptive

Here, the critic concentrates on the form of a work of art and describes the important characteristics of that form in order to improve our understanding of the entire work. In this way, critics turn our attention directly to the work itself, helping us "see" it. In other words, good descriptive criticism calls attention to what we might otherwise miss in artistic form, which we have defined as the interrelationships of part to part and part to whole in a work of art (p. 50).

For example, notice how Martin and Jacobus direct our attention to the three primary images of Aunt Jemima in The Liberation of Aunt Jemima (1972), so as to highlight Betye Saar's use of repetition--thereby emulating advertising's repetition of this cultural icon (as a brand name). As the authors point out, what we see when we glance at the title is an "ironic" liberation (p. 51).

Remember that form has two distinctions:

* details, which are the objective qualities that belong to the work, i.e., the connections of a dancer's movements at one moment to those of a subsequent moment, and

* structure, which concerns itself with the totality of the work of art and the relation of any details or regions to that totality. Of course, structure is...

Find Another Essay On Being a Critic of the Arts

The Benefits of a Liberal Arts College

1134 words - 5 pages out indicating that post-undergraduate students have been more “successful” coming from a liberal arts college than from a large research university. In fact, the idea that liberal arts colleges are the “hidden ivy league” is becoming more popular in society today. The assumption that many make is that attending a liberal arts college for a bachelor’s education costs a whole lot of money, with no return on the investment. Meaning that, a

Critic of "The Convergence of the Twain"

1360 words - 5 pages ; commentary".In line one of the poem "In a solitude of the sea" you get a real sense of being painfully alone. In the second line "Deep from human vanity," I get an image of being stranded in the sea or sinking deeply down into it. In the third line "And the Pride of life that planned her, stilly couches she." The way this is put makes me feel as if this was a predetermined act. Something fated as the source " Poetry of Thomas Hardy, A handbook &amp

"The Critic" Twain, a severe critic of the general public and its cruel, inane conventions, ridicules religion, lower class, and upper class, in "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn."

642 words - 3 pages The CriticMark Twain's novel, "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn," pokes fun at society on all different levels. From dialect and word usage to religion and people's actions, many aspects of society are satirized. This criticism makes the drama in the book light instead of heavy. Twain, a severe critic of the general public and its cruel, inane conventions, ridicules the following three aspects of society; religion, the lower class, as well as

Censorship of the arts

942 words - 4 pages . (This comes from the book Censorship in America) I agree with defenders of government arts funding, that if the government wishes to fund a constitutionally protected activity such as artistic expression, it must do so as indiscriminately as possibly. Otherwise, it illegally relegates certain viewpoints to second-class status. This violates the First Amendment whose primary purpose is to protect unpopular or minority views from being silenced

Bullying Of The Arts

1033 words - 5 pages focused on test. In 12 of 15 school shooting cases in the 1990’s, the shooter had a history of being bullied. The arts have open there doors to bullied victims for a very long time, and have been known to help much with their emotional problems and give the victims a sense of security to be themselves without being harassed, embraced, and picked on. The arts have many branches, there is dance, theater, vocal, band, piano, orchestra, visual

purpose of the arts

841 words - 4 pages Our society today is a visual one that is greatly influenced by the by the arts: painting, prints, dance, photography, movies, television, and literature. Imagine lives without art, businesses would not advertise as easily, we would not be able to look back at the past, or express our inner feelings. The arts help serve many purposes for awareness of social causes, propaganda, and recreating experiences. Social causes are a widely discussed

The Birth of the Reader of the Critic?

987 words - 4 pages “blend and clash” (1324). Instead of the stifling singular meaning that the author and critic create he believes that he reader, “the space on which all the quotations that make up a writing are inscribed without any of them being lost” (1325), should discover the meaning of the text for themselves by playing with the work. Barthes agrees with many of the methods that Wimsatt and Beardsley advocate in their two essays, such as disregarding the

The Arts of Mozart

754 words - 3 pages Description The asterisk (*) represents (zero or more) characters. Thus, the complete expression asks Access to check that the value starts with R (or r), followed by a series of zero or more characters. starts with Like "R*" The text must start with the letter R. ends with Like "*ed" The text must end with the letters ed. Contains Like "*5*" requires that number 5 appears somewhere in a text field You can use the wildcard

The Benefits of a Fine Arts in Education

2614 words - 10 pages disappointment that was regrettably expressed” (Hooke, 2004). This is an example of a tragic incident in regards to fine arts in education being cut in order to pay for other schooling expenses. Fine arts are too important to cut from our children’s education because they gain so many skills from taking these classes. Conclusion Overall, fine arts education is extremely essential to the education of our students. The areas of dance, theater

The Value of a Liberal Arts and Sciences Education

1144 words - 5 pages afford it, should be educated in the seven liberal arts in order to take an active part in civic life. The goal of these studies was to make a well-informed, virtuous and eloquent person. Nowadays, the artes liberales is still a renowned manner of education, but the methods have slightly changed. For instance, it is now called Liberal Arts and Sciences and it is divided in three academic cultures which together include all academic fields. These

The importance of being a Global Citizen

642 words - 3 pages "The essence of the beautiful is unity in variety." - W. Somerset Maugham It's not a secret that our world is far from being perfect. But both now and always there are people who want to make it better. Some of them expresses this through the arts, someone tries to take actions. Bit by bit people have changed their mind about world's arrangement, but the main problems still remain. Our community

Similar Essays

Critic Of The Power Of A Positive No

2418 words - 10 pages get rid of it. On the contrary, when they strongly desire a positive outcome to an exciting or a challenging negotiation, they might yield to any agreement, just to close the deal. Sometimes, they can do so even if the agreement does not meet their objectives. In order to address this human propensity that might be painful both in negotiation circumstances and in everyone’s private life, William Ury wrote the book The Power of a Positive No

Critic Paper About Passion Of The Christ School Critic Papepr

1868 words - 8 pages source of much controversy, and has been used in the past to justify anti-Semitism. Modern Christians do not blame the Jews for the death of Jesus. The Jewish authorities had several reasons for being angry with Jesus: 1. Jesus had challenged their authority - earlier in the week Jesus had gone to the Temple and protested against the moneychangers, as a symbolic denunciation of all the injustices the Temple stood for. 2. Jesus was reinterpreting

The Difference Of How A Theatrical Critic And A Reviewer Look At A Performer

1462 words - 6 pages intelligent in the arts and is a knowledgeable scholar. The general overview of the subject matter in this article is that Cardullo tries to settle the controversy that has occurred with people confusing the occupation of a critic and reviewer. Based on his article, Cardullo establishes that it “is certainly true that the critics—those persons whom the dictionary describes as “skilled in judging the qualities or merits of some class of things

The Role Of A Critic In Defining A Piece Of Art

3336 words - 13 pages world. Eliot's views on the nature and function of criticism and the qualifications of a critic have been elaborated in the essays like: "THE PERFECT CRITIC", "THE IMPERFECT CRITIC", "THE FUNCTION OF CRITICISM", "THE FRONTIERS OF CRITISM". According to Eliot a critic is also credited with the responsibility of preserving the living literary traditions and revealing them in good light. All profound work of arts must be judged by sound literary