This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Being Morally Justified In Disobeying Laws We Consider To Be Immoral

880 words - 4 pages

Being Morally Justified in Disobeying Laws We Consider to be Immoral

The answer to this question depends very much on our understanding and opinion on the status of the law. On this issue it is likely that everyone falls into one of two broad categories. People falling into the first of these categories would be those who consider that through social contract we are obliged to obey the law, whatever the law states and regardless of our opinion on the moral status of that law and that we are morally obliged to operate within the law. Furthermore by this way of thinking we can conclude that if the law binds us over to commit, what we consider to be an immoral act then we must be exempt from guilt as our morality dictates that we should obey the law regardless. Those who fall outside of this category would therefore believe that we are not bound over to obey the law and that in fact we should be morally obliged to disobey any law that we consider to be immoral. There is however a problem with this situation, in so much as it relies on appealing to a set moral code to justify our actions and such a moral code is merely an abstracted system of laws.
I believe that we can be morally justified in disobeying laws, which we consider to be immoral and there are several reasons for this. I believe that it is only possible to happily live in accordance with our own moral code, it may also be possible to live without too much dissatisfaction within the bounds of laws, which dictate a stricter moral code than our own. However I do not believe that it is possible to happily exist under a system of law whereby we are obliged at times to break our own code of morality. In this situation we are likely to find ourselves in a constant struggle between conscience and consequence.
Personal morality could be considered to be a set of internal laws and just like laws existing within a society there is mechanism to prevent us from committing crime. The fear of punishment is an example of one such mechanism: the consequence of committing a given crime out weighs the benefit and as such deters us from committing that crime. Within the realm of our own morality conscience can be seen perform this role, just ac if we contravene laws we must live with punishment, if we break our own morality we must live with our conscience. All of this is fine until a situation arises where our morality clashes with the law, and at that time we are faced with a stark choice, a choice between the punishment...

Find Another Essay On Being Morally Justified in Disobeying Laws We Consider to be Immoral

Gay Marriage Should be Legal Despite Being Immoral

979 words - 4 pages Romney maintained that the voters, not the courts, should decide the legality of gay marriage. This is ostensibly a logical solution-- let the voters decide their own laws. However, as we have mentioned, the majority of people can be wrong, especially when it comes to protecting the rights of those with little power. It is my opinion that one may personally believe gay marriage is immoral while still believing that it should be legally

To What Extent Should Debt Be Justified In The Economy?

1005 words - 5 pages Keynesian economics is the idea that government spending can be used to stabilize the economy, and stresses the importance of moderate economic growth. According to Keynes, during prosperity governments should reduce spending to avoid inflation and to slow down consumer spending in order to maintain stable growth. During times of prosperity Keynesian theory states that governments should pay off debt, reducing the amount of money lost to

Can Terrorism be morally justified? How and when? Or Why not?

2434 words - 10 pages Can Terrorism be morally justified? How and when? Or Why not?On September 11th 2001, two aeroplanes crashed into the world trade centre in New York, this was the horrifying beginning of what would come to be known 'the age of terror.' Although terrorist acts date back decades, it was this attack on the world's most powerful nation, America, that struck fear into the hearts of the Western people and the potential severity of these attacks was

Should we, as citizens, be morally concerned with the poverty and hunger rampant in our world today?

2606 words - 10 pages discuss, because it is not acceptable that in the year of 2006 when we can walk on the moon, clone animals and do the most incredible things but not succeed to give every human being an acceptable standard of living.The poverty is the main reason for starvation. Starvation is the biggest consequence of poverty.Justice is an important conception to reflect when you are discussing poverty and which measure that has to be done to fight it. Poverty

"What Does It Mean To Be A Morally Responsible Teacher In A Social And Political Society"

555 words - 2 pages causing him/her to be unable to focus in class. It is very important to know what is happening in the world and also knowing the students outside of class, but it is also important for a teacher to be able to tell the students their rights and not to bad mouth other teachers. Being a morally responsible teacher means being a teacher of life, not being person who comes to school everyday ignoring the students and not giving a care in the world of what

Revenge, is it morally justified? Refers to The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas

1023 words - 4 pages example when the Abbe was dying, Dantes did not abandon him. Which shows us that Edmond Dantes is a good man.As we can see, Monte Cristo took his revenge in a way that didn't involve any act that was illegal. I think that revenge is morally justified in this particular story, because he did suffer a great deal, and there was a very good reason for his revenge. In every day life taking revenge is somewhat childish, but not taking it is surrendering. In my opinion revenge should be taken, and a person should be punished for a bad thing he did. The power of revenge is found in everyone of us, but we all have to know how to use it wisely.

The name of this essay is "Why We Need Tougher DUI Laws in The United States". This essay is about how the laws need to be tougher for DUI offenders and why

1502 words - 6 pages Why We Need Tougher DUI Laws in The United States There are many reasons that the laws for DUI need to be tougher in The United States of America. The ones that are of greatest concern are the death rates due to DUI offenses, the cost of these offenses and the repeat offender rate. The best way to combat these offenses is to make the fines larger, make the prison sentences stricter and make it harder for the offender to get their license

Is the new policy on steroid testing in Major League baseball morally justified??

958 words - 4 pages The new drug policy issued recently by Major League Baseball regarding steroid use is justified in my opinion (morally would depend on your individual beliefs or values). Today there are many celebrities and sports figures that get paid tremendous amounts of money and are afforded the opportunity to live the high life. When you become famous and part of your income comes from your public image then you owe those who support your lifestyle and

Is the new policy on steroid testing in Major League baseball morally justified??

955 words - 4 pages The new drug policy issued recently by Major League Baseball regarding steroid use is justified in my opinion (morally would depend on your individual beliefs or values). Today there are many celebrities and sports figures that get paid tremendous amounts of money and are afforded the opportunity to live the high life. When you become famous and part of your income comes from your public image then you owe those who support your lifestyle and

Getting Something with Nothing: Way to Be Immoral

736 words - 3 pages University in the United States. They also know downloading illegally is against the uni rule and the state law, but play on it due to an easy online access and the fact that many of them already enjoy a media file for taking, thus think it of not being immoral. Although it rings true as what brings happiness to the greatest number of people is moral, in the long consequence and the individual terms is the conduct certainly immoral. Downloading

Scholars Being Justified in Using the Term Golden Age to Describe the Economic History of Western Europe During 1950-1973

2059 words - 8 pages Scholars Being Justified in Using the Term Golden Age to Describe the Economic History of Western Europe During 1950-1973 ‘Nothing in the history of Western Europe resembles its experience between 1945 and 1968.’ Milward, European rescue, pg. 21 In the quarter of a century that followed the Second World War, the achievements of the European economy were so impressive that the period was often referred to as the

Similar Essays

How Can, Under Catholic Laws, The Killing Of Another Human Being Be Morally Justified?

1470 words - 6 pages evil. The death of the criminal was unintended, and therefore there is sufficiently grave reason to permit the evil effect.There are several situations in which going to war, and therefore killing another human being, can be justified. "The traditional reasons include self-defence, the defence of the homeland, the defence of allies, the bringing back to the status quo after the theft of goods or expropriation of territory, the punishment of guilty

Consider The Relationship Established Between Willy And Linda In The Opening Of The Play. What Do We Learn Here About Their Marriage? What Clues To Future Events Are Subtly Being Introduced Here?

1016 words - 4 pages Consider the relationship established between Willy and Linda in the opening of the play. What do we learn here about their marriage? What clues to future events are subtly being introduced here?Miller establishes the relationship between Willy and Linda as quite one-sided, because of Linda's supportive nature; this unintentionally leads to his tragic downfall.She acts as a mother and in a very sweet manner with him because she recognizes his

“Abortion Is Impermissible, Because It Deprives A Being Of A Future Like Ours. Accordingly, It Is Morally Similar To Killing A Healthy Adult.” Critically Discuss This Argument, Drawing Upon At Least...

1158 words - 5 pages Philosophy essayTopic: "Abortion is impermissible, because it deprives a being of a future like ours. Accordingly, it is morally similar to killing a healthy adult." Critically discuss this argument, drawing upon at least one of the authors we have looked at in the readings.Abortion remains one of the most controversial moral issues. Aside rare exceptions, the perception that abortion is seriously immoral has received little support in

Can Euthanasia Be Justified Morally? Essay

1152 words - 5 pages "morality" in various ways. Aristotle posits that the highest good is always an end and not the means, whilst Hobbes and Locke refute this concept, stating that what is essentially deemed good is all relative to the desires of the agent (the individual or entity) (Macintyre 1996: 57-157). The universally agreed meaning of morality might never be achieved but we can all consent to the "good" being apparent in all that is presumed to be moral. Euthanasia