This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Advantages To A Rigorous Approach To Environmental Virtue Ethics

1854 words - 7 pages

A good ethical theory requires both logical rigor and intuitive appeal to provide an effective tool for understanding what is right and what is wrong. In the field of environmental ethics, there has been significant scholarship in developing a duty ethics based on the inherent value of nature, most notably by Paul Taylor. Taylor indeed provides a logically clear argument for protecting the environment by building on the principles he calls the biocentric outlook (Taylor, 99). While this scholarship has been helpful in offering an explanation for what those who value the environment intuitively recognize, some have noticed that it does not provide positive answers to how we should live (Cafaro, 31). Virtue ethicists, on the other hand, have specifically addressed this question (Sandler, 6), and the result is a very accessible theory that harks back to the classic naturalists like Thoreau (Cafaro). Environmental virtue ethics has its own problems, however; sometimes seems that virtue ethicists are valuing human “flourishing” or “experiences of wonder” before the natural environment they’re claiming to uphold (Rolston, 70). This paper attempts to provide a framework for addressing this critique of environmental virtue ethics by defining the limitations of normative ethical systems and outlining guidelines for environmental virtues as well as some of the advantages a system of virtue ethics has over other ethical approaches.
Ethical Systems
In order to discuss a system of environmental virtue ethics, it is necessary to determine what we mean when we speak of an ethical system. Ethics is a “branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of ultimate value and the standards by which human actions can be judged right or wrong.” (Britannica, “Ethics”) So, an ethical system is a logical framework for evaluating human behavior according to standards of right and wrong. Additional insight is gained by examining the formal conditions presented by Taylor (Taylor, 27.). A summary of these conditions is that an ethical system must be: general in form, universal in application and, as a standard of right and wrong, it must outweigh any non-moral concerns.
Because of this universal nature, these systems are described as normative ethics (as opposed to meta-ethics, which describes the nature of ethics itself, or applied ethics which applies an ethical standard to a practical situation). Any discussion of norms quickly encounters the problems familiar to the other branches of philosophy: Are universal norms? If there are how can we know what they are? How do I demonstrate that something is a norm? These questions are far beyond the scope of any one system of normative ethics and certainly beyond this paper. Thus, we must leave an elaborate justification for the reason for adopting a specific set of norms to different discussion.
To that end, I propose that the purpose of a system of ethics should be to identify a self-consistent set of normative claims that...

Find Another Essay On Advantages to a Rigorous Approach to Environmental Virtue Ethics

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of a scientific approach to the study of society

1625 words - 7 pages absence. Thus if heat, an external stimulus, is applied to matter, that matter will react but positivist approach to human behaviour applies a similar approach that people react to external stimuli and their behaviour can be explained in terms of this reaction for example they enter into marriage and produce children in response to the demands of society; society requires such behaviour for its survival and its members simply respond to this

From Western to Asian Environmental Ethics

3957 words - 16 pages from food exporters to food importers, and African countries increasingly approach starvation as the deserts expand upon once-arable land. The limitations of food, fuel, and land become painfully evident. The only viable solution to these crises involves a changing of ideals, from consumptive to sustainable, from linear "use and dispose" to cyclical "reuse and recycle." In practical terms, this means that everything which is mined, manufactured

A Writer's Approach to Death

870 words - 3 pages A Writer's Approach to Death Although death seems to be a theme for many literary poems, it also appears to be the most difficult to express clearly. Webster’s Dictionary defines the word “death” as, “A permanent cessation of all vital function: end of life.” While this definition sounds simple enough, a writer’s definition goes way beyond the literal meaning. Edwin Arlington Robinson and Robert Frost are just two examples of poetic

A Peaceful Approach to Equality

1032 words - 5 pages the massacre of East St. Louis in 1917 (White, Bay, and Martin 2012, 501). Unlike the violence, which the whites had utilized in their demonstration, the black population took the opposite approach and joined together in a wholly peaceful protest. Nearly 10,000 black Americans, inclusive of men, women, and children, dressed themselves completely in white and united together to march silently down Fifth Avenue in New York City (White, Bay, and

A Peaceful Approach to Equality

1772 words - 8 pages during the massacre of East St. Louis in 1917 (White, Bay, and Martin 2012, 501). Unlike the violence, which the whites had utilized in their demonstration, the black population took the opposite approach and joined together in a wholly peaceful protest. Nearly 10,000 black Americans, inclusive of men, women, and children, dressed themselves completely in white and united together to march silently down Fifth Avenue in New York City (White, Bay

A Natural Approach to Migraines

2073 words - 8 pages A Natural Approach to Migraines Research has shown surprising links between migraines and food. Certain foods can cause migraines, while others can prevent or even treat them. Coffee, for example, can sometimes knock out a migraine and foods rich in magnesium, calcium, complex carbohydrates, and fiber have been used to cure migraines. Some reports suggest that ginger-the ordinary kitchen spice-may help prevent and treat migraines with none of

Aristotle's Approach to Ethics and Plato's Divided Line

780 words - 3 pages Aristotle's Approach to Ethics and Plato's Divided Line I. PLATO 3) Explain the so-called ‘Divided Line’. What do the different levels mean? How does this apply to ethics? How does this apply to Knowledge, perception, and/or awareness? Explain in depth and detail. Plato’s ‘Divided Line’ is a model indicating not only levels of knowledge, but basically levels of everything. It is divided into four levels and two sides. The

A New Approach to a Healthier Future

1246 words - 5 pages certain diseases (e.g. hypertension, diabetes). The EOSS helps health care professionals determine which patient’s do not need to lose weight at all. This in turn will reduce health care costs. Lastly, I recommend a shift in the approach to obesity prevention by emphasising Health at Every Size (HAES). HAES promotes weight maintenance and body acceptance. It also supports the reliance on internal processes, such as hunger and satiety instead of

Situation Ethics, Natural Moral Law And Utilitarian Approach To Sexual Ethics - Philosophy and Ethics - Essay

1607 words - 7 pages ‘Demonstrate The Differences Between The Situation Ethics, Natural Moral Law And Utilitarian Approach To Sexual Ethics.’ In Christianity, sex before marriage is typically scorned. Therefore, Christian youth are advised to don ‘Purity Rings’ which symbolise their pledge to abstain from sex until they are married (however, Ariely claims that providing youth with condoms is more effective as they tend to behave irrationally when aroused and break

A Systems Approach to the Employment Process

2630 words - 11 pages the employment process form an interconnected web where any changes in one phase will undoubtedly influence other phases. Or to put it more simply, it boils down to a systems approach to looking at the employment process. 3. A systematic approach to human resources needs The main problem that Monomotapa Mining has to deal with at the moment is the lack of a systematic procedure for anticipating and responding to their human resource needs. This

A Systems Approach to Small Group Interaction

2816 words - 11 pages A Systems Approach to Small Group Interaction Introduction For the purposes of this assignment I will be discussing a group of which I am a part of in my place of employment. In my career as an employee of the State of California working for the Department of Transportation—CalTtrans, I am involved with district-wide accident prevention committee. This committee referred to as the DAPC, is comprised Of members of management, as well

Similar Essays

Virtue Ethics Approach Essay

1011 words - 4 pages solution to specific moral dilemmas b. Not everyone has the equal opportunity to develop morally – do we judge them the same? c. Many non-virtuous people live happy lives, many virtuous people are miserable d. Cultural relativism – whose virtues are best? e. We recognise that some non-virtuous people are useful in our society; life would be dull without them 2. What are the strengths of using a virtue ethics approach to resolve your case study

Virtue Ethics' Application To Business Ethics

2410 words - 10 pages approach to ethics which relies on universal principles, results in a rigid and inflexible moral code, which we are obliged to follow as moral agents. These rigid rules are counterproductive because they oblige people to follow a certain way. Proponents of virtue ethics would argue in our secular society people don’t want to have a lawgiver, rather to make their own informed choice. Particularly in Kant’s ethics is a certain

The Alternative View To Virtue Ethics

1093 words - 4 pages . Some of the attractiveness that virtue theories enjoy is due to a misunderstanding of rival moral theories. Advocates of virtue ethics sometimes offer self-characterisations that make them appear to offer advantages that are in fact shared by rival, sophisticated moral theories. For example, some virtue theories tell us to habituate rule following, because we want to develop character, or an internalisation of the rules, a

What Is Virtue Theory? "Virtue Ethics Is Of Little Practical Use To Someone Faced With A Moral Problem." Discuss

1103 words - 4 pages AVirtue Theory is the theory that right actions follow from becoming a moral person, and that by becoming a moral person we will automatically know what is right and wrong. When we know what is truly right or wrong we have flourished as humans, and we have eudemonia. Virtue ethics is one of the main forms of normative ethics, and often called arêtaic ethics (arête- virtue, from Greek). It contrasts deontology, which emphasizes rules