Machiavellian And Kantian Analysis Of Buddy Fletcher And Sec

1748 words - 7 pages

Machiavellian Analysis
Buddy Fletcher was able to use his financial success and philanthropy to win respect and power. His high esteem combined with his ability to deliver strong profits lead to blind deference. As Machiavelli wrote, “he who is highly esteemed is not easily conspired against”11 (Ch. 19). In the beginning of his career, Fletcher embodies the spirit of a Machiavellian leader by commanding influence through his success. However, in the spirit of Kant, he seems to adhere to strong moral principles, such as not lying and using others as merely means to his end.
However, as details of his success were revealed, his moral character becomes increasingly questionable. Firstly, he did not disclose the methods by which he was making enormous profits, and the stakeholders, with their singular desire for profit, did not care about the legitimacy of its conception nor did not ask questions. As Machiavelli writes, “It is unnecessary for a prince to have all good qualities… but it is very necessary for a prince to appear to have them”11 (Ch. 18). Fletcher looked like an upstanding citizen. He donated to charity and was extremely smart and charming. Machiavelli also writes, “the means will always be considered honest… because the vulgar are always taken by what a thing seems to be and by what comes of it”11 (Ch. 18). This points to Fletcher’s ability to appeal to unwitting investors, paralleling the “common folk” Machiavelli rudely called “the vulgar”. Through charm and exciting results, he convinced many to invest in his fund. As long as he maintained the image and promise of high returns, it did not matter how the ends were achieved.
As we now know, it was all a fugazzi, and his motivations were self-serving. He took money directly out of the funds for personal use and was not successful in generating the high returns he promised. While Machiavelli would have supported this deception, Kant would not. He lied, cheated and stole his way to a position of influence, harming many in the process.
Machiavelli also writes that the end justifies the means11 (Ch. 18). According to this, any casualties in the process of attaining his goal are justified if the long-term goal is accomplished. In the case of Buddy Fletcher, he believes that his actions are justified because they serve a greater goal of promoting civil rights, his major philanthropic cause. However, in the process of acquiring wealth to promote civil rights, he loses millions of dollars of investor funds, ultimately not even securing funds to promote his causes.

Kantian Analysis
Kant’s ethical theory provides an unwavering framework for determining the ethics of actions. Kant believed that actions could be dictated by a set of maxims that govern our actions. Further, these actions must be universalizable. By making actions dependent on maxims, Kant says that the “morality of our actions depends not on their results, but on our maxims”12 (pg. 148). By acting in accordance to a maxim,...

Find Another Essay On Machiavellian and Kantian Analysis of Buddy Fletcher and SEC

On Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics Essay

1914 words - 8 pages 1. Introduction There is little doubt that Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics are by far the two most important ethical theories throughout contemporary philosophy. Though both attempt to answer questions about morality and behavior, the two theories have many fundamental differences: one evaluates actions in terms of the utility they produce whereas the other considers whether actions fulfill duty; one emphasizes consequence where the other

Kantian Ethics and Christian Ethics Essay

1711 words - 7 pages Kantian Ethics and Christian Ethics Immanuel Kant the founder of the "Categorical Imperative" (CI) argues that morality is based on standards of rationality. Therefore, to act in disaccord with the CI is to act irrationally or immorally. In comparison to Christianity, to act immorally is to act in disagreement with God's laws. Kant's CI is formulated into three different ways, which include: The Universal Law Formulation, The Humanity or End

The Fated Donor: A Case Analysis on Kantian Philosophy,Imperative, Will, and Human Dignity

1462 words - 6 pages The Fated Donor: A Case Analysis on Kantian PhilosophyImperative, Will, and Human DignityIt is a common knowledge that Immanuel Kant's philosophy focused in autonomy, rights, and respect. To better understand Kantian philosophy, a case is presented below which can be analyzed in the light of his propositions, particularly regarding imperatives, will, and human dignity. To facilitate the analysis, the arguments of the persons involved in the case


1209 words - 5 pages . However Machiavelli criticizes religious institutions that are corrupt, which in that time period were involved in politics and in turn caused corruption inside the citizenry and divisions in the state. This essay will examine Machiavelli's analysis of religion and discuss the relationship between religion and politics in Machiavelli's texts. In the subject of Machiavelli's view on religion's relationship to political authority he feels religion is

Political Action and Morality in Machiavellian Times

1453 words - 6 pages The Renaissance era of Europe produced a great multitude of political thinkers. Among this plethora is perhaps the most controversial philosopher of his age, Niccolò Machiavelli. The Florentine politician, known most famously for his work, The Prince, discusses, among other things, the relationship between morality and political action. However, unlike the vast majority of his European predecessors, who often argued that political power should

The Utilitarian and Kantian Perspective: Prompt #2

1068 words - 5 pages “Happiness has an intrinsic value in and of itself”, or in other words not dependent on anything else to define its worth (Wetzell PP). Life on the other hand gets tricky. In the context of war, the human life’s value is based on the ability to contribute to the war, whether fighting and carrying out orders as a soldier or collaborating to make strategic plans to reach victory as a general. It is interesting to think that the human life

The Bell Jar, Sylvia Plath, Struggles between Buddy, Doreen, and within herself

1247 words - 5 pages Southern blonde sex kitten who always knows how to get her man;(Perloff ,CLC Vol. 62 p.392). Doreen was the girl who Esther wanted to be deep inside, yet she could not because she had to be a good girl. Betsy, who is the college good girl, is also a friend of Esthers. She is the girl who is straight from Kansas with her bouncing blonde pony-tail and Sweetheart-of-Sigma-Chi(Plath 6). Old friends, like Buddy Willard visited her at college and


1286 words - 5 pages At first glance, Machiavelli and Han Fei Tzu may seem extremely alike in their attitudes towards ethics and politics. Although both philosophers lived in a different period of time and part of the world, their similarity in thoughts categorized them under the same title as "Machiavellian thinkers".However, with a closer examination of their writings, it is not unreasonable to notice that they are, to a certain extent, different in both

Kantian Peace Theory: Insight Ino the Future Relations Between the United States and China

684 words - 3 pages The rise of China as a global power is a troubling concept for many Americans. China's economy is one of the fastest growing in the world and China holds a plurality of the US national debt. The two countries are inextricably linked, which is one reason why a change in the status quo is an unsettling idea. Kantian Peace Theory may offer an insight into the future relations between the United States and China. If we look at the first principle

An Analysis of Iago’s Characterization in “Iago’s Art of War: The “Machiavellian Moment” in Othello” by Ken Jacobsen

904 words - 4 pages As well, a Machiavellian villain is someone who can be categorized as duplicitous or deceitful. Jacobsen does not elaborate as fully on this point however, that is not to say there is no evidence in the play. Jacobsen does say that, “No ideal of civic virtue or social solidarity animates the innovator’s pursuit of power; he cares only to achieve “peculiar” or private ends, and he inflames the private resentments of the other characters, turning

Leadership and Ethics Course, Through Military Discussing Ethical Decisions as They Relate To Utilitarian Teleologist, Kantian Deontologist and Decision Making,

3080 words - 12 pages protection. Additionally the Kosovo Liberation army is pressuring a male interpreter for information regarding the police. The threats have been entirely directed at the interpreters and not towards the other locally employed staff.AimThe aim of this essay is to discuss the morally right thing to do from the aspect of a utilitarian teleologist, Kantian deontologist and the reasoning behind their decision whether or not to obey the order or to

Similar Essays

Machiavellian And Proud Essay

734 words - 3 pages Those who are known to use cunning and deceiving tricks to get ahead are often called Machiavellian. Yet, they can also be described as realistic and practical. Unlike Plato, Niccolo Machiavelli sees mankind as it truly is. Machiavelli knows what humans really want and he sees us for what we really are. Whether that be selfish, conceiving, ungenerous, or immoral, it is true. He shows us how to use all our qualities to better ourselves, and how

Utilitarianism And Kantian Ethics Essay

1178 words - 5 pages Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics      Ethics is one part of philosophy that will always be studied, and like most subjects in philosophy, will never be viewed the same by everyone. There are so many cultures that have so many different beliefs about the way a person's life should be lived out. Things like religion, poverty, and mental health all contribute to our beliefs in ethics. Some people believe that the

The Machiavellian Analysis Of Politics

1834 words - 7 pages to the times only to be prosperous, but more importantly to retain and gain power. In the case of President John F. Kennedy during the Civil Rights Movement, the Machiavellian analysis of politics holds true. United States President John F. Kennedy experienced the full swing of the Civil Rights Movement that was attempting to end an era of racial discrimination in the United States when he took office. Acknowledging the rising racial issues that

Hamlet's Famous Soliloquy And Machiavellian Sense Of Being And Acting

1541 words - 6 pages 9. "Hamlet" is famous for its soliloquies. Choose one and carefully explain its meaning and its significance for the plot. You may consider issues from any of the above questions, but please be sure to relate the soliloquy to Machiavelli.HAMLET'S FAMOUS SOLILOQUY AND MACHIAVELLIAN SENSE OF BEING AND ACTINGNiccolo Machiavelli, in his book, "The Prince" is brave enough to give the leaders of his day a guide for leadership. In this work, the