This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Bilingual Education Essay

2022 words - 8 pages

Bilingual education, as an educational program, was initially promoted by educators in the seventies (Hunger of Memory 26) and since then has been a topic of many debates in America. Some argue that bilingual education only serves as a detriment to American culture. Others argue that bilingual education is beneficial to those who come to live in America and want to become a part of the culture, but lack proficiency in the English language. Two authors, who have each taken opposite sides of the debate on bilingual education in America, are: Richard Rodriguez and Ariel Dorfman. Richard Rodriguez believes that bilingual education creates a feeling of separateness between foreign language speakers and American society; therefore, delaying the formation of a public identity. In contrast, Ariel Dorfman argues that bilingualism in America will be a bridge to better understanding other cultures. I assume the position of being neither, against or entirely in favor of bilingual education. I am in favor of bilingual education because it can be an effective segue to learning the English language and I believe it is very important to remain connected with our family’s language and culture. However, I also recognize the negative feeling of separateness from the larger public that bilingual education can have on foreign language speaking families, which hinders my ability to fully embrace bilingual education.
Ariel Dorfman is an Argentinian author who struggled throughout his life to find a balance between the Spanish and English languages. As a result of Dorfman’s “bilingual journey” (Heading South 25), he argues that bilingual education is beneficial to American society. Dorfman believes that bilingualism will serve as a channel to better understanding the multitude of cultures that are present in America. Dorfman, in his essay “If Only We All Spoke Two Languages”, states, “The bilingual method, in spite of what its detractors claim, does not imprison a child in his or her original language. Rather, it keeps it alive in order to build bridges to English.” (1). One language does not have to be sacrificed in order to acquire a new language. Both languages (original and new) can be seen as complimentary and not as substitutes for one another, therefore creating a stronger bond between languages. Also arguing against the immersion method, which Richard Rodriguez is in favor of, Dorfman states that, “The immersion method…wants youngsters to cut their ties to the syllables of their past culture. Both methods can work. I should know. I have endured them both. But my experience was unquestionably better with bilingual education.” (“If Only” 1). Recognizing the importance of remaining connected with one’s culture, the immersion method seems rather futile as a method of education for foreign language speaking children, as it results in the removal of their original culture. Dorfman makes a strong case for Americans to accept bilingual education and the benefits it...

Find Another Essay On Bilingual Education

Bilingual Education Essay

1643 words - 7 pages An Integral Aspect of the No Child Left Behind Philosophy Introduction Bilingual education, by definition, is an ?education strategy that uses English and the native language of students in classroom instruction? (Johnson, 2002). This strategy is at the center of an ongoing debate among educators, government officials and parents of children whose primary language is not English. The premise of proponents of bilingual education is that children

Bilingual Education Essay

1354 words - 5 pages Bilingual education is any school program which utilizes two languages. An example of legal rationale in regarding bilingual education is English being the only language approach that is taught to English language learners in the United States in school districts according to No Child Left Behind Act of 2001(NCLB). However, historical rationale concerning bilingual education is the history of events that occurred due to bilingual education not

Bilingual Education

520 words - 2 pages opportunities in the workforce that students who only speak one language will not have.Some positive effects of obtaining a bilingual education is that it makes an individual more competent in the workforce. Being bilingual gives you the opportunity to interact with both sides of a nation, the chance to conduct business more efficiently with other countries. Being bilingual is not a non-language deficient but it is a language-endowed! Being

Bilingual Education

1693 words - 7 pages Bilingual Education      Education is very important. There use to be a time when you didn’t have to go to school. When it was only important for men to have an education. Times have really changed. Now it is crucial for everyone in our society to have an education. Survival is the main reason: a cohesive society is another. Our schools today need to keep Bilingual education as a tool for teaching: not only for the

Bilingual Education

1189 words - 5 pages Bilingual Education = Unilingual Education Bilingual education in America is a sound idea, but it is not truly bilingual education, it is only bilingual for those who do not already speak English. America is a country with more and more cultures mixing together with different areas of America speaking different languages. In California, Spanish is the dominant language next to English, and in states such as Maine, French is spoken. Other

Bilingual Education

923 words - 4 pages Bilingual Education Public Relations Address – Multiculturalism Celebration Saturday, April 7, 2001 – Central Park Keep bilingual education programs in New York City’s Public Schools Buena tarde, Bonsoir, Gutenabend, Buoa sera…Good evening! I would like to thank you the Concerned Clergy Organization for inviting me. And I would also like to acknowledge my esteemed fellow panelists, Dr. Hopkins and Sarah Jenkins (nod in respect

Bilingual Education - 1189 words

1189 words - 5 pages Bilingual Education Bilingual Education Bilingual education has often been defined simply as the use of two languages as the medium of instruction within a school curriculum. One of the languages used is the students' native language, and the other is the language used to educate students in a particular country-that is, the majority language. The specific purpose of bilingual education is to teach academic content to

Bilingual Education - 1059 words

1059 words - 5 pages bilingual program (Laureate Education, n.d.). Dr. Stritikus asserts that it takes between four to seven years for students learning another language to be able to meet the academic demands of the second language. With this in mind, it takes everyone involved in the school community to be activists and understand the challenges the bilingual student faces. These demands stretch across the entire student curriculum, not just English class. The

Bilingual Education - 634 words

634 words - 3 pages As the government and citizens of California know, the population is growing rapidly. Most of the population are Spanish speaking people. In schools, the ongoing controversy of bilingual education is beginning to strike the curiosities of administrators and parents as well. Some people believe schools should not provide bilingual classes and force Spanish speaking students into an environment of the English language only. I, on the other hand

Bilingual Education - 1571 words

1571 words - 6 pages Bilingual Education Our school systems play host to dozens of languages in addition to the standard fare of English. Starting in the late 1960s, partially as a swing off the Civil Rights Movement, school systems were required by law to provide bilingual education anytime twenty or more children spoke the same foreign language, and were found to be limited in their English proficiency. At first, the need for such programs was small, but

Bilingual Education - 1479 words

1479 words - 6 pages Bilingual education was first initiated in 1968. It was a new means to educate the children who spoke a minority language. thirty-one years later the same problems exist for those children who speak a language other then English. The experiment of Bilingual education has been a failure and now it’s time to move on. The first English only initiatives were brought forth in 1981 by newly elected president Reagan. Since then the conflict over

Similar Essays

Bilingual Education Essay 1597 Words

1597 words - 6 pages Benefits of Bilingual Education David Hosterman The issue of bilingual education is a very controversial issue and many people have different views concerning this subject. "Bilingual education began in 1968 as a small, $7.5 million federal program to help Mexican-American students, half of whom could not speak English well when they entered first grade" (Chavez 23). In addition, it began 23 years ago as a historic order for busing

Bilingual Education Essay

552 words - 2 pages Bilingual Education OutlineIntroductionAccording to the National Association for Bilingual Education, bilingual education is defined as, "the meaning of any use of two languages in school, by teachers or students or both for a variety of social and teaching purposes".In other words this means in a school environment where information to the students is presented in two or more languages, and any school system using more than one language for

Bilingual Education Essay 967 Words

967 words - 4 pages Schools throughout the United States have to deal with a growing number of students speaking different languages. The bilingual education system was first introduced in the 1960s (Donegan 3) as an alternative way to solve social problems at the time when ethnic-pride-movement supporters insisted that all ethnic subcultures should be treated equally. The program's original goal was to offer minority language students the way to improve written

Bilingual Education Essay 876 Words

876 words - 4 pages English Immersion V.S Developmental Bilingual education in Public schools for Spanish speaking students. RITA MONTERO, Parent: He was bringing home pieces of paper that he had written "dog, cat, ball" across the top of the page. And this child was reading full books at home, and so to be writing this across a sheet of paper was just not doing it. So I said to the teacher this is it; I want him to be taken out and put in an English-speaking class