This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Billy Budd Essay: Comparing Christ To Billy

3262 words - 13 pages

Comparing Christ to Billy of Billy Budd

      "I stand for the heart. To the dogs with the head!" wrote Herman Melville in his June 1851 letter to Nathaniel Hawthorne (Davis and Gilman 3). Yet, by the time he began writing Billy Budd, Sailor in 1888, Melville must have tempered this view, for Billy Budd depicts the inevitable destruction of a man who is all heart but who utterly lacks insight. Melville no doubt intends for his reader to connect this tale with the gospel of Jesus Christ. Billy Budd endures a persecution similar to Christ's; he is executed for like reasons, and he eventually ascends, taking "the full rose of the dawn" (BB 376). Yet, in creating Billy Budd, Melville forms a character who is but a half-Christ, more like the Child than the Man. Indeed, a number of characteristics and circumstances sharply distinguish Billy Budd from the complete Christ. These differences ultimately work to support Melville's (now refined) philosophy that innocence, unaccompanied by wisdom, must inevitably meet with destruction and that only when a man balances the "spontaneous impulses of [his] 'heart'" against the experiential "wisdom of [his] 'head'" (Howard 328) can he prevail in a fallen world.


Critics often connect Billy Budd with the Christ Child. Richard Chase, for instance, writes that Billy Budd is the realization of Melville's "fresh commitment to the infantile Christ" (267), and Milton Stern claims that Billy's behavior represents an "ideal Christliness" because he accepts "everything with animal insightlessness and the childlike faith of innocence" (216). Christ taught that to enter heaven, one must become like a little child (Matt. 18:2-3). Many have inferred from this that, from a Christian perspective, childlike ignorance must be good while experience and wisdom must be bad. Yet, in so doing, they apparently forget that not only did Christ evaluate things with insight, but He also insisted that His disciples be "wise as serpents" as well as "harmless as doves" (Matt. 10:16).


Billy Budd is neither. He may possess the heart of Christ in that he usually unconditionally loves others, but he lacks "any trace of the wisdom of the serpent." Nor is he "yet quite a dove" (BB 300). If a peacemaker, he is a "fighting peacemaker" (BB 296). He does not, as Christ taught men to do, turn the other cheek to insults. (Unless, of course, he fails to recognize them.) When "the Red Whiskers . . . insultingly [gives] him a dig under the ribs," he hits the man (BB 295). Yet the "Red Whiskers" grows to love Billy nonetheless, probably because the sailor has a harmless heart, if not a harmless arm. Billy is like the Christ Child--loving, innocent, and never maliciously harmful--but he little resembles the mature Man.


Melville, as can be discerned from reading his novels, was clearly no orthodox Christian. However, he had a more complete view of Christ than that with which most critics credit him, a more complete view,...

Find Another Essay On Billy Budd Essay: Comparing Christ to Billy

Billy Budd Essay

2773 words - 11 pages To form simply one opinion or show merely one aspect of this story is naive, rude, and closed minded. How may one stick to one deli mea, moral questioning, or out-look on a book that jumps from such cases like frogs on lily pads? Just as Melville has done, I shall attempt to arrange my perception of Billy Budd, in a similar fashion. That is, through an unorthodox practice (that is; jumping from pt. to point), of writing an essay I shall

Billy Budd Essay

708 words - 3 pages enemy. Claggart later wishes to have Billy punished, so he lies to the captain of the ship, saying that Billy Budd is the leader of a rebellion. Claggart's blatant lies angers Billy to the point where he can't think of a response and thus hits Claggart on the head. This is the turning point for Billy, as he is momentarily converted from gentle and loving to vicious and aggressive. Billy is completely shocked by his own actions, and saddened

Billy Budd

1920 words - 8 pages , Captain Vere and Billy Budd, I will examine their relationship in the context of what Neitzsche calls the "contractual relationship between creditor and debtor" in the second essay of On The Genealogy Of Morals entitled, "’Guilt,’ ‘Bad Conscience,’ and the like." Captain Vere is the creditor and Billy Budd is the debtor. According to Nietzsche, "the major moral concept Schuld [guilt] has its origin in the very material concept Schulden [debts

Billy Budd

576 words - 2 pages In the story Billy Budd, written by Herman Melville, there is a pattern of symbolism the author is trying to convey. Melville notes the symbolism of "Innocence" in the character of Billy Budd, a bright-eyed, twenty-one year old sailor in the British Fleet. He notes the symbolism of "Justice" in the character Captain Vere, nicknamed "Starry Vere", a bachelor of about forty, and the captain of the ship Bellipotent. He also notes

Billy Budd

1039 words - 4 pages righteous will triumph over evil at the end, even over death.      The protagonist, Billy Budd, is the major force of innocence in the book. Billy is a young man who seems to have everything going for him. He is big, strong, handsome, and he has a personality that draws everyone to him. Everywhere he went he charmed people, gaining the respect of those around him. A great deal of imagery is used describing how

Billy budd

1116 words - 4 pages the end, even over death. The protagonist, Billy Budd, is the major force of innocence in the book. Billy is a young man who seems to have everything going for him. He is big, strong, handsome, and he has a personality that draws everyone to him. Everywhere he went he charmed people, gaining the respect of those around him. A great deal of imagery is used describing how aesthetically perfect Billy is. Besides Billy's stutter, he seems

Billy Budd

626 words - 3 pages Discussing good and evil are very relevant. In a way good and evil are stuck together, because usually when there is good there is always evil. For example, when you read a story there is usually a hero and a villain. Good can be explained as a person who shows unstoppable love for life and a heart of pure virtue. To me a person who is good is one who is trustworthy like Billy Budd. Budd was very trustworthy in his works and towards others. A

Billy Budd - 780 words

780 words - 3 pages BILLY BUDD      There are many ways you can argue if the novel Billy Budd was a good novel or a bad one. You can determine this by looking at such things as plot, character, and the use of language. The book is about a sailor that has been impressed (the act of forcibly taking sailors and making them serve in the navy) by the British navy. It is set in the late 1700’s during the French Revolution which overthrew the

Essay on the Dilemma of Billy Budd

683 words - 3 pages ;   After the hanging of Billy Budd, the story no longer relates the events on board the Indomitable. For this reason we are never shown Vere's emotional reaction to the decision to kill Budd. The only reaction we get is immediately before the death, when Billy cries out, "God bless Captian Vere!" At this moment, Vere "stood erectly rigid as a musket in the ship armorer's rack." Melleville accounts for Vere's emotion at this point by

Irony in Billy Budd

604 words - 2 pages Billy Budd is a story filled with irony. This literary aspect can be seen through the plot and characters of the work. As defined in The American Heritage Dictionary, irony is the use of words to convey the opposite of their literal meaning. After a casual reading of the story' the many ironic aspects may have been igonred, but after analyzing the story it becomes obvious that they are of great importance. "...The fate of each character is

Billy Budd (play)

639 words - 3 pages There is much to be said about innocence. If one is withinnocence than one can do no wrong. But that is not all to be said.Innocence is not always a good thing. It could make one naive or blindto certain evils. Like in the case of Billy Budd. Billy was innocentfrom evil and therefore could not see the evil of John Claggartapproaching him, out to destroy him. It is known Billy's innocence washis down fall by hiding the true evil from his eyes

Similar Essays

Comparing Billy Budd And Christ Essay

3108 words - 12 pages Comparing Billy and Christ in Billy Budd Herman Melville's Billy Budd provides us with a summation and conclusive commentary on the ambiguities of moral righteousness and social necessity. The conflict that arises pitting natural justice in opposition to military justice essentially deliberates over whether the sacrifice of the individual is required for the continuum and conservation of social order. The deep allegorical theme of the

Billy Budd, Sailor Essay

841 words - 4 pages , Captain the Honorable Edward Fairfax Vere, who was linked to God with Billy linked to Jesus. How? According to the Bible, God had to sacrifice his own son Jesus Christ to obtain obedience from his Kingdom. In Billy Budd, Sailor, Vere was perceived to possess strong feelings of care for Billy almost like a father would for a son. Vere had an internal conflict that had him choose between Billy to stay alive or dye because Billy had allegedly killed

Billy Budd Essay

1313 words - 5 pages Often a person is torn between doing his duty, and doing what is right. This is a common problem to many people in everyday life, a problem that can have terrible results, such as death. Many authors have had to deal with making a tough choice, and so they try to capture the struggle between duty and heart in their books. A prime example of this is Billy Budd by Herman Melville. In this novel, Captain Vere was the man who found himself

Billy Budd Essay

885 words - 4 pages Billy Budd & Typee takes place around the late 1700’s. Billy Budd is assigned to The British naval ship H.M.S. Bellipotent from his previous ship the Rights-of-Man, a merchant ship. Billy's commanding officer, Captain Graveling, doesn’t want to let one of his best men go, but has does not have choice in the face of the superior ship.       Billy packs up his gear and follows the officer of the Bellipotent. After