Bioethics And Health Care Essay

1581 words - 6 pages

The controversy with community water fluoridation arises from moral, ethical, political and safety concerns with respect to water fluoridation. As far back as 1930, there was a relationship inversely between the levels of fluoride in drinking water and existence of dental caries. Any practice like fluoridation, which uses the public water supply to deliver the medicine violated the medical ethics. The ethical issues associated with the water fluoridation include- balancing risks and benefits, presence of any other interventions with the same outcome, the role of consent. Fluoridation violates the principle of informed consent. On the other hand, in public health practice the principle of beneficence has more weight than the principle of autonomy.
There were two objections because the fluoridation of water has some undesirable side effects such as development of Down syndrome and Cancer in the areas where fluoridated water is supplied. Apart from this, the second objection was allied to it being a compulsory medication. Opponents insist compulsory community water fluoridation violates the ethical principle of autonomy. Objection due to suspicion of more amount of fluoride which leads to cancer is justifiable with the ethical principle of Non-maleficence. However, it is not actually based on scientific aspects. The second objection i.e. compulsory medication is related to the principle “autonomy” this demonstrates the controversy between the principle of autonomy and positive effects of community water fluoridation (beneficence).
However, in Britain (1985), the report of the working committee on fluoridation of water and cancer has no evidence in development of cancer in association with fluoridation of water. And many other groups reached the same conclusion. Harris in his article pointed that, in a society we have to accept the diminution in our autonomy. (Harris). The ethics committee should be elaborated to incorporate community and primary care services, and certainly department of public health. The public health should respect the individual rights of the community and achieve community health. So, many questions arise here e.g. Is mass medication of uncontrolled dose of fluoride in community water supplies wrong? Is fluoridation right if there are fewer risks than benefits?
LITERATURE OVERVIEW: The literature review revealed that the first argument against the community water fluoridation was related to the principle of autonomy. There are many people who are drinking artificial fluoridated water worldwide due to the supply of fluoridated water in many countries. Some countries like china, India and Africa have areas with natural fluoride levels in water. As fluoride causes many health related problems these countries are taking some measures to remove the levels of fluoride content in water.
In 1957, New Zealand Commission of Inquiry put at rest the ethical concerns related to water fluoridation because they found...

Find Another Essay On Bioethics and Health Care

Racism and Health Care Disparity Essay

1332 words - 5 pages Is Racism the cause of Health care disparity? In recent discussions of health care disparities, a controversial issue has been whether racism is the cause of health care disparities or not. On one hand, some argue that racism is a serious problem in the health care system. From this perspective, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) states that there is a big gap between the health care quality received by minorities, and the quality of health care

Socioeconomic Status and Health Care Essay

2097 words - 8 pages Socioeconomic Status and Health Care Sharing My Own Perspective There is a strong correlation with an individual or group SES and the quality of health care received. Social Economic Class relates to what group of class an individual fit in based on their income, which can include wages, investments or other source. The quality of care depends on the facilities that is offering the services, the staff, accessibility to the service and the

Technology and Health Care Paper

1457 words - 6 pages Technology and Health Care PaperFebruary 25, 2013AbstractIn the today's global world, technology has grown rapidly and there seems to be no signs of it ever slowing down soon. Computer software's have provided technological advancements in the health care industry. Consultants have become synonymous within the medical practices and community to provide a wide range of innovative ideas that is geared to making any organization thrive. ABC

Health Care and Tort Reform

1649 words - 7 pages Rising health care costs have caused a national crisis, and all agree we must embrace reform. President Obama has initiated his national health care plan in the hopes of decreasing some of the inflated costs. When attempting to resolve this issue, one must always address the root of the problem. A large portion of these inflationary costs stem from malpractice lawsuits, and so begins the debate for tort reform: legislation which would cut the

Health Care and Insurance Coverage

845 words - 4 pages Everyone knows that in order to be a functional human being, your health must be in order. Bacteria and diseases can be devious forces if someone's system is not equipped to fight them off. In order to prevent said things from attacking our immune systems, we go to the doctor for guidance in the areas of taking care of ourselves, but going to these doctors has a price. Most people living comfortably would tell you that their insurance covers

Health and Social Care Management

4825 words - 19 pages Safya KhanStudent number :03018293Word count: 4613Post Graduate Certificate in Health and Social Care Management.Managing Self and OthersModule No : HHM-705TAssignment Type: 5000 words essayA review of your role as Manager and appraisal of your effectiveness in Managing others.An analysis of your management style and the impact it has on others.A discussion of your personal development needs and how you intend to address these needs.A Personal

Elderly Health Care: The Line Between Care and Killing

1046 words - 4 pages The article Elderly health care: The line between care and killing, from the Hearld-Review, illustrates the many problems the courts have with elder abuse cases. The case involved the death of 91 year-old Maria “Concha” Lopez of Madera, California who was being cared for by her 26 year-old grandniece, Stephanie Hernandez. Ms. Hernandez called 911 when her aunt stopped breathing. Arriving firefighters and paramedics were inundated with the

Principles and Components of Primary Health Care

2242 words - 9 pages Principles and Components of Primary Health Care According to World Health Organization (1978), primary health care is defined as a universally accessible health care that is socially acceptable, affordable and requires individuals to be more self-reliant with their health care needs. Primary health care has many goals, but the most important is introducing the importance of self-reliance to individuals. The main objective of primary health care

External and External Influences in Health Care

789 words - 3 pages Abstract External and internal influences are relevant in health care. These influences continue to affect the total operations of a health care facility. I will summarize the insights I have gained into the external influences of the new health care reform policy and quality initiatives. The recent health care reform legislation was passed in the house and senate this year. The senior vice president, that I have interviewed, states that

Tommy Douglas and Health Care System

1775 words - 7 pages Tommy Douglas and Health Care System One man can save the lives of millions of people with one idea. An idea that separates Canada from any other country in the world. Tommy Douglas is the reason we have our health care system and without this man many Canadians would have lost their lives. Tommy

Human Dignity and Universal Health Care

1782 words - 8 pages Intro: The universal health care was implemented in 1974 in Australia, providing health care and financial protection to all global citizens. Thus allowing every human a right to a standard living without separating citizens due to their disorder, illness or lifestyle. Human dignity can be explained as a form of inherent and self-worth, however this can also have the potential to be taken away from someone either by their actions or the society

Similar Essays

Health And Social Care Essay

1437 words - 6 pages Introduction One of the five key principles of care practice is to ‘Support people in having a voice and being heard,’ (K101, Unit 4, p.183). The key principles are linked to the National Occupational Standards for ‘Health and Social Care’. They are a means of establishing and maintaining good care practice. Relationships based on trust and respect should be developed between care receivers and care givers, thus promoting confidence whilst

Racial Discrimination And Health Care Essay

2300 words - 9 pages granted even though the objection can be acknowledged through examination of a different set of ethical teachings. Using one of the core principles of bioethics I support my claim that it is not ethical to racially discriminate against the professional delivery of health care services. Principle number three is to “refrain from harming other persons,” and in this instance racially discriminating by race would be harming someone, a qualified

Gender Equity In Health And Health Care

2727 words - 11 pages Introduction It is often challenging to have health care services that meet the needs of Canada’s diverse population and the needs of both men and women. Gender influences access to care and women in particular are at risk for face difficulties to care (Ontario Women`s Health Equity Report, 2010 p.1). Women are more likely to be poor and have greater caregiver responsibilities in contrast to men. These both factors are barriers to accessing

Australian Health Care And Reform Essay

3784 words - 15 pages Introduction A country’s health care system refers to all the institutions, programs, personnel, procedures, and the resources that are used to meet the health needs of its population. Health care systems vary from one country to another, depending on government policies and the health needs of the population. Besides, health care programs are flexible in the sense that they are tailored to meet health needs as they arise. Among the