This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Biological Determinism Essay

2917 words - 12 pages

1. According to the author of the article 'All in the Genes?', there is no intrinsic causality between genetics and intelligence. The author analyses different aspects of biological determinism, and supplies many examples, which illustrate aspects of this problem that are being discussed since the time when these ideas became popular. He does not agree with biological determinist that the intellectual performance of a person depends on genes inherited from his parents. There are a lot of different theories about intellectual capabilities. All these theories reflect different points of views, depending on the period of time the authors of these theories lived.The author argues for the theory that in the nineteenth century , artificial barriers in social hierarchy prevented people from achieving higher intellectual performance. In the end of XX century, in most places these barriers were removed by the democratic processes, and nothing artificial can stand between the natural sorting process and social status of the people. These changes can not be considered as historical because the age of democracy is just two hundred years , and the time when inequality between classes and between people was a natural situation is almost as long as the history of the world .The author insists that there is no connection between environmental differences and genetics. In support of his idea the author state that any Canadian student can perform better in mathematics than some ancient professors of mathematics. The author comes to the conclusion that changes in a cultural environment are the main factor that determines level of intellectual performance, not inherited combination of parent's genes . He argues that genetic differences that appear in one environment may easily disappear in another. A theory that twins were raised in different social conditions will have the same level of intellectual performance because identical genetics constitution was used by the ideologist of biological determinism. The author rejects this theory because from his point of view, all these cases cannot be considered as always reliable on a close look, in most cases, twins were raised by the members of the same family or in other words, not in a diametrical opposite level of society. The author believes that there is no convincing measure of the role of genes in influencing human behavioural variation.During the argumentation of questions of biological determinism, the author supports his idea with numerous examples. He gives examples of supporters of bio determinism and outlines that these examples are not reliable. One of the fallacies of biological determinism is the result of IQ testing. According to some scientist only 20% of performance depend on environment and other 80% depend on genetic variations. The author state that this is completely fallacious because there is no connection between the variation that can be ascribed as genetic differences and whether an IQ...

Find Another Essay On Biological Determinism

Discussion on the Determination of Self

1141 words - 5 pages with the physical, scientific approach, the biological and psychological approach and the philosophical approach. The problem remains the same in all these areas, however various answers are given to the question of ‘who pulls the strings’ depending on the approach taken. Scientific determinism argues that causes and their effects are scientifically predictable. The laws in the universe are symbiotic. They operate

Free Will vs Determinism Essay

1413 words - 6 pages are primarily thought to include our biological make-up, family environment, socio-economic status and the laws of nature (Bartol, 1995). This debate is important to Criminology as it holds the key to prediction of risk and therefore prediction of crime. There are three major stances on determinism that are known as hard determinism, soft determinism and non-determinism (also known as free will) (Williams, 1991).The key issue stemming from the

Determinism

553 words - 2 pages choice; therefore, you are morally responsible for our actions because we have free will, and we are aware of your consequence. Soft Determinism in addition believes that all behavior is caused but they also consider that if there are no constraints complying him/her to do otherwise, they are considered to have free will. According to soft determinism, some people cannot be held responsible for their actions, due to biological and/or emotional

We Found Love Analysis

1203 words - 5 pages arrangements and how it is justified by biological determinism along with the normalization of objectifying women and the dualism of passivity from females in active male dominated relationships. Critical Analysis Beginning with the lyrics in the opening scene of “We Found Love”, a female voice speaking about being in a domestic violence situation and the difficulty she is having deciding between staying with her partner or leaving. The statements

Free will & Determinism - The debate

1797 words - 7 pages causes of behaviour, with the possibility of being able to predict and control.Determinism is incorporated within many areas of psychology such as physiological, social, biological which can all be considered as influencing behaviour to a varying degree.Reductionism can be considered as an extreme form of determinism in that it states that an event may be fully understood by uncovering the constituent parts. Reductionism ignores other levels of

Qumran: Identity, Spirits, Science and Dualism

2324 words - 9 pages 1. The topic of my research is the coexistence and dualism of determinism and free will or, natural evil and moral evil, within the texts of the Dead Sea Scrolls. I am interested in this subject because I was intrigued by the debate it sparked among scholars and scientists alike. When applied to a religious backdrop it seems to be an especially complicated puzzle which can’t be easily solved rationally or scientifically. As I am determined to

Causal Determinsim

1457 words - 6 pages Causal determinism is the concept that preceding causes give rise to everything which exists such that reality could be nothing but what it is. Science depends on this idea as it aims to find generalisations about the conjunction of certain causes and effects and thus hold some power of prediction about their future co-occurrence. However, in human interaction people assume each other to be responsible for their acts and not merely at the whim

Programmed To Be Free: Exploring Andrew Niccol's Gatacca

1201 words - 5 pages important load of determination has to do with his success. The main premise of determinism is the following: all events are caused and there is nothing that we can do to avoid it. There are several forms of determinism: social, religious, biological, psychological. B.F.Skinner, father of radical behaviorism supported the idea that “freedom is a myth” and tried to prove how behavior responds to natural laws and to a stimuli- response model. Skinner’s

Does Free Will Exist?

1023 words - 5 pages individual might try, but can’t discover where the notion comes from. It’s origin is a output of a intricate nexus of life biological science and environment about which the individual has very little experience with and does not oversee. He claims that people who believe they act willingly and are liable for their actions are being deluded by science. In Harris’s opinion, free will doesn’t exist because an individual can only do what the

The Illusion of Free Will

1180 words - 5 pages brain are responsible. We do not typically claim people to be conscious of their thoughts and actions when they have some particular brain state caused by a tumor or some other disorder. Because we know that all human action is determined by brain states which is dependent on factors over which we have no control so why doesn’t this conception of biological determinism extend to all brain states? The same brain functions that force someone count

The Rational Choice and Biological Trait Theories

2003 words - 8 pages not affect the behavior of an individual under the biological theory. Some criminologists that study the biological trait theory believe that some men are just born criminals and this is called atavism. Today, biological trait theorists are trying to establish a connection between different criminal mind frames (Siegel, 2011) Biological theorists also think about determinism which is a view of a criminal’s life style and how it became a

Similar Essays

Environmental Determinism And Biological Determinism Essay

628 words - 3 pages Environmental Determinism and Biological Determinism can set restrictions on a person’s behavior. Environmental Determinism is the view that the environment can have a great impact on a person’s behavior. Environmental Determinism is known as the name Climatic Determinism or the name Geographical Determinism. Biological Determinism is the view that a person’s genetic material can set limits on a person’s behavior. Environmental Determinism and

Arcadia Essay

878 words - 4 pages day. Religious determinism in Arcadia is shown to have to do with God, fate, predestination and the future whereas the scientific view has to do with Newton and with biological determinism. Although both stories do use both aspects of determinism, it is usually the story from 1809 using the scientific determinism whereas in the present day, they use more of the religious view of determinism.In the first story, a scientific view of determinism is

Do Gene Selectionist Approaches In Evolutionary Theory Entail Genetic Determinism?

1632 words - 7 pages "...what answers we find satisfying will always depend on the questions we ask." (Rowland 2004: 11)Gene selectionist approaches in evolutionary theory entail genetic determinism. Gene selectionist approaches concerning the individual do not entail genetic determinism although genomic structure is highly influential on an individual. Moreover the popular doctrine and dogma of genetic determinism needs to be revised in order to lessen confusion

Freedom Determinism Debate Essay

1693 words - 7 pages and soft determinism and there are four types of determinism, biological, genetic, psychic and environmental. Hard determinism is the belief that our behaviour is determined and predictable and controlled by these internal and external factors. Hard determinism is usually associated with social scientists such as Skinner, Freud, and Lorenz and usually rejected by philosophers. The behaviourist approach is in favour of hard determinism arguing