This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Birch Paper Company Case Study

1729 words - 7 pages

To: Commercial Vice PresidentBirch Paper CompanyAlthough the current financial implications for Birch Paper Company are not substantial, as the contract in question is less than 5% of the volume in any division, it is imperative that Birch Company establishes and addresses its transfer price policies and procedures with each division. This will ensure that the divisions are not putting their objectives ahead of the Company's and as a result, not maximizing the overall revenues and profits of Birch Paper Company. This report will highlight the issues while providing a complete analysis and recommendation for you to consider.Sincerely,In examining the information provided by Birch Paper Company (BPC) it became apparent that due to the decentralized manner in which BPC operates its four production divisions, the overall maximization of profits for BPC could be jeopardized if policies and procedures are not immediately established for setting transfer prices between divisions. Although, the decentralization of BPC's divisions certainly have proved successful in the past, it is critical for BPC to establish more concise guidelines to ensure that all the decisions that are made by each division are goal congruent and maximizing BPC's profits.The transfer price issue has come to your attention as a result of the Northern Division's request for bids on corrugated boxes from the Thompson Division and from two outside companies, West Paper Company and Eire Papers Limited. Because each Birch Division manager is encouraged to go with the most cost effective supplier, Mr. Kenton was troubled, as he did not find the current internal transfer price competitive, as the offer was 10% over the going market rate. As a result of the current dysfunctional transfer pricing policy, the division would undoubtedly go with an external supplier, even though it may not be in the best interest of BPC. Thus, the transfer pricing policy must be examined and addressed to insure the long-term growth and sustainability of BPC is not being compromised for short-term divisional gains.This analysis will first examine the market rate transfer prices and determine which bid the Northern Division would have made. The analysis will than examine the transfer prices at cost ("out of pocket costs" or variable costs) and determine which bid the Northern Division would have made. Finally, the analysis will highlight, which transfer price strategy would result in BPC maximizing profits and why.Exhibit 1Market Price - Sell $280 (70% 400) $480Transfer Cost $280 (70% 400) $480Market PriceVariable Costs $168 (60% 280) $120 (30% 400) $288Variable Costs - Out of Pocket Costs$430 $391* ($432 - $36 - $5)On analyzing the Southern Division's cost structure, it was determined, that they have variable costs of $168 / 1000 boxes. The Division than marks up its products to the going market rate of $280 / 1000 boxes to either sell externally or transfer internally to the Thompson Division. (Exhibit 1) The...

Find Another Essay On Birch Paper Company - Case Study

Ethics in the Workplace Case Study Action Plan: Scott Paper Company

2311 words - 9 pages suggests there are usually three primary motivations for reorganization; the first is the poor financial performance, second, is the need for a new corporate strategy, and lastly it is used to correct how the company is valued in the capital market (Jenkins, 1994). In this case the warning signs were clear at Scott Paper with the declining sales, stale product lines and some irrelevant business ventures; a lagging revenue stream and stock price, also

Case Study for Padgett Paper Products Company- analysis for the options

1843 words - 7 pages price to calculate ending inventory. As the value of the ending inventory being lower, according to the formula for cost of goods sold above, cost of goods sold would be higher. A shift to LIFO inventory valuation would save Padgett more cash than the cost of implementing the system which would result in a tax benefit of $500,000 for Padgett Paper Products Company. (Case Studies in Finance)Flat dividends would provide excess capital to reinvest

Lincoln Electric Company: Harvard Case Study

1171 words - 5 pages As we learn from the case study, the Lincoln Electric Company is the largest global manufacturer of machines for welding, which are used in all kinds of construction projects. This means that the company has a large global presence and many employees, so its culture affects thousands of its workers. Even though it is now 2014, the company still has a large market share and very satisfied employees, so clearly the culture leaves employees

The Pacific Oil Company case study

1097 words - 5 pages Introduction This paper will describe the problem that Pacific Oil Company faced as it reopened negotiations with Reliant Chemical Company in early 1985. Secondly I will identify and evaluate the styles and effectiveness of Messrs, Fonatine, Guadin, Hauptmann, and Zinnser as negotiations in this case. Finally I will outline what Frank Kelsey recommend to Jean Fontaine at the end of the case? Why? Managing Conflict in Negotiation The Pacific

Case Study of Callaway Golf Company

2781 words - 11 pages Case Study of Callaway Golf Company Section I. Summary Callaway Golf Company began to take form in 1983, after Ely Reeves Callaway Jr. sold Callaway Vineyard and Winery for a $9 million dollar profit. Shortly after the sell of the winery, Callaway ventured in to the golf equipment industry and bought 50 percent of Hickory Stick USA. Callaway knew from the very beginning that this company’s profits were limited as long as the product line

Clarkson Lumber Company Case Study Analysis

1157 words - 5 pages PAGE PAGE 4 Case Analysis: Clarkson Lumber Company Running head: Case Analysis: Clarkson Lumber CompanyCase Analysis: Clarkson Lumber CompanyFrank FoltynUniversity of Maryland University CollegeTMAN 625 section 9044September 10, 20071. Why has Clarkson Lumber borrowed increasing amounts despite its profitability? There are a couple of reasons for Mr. Clarkson wanting to increase the amount of borrowing that would be needed to continue with his

Case Study-Cooper Tire and Rubber Company

2334 words - 9 pages Introduction"Cooper Tire & Rubber Company, founded in 1914, specializes in the manufacturing and marketing of rubber products for consumers. Products include automobile, truck and motorcycle tires, inner tubes, NVH control systems, automotive sealing, and fluid delivery systems." (http://www.coopertire.com/about/).The case study on Cooper mainly concentrates on the tire industry, andTherefore the following analysis will be based on

E-Business Case study WHSmith Company

5752 words - 23 pages transaction should be some benefits to company. The benefits of WHSmith are stated as follows. Firstly, expenditure such as paper and administrative expenses can be deleted (Turban, Efraim and King, David, 2003, p. 208). It is cheap and saving to communicate and trade with retailers or wholesalers by means of internet. In the past, the process of distributing or trading must cost a lot of money while at present it has become facile to run the same

Case Study about Work System Framework of a Company

4058 words - 16 pages Executive Summary TradX is a company that aims to sell furniture to retailers and special targeted companies. By analyzing the case study, which is on TradX Company, we came up with two different work systems for the company's trade actions. The work systems are "Replenish Retailer Inventory" and "Direct Selling." Moreover, the performance variables for the business processes are discussed in detail in the report. The report then talks about

Case study The Walt Disney Company: The Entertainment King

1264 words - 5 pages where the firm operates and in and between all the actions that it is undertaking.Bibliography: - Strategic Management: Concepts, Second Edition (2008), by Mason A. Carpenter and Wm.Gerard Sanders, Pearson Prentice Hall. ISBN-10: 0132341409; ISBN-13: 9780132341400- Harvard online, buy Case study Walt disney

Turnover Case Study: Storck, A German Candy Company

1704 words - 7 pages situation, so the team stays intact and starts to work more harmoniously. Methodology The sales team in question were sent a Myers-Briggs Type Indicator profiling questionnaire. The following four profiles, together with the positioning of the company within the Competing Value Framework, formed the basis of this paper: Competing Value Framework • Storck: Control quadrant Myers-Briggs Type Indicator • Rico (Sales manager): ISTJ • Peter Paul (Key

Similar Essays

Case Study On Birch Paper Company With Regard To Transfer Pricing

1087 words - 4 pages cost if all transfer prices within the company were calculated at costs. Incurring the lowest costs would also enable Birch Paper Company to earn the highest profits possible.2. As alternatives for sourcing exists, Mr. Kenton should be permitted to choose the alternative that is in Northern division's own interests. The transfer price policy gives him the right to deal with either insiders or outsiders at his discretion. If he is unable to get a

Case Study Tony's Company

2439 words - 10 pages viewpoints of international business, discuss how to avoid these mistakes.The background of case studyThis case study states the failure of international business of a medium sized British manufacturer. Tony, as the manager of the international division, charged the project of providing the monitors to the hospitals in a large Latin American country. The order was too large for the company's existing manufacturing capacity, Tony found an Asian

Google Company Case Study

3482 words - 14 pages innovation is Google’s bloodline. In all, employees and stockholders of Google vended their Google share, where it is the first year as a public company. This made a large number of early employer’s become millionaire. Overall this case study investigation outcome help Google to improve the issues in their organization and found way of implementing solution that founded for each issue. Moreover GOOGLEPLEX at GOOGLE, every engineer is encouraged

Walt Disney Company Case Study

1551 words - 6 pages Walt Disney Company Case Study PART I Why is Disney so successful The success of Disney is a combination of creativity and innovations, and the managerial ability to identify and take advantage of every possible synergy. Walter Disney was the entrepreneur who had the creative skills. Knowing his limitations, he let other people do what he couldn't do good enough himself. This is an important skill, as it leads to quality products being