Bmi Does Not Determine Obesity Essay

993 words - 4 pages

The obesity epidemic makes headlines daily as newscasters recite statistics about the dangers of excess body weight. Mexican food, movie popcorn and the all-American burger have all fallen under the disapproving glare of public health proponents. Experts inveigh against the dangers of carrying extra flab and warn that without drastic measures, the current generation of overweight kids will become the first generation to lead shorter lives than their parents. All too often, this hatred of fat transfers itself to a hatred of fat people.

With so many terrifying statistics about heart disease, type 2 diabetes, stroke and organ dysfunction related to obesity, it's easy to conclude that any excess weight imperils people who carry it. To some extent, the concerns are justified; these risks are real at the highest ends of the weight spectrum. There's little question that significant excess weight contributes to serious health problems. Extreme obesity can also impede quality of life as well as its quantity.

However, the foundation on which the notion of obesity rests -- body mass index, or BMI -- is fundamentally flawed. Without a clear vision of what constitutes overweight and obesity, it's impossible to assert that any amount of excess weight is bad. On the contrary, studies of the health consequences of significantly low body weight reveal that too little weight is as lethal as extreme obesity and considerably more dangerous than having a moderately high BMI. These statistics also look less alarming under more careful scrutiny, as many studies fail to differentiate between a few extra pounds and a few hundred of them.

The Myth of BMI

In 1850, doctors had no antibiotics, nor did medical personnel have a germ theory of disease to explain why illnesses happened. Doctors who washed their hands between patients drew scorn from colleagues for their fastidiousness. Surgery without anesthetics or blood typing was frequently fatal. It was also the year that the Body Mass Index, or BMI, came into being. Unlike other outdated medical practices, BMI still remains in use.

The calculations for BMI involve only height and weight. Measuring the relationship between these two characteristics against a set of ideal characteristics theoretically gives an idea of an individual's overall health. For people with moderate muscle mass, this relationship can indicate overweight or obesity. However, because BMI fails to take gender, age, fitness or body composition into account, millions of healthy people wind up in the "overweight" or "obese" categories.

At the extremes of physical fitness, BMI is not only inaccurate, it's absurd. Many professional athletes are overweight or obese according to BMI figures. NFL quarterback Tom Brady falls in the middle of the overweight category with a BMI of 27.5, while his shorter counterpart Drew Brees edges dangerously close to obesity with a BMI of 28.5. Tony Romo has even less wiggle room with his BMI of 29. One...

Find Another Essay On BMI Does NOT Determine Obesity

What is Obesity? Essay

3888 words - 16 pages determined as obese, while he/she is not in fact.   What is the body mass index (BMI)? Nowadays BMI is one of the most widely used and simple measurement of body fat. It’s choice for many physicians and researchers studying obesity. The BMI uses a mathematical formula which uses both person’s weight and height. The BMI has problems as like weight-for-height table, because it doesn’t give accurate percentage of body fat and not everyone agrees

Fast Food Is Killing America Essay

1496 words - 6 pages solution to obesity, which is less food and more exercise, is not working, it can be assumed that either obese people are unwilling or incapable of healing themselves; or the explanation is wrong.(Taubes) Even if a person’s calorie intake does not exceed recommendation, the person may still be overweight.(Kelly) This could be because of a lack of exercise and physical activity.(Kelly) The average person spends most of their day sitting in a car or

The Obesity Epidemic: Constructed for the Benefit of the Medical Industry

1236 words - 5 pages generally considered to be obese if their BMI is 30 or over. However, this method has been criticised as it fails to tell us what this weight it made up of as it does not distinguish between muscle, fat, organ and water. Athletes and body builders for example, may carry less fat, but have a high BMI as muscle weighs more than fat. Using this method may result in a healthy person being classified as obese. The development of the BMI and its standard cut

Childhood and Adolescent Obesity

2520 words - 10 pages measured weights and heights according to age; this measure does not determine where fat deposits exist on a child’s body. The causes of obesity are complex they include a genetic predisposing for the condition with contributing factors; factors of behavior, environment, culture, ethnicity, psychological and socioeconomic status. Obesity defined in the simplest form is the imbalance of energy (food) taken in and energy expended (physical activity

Obesity: An American Epidemic

1281 words - 5 pages for diseases because of the changes that are transpiring in their bodies. Obesity, and being overweight in general, is a risk factor for diseases like diabetes and cardiovascular diseases; however, as an individual gets to a particular age, 65 years and over, having a greater BMI may not be such a bad thing but this idea is still ongoing and is inconclusive at this point. What the elderly should do to maintain a healthy aging process is to eat

Losing Weight: The Battle of the Bulge

3862 words - 15 pages adults and being overweight in adulthood is a health risk.” (Alpert, 2009) Obesity and overweight can be defined by at least two measurements: BMI (Body Mass Index) and waist circumference. According to common nutritional knowledge, the conditions of obesity and overweight occur in a person when the amount of calories consumed exceeds the amount of calories burned, repeated over time. The use of BMI and waist circumference can be used to determine

The Obesity Epidemic

1230 words - 5 pages weight to height) and relative weight index, such as percent desirable weight (Body Mass Index , 2013). BMI is the most frequently used measure of obesity as it has a strong correlation with more direct measures of adiposity, such as underwater weighing (A Report of the Surgeon General, 2013). Some have proposed that genetics are at the root of obesity. While genetics may play a role in obesity, it is still not clear what role this is (Chagnon

Roles of Metabolism and Behavior in Obesity

641 words - 3 pages everyday lives. Amercian views on obesity are not as strong as they should be .Obesity is a condition which is usually defined as person's body mass index (BMI). Obesity can also used as a general term for a person that has an excessive amount of body fat. Many people have argued that the obesity epidemic is very overblown

Obesity In The United States

1492 words - 6 pages diet can prevent people from being obese and having complications such as sleep apnea. The only problem is once a person becomes obese, he/she may not be as motivated to exercise or diet (Obesity & Sleep par 8). Not only does obesity contribute to sleep problems such as sleep apnea, but sleep problems can also contribute to obesity. A 1999 study by scientists at the University of Chicago found that building up a sleep debt over a matter of days


940 words - 4 pages As much as obesity is a complicated issue that even scientist are still trying to figure out, the reality is that it has increased in the United States by over 50 percent (Center for Disease Control and Prevention). It is commonly calculated by, the body mass index (BMI) VS weight/height. Most medical practitioners uses the BMI to determine if a person is overweight. When the BMI reaches 30 or above one is considered to be obese. It is

Childhood Obesity: Evidence based nursing research

2498 words - 10 pages substantial increased, from 5% to 18.1% (National Center, 2010). Although there is no concise definition for childhood obesity the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) states that a child with a BMI of 85% to less than 95% is considered overweight and "those children with a Body Mass Index (BMI) of greater than the 95th percentile are considered obese" (AAP, n.d.). The Body Mass Index was invented by Adolph Quelet in the mid 1800s and while it is not a

Similar Essays

Obesity Is An External Consequence That An Individual Does Not Have Much Control Over

1678 words - 7 pages medical condition results in weight gain, upper-body obesity, a round face, neck fat, and thin limbs (National Heart Lung and Blood Institute, N.d). People might argue that depression can be controlled through antidepressants. This may be true, however, it does not solve the obesity link to depression. Medications for depression and other mental illnesses can cause dramatic weight gain, which contributes to being overweight (Psych Central, 2013

A New Approach To A Healthier Future

1246 words - 5 pages youths. I argue that the Canadian health care system must adopt weight management in the place of weight loss and end the standard use of body mass index (BMI) in order to successfully combat obesity. Body mass has long been thought to influence health and well-being. Since excessive weight is believed to increase a person’s risk for disease the BMI tool is used to determine standard recommended weight. Medical, government and public health

The Relationship Between Anthropometric Measurements And Percent Body Fat (Pbf) In Students

1701 words - 7 pages obesity1. BMI is not a direct estimate of adiposity as it does not distinguish fat mass from fat-free mass and so some individuals have a high BMI due to a large muscle mass2. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1999 quotes ”Body fat expressed as a percentage of body weight is the most relevant measure against which anthropometric measurements should be correlated”3. A number of studies in the past have shown that the relationship between BMI

Obesity And Asthma Essay

894 words - 4 pages . Moreover, the fact that asthma severity is significantly correlated with increasing BMI in women, but not in men, is reported by Varraso et al2 in his study of the relationship between BMI and asthma severity by the sex. This study showed that sex is one of the several factors that associated with the obesity and severity of asthma. All in all, it is clear that there is a positive relationship between obesity and severity of asthma