Body Language: Cultural Or Universal? Essay

1707 words - 7 pages

Body language and various other nonverbal cues have long been recognized as being of great importance to the facilitation of communication. There has been a long running debate as to whether body language signals and their meanings are culturally determined or whether such cues are innate and thus universal. The nature versus nurture dichotomy inherent in this debate is false; one does not preclude the other’s influence. Rather researchers should seek to address the question how much of nonverbal communication is innate and how much is culturally defined? Are there any true universal nonverbal cues or just universal tendencies modified to suit cultural ideals and constraints? It is my proposal that of all forms of nonverbal communication the most universal is the communication of emotions through facial expression.
Other channels of nonverbal communication are also of great importance in many cultures. However which channels are emphasized, what cues are considered acceptable and the symbolic meaning of the cues may vary from culture to culture. Ekman and Friesen (3) undertook an important cross-cultural study to determine how easily and accurately people from various literate Western and non-Western cultures could identify the appropriate emotion term to match photographs they were shown. The photographs were of Caucasian faces posed in certain facial expressions. The terms the subjects were given to choose from were happiness, surprise, disgust, contempt, anger, fear and sadness. The result was consistent evidence of agreement across all cultures examined. In order to rule out the possibility that exposure to mass-media had taught the subjects to recognize Caucasian facial expressions Ekman and Friesen undertook a similar study among a visually isolated culture in New Guinea (1). A different methodology was used; people were shown the photographs of posed Caucasian facial expressions and were asked to make up a story about the person and the moments leading up to that image. From these stories Ekman and Friesen concluded that these subjects were able to identify the emotions accurately. The one exception was that there seemed to be some confusion between expressions of surprise and fear.
A similar experiment compared the perception of the emotions of English, Italian and Japanese performers by people from these three countries. The results were as follows: Both the English and Italian subjects could identify their own and each other’s emotions but had difficulty with the Japanese. The Japanese subjects were able to identify the emotions of the English and Italians better than those groups had been able to judge the Japanese. However the Japanese subjects had difficulty determining Japanese facial expressions. This would seem to indicate that the Japanese face does not express emotion in the same manner as those of other cultures. However, another experiment (3) demonstrated different results. American and Japanese subjects were observed...

Find Another Essay On Body Language: Cultural or Universal?

You're Speaking My Language Essay

1648 words - 7 pages addition to this language organ, Chomsky argues that organism's utilize and learn language through an idea called “Universal Grammar”, which is the idea that in every developed language, there are universal grammatical laws that govern the structure and how language is structured. This notion actually agrees with the “cultural/genetic interaction” idea, but the problem with Chomsky's view is that there is no known way of depicting how the language

Linguistic Determinism: Words and Thoughts Essay

2198 words - 9 pages determinism and the support of the semantic studies in order to understand words and sentences produced in human mind when the cultural and social pattern it is taken into account. Yet “knowledge an individual speaker of a language possesses which makes it possible for them to communicate with one another.” (Riemer, 2010: 13). Semantics is a theory of languages, natural or artificial, and it is part of grammar from those languages. In

George Steiner wrote that the translator is the mailman of human thought and sentiment. Examine some of the difficulties involved in accurately translating works of literature.

1824 words - 7 pages a single word may have many different meanings - take for instance the word 'orange' - it could refer to the colour or the fruit, or the word 'bad' - it could be translated as naughty, wrong or rotten, and if the interpretor picks the wrong meaning of the word it could effect the entire translation.Another cultural translating problem is the fact that they may use more body language and signs and symbols to express themselves, rather than spoken

Deaf Culture versus Deaf Community

995 words - 4 pages people you hold is essential because it will determine the relationship you have to, and with, the Deaf community. Your attitudes towards the community's language and its culture determine your perception of Deaf people. As a hearing person, you will hold either a pathological or cultural view of the Deaf community.


569 words - 3 pages to translate their documents from their language to English. He or she has to pay a certain amount of money in order to get their documents translated. Everyone could save both time and money if sucha universal language exists. There are also disadvantages in the establishment of a universal language. One of them would be the loss of identity. Without an individual language, people would have difficulties maintaining their self identity. The

This essay is about the cultural communication differences

848 words - 3 pages between two or more human beings. Some say that words have intrinsic and universal meaning; others say they are conventional and are used loosely; that the exchange of information requires an open semantic system. Relating to signification or meaning.Kinesics - The study of those body movements and gestures by which, as well as by speech, communication is made; body movements and gestures which convey meaning non-vocally.Cross-cultural

All tertiary-level students should be required to be competent in a foreign language

561 words - 2 pages Name: Richard Nattoo 1005015Topic: Whether or not tertiary-level students should be competent in a foreign languageNarrowed Topic: All tertiary-level students should be required to be competent in a foreign languagePurpose: To convince tertiary-level students that being competent in a foreign language is beneficial to their future careersThesis: Although some may disagree, all tertiary-level students should be required to be competent in a

American Sign Language

1811 words - 7 pages Sign language has played an important part throughout history; it has removed the barrier between those who can hear and those who are deaf. Sign language is a form of communication that does not rely on verbal speech. It uses visual-spatial medium to express communication (Stewart & Akamatsu, 236). Hands, fingers, body, and facial features are used to visually transmit linguistic information. The signs are formed by hands, which convey symbols

Body Language

935 words - 4 pages Body language is non-verbal communication where your body reveals unspoken, usually subconscious, feelings and intentions physically. Body language is expressed through eye movements, facial expressions, body postures and gestures. It plays a part in how humans judge you while communicating or first meeting which is what we do when we see a characteristic we wouldn’t tolerate to possess or envy of the person which drives you to find faults

To What Degree Might Different Languages Shape In Their Speakers Different Concepts Of Themselves And The World

1109 words - 4 pages only way to solve this problem would be to either learn every language on the planet, or to speak the universal language of Esperanto created in 1887 by Dr. Zamenhof which, if possible would bring an end to our cultural differences – how boring!      In conclusion, each country has the knowledge and understanding of its own culture and will therefore have a different perception of foreign cultures due to the possible lack

Reconciling Values and Ethics in a Global Setting

1132 words - 5 pages culture.Cultural Ethics and ValuesCultural ethics form a moral code of conduct in the same vein as organizational ethics, but govern the behavior of each society as a whole. Cultural values such as ethnicity, faith, history, language, nationality, tradition, and unselfishness are passed down from generation to generation (Seneca College, 2001). For example, women of Islam must observe a dress code where the entire body must be covered with opaque

Similar Essays

Discuss How Social And Cultural Contexts Influence Children's Learning And Use Of More Than One Language Or Variety.

2540 words - 10 pages when they got excited in a card game, they switched to Spanish, as seen in Alan's speech when he said "Mami, es un tramposo!" or "Mummy, it's a cheat!"This case study on the Drummond's family, shows that the language acquired or used by a child is dependent on the social and cultural context of their environment. (Mayor,2002; Drummond,2002; Video Band 5)According to Li Wei (1994), in some bilingual families, the choice of language depends on the

What Is The Advantage Of "Body Language" In Communication?

959 words - 4 pages of visual movement one is more interested in what someone is trying to say. Through body language one can tell if a person is sad or happy, glad or mad. Body language conveys a lot of expression to are inner feelings and thoughts.Body language can show many things about you and the way you think. It can also show the way a person reacts to what you try to convey to them. If the listener isn't responding one must try and change the topic without

Business Body Language Essay

7011 words - 28 pages styles�provides useful additional perspective. Women tend to have more empathic sensitivity than men, which naturally aids body language awareness and capabilities. Aside from gender differences, men and women with strong empathic sensitivity (typically right-basal or rear brain bias) tend to be better at picking up body language signals. � The six universal facial expressions�- recognized around the world It is now generally accepted that

Incorporating Culture In Foreign Language Teaching

1413 words - 6 pages . To finally add before starting some cross-cultural compatibilities and incompatibilities, Buttjes (1990, cited in AbiSamra, 2001) shows the reasons of why language and culture are from the start inseparably connected as follows:1. language acquisition does not follow a universal sequence, but differs across cultures;2. the process of becoming a competent member of society is realized through exchanges of language in particular social situations;3