Book Comparison Of The Rise Of Communist Parties, Soviet Union, And China

1496 words - 6 pages

Book Comparison of the Rise of Communist Parties, Soviet Union, and China



The first half of the twentieth century were the breeding years of Communism. The books Hitler, Stalin, and Mussolini by Bruce F. Pauley and China in Transformation by Colin Mackerras both deal with the rise of Communism, the former in the Soviet Union and the latter in China. Although one book deals with the rise of Communism in the Soviet Union and the other book deals with the rise of Communism in China, both authors have similar abstract ideas about the elements necessary for a Communist takeover, such as the importance of “revolution, reform, change, and reaction”. (Mackerras, 2) One can see that what both these authors agree on, when looked at abstractly, is that for a “Communist victory” to occur, the course of events must happen in that sequence.
What Pauley and Mackerras agree on, as an obvious element necessary for the rise or victory of Communism, is the presence seemingly qualified leader. In the Soviet Union, it was Lenin (later Stalin); in China it was Mao Zedong who finally brought the Communists to power. “An eloquent, charismatic or powerful leader” is the key to any type of government takeover.
An underlying element necessary for the rise or victory of Communism would have to be a certain state of being that the country would have to be in at the time of the takeover. Although the full takeover of the Soviet Union by the Communist Party happened earlier than in China, many similarities can be seen in the political, social, and economic sectors of the countries in the years directly preceding the takeover.
Since the Communist takeover in the Soviet Union happened earlier than in China, as mentioned above, one should read these books in sequence; Hitler, Stalin, and Mussolini first, and China in Transformation second. Not only will one be able to make a cross comparison between the Soviet Union and China, one will be able to compare and contrast the rise of the fascist totalitarian regimes (Germany and Italy) as well. Also, since the Communist takeover happened later in China, one might be able to see certain aspects of Soviet Communism in Chinese Communism. One would think that China would be able to learn from the mistakes of the Soviet Union.
This paper intends to make a cross comparison of the Communist rise to power in the Soviet Union and in China. Also, this paper intends to examine the necessities required for a Communist takeover to be successful, such as the sequence of events, an apt leader, and the installation of fear to keep the power one has acquired. The evidence in the books written by Pauley and Mackerras can make these comparisons.

Obvious Necessities for a Communist Takeover
As stated before, any takeover, Communist or otherwise, needs a leader. For the Soviet Union, they were lucky enough to have two distinguished leaders, Lenin and Stalin. In 1920, Soviet Socialism was only three years old. ...

Find Another Essay On Book Comparison of the Rise of Communist Parties, Soviet Union, and China

Analyses of the factors that led to the rise of the communist party in China.

2422 words - 10 pages advantage of the actions of the KMT, gained popularity among the peasants, and the overall suitability of communism for China at the time are the causes for the rise of the communist party. This essay will elaborate these factors, and analyse the relevance of each.The Manchu dynasty began losing power toward the end of the 19th century. There were many imperial advances in China by Europeans. The British were a prominent threat. Britain fought two Opium

Collapse of the Soviet Union Essay

1001 words - 4 pages The Soviet Union was a global superpower, possessing the largest armed forces on the planet with military bases from Angola in Africa, to Vietnam in South-East Asia, to Cuba in the Americas. When Mikhail Gorbachev succeeded Konstantin Chernenko as General Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in March 1985, nobody expected than in less than seven years the USSR would disintergrate into fifteen separate

The Roots of Communist China

1808 words - 7 pages the Chinese Communists, like most politically consciousChinese, were aware of these conditions and anxious to eliminate them.Mao Tse-tung envisioned a mixed economy under Communist control, suchas had existed in the Soviet Union during the period of the NewEconomic Policy. The stress was more upon social justice, and publicownership of the "commanding heights" of the economy than upondevelopment. In 1945, Mao was talking more candidly about

The Cold War and the Collapse of The Soviet Union

2444 words - 10 pages Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the Soviet Union was eager to catch up with the Americans. This “need” would lead to the concept of brinkmanship, a nuclear arms race, and the expansion of Soviet ideals. The Soviets were successful during World War II, which resulted in the growth of the economy, nationalism, communist movement, as well as the need for nuclear power. Although the Soviet Union culminated great economic prosperity and power during World War II

The Collapse of the Soviet Union

1014 words - 4 pages and political problems. A reform of the military was necessary. In the midst of all these turmoil, “there was also corruption and inefficiency within the states bureaucracy” (p.3 smitha.com) and nothing seemed to get done. The soviet people and some Eastern European countries were fed up of all these ongoing problems the Soviet Union was facing. The soviet people were fed up with the high communist party which stood ground and dominated the entire

The Collapse of the Soviet Union

998 words - 4 pages The Collapse of the Soviet Union The Soviet Union was a global superpower, possessing the largest armed forces on the planet with military bases from Angola in Africa, to Vietnam in South-East Asia, to Cuba in the Americas. When Mikhail Gorbachev succeeded Konstantin Chernenko as General Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in March 1985, nobody expected than in less than seven years the USSR would

The Beginnings of the Soviet Union

1482 words - 6 pages trying to build societies from the bottom up. John Scott portrays this brilliantly in his book "Behind the Urals" as he examines individual people and their struggles as they worked in Magnitogorsk. These citizens worked in the most inhumane conditions, all with the intention to help their country develop under the new system of the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union had just gone through an entire turn around in their political, social, and economic

Comparison of the Confederate and Union Economies

608 words - 3 pages The Confederation and the Union had variant economic statuses, the Union's being more stable than the South’s because of its successful sales of bonds, its more dependable form of wealth, and the fact that it was a preestablished country with wartime funding experience. Though the Union’s banking system was far from perfect, its superiority placed the Union ahead of the South financially. The Union developed a technique that boosted the sales

The Communist Party's Successful Gain of China

1220 words - 5 pages set up at Hankow during when the Northern Expedition collapsed. Mao, the elected leader of the Communist party believed that the peasants should spearhead the revolutionary movement in China and was not shared by most of the Communist party leaders. Mao and his followers settled in Kiangsi and named it “Kiangsi Soviet,” it was a mountainous area full of peasants. Mao’s decision to use the peasants contradicted the

The Causes of the End of the Cold War and the Fall of the Soviet Union

819 words - 3 pages affected the Soviet Union by creating many new policies, like the freedom of speech and an improved economic reform. What he did not know what that he was putting together his own downfall. With the freedom of speech the citizens were able to criticise the communist government and Mikhail Gorbachev which lead to more people going against the communist government. That led to the end Soviet Union Gorbachev also tried to strengthen his relationship

The Nonthreatening Rise of China

2247 words - 9 pages Mao Zedong, which led to its economic revolution in the 20th century. This formula proved successful as it initiated the Chinese Communist Party, amending China’s interior chaos (Dellios). Therefore, China’s communist control did not negatively affect China’s economic growth, as communism rehabilitation drove this country into modernization in the 21st century. The rise of China fostered this country to become a great power through military

Similar Essays

The Soviet Union And The Legacy Of Communist Rule

1737 words - 7 pages The Soviet Union and the Legacy of Communist Rule The December of 1991 marked the end of the Soviet Union—and with it, an entire era. Like the February Revolution of 1917 that ended tsardom, the events leading up to August 1991 took place in rapid succession, with both spontaneity and, to some degree, retrospective inevitability. To understand the demise of Soviet Union is to understand the communist party-state system itself. Although the

Korean War: Roles Of China And Soviet Union

3217 words - 13 pages approaching with a broader view point. He starts with the role of Japan in the chains of the events leading to the Korean War. As he claimed in this part of the book, the re-emergence of a strong Japan under the guidance of the United States would pose a threat to North Korea since it would mean the revival of Japanese Empire and, less directly, to the Soviet Union`s far eastern territories. The triumph of Mao`s communist regime in China had

How Would You Account For The Collapse Of Communist Rule In The Former Soviet Union?

2056 words - 8 pages these countries were occupied by the Soviet military who had aggressively assisted the Communist parties to power. These Eastern European countries then supplied the Soviet Union with machinery and raw materials.However, despite this expansion, economic insecurity hovered below the surface, gradually beginning to appear after Stalin's death as his successors avoided making any major changes to domestic policy. As a result of this, the basic

The Alliance Between China And The Soviet Union

1594 words - 6 pages The alliance between the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and the Soviet Union was formed as a result of mutual interests and the desire of both states to pursue their respective national and geopolitical imperatives. Although Chinese historical experience and Marxist ideology played a role in constructing these interests, the actions of the Chinese Community Party (CCP) reflect an overarching proclivity toward solidifying their power and