This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Book Vs Movie, Gone With The Wind

947 words - 4 pages

The first time I saw the film adaptation of a book I had read, I was appalled at the changes that had been made to the story. Both “Gone With the Wind”, the movie, and “Gone With the Wind”, the book, tell an epic story of life in Georgia at the time of the Civil War and Reconstruction Era and the effect of the war on the life of a spoiled Southern belle, Scarlett O’Hara. But there are significant differences in the characters, events and perspectives that made me realize that a screen adaptation will never be able to capture the details and background stories that are included in a novel.
Characters
. For those who have never read the book, the characters are defined by the actors who ...view middle of the document...

One very significant change in characters was the portrayal of Scarlett’s attacker as a white man in the movie instead of the black attacker in the book. This change completely altered the significance of the attack and the subsequent events.
Events
In the movie there are a couple of instances where the order of events is changed. For example, in the movie Melanie and Ashley get married first but in the book Scarlett and Charles get married first. Because Melanie was engaged first, it was protocol that she should be married first, but in the book Scarlett specifically planned her wedding to occur before Melanie’s. For the reader, this illustrates how conniving Scarlett was but the movie-goer does not get this insight into Scarlett’s personality. In the movie, Melanie is the first to donate her wedding ring to the cause, and Scarlett follows suit; in the book, Scarlett is the first to put her ring in the basket. Scarlett’s donation of her ring was not really a sacrifice because it didn’t have any sentimental value to her. In the movie, Rhett Butler returns the rings to both of the women but in the book he only returns Melanie’s ring.
There are a couple of significant changes in the scenes regarding the escape of Scarlett, Melanie and Prissy from Atlanta. The importance of finding the cow as was completely understated in the movie. Melanie had no milk and her baby was starving so, without the cow, the baby would have died. .An event that was completely added to the movie was the rain storm they encountered night they escaped. There was no rain in the book. ...

Find Another Essay On Book vs Movie, gone with the wind

Gone with the Wind Essay

825 words - 4 pages The character I have chosen to study is from Victor Fleming’s 1939 screen adaptation of the Pulitzer Prize winning novel; “Gone with the Wind” by Margaret Mitchell. Melanie (Hamilton) Wilkes, a female lead, in the film she is also lovingly called Melly; and is played by Olivia de Havilland. The writer portrays Melanie as a delicate character, loved and admired by all except one. Melanie is ill-fated to be the best and only friend of Scarlett

Gone with the Wind Essay

783 words - 4 pages Gone With the Wind The classic movie Gone with the Wind is a love story that takes place during the Civil War and was made in 1939. The character, Scarlet O’Hara (Vivien Leigh) is the heroine in the film whose family owns a plantation in Georgia. She loves the attention from all of the gentlemen but has fallen in love with Ashley Wilkes (Leslie Howard) who is marrying his cousin Melanie Wilkes (Olivia de Havilard). Everyone attends the annual

Gone With The Wind

1045 words - 4 pages Gone With the Wind The novel being summarized is titled Gone with the Wind, written by Margaret Mitchell. It was published in 1936, after it took her seven years to write, and won a Pulitzer Prize in 1937. Gone with the Wind was the only book Ms. Mitchell wrote and is an American Classic. Gone with the Wind was a story of men and women living in the south during the war between the states and of the south’s transformation after the war

Gone with the Wind

1074 words - 5 pages of Gone with the Wind. Slavery, racial symbolism, social commentary, feminist undertones, the list goes on forever. To address the litany of social issues in the story would fill a book twice as long as the original work. Mitchell made her point on so many issues and themes with a timeless story that is entertaining on the surface with deep provoking moral dilemmas that bring an insider’s perspective to the antebellum south. For a Great-great

"Gone with the wind"

2908 words - 12 pages , maybe.2. Gone with the wind is rather a large and complex book with different character that is worth identifying and naming. But the main characters that I mostly identify are Scarlett O'Hara the beautiful, cunning, crafty and the farsighted, Rhett Butler the arrogant and the wealthy. Also Melanie and Ashley were wildly mentioned in the story but not as much as Scarlett and Rhett Butler .2b. I identify most with Scarlett O' Hara and Rhett Butler

Gone With The Wind, A classification essay

836 words - 3 pages A Great MovieGone With the Wind is a wonderful movie its story line is spectacular and easy to follow. The characters really bring the movie to life and make you actually feel as if you are there with them. It's setting is absolutely gorgeous.I.) Story lineA.) A an impossible loveB.) A girl having to grow upC.) The war to end slaveryII.) CharactersA.) ScarletB.) AshleyC.) MelanieD.) RhettIII.) SettingA.) Atlanta, GeorgiaB.) Tara just outside of

Popularity of Gone With the Wind

969 words - 4 pages Popularity of Gone With the Wind Margaret Mitchell's romantic epic, Gone With the Wind, owes its remarkable popularity to the climate of sudden self-destruction and dreariness the Depression created. The Old South's grandeur, coupled with its Civil War-era decadence, provided much-needed escapism for readers, as well as paralleling the U.S.'s own plight in the 20s and 30s. In addition, Scarlett O'Hara's feminist role, her devotion to

Comparing Time of the Temptress and Gone With the Wind

2059 words - 8 pages in her own novel, but her references to alternate literature and culture are embarrassingly obvious and awkward. Another inter-literary connection, though, is more difficult to notice unless the book is pondered -- something the typical romance reader is not likely to do. Although Winspear attempts to give her book literary value by tying it to Gone With the Wind, because of the limitations of her chosen genre, and her own apparent

Report on "Gone With the Wind" by Margaret Mitchel

998 words - 4 pages Gone With the WindGone with the wind is one of best novel I have ever read. It is also in my opinion the greatest love story ever written. It is set during the American civil war in which the Southern states (the Confederacy) tried to free themselves from the northern states.The main character of this story was the beautiful Scarlett O'Hara. Her father, Gerald O'Hara was an old Irishman who owned a big cotton plantation named Tara. He also owned

The Hobbit: Book vs. Movie

786 words - 4 pages book it talks of Gandalf throwing pinecones lit with fires of many color, but in the book they were all one color; and the movie featured an attack from the orcs after the dwarves and Bilbo escaped from Mirkwood, whereas the book did not. Despite many differences, the movies are in my opinion an almost perfect representation of the book. Everything from the camera angles to the sound effects collaborate to create a beautiful picture which made

Coping With the Civil War in Gone With the Wind by Scarlett O'Hara

1129 words - 5 pages Gone with the Wind is a historical novel by Margaret Mitchell that tells the story of Scarlett O'Hara, a young southern woman, during the Civil War. It describes how people coped with the war during this time period. As illustrated by Gone with the Wind, the civilians had to cope with the death of family members and the soldiers' transformation when they returned from war. Moreover, the civilians had to deal with drastic changes in their way of

Similar Essays

Pragmatism Versus Idealism Book Review On Gone With The Wind

786 words - 3 pages Mitchell was born in Atlanta, Georgia, in 1900. Divorcing her first husband and pursuing a career in journalism despite the disapproval of society, Mitchell lived a lifestyle considered wild by the standards of 1920s. Mitchell was a willful woman and frequently defied convention, which was embodied in the character of Scarlett O'Hara, the heroine of Gone with the Wind. It is Mitchell's only novel and she refused to make any modification to the book

Gone With The Wind: Compare And Contrast Of Book Versus Film

1297 words - 6 pages the film rights for $50,000. The movie was just as big of a hit as the novel. Gone with the Wind won ten Academy Awards out of thirteen nominations. By today’s box office records, after adjusting for inflation, Gone with the Wind is still the most successful film in box office history. (IMdB) This captivating story transitions from the book to the big-screen magically. I will never forget the first time I watched this film. The characters are

Gone With The Wind Essay

1944 words - 8 pages since its publication, the novel has achieved the status of an epic. The only book that has sold more copies than Gone With the Wind is the Bible. It is a masterpiece of American literature, and highly suggested to those who enjoy Civil War fiction because of its historical accurateness. Mitchell once wrote the following about her novel. "Despite its length and many details it is basically just a simple yarn of fairly simple people. There's

Gone With The Wind Essay

1803 words - 8 pages needed for the war. Being a blockade-runner was an extremely dangerous job and by doing this you were risking your life, Rhett could have been killed at any time. These men that volunteered to do this were often paid large amounts of money and became very wealthy. Many of these men were often just in it for the money, not to help their country. ​Gone With the Wind was a phenomenal book. As I mentioned above, I would recommend this book to anyone who