Books Vs. Movies Essay

799 words - 4 pages

Generally, movie adaptations of books are not exact replicas of the original. The reason is mainly that the original storyline needs to be modified in order to quench the audience's thirst for action, whereas those who read books usually enjoy the slow, steady build-up of a valuable plot which will never be replaced by movies. Moreover, books allow the reader’s imagination to roam free, but movies can offer a new and different perspective. The fictional novel The Sword in the Stone by T.H. White and its animated counterpart, also named The Sword in the Stone, by Disney are no exception. The animated adaptation includes several similar features as well as different elements, as shown in the plot events and the characters, which are essentially the deciding components in deciding which form of the story is superior.
First, the plot indicates some similar structures as well as different events. One example of a difference is the scene in the novel in which the Wart travels into the forest in order to “bring Cully,” the goshawk, back to Hob, whereas in the movie, the Wart ventures into the forest to retrieve an arrow that Kay shot. It indicates that the reasons behind the actions differ, despite the fact that the actions themselves are the same. The scene is an instance of a critical difference between the book and the movie because it is fundamental for the exposition, even if it looks insignificant at first. Although there are differences between the two, there are also many similarities, as shown when the Wart is transformed into different animals in order to experience and learn about important lessons. For example, the Wart learns to not “be tyrannical,” from being a badger in the novel, and about the powers of love from being a squirrel in the movie. Even though the lessons in themselves are not exactly the same, the plot structure remains relatively similar. Such similarities shows that the movie-makers attempted to remain as close to the original storyline as possible, despite the minor changes. These seemingly trivial modifications occur not only in the plot structure, but also in the characters.
Secondly, the characters appear mostly the same, but when one takes a closer look, their particular roles amongst each other are not depicted the same in the movie as it is in the...

Find Another Essay On Books vs. Movies

Antitrust Practices and Market Power Essay

668 words - 3 pages Antitrust Practices and Market Power Apple was investigated and subsequently ruled against in United States District Court giving the US Justice Department an antitrust victory. The case alleged Apple had colluded with five major publishers to fix the prices of electronic books (e-books). In 2010 Apple introduced an in which the publishers set retail prices in return for a commission paid to Apple. The publishers were under a contract which said

Comparison and Contrast of "The Most Dangerous Game" by Richard Connell with the 1930s movie version -short

585 words - 2 pages "The Most Dangerous Game" is a short story about a hunter named "Sanger Rainsford" who is marooned on an island after accidentally falling off a yacht and is a highly anthologized story. As the film industry has done many times before and will continue to do so, very popular short stories, such as this one, and books get remade as movies. Traditionally when Hollywood does this, a few liberties are taken and some elements of the original work are

Possession of Obscene Material and Infringement on Civil Liberties

1298 words - 5 pages possession of obscene material in ones’ home may not be prohibited by law. Writing for court in case Stanley vs. Georgia Justice Thurgood Marshall wrote “if the First Amendment means anything it means that the state has no business telling a man sitting in his home what books he may read or what films he may watch”. With regards to the law of obscene, the only thing I would change is to take it out of law. However, I would leave in and stricken

The hunter or the hunted

999 words - 4 pages jungle and, of all things a majestic chateau owned by General Zaroff. Connelle lets you know right away General Zaroff is the story’s antagonist. Zaroff is a former aristocratic Cossack commander and Russian big game hunter. Zaroff tells Rainsford he is aware he is also big game hunter tells Rainsford he has read all his books on hunting. During the dinner that night while enjoying champagne, borsch and filet mignon, Zaroff comments on how he

Screenplay Writing

1733 words - 7 pages the writer, and makes his writing better than before. He is well on his way to a superb screenplay.Watching movies and talking to friends are good, but another good way to gain writing skills is to read books. Books open the doors to a deeper grasp of what a story should be, and what characters should be like. The story is raw and observable. You can flip through and through meditating on story. Pure story can be read and reread, and then

Motion Pictures with Sound

2953 words - 12 pages ever movies, sound was not in any of the motion pictures directly. Silent films would have accompaniment from full orchestras to one piano player. Films would come with a list of suggested music to be played and books were published that categorized pieces according to the mood or situation. In fact, the very first silent film that had a musical score put together specifically for it was in 1915 called Birth of a Nation. One of the reasons that live

Definitions of art and how the 8 forms fit into that definition!

965 words - 4 pages disagreement is what constitutes art and good art vs. bad art. With both there is no single definition that is widely agreed upon. A common and well known view is that art requires a creative and distinctive perception of both the artist and intended audience. The work of art must also possess a sense of quality in order to be considered "good art." The following websites provide insight to how dance, visual arts, music, film, television, radio

John Grisham

804 words - 3 pages expensive material objects. In the novel, John Grisham puts Mitch McDeere in a crossfire between the FBI, the Mob, and the Firm, these groups played a major part in the plot, this is were Grisham uses the “David and Goliath Sagas,” (solo man vs. FBI, Mob, and the Firm). Seitz confirms ”Grisham has a disarmingly genuine sympathy for ‘little people’.”      Contemporary viewers demand law based movies/TV shows, for the reason that

Stephen King

849 words - 3 pages other vicarious thrills from listening to tales of horror on the radio, reading such spine-tingling comic books as Weird Science, Tales from the Crypt, and Tales from the Vault. He also went to see science fiction and monster movies. In October 1957, the local theater manager interrupted a Saturday matinee screening of Earth vs. the Flying Saucers to announce the Soviet Union’s launching of Sputnik, the first artificial earth satellite. It was

Free Speech

805 words - 3 pages , when the Congress enacted the Alien and Sedition Acts. These acts made it a criminal offense to entice people to overthrow an established government" (Microsoft "Speech, Freedom of"). Once again, one can see how the freedom of speech is not completely absolute. The government can also interfere in the freedom of speech by enforcing censorship. Censorship is evident in the movies, music and books. Some states have eliminated

IPod vs. Zune

1777 words - 7 pages Outline iPod vs. ZuneIntroduction:I. DimensionsA. Cost1. What comes in the boxB. Size/Capacity/Storage1. Songs/Video2. Battery Life3. DisplayC. What can they do?II. iTunes vs. Zune MarketplaceA. Cost of CD download vs. subscriptionB. Price Per SongC. Song ListingsD. UsabilityIII. AccessoriesA. Types of Cable connectionsB. DocksC. Carrying CasesD. Speakers and HeadphonesIV. CritiquesA. Internet ChatB. CritiquesV. ConclusioniPod vs. ZuneThe battle

Similar Essays

Books Vs Movies Essay

760 words - 3 pages PAGE PAGE 1 Andrew Donner Donner Professor Curtis English 2010 31 August 2008 Books vs MoviesEntertainment is when the mind becomes intrigued with a book or movie that captures your attention in a story. One of the ways a person or an audience stays interested is if they feel they can relate to a situation in a world that they only hear about in movies or read in a book. Both of these ways of entertainment can receive attention, but only one

This Is An Essay About "The Classical American Journey" As Portraid In Many Books And Movies

707 words - 3 pages just south of America. The brand new Disney movie, Brother Bear, also is a movie of a man's physical journey across America who on the way goes through many emotional journeys. These types of movies and books that come out are directly influenced by America's journeying history and the fact that journey stories have been unrelentingly popular.

My Criteria For Film Evaluation Essay

1053 words - 4 pages strong and stable standard for deciding which film to go to, because with such a large population of movie watchers, major biases don't affect the reputation and ratings are fair and accurate. Also, people are inclined to give high ratings to movies that touch them or really make them think regardless of the actual film taking quality. This implies that the highest ratings are something not to miss out on, because I personally believe that movies are

Harry Potter Vs. Edward Cullen Essay

1052 words - 4 pages fans, witches and wizards vs. vampires and werewolves, Harry vs. Edward, Magic vs. romance. But why are these books popular? What sparks peoples interest? Will they be around forever? Or just a passing fad. In order to understand why the phenomena of these books a basic understanding of the plots is necessary. The Harry Potter series is a seven book series about a boy wizard by JK Rowling that started in 1998. At age, eleven he's introduced