Borders And Dreams By Chris Carger

1825 words - 7 pages

Borders and Dreams by Chris Carger

In the book Borders and Dreams, Chris Carger shows the readers the hardships of Alejandro, a Spanish-American boy with very little educational background. In her case study of both Alejandro and his family she shows how the limitations of Alejandro, his parents, and an overpopulated school system can make succeeding in an American school nearly impossible. In this paper I will look at all the obstacles that Alejandro faced both before and during his education. Also, I will identify both the things that I felt were done right in his schooling and the things I felt were done wrong. To finish I will give some of the idea's I have that could possibly have helped Alejandro.
1. Describe at least three ways that educators characterize their students' abilities and needs? The first way teachers characterize their students abilities is by labeling them. Throughout Carger's book we see this, both in Alejandro and in Alejandro's sister Alicia who was called "At risk," limited English proficient," "learning disabled," and Linguistically delayed"(p. 54) Labeling is something we in American have to do, it's just our nature. However, labeling can be dangerous because it can be a stigma that they have to live with for the rest of their lives, also I think it gives the child an excuse to fail. They can just say well, I'm dropping out because I'm learning disabled.

A second way is by ethnicity or social standing, granted this is a sometimes racist way to characterize children. We do see this in Borders and Dreams, with Alejandro who was put into a Latino private school instead of a regular public highschool. This was possible because Chicago is a big culturally diverse city, with 20000 Latinos in the Chicago elementary school system(27) In schools I have gone to social standing is very important, children of important members of society always had it easier than children who were poor, or whose parents were not in the PTA. In small cities where everybody knows everybody this is a very common occurrence, even though it is very wrong.

A third and the most obvious way that educators characterize the needs and abilities of their students is with grades. Whether your in first grade and get U's or S's, or your in highschool and get A's, B's, C's, D's, or F's teachers are always judging students ability levels. Another tool used for this is standardized testing. The two are then combined to decide whether a student is smart, average, or in need of outside help. Grades though they were certainly harsh to Alejandro, are a necessity of teaching.

2. Using deficit-model language, describe Alejandro's situation. What educational implications or actions does your description suggest?

Alejandro had several strikes against him when it came to his education, first and foremost was cultural. Alejandro, though he went to kindergarten in Chicago had most of his early schooling in Mexico(1st-3rd...

Find Another Essay On Borders and Dreams by Chris Carger

Dreams in Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck

1671 words - 7 pages Dreams in Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck A dream can be described as an ambition or the aspiration to reach a goal in life. In the novel "Of Mice and Men" John Steinbeck creates characters to have an optimistic dream. These dreams are ones which they would all like to make a reality. They all have a longing and desire to fulfil their dreams. For example, Lennie and George are both working to get their own land

An African American's Dreams and “Harlem” by Langston Hughes

1255 words - 5 pages “Harlem” by Langston Hughes is a poem that talks about what happens when we postpones our dreams. The poem is made up of a series of similes and it ends with a metaphor. The objective of the poem is to get us to think about what happens to a dream that is put off, postponed; what happens when we create our very own shelve of dreams? The “dream” refers to a goal in life, not the dreams we have while sleeping, but our deepest desires. There are

Dreams in 'Of Mice And Men' by John Steinbeck

1621 words - 6 pages Weed because of some trouble that Lennie caused. This seems to forebode that they might fail to realize their dreams because of Lennie´s fondness for petting things. And this is exactly what happens. Lennie, although killed by George, really died when Curley´s wife set her sights on the big man. When George meets up with Lennie after the accident, he knows the dream is over for him too. He also knew what he had to do as soon as he

The Lost Generation in The Swimmer, by John Cheever and Winter Dreams, by F. Scott Fitzgerald

662 words - 3 pages “The Swimmer” by John Cheever and “Winter Dreams” by F. Scott Fitzgerald have many elements in common. These stories are about two wealthy men interacting with other wealthy people. As the stories progress Neddy and Dexter search for the truth and the meaning of life. These two literary works fall under the literary movement called The Lost Generation. Finally, at the end of the narratives they are both grieving for themselves and realize that

Broken Dreams and Predictable Future in Ex-Basketball Player by John Updike

1124 words - 4 pages , Nibs, and Juju Beads.” This is referring to Flick’s childhood. He is sitting and looking right past Mae at the candy, which reminds him of when he was a kid and used to eat candy. John Updike does a wonderful job bringing together multiple themes by telling the story of Flick Webb’s life. The biggest theme is that of broken dreams. Flick had the talent to make it far in his basketball career but sometimes our dreams do not work out like we would

Compares and contrasts How Krakauer's life (the novelist) parallels Chris McCandlesses's in the Novel Into the Wild, by Jon Krakauer. Includes 3 in text citations and 3 works cited.

1373 words - 5 pages , Krakauer looks for the clues to the mystery that is Chris McCandless. What he finds is the intense pull of the wilderness on our imagination, the appeal of high-risk activities to young men. When McCandless's mistakes turn out to be fatal he is dismissed for his naiveté. He was said by some to have a death wish, but wanting to die and wanting to see what one is capable of are too very different things. I began to ask myself if Chris really

Comparison of Mitty in real life and in his dreams: "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty" by James Thurber.

738 words - 3 pages , "Not so fast! What are you driving so fast for?" (3). Mitty is sent briskly sent back to real life and continued his path silently with an inner disappointment. Mitty is a sad man when people derive him of his dreams. Mitty tries to improve his life and the only way to do so is by daydreaming in his globe.Mitty's life is alienated into two existences; his ideal daydreams and his flawed life. Not only does his wife disrespect him but also the

"Of Mice and Men" by John Steinbeck: The theme of dreams in this novel, but explaining a quote from the story.

815 words - 3 pages it, but it's jus in their head.""Of mice and men", written by John Steinbeck, the quote was taken form this novel. Spoken by a negro stable buck named Crooks on the subject of dreams. Broken,unachieved, unfinished and unreachable dreams is what the quote is about. One of the themes of the novel is the typical American dream. A dream for owning their own piece of land and working for oneself. Looking back at the title of the novel, it means that

Gatsby's dream was what destroyed him- an essay about The Great Gatsby by Scott Fitzgerald, and the way dreams can destroy the actual life

987 words - 4 pages dreams, his happiness and his grief, his success and his failure. She was the kind of girl who could impress everybody both by her beauty and charm and the social status of her family. For the young Gatsby, coming from an ordinary poor family in a small town, the excitement of the fancy house and the beauty of Daisy come as one dazzling image that imprinted in Gatsby's mind and left a sign in all his further life. For him being near her was an

"Julius Caesar" by William Shakespeare: Explain how omens, dreams and supernatural events feature in the play, Julius Caesar. What do they contribute to the play?

1085 words - 4 pages shows how the supernatural were important to Elizabethan times as fate played a major role in their lives. It also contributes to the foreshadowing and the fact that dreams play a huge responsibility in peoples' lives in the time Shakespeare was alive.The supernatural events continue to feature in Julius Caesar as they show character traits by their responses to certain issues. Shakespeare gives us insight into Caesar's character when a Soothsayer

What "The Standard of Living," by author Dorothy Parker, suggests about the beliefs, dreams, and value systems of today's materialistic society.

1047 words - 4 pages The following is a discussion of what the short story "The Standard of Living," by author Dorothy Parker, suggests about the beliefs, dreams, and value systems of today's materialistic society through a satire of the lives of two young American working girls.People are shallow, greedy, selfish, and generally immoral creatures--they were in 1941 (when the story was written) and they still are now. What some people do not accept is that a person's

Similar Essays

Geographic Borders: Borders: A Very Short Introduction, By Alexander C. Diener And Joshua Hagen

1479 words - 6 pages Borders: A Very Short Introduction, by Alexander C. Diener and Joshua Hagen, is a brief the history of geographic borders and their implications on the world throughout history. Diener and Hagen make the argument that borders, as commonly understood today, are a relatively new phenomenon and as humanity moves forward borders modern boarders will no longer be possible. The writers maintain as globalization continues to make the world a smaller

Used Both Hardball By Chris Matthews And The Prince By Niccolo Machiavelli

3451 words - 14 pages Good government is defined by the competing values of efficiency and effectiveness and is dependent on quality leadership. Niccolo Machiavelli's treatise, The Prince and Hardball: How Politics Is Played Told By One Who Knows the Game, written by journalist and commentator, Chris Matthews are two books that explain the art of leadership from a political perspective. The Prince was initially published posthumously in 1531-1532. While working for

Political Views From The Tip And The Gipper By Chris Matthew

730 words - 3 pages not Democrats and Republicans. We were Americans"(321). Chris Matthews made the decision to focus on the key events of the Reagan presidency In which the the Speaker and President work together for the benefit of the country. Foreign policy with the Soviet Union, tax reforms, and the nations deficit are all deeply analyzed. Matthews transports us back to 1980, where Washington is run by a Republican President and House but a Senate ruled with

A Brief Moment In The Life Of Angus Bethune, By Chris Crutcher And The Scarlet Ibis, By James Hurst

1288 words - 5 pages Angus Bethune, a big kid with gay parents. Doodle’s brother, a relation to an invalid sibling. Who would have thought that these two boys could have anything in common? In “A Brief Moment in the Life of Angus Bethune,” by Chris Crutcher, the main character, Angus Bethune, is an adolescent full of insecurities. In “The Scarlet Ibis,” by James Hurst, the narrator is a boy who has trouble with his own pride. Each of these boys change their view on