This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

New York Times Vs Sullivan An Opinionated Overview Of The Case And Our Thoughts On What Category It Should Fall Under.

866 words - 3 pages

The New York Times carried a full-page advertisement entitled, Heed Their Rising Voices for the Committee to Defend Martin Luther King and the Struggle for Freedom in the South. In short The advertisement suggested that public officials in the South were using violent and illegal means to try to stop the civil rights movement. Although the advertisement's claims were somewhat truthful, some minor factual errors were made. Sullivan, the Montgomery Alabama Police Commissioner, claimed these errors damaged his reputation and he won $500,000 in a libel case in Alabama.
The case was appealed to the US Supreme Court, where the decision was unanimously reversed, saying the New York Times was not guilty of reckless disregard for the truth. The Court ruled that the importance of free debate in a democratic society was more important than factual errors that might upset or even damage public officials. To win a libel case, public officials now needed to prove that damaging statements were printed with malicious intent (actual malice). The Supreme Court( mostly Brennan )defined malice as "A reckless disregard for the truth, or advance knowledge of falsity."Since the ruling made it difficult for public officials to sue for libel, questions arose as to who was and who was not a public official. The Supreme Court eventually changed the term to public figure. The Court continues to give the mass media room for honest error. Which is very much needed. Allowing reporters, government officials, and such to have some sort of leeway when giving reportsAlong with this standard Justice Brennan had redirected the burden of proof onto the plaintiff. Originally it was the defendants job to prove to the court of his/her own innocence. A total of six rules were standardized to prove the actual defamation. As listed; the use of defamatory language, to whom the defamatory language was being directed, whether the defamatory material was widely spread, if the article was negligent or reckless, if the article is related to matters of public concern then they must prove it to be false, and last of all would be personal damages whether they be financial or emotional.
Along with these standards the supreme court had extended the ideas of the New York Times Vs Sullivan case to all other cases. However they divided them into sub categories such as; Public Figures, All Purpose Figures, Vortex Public Figures, and other limited public figures.
An All Purpose Public Figure is a person who is very well known and has achieved either famous or infamous status. The Vortex variety are people that get sucked in...

Find Another Essay On New York Times vs Sullivan An opinionated overview of the case and our thoughts on what category it should fall under.

The New York Times Coverage of the Holocaust

1607 words - 7 pages were under informed, to the billions of lives living and learning about it today. In the time of the Holocaust (1933-1945) The New York Times under informed the American public and made them blind to the events occurring in Eastern Europe; their negligence impacted the Holocaust because America could have done more to stop the atrocities. Highlight the importance In a newspaper, normally more important news is published on the front page, except

The New York Times coverage of the Holocaust

1594 words - 7 pages The New York Times coverage of the Holocaust A lesson in time The years of the Holocaust was an experience people will never forget. Everyone is involved; including those who suffered in Eastern Europe as well as those who were informed and those who were under informed, to the billions of lives living and learning about it today. In the time of the Holocaust (1933-1945) The New York Times under informed the American public and made them blind

Channels of Distribution- New York Times

554 words - 2 pages The New York Times Channels of DistributionNews and information is vital to community awareness. Establishing and maintaining credibility in the delivery of news and information is an ongoing task. Capturing new customer use of the New York Times is the focus of the following paper. An overview of strategic multi-platform, multi-channel approach to grow both their national/global Knowledge Audience business and our Local Market business will be

This essay is about the book A Seperate Peace by John Knowles. Wasn't really sure what category this should go under; it's literature but i don't know what it means by North American or European, etc

811 words - 3 pages Peter Stephens Framed Dr. Hawley Crippen, a well respected professional living in a suburban lifestyle, was hanged in 1910 for supposedly poisoning and dismembering his wife. It wasn't until 2008, nearly a century later, that his innocence was proved with a DNA test. Our novel contains a very similar incident regarding the death of Phineas. In A Separate Peace by John Knowles, Gene is thought to be the primary factor behind Finny

HARD TIMES Book Review: Hard Times by Studs Terkel An Oral History Of The Great Depression New York: Pantheon Books, 1970

1643 words - 7 pages different thing," as Moley remembers. It is interesting to read what one of the presidents right hand man recalls about his similarities and experiences with Roosevelt. Then goes on to talk about the presidents plans and his influence in his decisions. However, Stud Terkel's book would be greatly constructed if he had included an index and a bibliography for his interviewees, and interesting and important subjects. The titles Hard Times

The 1863 Draft Riots: New York City Under Siege

2379 words - 10 pages began. (Bernstein, What Did the New York City Draft Rioters Think They Were Doing?, pg. 277).As this was happening another mob attacked the Colored Orphan Asylum over on Fifth Avenue. This orphanage housed 237 children under the age of 12. The rioters saw it as symbols of white charity and black upward mobility. A mob of several thousand men, women, and children raided the asylum, looted it, and set it on fire. The building was burned to the ground

The Test" written by Njabulo Ndebele and the New York Times 2005 World Cup Sports Report

1499 words - 6 pages Text 1a) is an extract from a short story named "The Test", written by Njabulo Ndebele (1983). It is about a young boy called Thoba and its passion for playing street football with his friends, before he heads home. Text 1b) is a newspaper article (sports report) from the New York Times (2005) which treats the World Cup, a real event happening every four years.Both texts share the theme of football, however they approach this sport in a

Stereotyping of Arab Muslims in the New York Times for the Past Forty Years

3594 words - 14 pages years? The goal of this research project is to reveal the negative stereotypes directed towards Arab Muslims in the New York Times. The critical focus of the research is the consistency of the negative stereotypes. The underlying focus is what theoretical and historical effects result from the negative stereotypes. WHAT IS STEREOTYPING? The operational definition is "an idea, expression, lacking in originality or inventiveness. A simplified

New York Times Scholarship Part 3

277 words - 2 pages New York Times Scholarship - Part III                  My one greatest academic achievement that I've accomplished         would have to be keeping good and consistent grades throughout my         three and half years in high school.                  This single thing, even though it is over a span of years, is the most                  important to me because after all the hard work that

Analysis of Andrew Rossi´s Documentary Film Page One: Inside the New York Times

645 words - 3 pages a few months ago, a story of a Florida sinkhole showed up in the paper. It is also known that many local news stations and newspapers consult the Times when deciding what to publish. For example, Channel 5 WPTV has 15 copies of the times delivered to their station every day. The station does not publish anything until it has consulted with the Times. This shows that in addition to the New York Times profound widespread influence, there is also a

Hard Times Living In New York

600 words - 2 pages , the English and the French fought for control of it. Finally, in 1763, Martinique was definitively declared French. Since then, it has followed the same course of history as France. It was an agricultural country, and in the 18th and 19th centuries, slaves worked the island's tobacco and sugar plantations until slavery was abolished in 1848. Its status as a French colony continued until after World War II, and it became a department in 1946. It

Similar Essays

New York Times And The Republican Party

1303 words - 6 pages In 1884, the New York Times was under the direction of a new publisher, George Jones, Jones was disgusted with the way the Grant administration was governed and allowed for constant scandal to plague its effectiveness. Previously the paper had a strong connection to the Republican party, under their new direction the paper choose to endorse the Democratic party. Those who were running on the Republican ticket were not qualified to fix the issues

The Daily News Vs. The New York Times

801 words - 3 pages . Listings.Furthermore, The Daily News and The New York Times are also different in many ways. The Daily News has lots of large and bold print headlines to catch a person's eye. In certain ways, the headlines are sensationalized such as this headline: "Con Care, Home for elderly hires drug criminals as nurse's aides." Moreover mostly all of their articles have a picture beside it. The Daily News not only reports about the local news, but also on

Case Analysis : New York Times Digital

1602 words - 6 pages Wall."This case analysis focuses on the New York Times Digital (NYTD), The New York Times Company's business unit, launched in 1995, that provides online news and information services in multimedia format, and includes NYTimes.com, Boston.com, and an archive distribution business. It operates by providing a high-quality, worldwide online audience with trusted editorial content from The New York Times and the Boston Globe. It is focused on

Case Analysis : New York Times Digital

1551 words - 6 pages Wall."This case analysis focuses on the New York Times Digital (NYTD), The New York Times Company's business unit, launched in 1995, that provides online news and information services in multimedia format, and includes NYTimes.com, Boston.com, and an archive distribution business. It operates by providing a high-quality, worldwide online audience with trusted editorial content from The New York Times and the Boston Globe. It is focused on