Brian Clark's Play Whose Life Is It Anyway?

1160 words - 5 pages

Brian Clark's Play "Whose Life Is It Anyway?"

The play "Whose Life Is It Anyway" by Brian Clark was made into a stage
play and film. The television play was made in 1972 and the stage
plays in 1978. In the play,” written by Brian Clarke, the intense
argument of committing Voluntary Euthanasia is discussed.

The main point of the play, Ken Harrison, once an imaginative, devoted
sculptor, is involved in a terrible car crash. Following a long
operation, Ken is paralyzed from the neck down; he is informed that he
may never be able to move his body ever again.

Brian Clark in a similar way uses different characters to show a
different view of Ken's possibilities. Dr. Emerson thinks Ken's life
is precious and should be kept at any cost, no matter what Ken's
wishes are. Dr. Scott also wants Ken to stay alive but values Ken's
opinion and thoughts more than Dr. Emerson, she thinks sympathy a lot.
Dr. Travers shows a view on Ken's problem, he sees it the same way as
Dr. Emerson, and thinks of it as a mental patient wanting to commit
suicide, and is happy to back up Dr. Emerson in a court of law, and
also sees it as doing a favor for Dr. Emerson, no matter what he finds
whilst talking to Ken.

In order to make the play more dramatic the debate further Brian Clark
uses a dramatic point. The point is that before Ken suffered his
accident he was happy and wanted to go on living, but at that time
people listened to him and he could have argued a point and people
would have listened to it. Now that Ken finds himself in a situation
where he doesn't want to go on living, few people want to listen to
him: 'Only my brain functions unimpaired but even that is futile
because I can't act on any conclusions it comes to. This hearing
proves that. Will you please listen?' The entire play is a power
struggle between Ken and the medical establishment. Ken is visited by
Mrs. Boyle, a social worker who tries to help Ken to move on and
accept his disability and living a life with the disability. Mrs.
Boyle is capable of helping some people but Ken isn't interested, his
greatest passion in life was his sculpture, and because Dr. Emerson
has confirmed his worst fears - that he will never use his hands
again, he can never sculpt again. Without this his life is meaningless
and Ken doesn't want Mrs. Boyles help, Ken absolutely takes her to
pieces, he throws everything he has at her.

The title starts the play with a question and it’s answered towards
the end of the play. The title in a way shows that it is meant to be,
partly, a clash of wills between two sides. In Act 1 the audience
finds out about the main character, Ken Harrison, about his accident
and the injuries it caused. Dr. Emerson, the attending physician,
believes that Ken is just depressed and that if given time will choose
to live. He states, "It is impossible to injure the body to the extent
that Mr. Harrison had and not affect the mind." From his experience,
he...

Find Another Essay On Brian Clark's Play Whose Life Is It Anyway?

Whose life is it? Reasons for legalizing euthanasia

1976 words - 8 pages "Whose life is it, anyways?" Life itself is complicated but allowing people to die by assistance is far more complex. Euthanasia is still a controversial issue in North American society, in particular Canada. Euthanasia comes from the Greek word euthantos literally meaning "well death." In modern English, it is defined as "bringing about of a gentle death in the case of incurable and painful disease." There are two basic types of euthanasia

Whose Job is it Anyways Essay

1267 words - 6 pages on modern life. This could be a great help when you have a very male-driven job and all the ideals were becoming the same; having some womanly insight could just be enough change to make new ideas spark. Although this is not supporting equal opportunity, it would not eliminate the presence of men and women co-functioning together. Universalizability would be the best theory of morality for modern cultures decision making. This idea highlights the

Physician assisted suicide: Whose Choice Is It?

1292 words - 5 pages Euthanasia: Whose Choice Is It?Most people in North America die what may be called a bad death. One studyfound that, "More often than not, patients died in pain, their desires concerningtreatment neglected, after spending 10 days or more in an intensive care unit."(Introduction 1)Is a painful death a natural and acceptable fact of life? It is my belief that aperson with a terminal disease enduring uncontrollable pain who has the desire toend

Crimea-Whose Land is it Anyways?

1796 words - 8 pages Crimea - Whose Land is it Anyways? Imagine that all your life you have been immersed in the culture of your homeland and then your land is suddenly given to another country. You and your people are not represented by this country’s government what-so-ever and you have been forced to live under that country’s flag and leadership for 20 years. The new government created a regional governmental representation which has no power to get rid of

Translations(Brian Friel)is best read as an elegy for a doomed culture. The only response it elicits is to mourn that culture depicted in the play as forever lost. Do you agree?

1623 words - 6 pages through life with a story about themselves, where they came from who their friends are and who their enemies are. The play makes us question whether what we believe, think or even remember is true. Our memories and our histories are so influenced by parents, literature and education it would be possible to especially in 1980's Northern Ireland to grow up with a very one sided view of your personal history. Even though the play obviously has its own

Whose role is it to develop the skills needed by future professionals?

1396 words - 6 pages "It is …commonly asserted that students are ill-prepared for the future workplace and that they need new kind of skills to perform well" Stasz et al. (1996:1).In the light of this statement, whose role is it to develop the skills needed by future professionals?Develop the Generic SkillsRecently, the generic skills are become more and more important. People always want to become more valuable and secure. The future workplace has been

[Twelfth Night] Compare what the men and women do for love in the play. Whose love is more passionate?

1355 words - 5 pages saying her love's complexion and age is similar to Orsino's. Same scene 101-117, her story of her sister's concealed love further hints her love for her master and tension between them is built up. In Act V sc I 121-127, she declares her love for Orsino and vows that she will even die for him. It shows her willingness to sacrifice for love even it's her own life. Ambiguity in her lines may suggest passivity, but it seems to be more convincing that

This essay tells about the views of cloning and how it is wrong to play God and create another life

1222 words - 5 pages expecting new strands of DNA that are not damaged, and thatcarry no diseases. There is just not enough knowledge about cloning to date tobegin to clone humans.What will these human clones be used for anyway? They certainly cannot replacesomeone that may be deceased. Just by replicating a persons genes does notreplicate the environment and the development experiences that makes a personwho that are. If you do clone a human, it doesn't mean that

'It is difficult to see Othello as a hero. Rather, he is a weak, gullible, proud man whose tragic fate leaves the audience feeling little sympathy.' Do you agree with this statement? Support your...

1175 words - 5 pages guardage to the sooty bosom of one such as thou." This statement by Bravantio claims that he thinks he is worthless and that he does not deserve his daughter because of the colour of his skin. The amount of racist comments made against Othello throughout the play helps you to sympathise with him as it shows how prejudice the state was to him.I also sympathise with Othello because he lands himself in a place of psychological distress. You see how

Whose Hair is it Anyways

1799 words - 8 pages If something was given away for free, would you then pay an outside source to retrieve it? The common sense answer would be no or at least not much. Paying for something free is ignorant, especially when the person who gave it away doesn’t even want it. They gave it away frivolously for either religious reasons or no reason at all. Unfortunately, not that many people have common sense. Today buyers are spending thousands and thousands of dollars

Columbine whose fault is it

1125 words - 5 pages (Balk, p.473). It is a well-known fact that the Harris and Klebold both liked to pass the time playing violent video games and watching violent television and programs. The boys' favorite game was Doom II. The object of the game is to kill the enemy by shooting them to death. According to Zillmann (1989), exposure to pornography desensitizes viewers' to the crime of rape (Balk, p. 388). Can this theory also apply to violence? Klebold and Harris

Similar Essays

How Does Brian Clark Make His Play Whose Life Is It Anyway?

1269 words - 5 pages How does Brian Clark make his play Whose life is it anyway? Interesting, Memorable and Dramatic for a modern audience. Brian Clark makes “whose life is it anyway?” an interesting memorable play for a modern audience by using a wide variety of techniques that are available when writing plays. The play addresses a range of modern day issues. Recently Charlotte Wyatt’s case and Christopher Reeves’ death have broadened the awareness of the

How Brian Clark Avoids Senintimentality In Whose Life Is It Anyway

1633 words - 7 pages ‘Whose life is it anyway?’ follows the story of ‘Ken Harrison’, a man who tries to exercise a choice over his own life or death after being completely paralysed from the head down. Harrison received these horrific injuries after being involved in a car accident 4 months before the story starts. He is now in constant care within the hospitals walls being treated and cared for by the medical profession. The play centres on Harrison’s determination

Whose Life Is It Anyway? Essay

4522 words - 18 pages Does Clarkpresent arguments for and against assisted suicide without prejudicing the audience in Whose Life Is It Anyway? The central character in 'Whose Life Is It Anyway?' is Ken Harrison who is a patient in the hospital, in which the play is set. The play sees Ken, who has been involved in a horrific car accident, recovering from various injuries, some of which will never heal. The accident leaves Ken paralysed from the neck

Kwame Anthony Appiah's Whose Culture Is It Anyway?

976 words - 4 pages To: Dr. Daniel H. Levine From: Yiqun Ren Date: March 27, 2014 Subject: Discussion of “Whose Culture Is It, Anyway?” by Appiah Kwame Anthony Appiah argued that objects of cultural are of potential value to all human beings, holding an opinion of a universal ownership of cultural objects and the on-going appropriations underwritten by such claims. However, his support for pan-human ownership of cultural artifacts and cosmopolitanism are