This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Brigham Young University And The Mountain Meadows Massacre By Juanita Brooks

1092 words - 4 pages

Brigham Young University and The Mountain Meadows Massacre by Juanita Brooks

The Mountain Meadows Massacre by Juanita Brooks recounts a tragic historical event in a manner that can teach important lessons. The book is well researched and well written and reflects the great historical significance of the massacre. In addition, students learn religious lessons studying the book and its subject. Although some members of the Church and a few of Brigham Young University's faculty doubt the wisdom of teaching The Mountain Meadows Massacre, this book should be taught at BYU.

The Mountain Meadows Massacre is an important book written by an important author. Some justifiably argue that Brooks's book is invalid because she is excessively defensive of John D. Lee-thus, they reason, the book is too subjective to take seriously as a historical work. Despite this shortcoming, the book is, overall, an excellent piece of critical writing. Brooks bases her book on primary sources displaying various opinions about the massacre. Even if the book is not completely objective, students can learn from bad examples as well as good ones. Studying The Mountain Meadows Massacre, especially under the direction of a competent teacher, can teach students to think critically about literature and avoid errors in their own writing. In addition to its literary merits, the book is a prime example of how authors can have a significant influence on the public. After Brooks's book was published, members of the Church began to research and discuss the Massacre more openly. One Mormon historian states: "Beginning with the landmark work of Juanita Brooks and proceeding at an increased pace during the past dozen years a spirit of openness, reconciliation, and healing has unfolded" (Leonard 14). The extensive research that has been performed on the Massacre has catalyzed important changes, such as the construction of a memorial at Mountain Meadows and the reinstatement of John D. Lee to the Church. A Mormon woman historian was able to change her world through her research and writing. The book and its author are significant enough to warrant study.

Students should also study the Mountain Meadows Massacre as an important event in history. It is relatively rare that 120 innocent people are slaughtered, especially by members of a church that generally endorsees pacifism and certainly not murder. It is extremely important to know how and why these things happened. When students understand mistakes made by others they are less likely to make the same mistakes themselves. The Mountain Meadows Massacre exposes the dangers of "us-versus-them" thinking and the devastating effects of mass hysteria in a militaristic atmosphere.

A university is more credible when students and teachers can discuss any event, no matter the controversy surrounding it. Richard L. Bushman, professor emeritus of Columbia University, stated concerning controversial matters in Mormon history, "You don't want...

Find Another Essay On Brigham Young University and The Mountain Meadows Massacre by Juanita Brooks

The Mother by Gwendolyn Brooks and The Man He Killed by Thomas Hardy

2070 words - 8 pages works of an author or authors. The works of poetry in this comparison are “The Mother,” by Gwendolyn Brooks; “The Man He Killed,” by Thomas Hardy; and “Ballad of Birmingham,” by Dudley Randall. At first glance, each of these poems seems to have very little in common with one another. On one hand, they are unique to each specific poem unto itself. On the other hand, these three pieces of poetry are alike in many ways. The analysis of each poem in

The Formalist Critics, by Cleanth Brooks

1821 words - 7 pages through a subjective lens, since the author and the critic cannot subjectively separate themselves from themselves and in making these points he contradicts himself. Cleanth Brooks starts his essay by listing “articles of faith I could subscribe to” (Brooks 19) and pointing out statements about literary criticism that might go with a formalist criticism. Yet he questions that list in its end, and seems to slate that his writings have been largely

Analysis: The Explorer by Gwendolyn Brooks and Fredrick Douglass by Robert Hayden

1456 words - 6 pages . They couldn’t be or do what they wanted because they were forced to live and do what and how the white people wanted. No matter how hard it got, they still had hope. They knew that their ancestors had succeeded and that if they continued to try they would succeed. In The Explorer by Gwendolyn Brooks and Fredrick Douglass by Robert Hayden show in three way hoe people were hurt, but also the wants of the people: freedom, hope and individuality

The Mountain by Robert Frost

859 words - 4 pages trying to persuade the narrator to climb the mountain, he speaks about the beautiful scenes surrounding the mountain. There are different ways to manipulate someone to do what a person would need from them. One way is by telling them about the beautiful experience and scenery they will observe. This is the exact route the farmer was going for; he could change the perception of one man by not doing it in such a horrid way. Overcoming fears is

An Analysis of The Explorer by Gwendolyn Brooks and Frederick Douglass by Robert Hayden from Both Archetypal and Social Perspectives

1396 words - 6 pages Brooks’ text The Explorer and Robert Hayden’s text Frederick Douglass are reflections of both the archetypal idea of universal human want, and the social interpretation of strictly African American culture. The social view of The Explorer allows for a very vast look into the lives of African American’s living in urban areas in the mid twentieth century. There was, and still is, a very distinct cultural separation between the lives of the colored and

Analysis of the Peom "The Crazy Woman" by Gwendolyn Brooks

733 words - 3 pages themselves, have individuality and not let what people say bother them. The speaker’s tone is portrayed as gloomy by using words as gray , frosty dark , and most terribly. It affects my interpretation of the poem by making it seem as if the speaker is depressed. When looking more into the poem I realized that it is more about how she breaking from them social norms and crossing boundaries. The speaker of the poem is Gwendolyn Brooks when

A Song in the Front Yard by Gwendolyn Brooks

1275 words - 5 pages “A Song in the Front Yard”, by Gwendolyn Brooks, illustrates the desire people develop to experience new things and live life according to their own rules. In the first stanza, Brooks uses diction of propriety and unfamiliarity to emphasize the author’s desire to change her life. In the first line, the author establishes that she is only familiar with one way of life since she has “stayed in the front yard all [her] life.” The author “stayed” in

Stone Mountain and the KKK

1020 words - 5 pages landmarks. Did you know that Stone Mountain might be a symbol of white supremacy? In this paper, I will try to explore the relationship that might exist between Stone Mountain and the Ku Klux Klan. Firstly, I will give a brief introduction to the Ku Klux Klan. The KKK was started in 1865 by a group of Confederate Army veterans as a social group. They took the Greek word “kyklos”, meaning circle, and the English word “clan” to come up with the name Ku

Olympic Massacre and the Effects of Relations

2299 words - 10 pages seriously.” A month later, a Lufthansa jet was hijacked by Palestinians who demanded the release of the Munich killers. The Germans agreed and let the terrorists go; in the meantime, an Israeli assassination squad was gathered and assigned to track the terrorists and those responsible for planning the massacre down. Eight of the eleven men targeted were killed, according to George Jonas. Two of the remaining three men were assassinated by unknown

Marc Lepine and the Montreal Massacre

2397 words - 10 pages friend named Jean Belanger that he hung out with frequently for a period of time during their adolescence. They did everything together, but gradually lost touch once Marc’s family moved away. It marked the beginning of a period where he described his life as unhappy. For those that knew Marc, the massacre was wholly unexpected. He had often been described as introverted by his peers and teachers, leaving behind an almost non-existent impression

Analogies in The Mountain by Robert Frost

1578 words - 7 pages the speaker lived in is shadowed by the mountain. His perspective of the town was different, meaning he viewed things differently and saw many things in the town that one from the mountains would see differently. In lines 3-4 it says, “I noticed that I missed stars in the west, where its black body cut into the sky.” The mountain not only gave the town it is located in a different perspective of its surroundings, it also gave the town it shadowed

Similar Essays

Implementing A New Wide Secure Wireless Network At Brigham Young University Hawaii

2628 words - 11 pages Introduction Brigham Young University Hawaii Campus wants to implement a campus wide secure wireless network. In their existing system there are some network security flaws such as rouge access point (Easily accessible open network), anyone can access and capture important information of users. We have been hired by the BYU-HAWAII to design and install a wireless network solution for the university. EXISTING SYSTEM Users-3000 User type-Students

Cycle: Beginning And End By Juanita Guccione

1581 words - 6 pages What lies beneath the chaos? I was surrounded by many interesting works of art as I walked through the Lowes Art Museum. One painting captured my attention; it was by Juanita Guccione entitled, “Cycle: Beginning and End.” It evoked thought in me because of its complexity; images were placed within images. The colors in the piece complemented each other. As I stood there gazing at the painting, I could continually make out new images. I

Film Analysis: Young Frankenstein By Mel Brooks

1236 words - 5 pages quote) Sexual scenes, though not graphic, appear at least three times in the film. The romantic themes in Young Frankenstein laugh at death and rebirth, and sexual awakening is seen as a lighthearted concept. Brooks is not scolding Frederick for his desire to bring life from death, nor is he ashamed of his character's sexuality, or in the creation of the creature--completely opposite of the original film in which Dr. Frankenstein was immediately

Details The Difference Between Short Stories Chee's Daughter By Juanita Platero And Siyowin Miller And The Hawk Is Flying By Harry Crews

565 words - 2 pages Great Minds Think DifferentGreat minds think alike, this statement is absolutely false. Authors are great because of their originality, not of their skill to mimic someone else. They use different style, theme, inspiration, and everything in between to write stories. The difference between two well written stories can be shown in "The Hawk is Flying" by Harry Crews and "Chee's Daughter" by Juanita Platero and Siyowin Miller. Different themes and