Bring Instant Replay To Major League Baseball

1143 words - 5 pages

Major League Baseball (MLB) has been losing fans for several years. The average attendance for a MLB game has been decreasing for a number of years. If Major League Baseball would like to compete with popularity of professional sports such as Professional football (NFL) and Professional basketball (NBA), they need to embrace some of technologies that have made those sports so successful in recent years. Right now, MLB has a replay system used for determining home runs that are either fair or foul, whether the ball actually left the playing field or whether the ball was interfered with by a spectator. MLB should have an instant replay system that can be used for all judgment calls excluding ball and strike calls. MLB could adopt a similar policy that the NFL has where the head coach is given a certain number of challenges he can use to begin the instant replay process i.e. limiting coaches to two to three challenges per game. MLB could also look into adding an extra umpire to help with the replay system and alleviate time used for the challenges.
The challenge for implementing an instant replay system in MLB can potentially impact the speed of the game. That has been one of the major arguments against replay in MLB by the baseball purists. The purists seem to like the human and the mistakes that come along with humans making judgment calls that impact the game. The purists don’t seem to want to embrace emerging replay technologies in an effort the get the call correct because replay would interfere with the human element the purists embrace. “The lack of instant replay in baseball is one of those crises, and simply curling up in a ball and pretending that an issue in 2011 doesn't exist because it didn't exist in 1911 is preposterous.” (Monta 2011) However, with the high salaries MLB owners are paying their players today, getting a call correct or corrected becomes so important. MLB owners are paying too much for players, stadiums, amenities, etc. to put fans in seats and I cannot imagine they appreciate going to that level of effort so that the outcome of a game may get decided on a blown call by an umpire.
If speed of the game is the major sticking point against implementing a fully executable instant replay system, then why can’t other steps be taken to make sure the game doesn’t last too long? Why can’t MLB games last 8 innings, or extra inning rules be tweaked so that games don’t last too long. The NFL has taken steps to improve their product and some of those steps including shortening games and the NFL remain extremely successful.
Admittedly, implementing instant replay for all levels of baseball would be economically challenging. However, at the very least, instant replay should be implemented on the professional level where the athletes are being paid and millions of fans are paying to watch a good game.
A very recent and well known incident that occurred during the 2010 MLB season cost Armando Galarraga, a pitcher for the...

Find Another Essay On Bring Instant Replay to Major League Baseball

Integration in Major League Baseball Essay

1392 words - 6 pages six decades that followed the only other attempt to sign a black player was made by Baltimore's Joan McGraw. He tried to pass of Charlie Grant as an American Indian in spring training of 1901” (Frommer 65). It had been years since anyone had even attempted to play an African American, but on April 15, 1947, the whole world of baseball changed. The fight for the integration of Major League Baseball had been going on for decades and it took not

Steroids in Major League Baseball Essay

1065 words - 5 pages Steroids in Major League Baseball Anabolic steroids have been abused by Major League Baseball players for years, it’s time to forever ban the use of Performance Enhancing Drugs before they ruin America’s past time. Why should athletes be able to cheat when teammates or rivals are competing with honest effort? Every year records are broken and new heights are achieved, the game of baseball is very simple yet very humble, and to deceive the

Major Baseball League Steroid Policy

1011 words - 4 pages The new policy for Major Baseball League Steroid policy is absolutely justifiable. Let’s start with the ethical principles of doing the right things in life. Ever since I remember, the major values that parents, school, and society taught us to, never lie, never cheat and never steal. I believe that using steroids or other physical drugs enchantment is completely unacceptable.The players are taking a big health risk. Let’s start with

Major League Baseball´s Culture

2016 words - 9 pages and how long the team has been around. These cultures are different in many, but all have a common similarity. All baseball cultures revolve around a Major League Baseball team. These teams can move, like the Dodgers from Brooklyn to L.A. and teams changing ownership, like when the Montreal Expos’s changed to the Washington Nationals. Cultures change as well, but I will be researching the in place steady cultures that have been around for a while

Kansa City Monarchs: Bringing Strength to Major League Baseball

940 words - 4 pages Kansas City Monarchs: Bringing Strength To Major League Baseball Kansas City Monarchs: Bringing Strength To Major League Baseball The Kansas City Monarchs was one of the strongest teams in Negro League Baseball, and played a big role in making America’s Major League Baseball a success. The Monarchs produced some of the first and best athletes that brought about racial integration of Major League Baseball in America. The Monarchs

Korean Players in Major League Baseball

1665 words - 7 pages about Major League Baseball, which led him into a Rookie contract with Seattle mariners after his graduation from high school in 2000. Therefore, he made up to Seattle Mariners’s Minor League and even up to Major League (“Choo Shin Soo”). Nonetheless, his debut in the Major League did not lead him into running for full season, and he mostly spent time in the minor league. Finally, he was traded to the Cleveland Indians in 2006. As soon as he was

A Proposal for Major League Baseball

1360 words - 6 pages Rodriguez. This incredible player has been in the league since he was 18 years old, fiercely destroying the minor league like if he was effortless. Being the only high paid baseball player in history, has many fans overwhelmed to the point that booing when he plays is normal. Being told that he is a cheater, a fraud, a disappointment and many more names made Major League Baseball to investigate thoroughly his case. A player who can feed his entire

Steroid Use in Major League Baseball

1053 words - 4 pages Steroids Used in Major League Baseball In baseball there have always been problems with steroids damaging our most talented Major League Baseball players. Some 1995, the steroid problem has amplified. Many of these major league baseball players are now in taking harmful drugs that boost their performance. Steroid products that should not be used; illegal to use them. Mandatory drug testing should be part of Major League Baseball, and all

Performance Enhancing Steroids in Major League Baseball

889 words - 4 pages Performance Enhancing Steroids in Major League Baseball The issue that our group is tackling is the use of illegal performance enhancing steroids in Major League Baseball. Major League Baseball is big business in the U.S., with 30 franchises valued at over 8.8 billion dollars. Player salaries range from the league minimum salary of three hundred twenty five thousand per year to ten million or more per year, and are based on the market

Keeping Major League Baseball Steroid Free

2098 words - 9 pages Since the mid 1990's, the popular opinion of Major League Baseball has been that the league is in a time period known as the "Steroids Era." With now retired players recently confessing steroid usage, they have also revealed key details and new information that has given insight as to how common steroids actually are within the MLB. It is true that recently the MLB has become more strict with procedures for testing and regulations against the

Steroid Use in Major League Baseball

1415 words - 6 pages Steroid Use in Major League Baseball Why Major League Baseball players would use steroids is the biggest question that every person in the world wants to know. I think MLB players use steroids so they can bulk up and get stronger, which will allow them to last through the long, seven-month season. I think that because they play 162 games a year during these seven months that this causes a great deal of wear and tear on their bodies

Similar Essays

Major League Baseball Expansion Essay

1201 words - 5 pages : "For the first time in the history of Major League Baseball, Interleague games are to be played during the regular season. Breaking tradition always brings about controversy and the matter of baseball records is no exception. It is the opinion of Major League Baseball that there is no justification for compiling a new volume of records based on Interleague Play. On the contrary, the sovereignty of each league's records will be retained, and if a

Major League Baseball Essay

1016 words - 4 pages Major League Baseball is a popular sport with many fans. The league consists of 30 Major League Baseball teams with each team needing time and money to recruit the best players for each of the franchises. Each team wants to recruit a winning team able to win the World Series, which will help create more revenue for the city and team. The alpha hypothesis test is going to help Team A conduct research to determine whether the millions of dollars

Major League Baseball Business Essay

2136 words - 9 pages steady diet of entertainment, drama, and controversy. Americans routinely interspersed their language with baseball metaphors. (36) As you can see, Americans cling to baseball as something they can participate in by keeping track of and fixing it to their lifestyles. As we all know, business is always followed by the money behind it. The owners of these major league teams know that good business makes them the most money. For an owner, being the

Salaries In Major League Baseball Essay

1808 words - 7 pages :// shows that there are currently ten Major League Baseball players receiving a salary of over $15 million dollars a year. However, these players' teams are owned by companies such as Disney and Fox television, which have annual revenues of billions of dollars. What the fans don't understand is that, in many cases, single individuals do not own the teams but large companies who are able to afford to pay the players such high