Britain's Electoral System Essay

932 words - 4 pages

The change of electoral system of Britain from first-past-the-post to form of proportional representation caused discussions and argues in the whole country. Does new system inspirit and change course to better or lead to weak and indecisive government? Whereas first-past-the-post developed stable majorities in parliament, there are always was a lack of suffer from grave shortcomings, for example majority of population remains unrepresented in government bodies, and a party, which wins less voices in selection than their contestants, can be represented by more seats. Nation is looking forward to see the fairness and progress of parliamentary works of country, which can be motivated by advantageousness of proportional representation. However, there are still many people who think critically about this newness. As said, all that glitters is not gold, proportional representation also has its disadvantages, so people, relying on them, are against to change from first-past-the-post.
The system of majority, which is used in Great Britain, is simple, understandable and conceptual. First-past-the-post is “winner takes it all” system, when candidates or political party are selected to parliament by majority of votes according to electoral districts where they are standing. One of the strongest advantages of FPTP is that there is close connection between constituents and their representatives. Furthermore, election provides people with open contest, where not just faceless lists, but candidates, whose personalities not indifferent for voters. In addition, first-post-the-post embraces single party government which could be base of stable, effective operating regime, if it will be lead by big, good organized political parties, which can easily win the election. In spite of these advantages, we have strong staying disadvantages. As it was mentioned above, most of population remains unrepresented in government as minor political groups, and also, even a party wins majority of voices, it can be represented by less seats than their contestants, which is noting to fairness problem of first-past-the-post. Moreover, party could be non-reacting to change of people’s opinion. What is more, ethnicity, religion, clan or region based groups could be encouraged to progress and develop. Consequently, these are the significant points which forced to change the electoral system.
Proportional representation never replaced first-past-the-post in British national election, which is quiet striking because of side by side location of Britain with other Europe countries, where PR takes up fundamental role as electoral system. In proportional representation mandate of a deputy in parliament are shared proportionally to the numbers of votes counted to each of candidates. Due to complexity of system, there are numbers of its different forms as Party-list proportional representation, Additional member systems, which includes mixed-member proportional representation, alternative...

Find Another Essay On Britain's Electoral System

Britian and the industrial revolution. Essay

1953 words - 8 pages perfection of the steam engines by Scottish inventor James Watt. Cotton production soared and became Britain's most important products and by 1815 Britain was exporting 100 times the amount of cotton it had exported half a century earlier.With the introduction of machinery, factories became the site of organized production of textiles, replacing small-scale manufacture in the home. At first most factories were comparatively small, employing fewer

Political Parties and Pressure groups Essay

2074 words - 8 pages rational and effective public policies in the areas of policy that the groups are involved in due to the large sections of society whose interests are represented. Interest groups claim a high level of legitimacy due to Britain's first past the post-electoral system. Britain is a unitary state with a local government suffering due to centralization of power to government. Power is now heavily concentrated in London and the executive a

Failure of the Campaign for Parliamentary Reform

2171 words - 9 pages Failure of the Campaign for Parliamentary Reform There were numerous reasons that accounted for why the campaign for Parliamentary reform failed in its objectives in the period 1780-1820, with arguably the most significant factor being that those in Parliament did not actually feel the need to reform the electoral system because of the lack of unified pressure from the British public. There was a substantial call for

Politics Of Honk Kong and Relations with China.

1549 words - 6 pages to 18 adding 2.5 million voters. This was not approved by the Chinese's government who accused Britain of trying too undercut the rightful rule (Ogden , 51-75). The Joint Declaration allowed Beijing to immediately remove this new electoral system and dissolve the 1995 Legislative. Patten had pushed for more political freedoms then Hong Kong had received in over a century of colonial rule .Hong Kong enjoyed great political stability prior to 1997

British politics

2705 words - 11 pages and rules that encompass the major institutions of the state, their functions and powers, and their relation to the rights and duties of the ordinary citizens.). 'Unwritten' is a little misleading. Many of the laws and rules that describe and regulate Britain's political system are in fact written down. They appear in acts of Parliament (statue law), treaties with foreign states, Orders in Council (government directives made in the name of the

The Scottish Parliament

3843 words - 15 pages ' system of voting in its general elections. This voting system dates back centuries and further to this has strong sentimental ties to British tradition and custom. The system, more commonly known as First Past the Post (FPTP) is similar to that of the US Congressional arrangements but despite this, is rarely found in democratic states.Arguably an easy system to understand and possibly the simplest electoral system to be found within any modern

New Labour

4607 words - 18 pages Cook and John Prescott. 14The 1992 manifesto promised reform of the House of Lords and the establishment of a Scottish Parliament and a Welsh Assembly. The manifesto also encouraged debate on the electoral system. John Smith promised a referendum on the issue of electoral reform, confirmed by Blair when he became leader 15(Blair, 1996c). However, the Labour Party is divided on this issue. Proportional Representation (PR) has probably seemed less


1621 words - 7 pages system within the UK and looking at other political actors that are outside of formal politics can help reveal the power the UK PM has and the ability to get things done their way. This can be achieved both by comparing and contrasting examples of Prime Ministerial role within parliament over time and that of different political systems in other nations. The ruling of the people of the UK and the collection of power has always been from a

The Success of the First Two Labour Governments was Outweighed by the Failures in Britain

2320 words - 9 pages introduce. The main three were the repeal of the 1927 Trades Disputes Act, raising the leaving age for school children to 15 and reforming the electoral system. Ironically, the Liberals later tried to support the reformation of the electoral system after Labour were in power, but have not been successful in achieving these aims. The second Labour government did however gain many foreign achievements. The most notable, was

The American Revolution.

2094 words - 8 pages The American Revolution occurred because of Great Britain's failure to adjust to conditions brought on by the growth and development of the colonies, and by the aggravation of a breakdown in the political and economic harmony that existed between the colonies and their mother country.America was a revolution force from the day of its discovery. The American Revolution was not the same thing as the American War of Independence. The war itself

The Causes of the American Revolution

1686 words - 7 pages For over a century Great Britain had ruled the colonies in America. Since the founding of the Chesapeake Bay colony in the south in 1607, and the Massachusetts Bay colony in the north in 1630, the colonies had relied on the crown for many of their needs. Over time the colonists established a social and economical system that was almost independent of the British Empire. In April of 1775, after many transgressions on both sides, the

Similar Essays

Uk's Main Electoral System And Should It Be Reformed

1737 words - 7 pages UK's Main Electoral System and Should It Be Reformed Over the years Britain's pluralist electoral system has been scrutinised by many political and pressure groups, such as the Liberal Democrats and the Electoral Reform Society. In their 1997 Manifesto, the Labour Party did state that they would look into the matter, by holding a referendum on the issue, however there was no change as Labour had a large majority in 1997

Examining Case For Electoral Reform Essay

1700 words - 7 pages to be easily drafted onto the British political system. There is little evidence that Britain's many economic and social problems can be laid at the door of 'first past the post' and pre-occupation with electoral reform will simply divert attention away from much more pressing needs. The denial of democratic rights to smaller parties was rejected by the European Court of Human Rights in 1979 when the Liberal Democrats presented their case.

Political Systems: Name Three Politcal Systems Around The World And Compare And Contrast Them. Give Examples(I.E. Countries)

2247 words - 9 pages of laws and people working for them, both would be the ultimate power within their established realm and each would have to be agreeable to a process of changing the Constitution (Tannahill and Bedichek, 1991).Central to the political system which currently exists in the United States is the electoral process. Under the Electoral College large, medium, and small states alike are rewarded with the same number of electoral votes as they have

Should Britain Reform The Existing Electoral System For General Elections?

1099 words - 4 pages The debate over electoral reform in Britain has risen up the political agenda in recent years. From 1979 to 1992 the Conservatives won overall majorities in the House of Commons in four consecutive elections without once winning more than 50% of the vote. In 1997 the Labour Party gained total power, even though 11 out of 20 people voted against them. Critics of our current system would therefore argue that the results of Britain's elections