Britain’s Support For Widening But Not Deepening The European Union

2172 words - 9 pages

Over the last 30 years Britain has consistently supported the enlargement of the European Union (EU). Both the former Conservative, and the current Labour governments have always presented favourable rhetoric for the ‘widening’ of the EU. This apparent consensus on European policy belies the fractious nature of opinions in Britain over the future of Europe. The rough undercurrents of Britain’s contingent support for the intergovernmental vision of the EU reflects just how complex and protracted the political discourse on Europe has become.

We often refer to ‘Britain’ as a single actor, but references to Britain are simply a convenient abbreviation used to represent the dominant political discourse of the elites, such as the political majority in Westminster or the Civil Servants in Whitehall (George 1994: Preface V). Britain’s policy regarding the future of Europe has been a compromise between at least two conflicting discourses, played out in the British establishment. Over the course of this essay I will explain how these schools of thought have shaped the debate over Britain’s vision of Europe

This essay will proceed in the following steps, first an examination of the eurosceptic narrative. Discussing how the touchstone issue of national sovereignty has stymied support for the European project from its inception, putting British nationalist in opposition to the federal supranational Europe. Second, looking at how Britain, unlike many other continental European nations, has consistently failed to develop a Europeanised national identity, that further exacerbates British exceptionalism. Finally, I argue that the neoliberal position, which has often been in contradiction to the exceptionalist discourse, has led to a compromise, an intergovernmental Europe that supports expansion as a vehicle for the spread of economic and political Liberalism, particularly eastward, into the former Soviet states.

One of the central themes of the EU debate revolves around the issue of national sovereignty. The European project has always involved, to a certain extent, the relinquishing of some national sovereignty, but in trying to persuade Europe’s established nations to cede powers to a European centre, often without the consultation of the general public, has created a growing eurosceptic backlash, a narrative that has been well received in Britain.

Many of Europe’s 'founding fathers' (such as Monnet and Schumann) shared a 'federalist' vision for Europe. They hoped for a European polity which would cooperate for the greater good, above the national divisions that had caused such calamity in the recent past. Convinced in that a strong supranational body, with the ability to make executive decisions, was vital for peace and prosperity that goes beyond what can be achieved with treaties between nations (Ash 2005).

The eurosceptics agree about the value of cooperation in many areas, but see this best achieved through intergovernmental...

Find Another Essay On Britain’s Support for Widening but NOT Deepening the European Union

The European Union Essay

4598 words - 18 pages impose guidelines for future expansion, the community rightly wonders how far the Union can afford to expand. Not only do culture and language become barriers, but the differences between legal communities cause a great deal of strife in establishing the existence of a European Union Constitution. Great Britain’s involvement in the European Union has helped establish the legal system, combining both common law and civil law aspects. Precedents are

The European Monetary Union Essay

602 words - 2 pages The European Monetary Union The European Monetary Union (EMU) serves as an economic necessity, a complement to the European single market, which is the free movement of people, goods, services, and capital within the European Union (EU). The Euro, a single currency created under ideals of the Maastricht Treaty, will strengthen European unity and constitute as a factor for stability, peace, and prosperity for all member states as well as

The European Union extended

4864 words - 19 pages April 2003: the 10 accession treaties are signed in Athens.1 May 2004: the 10 new member states join the EU.December 2004: decision on whether to start accession talks with Turkey.2007: the year set by the Copenhagen European Council for Bulgaria and Romania to become EU members.4. How does the Union work?The European Union is more than just a confederation of countries, but it is not a federal State. It is, in fact, something entirely new and

The European Union

5786 words - 23 pages MARKET?     19 3.2.     BACKGROUND     19 3.3.     CONTROVERSIES     20 BIBLIOGRAPHY     22 1.     INTRODUCTION 1.1.     MISSIONS AND VISIONS FOR THE EUROPEAN UNION After fifty years of evolvement, European Union is not a simply an international

The European Union

2088 words - 8 pages breaks these rules it faces punishment and possible fines. Another cost is that the UK does not always achieve what it wants from the European Union. For example Britain might want to impose a new law on immigration practices, but some other countries might disagree on Britain’s views. This way it takes longer for decisions to be met because 25 countries have to agree on one issue. There is also a financial cost of being a

The Western European Union

3693 words - 15 pages the European pillarwithin the NATO Alliance and should remain subordinate to NATO. Itrealises that for the moment without the same intelligence gatheringsources of the U.S. and it's strength in logistical support the WEUcould not hope to fight a conflict on the scale of the Gulf Warwithout superior U.S. influence. On the technological side theintroduction of the European Fighter Aircraft in the year 2,000 inwhich Britain is playing the leading

The European Union

935 words - 4 pages government and thereby surrenders a portion of its sovereignty. As member states they have accepted to open their borders completely to travel and trade coming from within the Union. The majority of the member states have adopted a single currency that is managed and issued by the Central Bank of Europe. The Bank also manages monetary policy for these states. International trade guidelines for the Union’s members are decided on a European level. These

Enlargement of the European Union (EU): The Implications for Business

1840 words - 7 pages There has been much debate surrounding the subject of Enlargement with regards to the European Union (EU) due to the political, institutional, cultural and economic factors that are involved. This essay looks at the way in which businesses from EU-15 countries have been able to exploit the increased number of consumers, the possibility of relocation for lower production and labour costs and the cross-border supply chains. There will also be

The European Union as a Model For Globalization

1899 words - 8 pages Polish president Lech Kaczynski stated in 2005 that what interested Poles was “the future of Poland and not that of the EU” (Kupchan, 2010, para. 13). The European Union is in trouble. Last August a member of the European Parliament told Charles Kupchan (2010) that the EU was “now just trying to keep the machine going [and that] the hope is to buy enough time for new leaders to emerge who will reclaim the project,” (para. 15). The project he was

The European Union and European National Sovereignty

889 words - 4 pages to the Council of Ministers for approval. The European Court of Justice is another institution of the European Union that almost acts like a supranational institution. The ECJ has the right of judicial review over the interpretation of the EU treaties and over the secondary legislation (directives and regulations) issued by the European Commission and approved by the European Council of Ministers. The final verdicts of ECJ over several

Italy and the European Union

1731 words - 7 pages were not looked kindly upon anymore, while in the civil society a trend toward decreasing in the support of integration was registered. Nevertheless, the pro-integration paradigm remained vivid in the centre-left parties, which continued to support it while in office, causing consistent shifts in the Italian European foreign policies, since the left and right coalitions had been winning the elections alternately (Daniels, 1998). However, the

Similar Essays

Contemporary Widening Of The European Union

3506 words - 14 pages out. To move forward in its integration, Ukraine must dedicate itself to three primary principles. First, it must begin several negotiations with other free-market economies to help stabilize its economy and further diffuse its toxic economic relationship with Russia. Secondly, Ukraine must not waver in its support of European Union agreements because of Russian antagonism over trade. While the short-term may be difficult for its economy, by

The United Kingdom Should Not Leave The European Union

1260 words - 5 pages strength. It is strong and influential to a certain degree. It currently has around 62.74 million citizens but as the independent and famous for her ideals Margaret Thatcher stated, “On our own as a nation of 55 million, we would have some voice, but not enough”. The European Union represents over 500 million people which means that if Britain decides to remain in the EU it is in fact much more powerful than any other susceptible country and has a

An Argument To Support The View That "Everything About The Play [King Lear] Hangs On The First Two Scenes Not Just The Plot But The Values As Well."

1465 words - 6 pages An argument to support the view that 'everythingabout the play [King Lear] hangs on the first two scenes notjust the plot but the values as well.''King Lear, as I see it, confronts the perplexity and mystery of humanaction.' (Shakespeare's Middle Tragedies, 169) As the previous quotationfrom the scriptures of Maynard Mack implies, King Lear is a very complexand intricate play which happens to be surrounded by a lot of debate. 'Thefolio of 1623

The History Tells Us That The First Display Of European Democracy Begins, Arguably, Not In Athens But In Sparta The History Tells Us That The First Display Of European Democracy Begins In Athens

2481 words - 10 pages The history tells us that the first display of European democracy begins, arguably, not in Athens but in Sparta. It seems quite strange that the very first features of democratic society came into the world exactly from this city which defined itself as the direct opposite of the " Open society ". But what really matter to us is Athens, where the earliest innovation of political equality was created, more thoroughly than in Sparta and where