This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Bruce Ackerman’s The Decline And Fall Of The American Republic: A Call To Action Or Tilting At Windmills?

2105 words - 9 pages

[T]hey came in sight of thirty [or] forty windmills…and as soon as Don Quixote saw them he said to his squire, “…[L]ook there, friend Sancho Panza, where thirty or more monstrous giants present themselves, all of whom I mean to engage in battle and slay…for this is righteous warfare, and it is God's good service to sweep so evil a breed from off the face of the earth."
"What giants?" said Sancho Panza.
In Bruce Ackerman’s The Decline and Fall of the American Republic, the author argues that the American presidency has become too powerful; that it represents an existential threat to our constitutional republic; that its current status is ripe for abuse by an extremist president; that current practices encourage the rise of an extremist president, and that significant substantive changes (which he, of course, considers “reforms”) to our political system are necessary in order to alleviate the threats presented. Ackerman professes fear that an extremist will rise and assume the office of the Presidency. He contends that either or both parties may be captured by extremists or that some economic or military disaster may occur “and the extremist reaps the whirlwind” (23). Once such an extremist takes office, Ackerman fears that he or she will manipulate public opinion and abuse the power of the office in a way that nullifies the true nature of our republican form of government. I found Mr. Ackerman’s argument, in which he identifies numerous interesting and significant issues that confront the modern American republic, to contain undeniably legitimate strengths–as logical points on which to build an argument. I concluded, however, his conclusion that extreme fundamental changes in our system of government are necessary or proper renders his argument a failure. While one might agree with his contention that “the pathologies of the existing system are too dangerous to ignore,” (3); one need not agree that the presidency has become “a vehicle for demagogic populism and lawlessness in the century ahead” (4); and one need not agree that such extreme measures as those Ackerman proposes are necessary or even beneficial to our country.
Ackerman’s argument is predicated by an interesting and undeniably accurate portrayal of the growth of power and influence of the office of the American presidency since the time of the Founders. He states that “the Founding design has been outstripped by contemporary realities” (15). Such contemporary realities include changes in the nomination process for presidential candidates: the rise of the modern party system, the loss of communication control from the party leaders to the media, and the movement towards state primaries (16-18). Ackerman argues that these developments “shifted the balance in the direction of extremism” (18). The growth of the Internet, and its ability to facilitate fund raising, weaken traditional elites, and mobilize voters is credited with “breaking the grip of the old political...

Find Another Essay On Bruce Ackerman’s The Decline and Fall of the American Republic: A Call to Action or Tilting At Windmills?

The Decline of American Education and the Decline of America

1776 words - 7 pages did not excel at school then there was a problem and parents were not doing their job” (Why Chinese Mothers are Superior). Realistically, not all parents have the ability to teach their kids, due to a lack of time or ability. It would certainly be unfair if students whose parents couldn’t teach them good work ethic were left behind to fend for themselves. Another group is those who agree with teacher Patrick Welsh, who says that students are

Edward Gibbon's The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire

876 words - 4 pages Roman Empire, at least three points seem to be beyond dispute. First, its decline was slow, proceeding at a glacial pace over several centuries. Second, a critical turning that hastened its decline occurred in 337 when its rule was divided into three zones – the east, central and west. Third, even though many scholars disagree that it marks the end point of the overall Roman Empire, 476 is commonly cited as the year that marks the end of its

The Decline And Fall Of The Romanov Dynasty

1465 words - 6 pages Alexandra. Alexandra was a German princess and the granddaughter of Queen Victoria. The people resented her influence over the Tsar, as he was very weak and easily influenced by his wife. Once Russia was at war with Germany, the people slowly began to detest her, calling her a German spy.Another influence on the decline and fall of the Romanovs? was the poor conditions that the peasants had to live in. The peasants made up the majority of the

Gnaeus Pompey and the fall of the Roman Republic

907 words - 4 pages Events which stretch as far back as the reforms of the Gracchi brothers’ meant that the Rome was facing a Republic that was already deteriorating before Pompey had stepped into power. While Pompey’s quest for power was harmful, many other factors were also baleful to the Republic, and were hence instrumental in its decline. Gnaeus Pompeius’s measures to gain power were harmful because it was primarily a paradox to the principles of being part of

Julius Caesar and the Fall of the Roman Republic

3531 words - 14 pages fortune to pass onto the future emperor Augustus, the future of the Republic would have drastically changed. One thing remains certain: Caesar’s deification did impact the fall of the Republic. Conclusion If Caesar’s large power was a contribution towards the end of the republic, it raises the question: Why didn’t the Senate just deny Caesar honours, power, or position? Following the civil war between Caesar and Pompey, Caesar’s armies and

How does 'The Death of a Salesman' by Arthur Miller and 'Better Days' by Bruce Springsteen position us to see the American Dream?

1328 words - 5 pages "Death of a Salesman" by author Arthur Miller and "Better Days" by singer Bruce Springsteen take slightly different stances on the American Dream. Arthur Miller both promotes and criticises the American Dream and allows the audience to make up their own minds. Bruce Springsteen presents a more negative picture of the American Dream, but of course, all impressions are in the eye of the beholder.The character of Willy Loman in "Death of a Salesman

Tilting The Balance

3020 words - 12 pages 1806 and offered them to become a part of the Americas. After gaining independence from Britain at the end of the American Revolution in 1783, the leaders of the US wanted to pursue their manifest destiny and expand their territories to all of North America. This meant pushing the indigenous peoples out, or including them into the Americas. Both letters outlined Jefferson's desire to open up the rest of North America to US territorial expansion

The Decline of American Economics

769 words - 3 pages policies convictions started in the 60’s to preach ultra liberal theories, de-regulation, complete government hands-off and without any monitoring or intervention. He was undoubtedly inspired by the high risk American culture originated in the spirit of the conquest of the Wild West, by adventurous cow boys searching for gold within a legal vacuum. In the 80’s a process set in motion by US President Ronald Reagan, British Prime Minister Margaret

The Fall of the Roman Republic

1077 words - 4 pages system of Rome that could have arguably been relieved either through the abolishment of slavery or through the eventual collapse of the Republic. Secondly, it can be emphasize that the extent to which the slavery division was the crucial division in Roman society, whereas there was a division inside the Senate itself. As Spiel Vogel suggests, “the magistracies and senate were increasingly controlled by a relatively select circle of wealthy and

The Fall of the Weimar Republic

822 words - 3 pages Fall of the Weimar Republic>> 1) Background> * The fall of the Weimar Republic goes hand in hand with the> rise of Hitler and the Nazi regime> * The Weimar Republic came into existence after WWI and> promised to give democracy, freedom of speech, return to the 8-hour> workday, and improvements in social security.> * The more power Hitler got, the closer he got to becoming a> complete dictator which would obviously put

The Fall of the Weimar Republic

1412 words - 6 pages The Weimar Republic would have continued to be a functional government far longer than achieved if not for the defeat of WWI, the economic burdens imposed by the Versailles Treaty, and the flawed Article 48 which all contributed to the down fall of Germany’s first attempt at a legitimate Democracy. This paper will argue that the societal, economical, and constitutional aspects all played a role in the hopeless Democracy Germany attempted which

Similar Essays

The Decline And Fall Of Empires

1294 words - 6 pages , economic burdens, dynastic successions, and external enemies, which have been known to contribute to the rise and fall of many once successful empires. One of the most common causes of the decline of an empire results from having weak military power and martial spirit. In order for an empire to be successful, that empire must present a strong will to fight or sacrifice property and life in order to defend its state. If an empire does not possess this

What Caused The Romanov Dynasty To Fall? Explain The Fall And Decline Of The Romanov Dynasty

1710 words - 7 pages depression saw Russia's peasants and urban workers increasingly resort to riots, demonstrations, and strikes to protest at their poor conditions. Russians people demanded the redress of numerous political, social, and economic problems. The Tsar persisted in the belief that to grant reforms would undermine his autocratic power.Peasant poverty was a long-standing problem. Russians peasants gained their emancipation in 1861 in the form of a decree from

Diversity In The Classroom: A Cognitive Call To Action

1746 words - 7 pages Diversity in the Classroom: A Cognitive Call to Action The United States is expecting drastic changes in the diversity of its population over the next 50 years. Minorities will become a larger portion of the country’s population. Changes will need to be made to the way our country operates, especially in education. New, innovative and inclusive ways of teaching will replace traditional methods. For these new changes to go smoothly, steps

A Call To Action: Opening The Ballot For Convicted Felons

1762 words - 7 pages that. Yes, their criminals, yes their crime may have include violating someone’s rights. But, as a country we must respect those who have done wrong and have lived up to their wrong. Then we have to look at the innocent people, those accused of something they didn’t do, those who are in the positions they are in because they weren’t allowed to voice their opinions on government decisions. We want to give them second chances because like it or not