Buddhism: The Problem With Pratityasamutpada. Essay

3107 words - 12 pages

In this essay I'll expound Pratityasamutpada as I understand it in the Madhyamika Karika and establish its significance in Buddhism. This will follow my speculation as to whether free will has any scope in this deterministic view of causation. Can man follow his duties without an individualistic aim? I'll like to refer to the butterfly effect, a hypothesis of the chaotic theory in order to present my case. Also if shunyata is tautologous with the Pratitya samutpada, then is human existence in a race without a finishing line?

The problem of causation has invaded human psyche since time immemorial and still remains persistent but in Buddhism it has provided a solution to many philosophical truths. Among the four Noble truths enumerated by Buddha, causation finds its place in the second noble truth ?of there being a cause of suffering. As a solution it is also present in the third noble truth which shows the cessation of suffering. The first and the last noble truth of suffering and Nirvana present the tension which has to be resolved through the dhamma. Buddha identified pratityasamutpada with the Dhamma. ?He who sees Dhammas sees Pratityasamutpada, and he who sees pratityasamutpada sees the Dhamma.? However within Buddhism itself different views have been developed regarding the nature of Pratitya samutpada which is ironical considering that in a dialogue between Buddha and an ascetic Vaccha it is revealed The tathagat is free from all theories.? This affirmation, a perfect example of self referential paradox, and in my opinion (I am no tathagat) it can be resolved if we consider the literal meaning of pratityasamutpada before we investigate the various interpretation of it which leads the different sects of Buddhism to see the Dhamma differently.

The term Pratityasamutpada is composed of two words pratitya and samutpada. The former word has the root in connating motion with the prefixes prati (getting) and the suffix vyap(after). With the prefix Prati the root connates the idea of ?getting? and with the suffix vyap it means ?after getting?. The word samutpada is composed of the root pad connating ?going? or ?getting? with the prefixes sam and ut (to originate) and the suffix ghan, making the word an abstract noun. The prefixes sam and ut make the meaning of the root ?to originate? and the meaning of the word is thus origination. The total meaning of the word is thus origination after getting (the causes) i.e., ?there being cause, there is effect.? Stcherbasky, however interprets the prefix sam to mean ?combined? and, thus, samutpada to mean ?combined origination?. The term pratityasamutpada for him means ?combined origination(sam-utpada) of some elements with regard (pratitya) to other elements, or ?combined dependent origination?. The concerted life of elements (dharmas) is called samsrtatva which is but another name of pratitya-samutpada. However in the sutras of the Hinayana the term applied to the doctrine about the 12 consecutive degrees...

Find Another Essay On Buddhism: The Problem with Pratityasamutpada.

Relationship of Buddhism with the Tang Government

1134 words - 5 pages Relationship of Buddhism with the Tang Government Since the introduction of Buddhism into China, it was not well received by the population as its foreign beliefs clashed with pre-existent principals of Confucianism and Taoism. On top of that, it was alienated by the Confucianism-based government in the late Han Dynasty. All in all, Buddhism was not a common nor a popular religion throughout China at first. Nevertheless, this all changed

Relationship of Buddhism with the Tang Government

2069 words - 8 pages Since the introduction of Buddhism into China, it was not well received by the population as its foreign beliefs clashed with pre-existent principles of Confucianism and Taoism. On top of that, it was alienated by the Confucianism-based government in the late Han Dynasty. All in all, Buddhism was not a common nor a popular religion throughout China at first. Nevertheless, this all changed after the rise of the Tang Dynasty. There is no doubt

The Problem With Food Porn

1431 words - 6 pages simply due to the craving of certain foods, people choose to view food porn. This becomes a problem because although it might seem to curb hunger, this causes one to crave food even more intensely. This desire for food porn is greatly amplified through social media outlets. Sites like Facebook, Tumblr, and apps such as Instagram and FORK spread food porn in an instantaneous manner. It is so easy to search for or even stumble upon food porn with

The Problem with My Writing

740 words - 3 pages Throughout this school year my writing has improve dramatically. I now know how to be organized and I also know how to use my sources. The problem that I still have is the hardest mountain that I must overcome, procrastination. The problem with procrastinating isn’t that I don’t want to do the work it just takes time for me to figure out how to do it. Writer’s block seems to be contagious and I think I may have caught it from a student elsewhere

The problem with free will

1602 words - 6 pages ( some events must be uncaused) hold a possible demonstration of free will, the problem occurs with the determinist theory of how cause and effect is applied to every action that takes place, if preceding events or ideas influence everything then how can free will exist?. Indeterminists will however point out that some advances in physics may give an indication of a refutation of determinism. They claim that " the work in quantum mechanics

The Problem With Helicopter Parents

3535 words - 14 pages . “Helicopter Parent” is a relatively new term to describe parents who impart an excessive interest in their child and overwhelm their children with support. It has most recently been applied to Baby Boomer parents whose offspring are in the Millennial Generation. These parents grew up in a time when having many children was common, but now live in an age where people have fewer kids. This means that they have more time to invest in each child’s safety and

The Problem with Lecturing: A Rhetorical Analysis

1395 words - 6 pages When I first read the title of the article “The Problem with Lecturing” I was immediately drawn to the subject at hand. Being a student who has struggled in the past with the teaching method of lecture classes, I was curious as of what aspect Emily Hanford was going to write about. I was curious to see what appeal she would use to make her point. Would she use ethos, logos, pathos or a combination of all three? And at what point would her

The Problem With Today’s Youth Language

982 words - 4 pages who is not familiar with them. The speaking mannerisms may also show up in writings, causing hardship on students in classes that require essays. If a teen has improper speech or cannot tell when to shift their mannerisms will likely not develop the skill in adulthood. This is a problem because once in the position of being seen as an adult, it means that you must behave in a certain way and give off a certain sense about you that shows

Testing and the Problem with Exams

793 words - 3 pages The Problem with Exams June first--the last exam is today. There has been one exam every day since Monday, which seems as if it was an eternity ago. Every class at school requires homework, quizzes, tests, and finally, a final exam. We take exams to prove ourselves--to prove we have advanced our education during the past nine months. In one and a half to two and a half hours, nine months of homework, quizzes and tests must be summed up

Financial Aid: The Problem with Merit-Aid

1397 words - 6 pages preferred means of financial aid such as grants and scholarships. The funds for merit based financial aid are growing rapidly, while the funds for need based aid is staggering along. The resulting circumstance is less financial support for low-income students. The newly found emphasis on merit-based financial aid over need-based aid serves as a disadvantage to students of lower incomes and should be disputed. What is so wrong with merit based aid

The Problem with Immgration to the United States

1316 words - 5 pages The Problem with Immgration to the United States The first move stopping immigration decided by Congress was a law in 1862 restricting American vessels to transport Chinese immigrants to the U.S. The Alien Contract Labor Laws of 1885, 1887, 1888, and 1891 restricted the immigration to the U.S. of people entering the country to work under contracts made before their arrival. Alien skilled laborers, under these laws, were allowed to

Similar Essays

The Problem With Marijuana Essay

1000 words - 4 pages The Problem with Marijuana The use of marijuana should be regulated and taxed by the government, whether federal, state or local. That’s what governments are for. It is a great mistake to allow the entire industry of marihuana, from beginning to end, to be conducted as a black market, without any control or regulation. It is the role and function of government to regulate the traffic in any material that is deemed to be hazardous in any

The Problem With Pa Cs Essay

575 words - 2 pages The Problem with PACs Over the past thirty years interest groups in America have gained more influence upon government officials and candidates for government office. Interest groups are "organizations of people with similar policy goals who enter the political process to achieve those aims." Interest groups have had a significant impact upon elections for many years and, since the invention of political action committees in 1974

The Problem With Profiling Essay

1438 words - 6 pages works with a lot of different people from all around the world but they specifically work with Muslims. A big goal that my church has is that it wants to help spread the word that not all Muslims are bad. There is a lack of education that clarifies this and it is a growing problem. “The press coverage –snatching at half-truths, misconstruing evidence, inferring racial bias in the absence of evidence and openly cheering for a conviction

The Problem With Vietnam Essay

2168 words - 9 pages The Problem With Vietnam Wartime in the United States has always placed pressure on the government and the citizens of the country to provide support by whatever means to the situation. During World War II, that support was propagated by the government in the form of censorship and a strategic public relations plan to maintain the public opinion in favor of the cause. Glorification of America's involvement in the war helped America