Buffalo Creek And The Question Of Punitive Vs. Compensatory Damages

1695 words - 7 pages

Buffalo Creek and the question of punitive v. compensatory damages
Damages are a fundamental principle in the American legal system. However, a number of recent cases in the United States have sparked a debate on the issue, the most famous one being the “hot coffee lawsuit”1. In 1994, Stella Liebeck bought coffee at a McDonald’s restaurant, spilt it, and was severely burnt. She sued the McDonald’s company, received $160,000 in compensatory damages, and $2.9 million in punitive damages. A judge then reduced the punitive damages to $480,000. The final out-of-court settlement was of approximately $500,000. For many, this case is frivolous (meaning that the plaintiff’s prospects of being successful were low or inexistent), but it really highlights the question of excessive punitive damages compared to the damage suffered and its causes.
Damages in the United States include two categories. Compensatory damages are intended to compensate for the plaintiff’s loss. Punitive damages, on the contrary, are meant to punish the defendant .The punitive damages exceed the plaintiff’s loss, to dissuade the defendant from any further wrongdoings. For instance, having a company pay significant punitive damages may encourage it to greater caution. Another difference between the two categories is the money involved. If the damages are compensatory, the money usually goes entirely to the plaintiff, but if they are punitive, part of the money goes to the law firm and part to the plaintiff.
One may however ask the following questions. How are punitive damages actually allocated? And what is the current trend in the United States and in France in this area?
In order to answer these questions, we will first see how American lawyer Gerald M. Stern managed to get the Pittston Coal Company to pay punitive damages to Buffalo Creek disaster survivors. We will then look at current trends in American and French law on punitive damages.
I-The example of the Buffalo Creek Disaster
In February 1972, a dam which had been built in 1968 and which belonged to the Pittston Coal Company collapsed in Middle Fork Hollow, West Virginia. The dam was a coal-waste refuse pile which, along with two others, was intended to filter black waste water from a coal-cleaning plant before the water flowed down to the valley. The pile collapsed and the water rushed into the valley, destroying anything it crossed. Over 125 people were killed, thousands of others were injured, and homes and possessions were destroyed. 200 to 600 survivors decided to sue the Pittston Coal Company, and were represented by an Arnold & Porter law firm lawyer, Gerald Stern, who tells about the lawsuit in his book The Buffalo Creek Disaster. Gerald Stern explained how the plaintiffs received punitive damages from the coal company. Gerald Stern relied on West Virginia cases in order to find the “punitive damages” standard. He found that two elements were needed in order to recover punitive damages: the coal company’s...

Find Another Essay On Buffalo Creek and the Question of Punitive vs. Compensatory Damages

The Damages of Cheating Essay

765 words - 3 pages The Damages of Cheating There are many meanings of the word cheat the meaning that sticks out the most to me is, to be unfaithful to somebody, to have a sexual relationship with somebody other than a spouse or regular sexual partner says MS Encarta. Relationships end everyday due to cheating and the emotional scares of cheating or being cheated on can stay with a person forever. Not only does cheating effect the person that has been

Sucesses and Damages of Mergers in the Motor Industry

1818 words - 8 pages Over the past decade, the motor industry has faced many of mergers between companies in the bid to get more clients and internationalize their market share. The well planned mergers have arguably led to relative success while those that might have omitted some vital factor have had to contend with the pain of getting into damaging losses. A merger happens when two companies decide to combine into one entity or when one company acquires

Common Symptoms and Damages of Measles

562 words - 2 pages The Latin name for measles is rubeola. The pathogen which causes the disease is a paramyxovirus, which is one of a group of RNA (ribonucleic acid) viruses. Measles is a respiratory disease caused by a virus, and also comes out in a rash. The virus enters the body via the respiratory system, and grows in the cells at the back of the throat and in the cells that line the lungs, from there it then enters the blood stream and circulates the body

Marijuana Damages the Mind and Body

1313 words - 5 pages seems as though marijuana and amotivation remains as a “chicken-and-egg question.” It is unknowable whether smoking cannabis causes amotivation. Moreover, these could by symptoms of just growing up (Macintosh, sec. 9). On the contrary, this is untrue. Chronic users of cannabis sativa may develop amotivational syndrome. Constantly being unconcerned about the future and even feeling unaspiring are signs of this syndrome, experts say (Hasday 40

Buffalo The Great Animal Of The Plains

871 words - 3 pages Buffalo The Great Animal Of The PlainsBuffalos or bison are one of the beasts that used to freely roam the Wild West. They are one of the strongest and most powerful animals in North America. Millions once roamed the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Today they're far fewer and less common. Most buffaloes live in national parks and protected areas.What Do Buffaloes Look Like?Buffaloes are very large animals that sort of resemble a bull. They

The Damages of Early Parental Separation

1076 words - 5 pages A parent's involvement typically begins early in a child's life. When a child first opens his or her eyes they should see their parent's smiling faces looking back at them. As the child continues to grow up and develop their parent's constant presence in their lives provides structure. But for some children they do not receive this kind of stability from their parents due to early separation from their parents. Children can be separated from

The Expansion of Buffalo Wild Wings

1046 words - 4 pages Country Study This study will focus on the casual dining restaurant and sports bar Buffalo Wild Wings which primarily sells buffalo wings, and its potential international expansion into China, one of the worlds fastest growing major economies. In order to gain a better understanding of China, it is important to understand the environmental factors associated with the country. I will begin by discussing economic, geographic, and political-legal

The Battle of Antietam Creek

772 words - 4 pages The Battle of Antietam Creek The Battle of Antietam Creek was a very bloody and important battle in the Civil war. The battle was fought by two different armies within the Union and the Confederacy, The Army of the Potomac (Union) and The Army of Northern Virginia (Confederate). Antietam Creek is located just to the east of the Potomac River in Maryland. The battle was fought on a hill just above the west bank of Antietam Creek. The Army of

The Question of Language Acquisition (Lenneberg vs. Chomsky)

867 words - 3 pages such as, linguistically isolated children (a.k.a. feral children) support Lenneberg's theory of the critical period because they are unable to fully acquire language. 2 Moreover, there is a non-uniform success rate in adults who try to attain a second language yet children can obtain a new language a lot more quickly and sufficiently than adults. 3 It is thought by many that a critical period for acquisition of a language does exist.The most common

Urban Renewal: The History of City of Buffalo

2474 words - 10 pages After his completion of the Delaware Park and Parkway system with Calvert Vaux throughout Buffalo, New York, Frederick Law Olmsted declared Buffalo as “the best planned city, as to its streets, public places and grounds, in the United States, if not the world.” Inspired largely by the baroque styling of Paris, France, Olmstead wished to create a park within urban Buffalo but rather put the city of Buffalo in a park system. The parks were non

Buffalo And Small Pox In The American West 1860's

1742 words - 7 pages contact with the indigenous peoples and the Europeans was with the Sioux Indians in what is now known as the state of Wyoming. "In the 1868 Treaty of Fort Laramie, the United States government granted the Indians the right to continue hunting on certain lands "˜so long as the buffalo may range thereon in such numbers as to justify the chase.'" There were a number of buffalo that once inhabited virtually all of North America mostly in

Similar Essays

Heat Wave Vs. Buffalo Creek Essay

1092 words - 5 pages INTRO An activity that we participate in on a daily basis is belonging and being part of a community. We live in a world where associating and identifying ourselves with certain groups is how we share common interests, and we are responsible for facing whatever may come our way. The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the differences and similarities between the approaches seen from the Chicago Heat Wave and Buffalo Creek Flood. The

The Pains Of Catastrophe In The Flooding Of Buffalo Creek, Virginia

2518 words - 11 pages Pain in the wake of catastrophe can be as elusive as pain in illness. Kai Erikson argues that the events of catastrophe such as the flooding of Buffalo Creek Virginia cause a syndrome which includes pains such as numbness, reliving of the event, familial loss, loss of community as well as many others. The problem that arises from such a catastrophe is how to handle the pain suffered by its victims. Veena Das and Elaine Scarry argue that pain

The Approach The Zimbabwean Courts Take Towards The Question Of Damages In Breach Of Contract Cases

1795 words - 7 pages Zimbabwean courts towards the question of damages in breach of contract.DAMAGES TO BREACH OF CONTRACTThese are monetary equivalents of specific performance. The fundamental rule in regard to award of damages for breach of contract is that the sufferer should be placed in the position he would have occupied had the contract been properly performed, so far as it can be satisfied by payment of money and without causing any hardships to the defaulting party

The Damages Of Smoking Essay

2071 words - 8 pages The Damages of Smoking “Smoking is good for you!” Quotes Geoff Pattison this week! “The secret to a longer life may have been discovered in the most unlikeliest of places according to scientists this week — the cigarette.” This is surprising. He also goes on to say, “Speaking from the Intensive Care Unit, where he was recovering from a sextuple heart bypass and having had both lungs removed, the report's author