This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Bulimia And Depression Essay

2378 words - 10 pages

Bulimia and Depression

The prevalence of eating disorders among American women has increased dramatically in the past decade. In turn, the psychological community has expanded it's scope of research and study by focusing more attention on eating disorders and concentrating on other extended issues related to eating disorders. The desire to distinguish and understand a possible relationship between bulimia nervosa and depression has become a major focus within the field. The purpose of this paper is to introduce the reader to literature from two different journal articles on this relationship.

How Are Bulimia and Depression Possibly Related?:

Presently, there are two predominant hypotheses on the relationship between bulimia nervosa and depression. The first hypothesis states that bulimia nervosa is an affective variant of depression. (Hinz and Williamson, 1987) This idea came about due to early reports of a high prevalence of clinical depression in bulimics and a high lifetime prevalence of depression in the families of these patients. Recent studies, however, provide evidence that this type of relationship between bulimia and depression is still unconfirmed. (Levy et al., 1989) The second hypothesis constitutes that bulimia is a "distinctive diagnostic entity with a psychopathological process different from that of other mental disorders". (Hinz, et al., 1987) The following articles review the findings of research which effect the level of support for these two hypotheses.

Cognitive Comparisons in Defining Bulimia and Depression:
Bulimia is characterized by a number of symptoms. Many of these symptoms are also common among depression. Schlesier-Carter, et al., 1989 state that for bulimia,

"the distinctive behaviors appear clinically to occur in the context of (a) unrealistic beliefs and evaluations about eating and body weight, and (b) dysphoric affective states... Cognitions manifested by bulimics include dysfunctional attributions regarding weight gain, guilt, and self-deprecating attributions centered on feeling out of control."

Schlesier, et al. (1987) state that depression:

"...carries characteristic cognitive features of clinical import. Maladaptive thinking patterns related to depressive symptomatology include negative automatic thoughts, dysfunctional attitudes, and causal attributions."

Therefore, there are connections between these two disorders. There is a link in the relationship between bulimia and depression. Understanding this link is essential for treatment and therapy.

Article I - "Bulimia and Depression: A Review of the Affective Hypothesis":
Lisa Hinz and Donald Williamson (1987) reflect on the evidence presented in past studies relating bulimia and depression and discriminate between the idea that bulimia is an affective variant of depression or a separate diagnostic entity often associated with depression. In their attempt to understand the relationship, the authors...

Find Another Essay On Bulimia and Depression

Understanding Bulimia Essay

852 words - 3 pages because patients with bulimia seem to have a higher risk of affective disorders after delivery, including postnatal depression (Conrad, R., Schablewski, J., Schilling, G., & Liedtke, R. 2003). 4 Menstrual dysfunction occurs frequently in patients with bulimia nervosa. Whether this is associated with diminished fertility is unknown. This study examined menstrual and reproductive function in bulimia nervosa patients retrospectively, with 10-15

Bulima Nervosa Essay

1122 words - 4 pages , menstrual status, social class, social outcome, anxiety and depression ratings and eating attitude rating. Many of the results obtained from this study agreeably compare with those of other studies. Yet, this study points out the difficulty of comparing such studies. The main complication being that the criteria chosen to categorize outcome groups may differ from study to study. Twenty-five percent of the sample still suffered from bulimia nervosa

Understanding Bulimia Nervosa

994 words - 4 pages , depression (mood swings), irregular menstrual periods in females, swollen cheeks glands, heart burn, bloating." (Bulimia) A doctor will be able to make a diagnosis based on the symptoms of the patient. Before heading to the doctors some of these symptoms should be monitored and recorded. A doctor does not base his information solely on the symptoms she/he will also question the patient example how they feel about their weight, body, exercise, or if

Different Types of Eating Disorders

945 words - 4 pages anorexics starve themselves, bulimics binge on food and then purge by self-induced vomiting. Bulimics also use diet pills, laxatives, and diuretics to reduce their weight. The purging can serve two purposes: preventing weight gain and also temporarily relieving depression and other negative feelings (“Bulimia,”).” Eating disorders such as these two are a major issue in todays society due to the stereotypical view of women and young teenage girls

The Causality and Development of Bulimia

1054 words - 4 pages case study and may contribute to the causality of Carla’s condition. The hereditary evidence is that Carla’s sister had recovered from Anorexia Nervosa and her mother had been diagnosed with depression and co-morbid Obsessive Compulsive Disorder. This disorder can be hereditary and a study by the National Institute of Mental Health revealed that many people with bulimia nervosa exhibit obsessive behavior as severe as


810 words - 3 pages the face, bags under the eyes, dehydration, fainting spells, tremors, and blurred vision. Loss of tooth enamel from repeated vomiting, suicidal depression, and rupture of the esophagus these are just few of the consequences regarding this disease ("Consequences on Bulimia" 1).Many people with bulimia manage to recover on their own with the right level of support. Nowadays there are many self-help programmers available. These can be used on their


618 words - 2 pages Anorexia Nervosa/Bulimia Anorexia nervosa is a disorder that is best explained as self-starvation. It occurs most commonly among adolescent females but is also observed in older women and in men. The disorder may appear when a young woman leaves home, or it may develop in connection with mental depression, peer pressure to lose weight, sexual temptation, the use of psychedelic drugs, or the discontinuance of oral contraceptives. Any of

Eating Disorders Among Teenagers: Annotated Bibliography

1735 words - 7 pages : Causes of bulimia Date of access: 06/05/2014 This source says that there is no certain cause of bulimia, it is linked to a fear of getting fat but complex emotions can contribute to the cause. Factors thought to influence the cause of bulimia are: • Low self esteem • Depression • Stress • Other mental problems • Cultural and social pressure • Puberty • Genetics (healthunlocked, 2012) This source is valid as it has been written

Dying to be Thin

1288 words - 6 pages rate is very low. They do suffer from brittle nails, dry skin and occasional hair loss. Binge eating occurs in 100% of the patients and must be present for diagnosis. (“Anorexia vs. Bulimia n.d.”) Some common symptoms they share are depression, fatigue and heart failure. Many bulimic patients have a past history of anorexic behavior. According to MFHealthHub, “The most important fact to take note is that bulimia is struggling with how to control

The Differences between Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia

839 words - 4 pages systems. With the brain it causes depression, anxiety, and low self-esteem. The female with bulimia can have cavities, gum disease, and sensitivity to hot and cold food. The throat and esophagus can tear and rupture due to prolonged vomiting. Stomach pain and ulcers are caused from the vomiting. Worst case scenario the stomach could rupture. Bulimia affects the heart by lowering blood pressure, weakening of the heart muscle, irregular heartbeat


1095 words - 4 pages report Dancing on my grave she reply's that " the head of her ballet troop once stopped class, thumped on the bones of Kirkland's chest and said must see the bones At this time she was weighing less than a hundred pounds". (Teen 34) Eating disorders don't always have to do with depression and what is going on in your life; it also has to do with striving for acceptance and high achievement in a certain activity."Bulimia affects about 10% young

Similar Essays

Bulimia;Topics;Symptoms, Causes, Effects, Treatments, What You Can Do To Help Get Bulimia Under Control, Risk Factors, Stress, And Peer Pressure, And Who Is Most Likely To Develop Bulimia

953 words - 4 pages individual wats a very large amount of food than most people would in a similar situation. Binge eating is not a response to intense hunger. It is usually a response to depression, stress, or self esteem issues.During the binge episode, the individual experiences a loss of control. The main topics dicussed are the symptoms, causes, effects, treatments, what you can do to help get bulimia under control, risk factors, stress, and peer pressure, and who

Identifying And Conquering Bulimia Essay

2492 words - 10 pages feelings instead of using it to satisfy their hunger. People can become bulimic to gain a higher self-esteem. It is not a response to hunger; it is a response to depression, stress, and low self-esteem. Bulimia has no concrete cause; researchers are beginning to think it is caused by dissatisfaction of the body (“Bulimia: Symptoms, Causes...” 1-4). Men are also susceptible to becoming bulimic. It is the drive for thinness, perfectionism, and the

Understanding Bulimia As A Disease Essay

702 words - 3 pages , hoarseness, broken blood vessels in the eyes, swollen cheeks, swollen salivary glands, weakness and dizziness. Others include tooth decay, mouth ulcers, acid reflux, stomach ulcers, ruptured stomach or esophagus, loss of a woman’s menstrual period, and chronic constipation (1). Bulimia can also affect pregnancy. The mother could miscarry, have high blood pressure, or suffer from depression and gestational diabetes, as well as possibly needing

Identifying And Solving Bulimia Essay

2575 words - 10 pages low frustration level. If the person is preoccupied with their body weight and constantly making comments about how fat or how much weight they are gaining, that could be a sign that they are suffering from bulimia. If someone shows signs of depression or extreme mood swings they could also have bulimia. Bulimics can suffer from anxiety and substance abuse. Furthermore, the bulimic person is contradictory, illogical, and irrational when it comes