Bush And The Patriot Act: Declaring War On Our Rights?

1631 words - 7 pages

Bush and the Patriot Act: Declaring War on Our Rights?

    When I decided to write this essay, I knew without hesitation that I would write about Washington's response to the terrorist attacks that struck New York and Washington. I did not realize how difficult such an undertaking would be, as I find myself in a somewhat an uncomfortable position. Forcing myself to confront the issues at hand means deciding which freedoms are acceptable casualties in this war and for whom.  To allow Attorney General Ashcroft to lead us into a new era of American justice that resembles McCarthyism or the internment of Japanese-Americans a half-century ago would be regrettable.


 I do not mean to imply that the US response should be weak; to the contrary, I support an expansion of this effort into Iraq. I've always had a passion for government, ours in particular. The difficulty comes from choosing how to defend that government, as it is our secular and modern way of life that is under attack. And though quoting ancient Greek is cliché, I find the rule of law to be reassuringly passion-free and just. My support for the ACLU stretches back ten years, which is considerable as I am only twenty years old. I also strongly support strengthening our law enforcement and intelligence agencies. The inability of the FBI, CIA, Justice Department, INS or NSC to detect the terrorist attacks before they were executed was grossly delinquent; to borrow a phrase from The New York Times' Maureen Dowd. This breach in intelligence is even more shocking when the amount of money poured into national security annually is considered. That we need added protections in this time of national crisis is indisputable. However, the manner in which we defend our way of life is by no means inconsequential.


The country and world need to have unwavering confidence in our government at this time. The world is now watching our actions closely. We are on the right side of justice in this war and should not give up our moral high ground in achieving our ends. Washington's immediate, bipartisan response to the terrorist attacks speaks well for our representatives and reflects the revived sense of patriotism prevalent nationwide. However, we are now sufficiently distanced from the attacks of September 11 to hold the Administration's proceedings to the very American standard of justice, which we are now engaged in defending. I am shocked to witness this country quietly succumb to the recent blatant and inappropriate expansion of powers the Justice Department and White House have assumed. This is not melodrama. A democratically elected US President and his Attorney General are proceeding as if they were reading out of a rouge states' instruction manual. This country is too great to fall to cave-dwelling terrorists who redirect a population's frustrations at us. It is not un-American to question the legitimacy of the recent anti-terrorism legislation, though risky for politicians...

Find Another Essay On Bush and the Patriot Act: Declaring War on Our Rights?

The War on Terror Meets the USA Patriot Act

573 words - 2 pages McIntosh Slaughter, the first Patriot Act was passed "because we were in some kind of shock." This was most certainly the case because now the Bush administration is having difficulty passing the newer Patriot Act. Many are questioning the effect that the new act will have on everyone's civil liberties. As discussed in class, this new law would limit one's privacy and freedoms, and make it easier for the government to check anyone's

The Patriot Act Infringes on American Freedom

758 words - 3 pages , people began to realize the rights they were losing to the government that were once granted to them by our founding fathers in the Constitution (Townshend).  There are many sections of the Patriot Act that infringe on the rights of the American people and there is no way for the public to know how the government is using these new found powers; because the Freedom of Information Act requests have been half answered and judiciary committee

The Patriot Act and The First Amendment

1849 words - 7 pages The foundations for personal freedom and the mark of an open society is defined in the First Amendment, which protects freedom of speech, press, religion, assembly, and petition. Shortly after the September 11th attacks the Patriot Act was passed in an attempt to secure the nation's safety. This set of new laws has collided with the rights of the citizens. The Patriot Act has been the center of a rigorous controversy around whether or not it

Al-Qaeda and the US Patriot Act

1782 words - 7 pages Abstract This paper is on the terrorist group Al-Qaeda and the US Patriot Act. This paper will discuss the history, ideology, structure, targets and tactics of Al-Qaeda. I will discuss the history and goals of the US Patriot Act as well as the controversy that surrounds it. Finally I will discuss how the US Patriot Act serves as a deterrent to Al-Qaeda by enhancing domestic security against terrorism, enhancing surveillance procedures and

The Patriot Act and American Libraries

749 words - 3 pages Patriot Act) was passed in October 2001. On the surface, the Patriot Act appears to address issues associated with maintaining the safety and security of the United States. There are, however, provisions of this law that affect every American in ways that would not have been imaginable prior to September 11, 2001. Thankfully, there are groups of individuals who have dedicated themselves to challenging these provisions and protecting the right

The patriot act

2267 words - 10 pages and accomplished very little. This paper will also discuss how the government has abused the constitutional rights of Americans in attempting to secure itself from terrorism, and how this abuse threatens Americans going forward. II. The Patriot Act: The beginning of the end of privacy in the United States. Initially the Justice Department was resistant to releasing information regarding the impact that Patriot Act had on the war on terrorism

The Patriot Act

1319 words - 5 pages The Patriot Act. On September 11, 2001 Muslim terrorists instilled with a hatred of the west attacked the United States in a brutal fashion. Planes were hijacked and flown into the World Trade Center in New York. Over three thousand people were killed and the impregnable nation known as America was know scared and vulnerable. Almost immediately the legislature began drafting an act that would make the war on terror and the fight for homeland

The USA Patriot Act

2666 words - 11 pages destruction on our soil? Ashcroft said. ?We have used these tools to provide the security that ensures liberty.? Anderson (2003) also reported ?The Patriot Act, Ashcroft said, allows the government to ?anticipate, adapt and outthink our terrorist enemy. To abandon these tools would senselessly imperil American lives and American Liberty, and ignore the lessons of Sept.11.? Taylor (2003) also reported that FBI Director Robert S. Mueller believes that the

The Patriot Act Persuasive

796 words - 3 pages The PATRIOT Act: Taking Law Too FarMartin Luther King, Jr. describes an unjust law as "a code that a numerical power majority group compels a minority group to obey but does not make binding on itself." While this definition is absolutely true, and was very relevant in King's time, the relevancy has decreased recently due to desegregation and civil rights. These days, however, we have a different kind of law that takes away from our freedoms and


1332 words - 5 pages United States and its citizens. By protecting the citizens it is compromising their constitution rights set forth by our fore fathers when this country's plans were first set. Many of these changes being made will be a turning point for the country. Either way, the PATRIOT ACT and the proposed Domestic Security Act will change the country forever.

The USA Patriot Act.

955 words - 4 pages that their freedom and civil liberties are being violated. The Patriot Act has done just the opposite. It protects our Constitution, because of certain important safeguards built into the law, and it is preserving our civil liberties, not violating them. There are several checks and balances, including strict judicial oversight, that ensure this new tool will not be abused. During the Senate committee hearings on April 5, 2005 Democratic Sen

Similar Essays

"The Case Against The Us Patriot Act" This Essay Explores The Effects Of The Us Patriot Act On Our Constitutional Rights.

1293 words - 5 pages The Case Against the USA Patriot Act"There is nothing to fear, but fear itself." This famous quote, spoken by Franklin Roosevelt, serves as a reminder to people everywhere that fear should not guide our actions, nor should they influence our lives. On September 11th, 2001, the American public saw the face of fear and stood bravely in its shadow, its shadow which covered New York City and Washington DC. Shortly thereafter, President George W

The Patriot Act, Is It Worth Our Privacy?

1699 words - 7 pages citizens, while simultaneously reducing checks and balances on a number of powers such as judicial oversight, public accountability, and the ability to challenge government searches in court. Many believe that parts of the Patriot Act directly infringe on our First, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendment rights, a blatant act of civil rights violation. Two major and notable opponents of the Patriot Act are the Electronic Frontier

"The Iraqi Road And Generalissimo George." Persuade Your Audience That The Bush Administration Was Justified Or Unjustified In Declaring War On Iraq.

1760 words - 7 pages The Iraqi Road and Generalissimo George"The threat from Saddam Hussein and weapons of mass destruction - chemical, biological, potentially nuclear weapons capability - that threat is real," explained British Prime Minister Tony Blair. The repeated violation of the United Nation (UN) Security Counsel's Resolutions (UNSCR's) prompted President George Bush of the United States to act without the authorization of the UN to disarm Hussein through war

War On Terror: The Rise Of The Us Patriot Act

2699 words - 11 pages attacks” (USA PATRIOT Act). He has these capabilities whenever we are engaging in battle or under attack from a foreign country. This gives the U.S. Government the power to control any situation by any means necessary. As you can see the US PATRIOT Act has played a big part in the War on Terror by giving our government the power to make and change laws that get in the way of catching and prosecuting terrorist. The U.S. Federal Government has been