This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Business Ethics Essay

1679 words - 7 pages

The stockholder and stakeholder theories are two popular frameworks used to examine the purpose of business and its ethical obligations. With reference to the quote above, both theories seem rational and enjoy strong support. However, a common failing of both is typically how humans interpret and implement the theories in contemporary business environments. For instance, Enron was so focused on the raising the price of their stock that they “cooked the books to produce fake profits”1. This paper will provide a description of each theory and, analyze ethical justifications and major objections to each theory. The ethical justifications will be based on pertinent examples - policies and actions, of businesses such as Wal-Mart. Based on this analysis, the paper will argue that the stockholder theory is more justified and maximally supported by ethical theory justification. An important point to note is that the two theories are extreme endpoints on a continuum of theories. The author of this paper will favor the stockholder theory with particular leaning towards the theory of moral minimums.
The stockholder theory is the classical view of the purpose of business, and candidly states that business exists to serve the interests of the stockholder by increasing profits from their investment. Per the stockholder theory, practitioners of the theory enjoy the moral “high ground’ as long as their business does not resort to coercion or fraud. Nobel-prize winning economist, Milton Friedman, takes the view that stockholders are owners of the business and are entitled to its profits while managers are agents of the stockholders, and do not have any right to donate money to charity. This viewpoint is embodied in the legal opinion “Dodge v. Ford Motor Company”, in which the court ruled that the benefits of higher salaries for employees and lower auto prices for consumers could not take priority over stockholder interests. The stock chart below illustrates how Wal-Mart, one of the companies seen as being stockholder focused, has benefited its stockholders immensely over the last three decades.
Ethical theories provide adequate support for the stockholder theory as detailed below.
Entitlement theory maintains that if someone acquires resources by just means they are entitled to those resources. Stockholders who acquire ownership of a business by investing in it are therefore the owners of the business and entitled to its profits. The entitlement theory also states that benefiting other stakeholders at the expense of stockholder dividends is akin to stealing. Year after year, it has been quoted that “Wal-Mart pays low wages and appears to aggressively seek to keep wages down”2. In this respect, Wal-Mart’s policy on employee wages seems to indicate that they respect the stockholder rights over those of their employees.
Utilitarianism theory holds the view that profit maximization directly or indirectly maximizes benefits for the greatest number of people....

Find Another Essay On Business Ethics

Business Ethics Essay

1817 words - 7 pages Business Ethics Business ethics is a diverse field that cannot be defined with a single definition. This area addresses numerous issues, problems, and dilemmas within the management of businesses. Does this through numerous perspectives and methods. Of course, in order to present the complexities of business ethics, we must explore the types of issues that business professionals are continuously confronted with. To understand one

Business Ethics Essay

952 words - 4 pages Business Ethics The statement has been made that "ethics has no place in business" and the implications of this statement and its inferring characteristics provide a complex issue in the operation of national and multinational corporations. Because ethical decision making is often not as profitable as choices that do not embrace ethical elements, the perspective has emerged that the nature of an effective business mindset inherently

Business Ethics

1783 words - 7 pages Outline : A) General overview. B) Utilitarian theory. C) Kant theory. C) Rawls theory. D) Conclusion. Foreword: This research paper discusses theories in business ethics. It also considers three cases that illustrate ethics principles violation. Thesis: Nowadays in the era of economic relations and international trade business ethics plays a very important role. Nowadays in the era of economic relations and

Business Ethics - 1441 words

1441 words - 6 pages In today’s global society, a Code of Ethics policy is used to label established, acceptable behaviors among that industry’s business associates, potential investors, and the corporation’s executive officers and employees, and most important, the consumer (Ethics Resource Center, 2003). In an attempt to promote an increased efficiency and productivity potential level, among employees and prospective clients, a corporation’s standard Code

Business Ethics - 941 words

941 words - 4 pages Business Ethics Business ethics is a multifaceted field that cannot be defined with a single definition. This area addresses numerous issues, problems, and dilemmas within the management of businesses. It does this through numerous perspectives and methods. Of course, in order to present the complexities of business ethics, we must explore the types of issues that business professionals are confronted with all the time. Business ethics not

Business Ethics

865 words - 3 pages BUSINESS ETHICS REFLECTION 1Business Ethics ReflectionKimberly AdcockXMGT/216August 10, 2014Shakema Fleming-SandersBUSINESS ETHICS REFLECTION 2DESCRIBE THE RELATIONSHIP AMONG VIRTUE, VALUES, AND MORAL CONCEPTS IN THE ETHICAL DILEMMACompanies often promote a particular set of values through a corporate mission statement, code of ethics. The extent to which individual employees apply these values on a day-to-day basis depends on an employee's own

Business Ethics

3512 words - 14 pages I. ABSTRACTWithout question "business ethics" is one of the hot topics of the day. Over the past months we have seen business after business charged with improper practices that violate commonly accepted ethical norms. This has led to a loss of confidence in corporate management, and has had severe economic consequences. Business ethics serves the important social function of integrating business and society, by promoting the legitimacy of

Business Ethics

1307 words - 6 pages Business Ethics PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Running head: BUSINESS ETHICSBusiness EthicsDon CarterGrand Canyon UniversityBusiness EthicsIntroduction: One of the great arguments in business has always been whether a certain amount of deception or trickery is an ethical practice. For decades businessmen have perfected some form of business bluffing whether it was to gain an edge against a competitor or to get a promotion. However, simply because

Business Ethics - 1292 words

1292 words - 5 pages an organization and its employees are part of the team, therefore the organization would benefit if their leaders are having strong ethical principles and positive relationships . Because business ethics helps the team work better both individually and as a unit, thus inspiring ethical values while maintaining innovation and overall productivity. Effective leadership is relevant for business ethics because increasing demands are placed on

Business Ethics - 550 words

550 words - 2 pages Business Ethics Discussing the ethics of big business can very well get complicated. At the same time they can be very simple. Ethics of big business in a free enterprise system consist of some ideas. Some important ideas are competition, workers rights, and consumer protection.Productive resources let businesses produce goods and provide services. The Idea of Maximum Profit is very important in business. Profit is the businesses earnings after

Business Ethics - 1178 words

1178 words - 5 pages Business ethics can be looked at in two different ways. First from an individual standpoint and also an organizational standpoint. Individuals have the responsibility to exhibit ethical behavior to both there employer as well as the customer. Organizations carry the same responsibility towards the customer but also carry a social responsibility to contribute to the community in which they conduct business in.The decision process in making

Similar Essays

Business Ethics Essay 1764 Words

1764 words - 7 pages 7CokeAbstractImportance of Business ethicsLeigha Coke and Trevor DosterDecember 20, 2013The objective of this essay is to explain the importance of business ethics for small businesses. The definition of business ethics is described in full detail to help better explain the purpose of ethics. Ethics are the moral guidelines in which an employer should govern their business. Most ethics are geared toward the business's customers. A business must

Business Ethics Essay 2216 Words

2216 words - 9 pages sounds simple, it is easier said than done! There will always be a conflict of interest between various groups of people. Any decisions made by businesses need to be made with an informed awareness of the specific situation and then act according to some sort of system of principals which is Business Ethics. In my report I will talk about business ethics, provide the benefits of ethics and the implications of ethics to a company's stakeholders.What

Business Ethics Essay

2231 words - 9 pages achieve business objectives. In an April 1997 study, the Chartered Financial Consultants and the Ethics Officers Association, found that 56% of all workers feel some pressure to act unethically or illegally. The study also revealed that 48% of workers admitted they had engaged in one or more unethical and/or illegal actions during the last year. Among the most common violations: cutting corners on quality, covering up incidents, lying to

Business Ethics Essay 1554 Words

1554 words - 6 pages the ethics and values contained in their mission statements produce graduates who are highly valued and sought by ethical organizations." (Procario-Foley and Bean, 2002:101).The question then becomes, "Who should teach ethics, when and how?" (McDonald, G, 2006). According to Klein's 1998 article, the one condition necessary for a business ethics course is that the teacher must be a philosopher. He argues that philosophers are best qualified to