Business Ethics And The Merck & Co., Inc. Case Study

2754 words - 11 pages

Susan GustafsonBusiness EthicsMark Matthews, Ph.D.February 10, 2004Applying Ethics to the Merck CaseThe purpose of my essay is to show whether the business decisions made by the management team of Merck pharmaceutical are ethical. Using corporate assets for charitable purposes, the company manufactures and distributes a drug called Mectizan at no charge to impoverished nations and their inhabitants.I will expound on three ethical theories and then analyze the Merck case according to each theory, summarizing how the authors and proponents of each theory would position themselves regarding this case. The three theories that will be used to examine the case are John Stuart Mill's ethical theory of Utilitarianism, Immanuel Kant's Supreme Principal of Morality theory, and The Voice of Care, which is a contemporary challenge to dominant ethical views such as Kants and Mills'.I have chosen to use only the materials covered in our classroom text and information gained as a result of classroom lectures. I will not interject my opinions but analyze the case from the perspective of the authors of the theories.The Merck CaseMerck & Co. Inc. is one of the world's largest pharmaceutical companies in the world. Corporate headquarters are here in the United States. In 2001 Merck recognized over 47 billion dollars in revenue.Research scientists at Merck discovered a cure for the disease river blindness, caused by a parasite and carried by the black fly, which adversely affects large populations in third world countries. After testing the drug through clinical trials to assure its' safety, the company tried to market the drug through sources such as The World Health Organization and several U.S. health agencies. The United States government was also called upon to introduce legislation to obtain funding for the distribution of Mectizan to impoverished countries. Merck's attempts to find buyers were unsuccessful. The management team decided to manufacture and distribute the drug for free, as the company held core values of "preserving and improving human life" and "being committed to the highest standards of ethics and integrity." These core company values were not taken lightly but literally. George Merck, the company president from 1925 to 1950, was quoted in the text as having written these words about Merck's values; "medicine is for the people. It is not for the profits. The profits follow, and if we have remembered that, they have never failed to appear. The better we have remembered that, the larger they have been."30 million people in 32 countries are now treated each year with Mectizan at Merck's expense. The cost of the entire program is unknown to management but they estimate that each pill costs the company around $ 1.50 to manufacture.In light of these facts, I have to question if management is making ethical decisions about the use of stockholder and or shareholder equity interests in deciding to provide this charitable contribution. I will now...

Find Another Essay On Business Ethics and the Merck & Co., Inc. Case Study

Polaroid Inc. Decision Case Study: Darden Business Scholl Case

1953 words - 8 pages given in the case and Polaroid's is very close to this ratio at the BBB level which matches the information presented in the case that they are indeed a BBB rating company. To determine the amount that can be borrow the differences between our ratio and that of the industries given in exhibit 9 were computed at each rating level. Polaroid's Current LT Debt of $526.70 was multiplied by 1 + the percentage change in the ratios giving us the implied

Ethics and Negotiation - Case study

2376 words - 10 pages Case Study: BP Texas RefineryIntroductionAccording to Lewicki, Saunders & Minton (2003), adopting an unethical approach to negotiation in business can have serious consequences. A recent explosion at the British Petroleum (BP) Texas refinery on 24 March, 2005 reiterated this and demonstrated the effect of an unethical approach to negotiation with the death of 15 contract workers.Ethical behaviour refers to the standards of conduct such as

Case Study Analyses: The Gap, Inc.

1658 words - 7 pages The central purpose of writing this Case Study Analyses on The Gap, Inc. is to identify and isolate key issues and their underlying implications and offer practical solutions and plans for implementing those solutions. This will be done by highlighting the social influences that influence the Gap, Inc. marketing strategy, segmentation strategies with respect to distinct retail markets, and positioning strategies that can be used or changed

Ethics and the Environment Case Study: Fueling the World

2393 words - 10 pages Ethics and the Environment Case Study: Fueling the WorldWe are a global society of energy junkies. Our utility grid runs at maximum capacity resulting in rolling blackouts, our consumption of fossil fuels creates greenhouse gases that result in global warming. Even with this knowledge our demand for energy continues to increase. Where are we going to get our "energy fix" when the world's oil fields dry out, and our government's energy

Ethics and the Environment Case Study: Fueling the World

2191 words - 9 pages "Humanity's way of life is on a collusion course with geology, with the stark fact that the earth holds a finite supply of oil" (Appenzeller, 2004, p. 88). The United States is one of the largest consumers of fossil fuels. This paper presents Learning Team A's fossil fuel case study analysis. The selected case study is, Fueling the World: What are the Alternatives? (Newton, Dillingham, and Choly, 2006, p. 157).This case summary details the

ABC Inc Case Study

1028 words - 4 pages June. Without further investigation, root-cause analysis is mere speculation. Based on the facts presented in the case study, this author has determined several root-cause factors, which may have contributed to this calamity. These root causes stem from two sources, Carl Robins and ABC, Inc.Carl could have overstated his qualifications prior to hiring upon which a hiring decision was rendered or does he have poor work ethics and incompetent

Case Study: Dell, Inc.

911 words - 4 pages assembly keeps Dell the low price leader in the PC industry. The Core Issues at Dell, Inc.: The Price War is going on between PC Makers. Revenues Down Worldwide sales of PC's Down Leadership at Dell Corporation Service Contracts Maintaining the Market Share Dividing Business between Consumers and Business Analysis of Strategic Factors Situational Analysis (SWOT) Strengths Production

Case Study: Caterpillar Inc.

1289 words - 5 pages or impossible for Caterpillar to do business in that country. The more countries that have trade barriers, the less Caterpillar's profits and revenues. 8. Caterpillar, Inc. has had severe labor difficulties during the past decade. What can the company do to establish a more cooperative environment in its US factories? Today's economy does not call for compromise. The company pays its employees well and the benefits are significant. The

ABC Inc Case Study

761 words - 3 pages Getting Employees Ready for HireCarl Robins is a new campus recruiter for ABC, Inc. He has enlisted and hired 15 new employees a few months after he was hired. The new recruits are to be trainees for Monica Carrolls, the Operations Supervisor. However, Carl has failed to make the necessary arrangements for the new trainee orientation that is scheduled to take place on June 15. He also has neglected to follow-up with each of the new trainees

AucScan, Inc. Case Study

1860 words - 7 pages AcuScan, Inc. Case StudyI am newly hired Vice President of Organizational Development, and will be responsible for creating the Organizational Development department over the coming year. This company is trying to find a new product based on their technology, a retinal scanning system, because revenues have been dropping. Two members of the management team have suggested a new product for a new market, but the manager of Product Development has

Entrepreneur case study-Turner Test Prep Co.

1948 words - 8 pages study effectively, she decided to start her own test prep business teaching specifically to the CPA exam. She was confident that students and professionals wishing to become CPA's would benefit from a full-service program that gave students full classes and individualized attention so that they could pass the exam.Jessica returned to California, put together a business plan, and secured financing from a local venture capital firm specializing in

Similar Essays

Vioxx And Merck & Co. Essay

582 words - 2 pages Vioxx/Merck Summary The painkiller Vioxx was introduced in 1999 by Merck & Co. It has been used by over 20 million Americans since it was put on the market. Vioxx remained on the market for approximately five years without adequate warnings about its risks. In September of 2004, Merck took Vioxx off the market after a study revealed that it doubled the risk of heart attack or stroke for patients that used it for more than 18 months

Business Ethics Case Study

1341 words - 5 pages could influence his judgment on his moral beliefs and begins to believe this common behavior in business. However, his obligation is to follow order and do what his supervisors ask him to do, but you override these obligations if they lead to harming others. B.F. Goodrich has a loyalty clause to the shareholders as well. 3. Moral Values: One of the most important values would be to Conduct Relationships with Integrity. By possessing firm

Case Study Merck & Co Make Sure You Label Graphs & Tables, Abstract Should Be Around 300 Words

2303 words - 9 pages AbstractLeading up to the year 2000, Merck & Co., Inc. had gained success in the pharmaceutical industry with drugs like Vasotec, for help with blood pressure ("Vasotec," 2013), and Pepcid, to relieve issues with stomach acid ("Pepcid complete," 2013). Merck had generate about $5.7 billion through the sales of their more popular drugs, however, the company fears that sales will decline as "generic substitutes become available." Looking to

China Ethics And The Environment Case Study

1506 words - 6 pages Are We Problem PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 China-Ethics and The Environment Case StudyAbstractAre We The Problem?"First of all, it is obvious when we examine the world's population problem that there are just too many Chinese" (Text, Year, p. 141). "At its founding in 1949 the People's Repulic of China had a population of 540 million" (IIASA, 2008, p.1). "Only three decades later its population was more than 800 million (IIASA, p. 1). "The U.S