Business Ethics Case Essay

910 words - 4 pages

The Reluctant Security Guard
1. Relevant Facts
1.1. David Tuff was a security guard at the Blue Mountain Company in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
1.2 As part of his job training, it was necessary for him to get a security guard license, requiring him to obey the Security Officer’s Manual, which included the following statement: “If a serious accident or illegal behavior should occur on the premises of the licensee, it shall be the responsibility of the licensee to notify the appropriate police department immediately”.
1.3. Fourteen months after Tuff joined the company, Blue Mountain issued new rules of pro¬cedure, demanding the security guards "to order and escort intoxicated per¬sons, including ...view middle of the document...

Its violation could result in dismissal or in disciplinary procedures.
1.10. Blue Mountain’s Council members advised Hernandez to give Tuff an unspecified number of days for reflection
1.11. Three days later an article about the com¬pany's policies relying entirely on Tuff’s testimonial, appeared in the newspaper, with data based on Tuff’s nightly shift reports. The article also initiated an editorial on a local television station, highly criticizing the company.
1.12. Blue Mountain’s Council of Managers considered Tuffs revelations an unfor¬givable act of disloyalty and had him fired.
1.13. Tuff brought his case to the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), whose members de¬termined that Blue Mountain was within its legal rights to fire him.
2. Problem / Issue
Was the Council of Managers of Blue Mountain morally justified to fire David Tuff because his revelations were "an unforgivable act of disloyalty" and he had violated the company policy by talking to the news media?
3. Moral Principles
3.1. Rationality
Rationality is the principle of adhering to the existent reality irrespective of one’s consciousness and thinking in accordance with the requirements of logic. One of the most important aspects of the virtue of rationality is respecting the law of causality; therefore we have a responsibility to consider the effects of a certain action before enacting the cause. It also means that one has to be able to base their decisions, beliefs and attitudes on facts rather than on wishes/emotions while evading and refusing to grasp logical inferences. In the decision making process, one should be aware of oneself and one’s characteristics and identify and investigate not only raw facts but also facts of reality not available to immediate sensory...

Find Another Essay On business ethics case

Business Ethics Case Paper - "Slavery in the Chocolate Industry"

1091 words - 4 pages bittersweet. Retrieved July 10, 2007 from, L. (2005). Chocolate, Unchained. Retrieved July 11, 2007 from, M. G. (2006). Business ethics: concepts and cases (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Business Ethics Case Study

1341 words - 5 pages could influence his judgment on his moral beliefs and begins to believe this common behavior in business. However, his obligation is to follow order and do what his supervisors ask him to do, but you override these obligations if they lead to harming others. B.F. Goodrich has a loyalty clause to the shareholders as well. 3. Moral Values: One of the most important values would be to Conduct Relationships with Integrity. By possessing firm

A case study on business ethics performed by Triodos Bank. -Ethical banking-

1835 words - 7 pages BUSINESS ETHICSAn analysis of Triodos bankIntroductionTriodos Bank is a social bank lending only to organisations and businesses with social and environmental objectives. Triodos Bank is well known for its innovative and transparent approach to banking. Savers at Triodos Bank know where their money is working. In 2001 the balance sheet totalled 461.841 GBP.History1968 an economist, professor in tax law, senior organisational consultant and a

Business Ethics - Case Study og Global Crossing and Its Owner Gary Winnick

952 words - 4 pages Ford Motors. Winnick employed the services of Salomon Smith Barney, who employed an analyst with unprecedented level sof influence of the telecoms industry, Jack Grubman. After a year of low revenues and lackluster of cash flow, Winnick sought to emulate WorldCom with its acquisition based business model. Hiring former AT&T executive Robert Annunziata as a new to lend credence to his company’s respectability he entered into negotiations to

Business Ethics

1783 words - 7 pages . It is utter injustice to test the products of the company on people of the underdeveloped countries. Business ethics promotes the principle of total fait and here we have an example of violating the principle. Nestle deals with foodstuffs and this worsens the situation. However, to my mind in case of any troubles Nestle will have to take responsibility and undergo penalty. I was surprised to find out that the company of Nestlé's size and

Business Ethics

3512 words - 14 pages are often more relaxed and multi-nationals are tempted to lower their standards when situations permit. In that case there are certain factors that effect business ethics such as bribery, influencing foreign governments, and exploiting third world countries. Bribery is the offer of money or property to a public official to influence a decision. The crime of bribery is made or committed when the illegal offer is made whether it is accepted or not

Business Ethics

1292 words - 5 pages an organization and its employees are part of the team, therefore the organization would benefit if their leaders are having strong ethical principles and positive relationships . Because business ethics helps the team work better both individually and as a unit, thus inspiring ethical values while maintaining innovation and overall productivity. Effective leadership is relevant for business ethics because increasing demands are placed on

Business Ethics

3055 words - 13 pages “reverse whistle blowing” (Laufer, 2002) or scapegoating. Roscoe Pound’s (1980) grave accepted wisdom on how rules have a propensity to promulgate and become mechanical. The inspiration of a mechanical jurisprudence is used to demonstrate the nastiest case implementation of ISCT, a mechanical business ethics. Pound writes that: The effect of [any] system is apt to be petrifaction of the subject systematized. Perfection of scientific system and

Business Ethics - 3763 words

3763 words - 16 pages operations and the ethics within the business community vary greatly from those that are established in America. As such the temptation exists to modify their business practices and code of ethics to mirror the other businesses within the country, which leaves the question is it ethical to do so? It is an interesting question, should a business seek to retain the business practices and ethical standards of the USA or should they seek to embrace

Business ethics

2215 words - 9 pages Business Ethics is one of the most challenging issues facing the corporate world today, here in the United States and abroad. The corporate world has been involved in a number of ethical scandals which involves several activities, which includes tax evasion, racial discrimination, insider trading, employee drug and alcohol abuse, and many more. Business ethics has a huge impact on the survival of many organizations. "An ethical manager in the

Business Ethics - 1679 words

1679 words - 7 pages theory establishes stockholders as the sole owners of the business and profits. In that case benefiting other stakeholders is unjust taxation on stockholders. There are certainly many examples where management benefited unjustly at the expense of stockholders, such as in the case of former Tyco CEO, Dennis Kozlowski, and CFO, Mark Swartz, who were found guilty of stealing hundreds of millions of dollars from the manufacturing conglomerate4. “History

Similar Essays

Starbucks Business Ethics Case Analysis

1544 words - 6 pages Starbucks Business Ethics Case Analysis INTRO Ethical issues in business are a common placed every day occurrence that will never cease to exist. We will discuss an ethical issue that involves a large American corporation and its practices when dealing with suppliers of produce that is essential but not solely used by this business. We will present several point of views backed by literary findings that suggest ethical practices may or

Business Ethics For National Semiconductors Case

2235 words - 9 pages Ethics in Business From a business perspective, working under government contracts can be a very lucrative proposition. In general, a stream of orders keep coming in, revenue increases and the company grows in the aggregate. The obvious downfalls to working in this manner are both higher quality expected as well as the extensive research and documentation required for government contracts. If a part fails to perform correctly, it can cause minor

Business Ethics And The Merck & Co., Inc. Case Study

2754 words - 11 pages Susan GustafsonBusiness EthicsMark Matthews, Ph.D.February 10, 2004Applying Ethics to the Merck CaseThe purpose of my essay is to show whether the business decisions made by the management team of Merck pharmaceutical are ethical. Using corporate assets for charitable purposes, the company manufactures and distributes a drug called Mectizan at no charge to impoverished nations and their inhabitants.I will expound on three ethical theories and

Describes The National Semiconductor Case Connected With Business Ethics

2212 words - 9 pages . Theexecutives within a corporation should not be forced to bring out all of the employees responsible into a public forum. A company should bereprimanded and be left alone to carry out its own internalinvestigation and repercussions. From a business law perspective this is the ideal case since a corporation is defined as being a separate legal entity. Furthermore, the opposition would argue that this resolution would benefit both the company and the