Calculus, Leibniz And Newton Essay

2320 words - 9 pages

It is interesting to note that the ongoing controversy concerning the so-called conflict between Wilhelm Gottfried Leibniz and Isaac Newton is one that does not bare much merit. Whether one came up with the concepts of calculus are insignificant since the outcome was that future generations benefited. However, the logic of their clash does bear merit.
In proposing that he was the first inventor, Leibniz states that "it is most useful that the true origins of memorable inventions be known, especially of those that were conceive not by accident but by an effort of meditation. The use of this is not merely that history may give everyone his due and others be spurred by the expectation of similar praise, but also that the art of discovery may be promoted and its method become known through brilliant examples.”
Newton on the other had would not allow himself to be usurped by stating that “second inventors have no right. Whether Mr Leibniz found the Method by himself or not is not the Question… We take the proper question to be,… who was the first inventor of the method." In addition, he continued on by stating that "to take away the Right of the first inventor, and divide it between him and that other, would be an Act of Injustice."
The argument in this paper that even though the onus of the discovery of calculus lies with Isaac Newton, the credit goes to Leibniz for the simple fact that he was the one who published his works first. Appending to this is the fact that the calculus wars that ensue was merely and egotistic battle between humans succumbing to their bare primal instincts. To commence, a brief historical explanation must be given about both individuals prior to stating their cases.
On January 4, 1643, Isaac Newton was born in the midst of the English Civil War, which lasted from 1641 to 1649. Around the same time in 1646, Wilhelm Leibniz was born in Leipzig during the Thirty Years' War (1618-48). At age eighteen, Newton was admitted to Trinity College, Cambridge. Leibniz decided to acknowledge family tradition by studying law and philosophy at the University of Leipzig, where at age seventeen, he was already defending his master's thesis, De Principio Individui.
Newton's mathematical acumen came to the fore when he read Rene Descartes' Geometry and John Wallis' Arithmetica Infinitorium. It was around this time that he was convinced that he would arrive at a conclusion where by analysis could be made on geometric curve via algebra—albeit calculus. Furthermore, Newton would improve on Wallis' Infinite Series by devising proofs of the various theorems. He was then conferred as a scholar at Trinity in 1664 but the following year, England was hit with plague and Cambridge was no exceptions; the university closed till 1667.
By the time, Newton returned to Cambridge, he had already written material for Opticks, in which he stated "that just a prism can split white light into this spectrum of colors, so can a second prism...

Find Another Essay On Calculus, Leibniz and Newton

Issac Newton Essay

942 words - 4 pages Newton or Leibniz was the inventor of the calculus. The committee sided with Newton, and he received the credit of the new mathematical inventionSir Isaac Newton was an amazing intellectual. Although he was not a perfect kid growing up, he brought humans through great leaps and to the forefront of the discovery and studying of science. He devoted much of his life to discovering the secrets of science. Newton determined many of the laws that are

Newton's Negative Neglect Essay

1154 words - 5 pages time. Another issue Newton faced was false accusations. Newton had a dislike for publishing his works, until it seemed as if others were beginning to reveal the same things he did. For example, a man named Gottfried Leibniz began uncovering things in the field of calculus, a field Newton claimed to discover well before Leibniz had. Newton was then inclined to publish his work in calculus, just before Leibniz did, which led to major controversy

The History of Calculus

1378 words - 6 pages astronomy and rapid mechanical inventions that required calculus were prevalent. During this time, there were multiple mathematicians who made substantial contributions to the field, but the two that are referred to as the fathers of modern calculus are Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Leibniz. What makes these two so intriguing and noteworthy is that both of them separately came to the same answers at the same time, but neither could show the beginnings

The Contributions of Isaac Newton

1164 words - 5 pages tail. Binomial Theorem is also used to expand polynomials. While he was still at home, Newton laid the foundations for his next discovery, differential and integral calculus, several years before its independent discovery by Gottfried Leibniz. He termed it the method of fluxions which was based on his crucial insight that integration of a function is only the inverse procedure to differentiating it. Newton produced simple logical methods

Essay on Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz

2087 words - 8 pages remembered as a philosopher, mathematician, historian and jurist, rival of Newton, with whom he feuded regularly over the invention of calculus. Although Gottfried Leibniz left behind no philosophical magnum opus, he is still considered to be among the great thinkers of his century (17th). Leibniz developed a philosophy of Rationalism by which he attempted to reconcile the existence of matter with the existence of God. Bertrand Russel wrote that

The Contributions of Isaac Newton to The Scientific Revolution

1163 words - 5 pages gravity to develop. Clearly without this understanding of gravity many modern advancements would of not have been possible. Newton also made advances in mathematics, particularly in calculus. Along with Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Newton co-developed the bulk of what is now modern calculus. Calculus is a branch of mathematics like algebra and geometry are. Calculus had many applications for Newton, he used calculus to help him develop his

Johann Bernoulli

1368 words - 5 pages French mathematician, Florimond Debeaune, and it consisted of determining a curve from a property of its tangent (Young 52-53). Also, Bernoulli addressed 2,500 letters with 110 scholars during his lifetime. In 1693, Bernoulli began talking to Leibniz, one of the famous scholars, about his scientific views (McElroy 32). He strongly defended the German philosopher as the real discoverer of calculus instead of Isaac Newton. Bernoulli wrote many

Sir Isaac Newton and his accomplishments with math and sciences

602 words - 2 pages problems with infinitesimal calculus. Not all of these rules of calculus was new, but the unification was his idea. Newton's algebraic symbolism was developed from Descartes, and was particularly powerful. However, his calculus notation was perhaps none too successful; although it was no problem to Newton since he worked mainly in isolation anyway. Interestingly it was Leibniz' misconceptions of differentials which provides us with successful notation

Sir Isaac Newton

1688 words - 7 pages piece with a force proportional to the produce of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.CalculusDuring Newton's plague years, he laid the foundation for elementary differential and integral calculus, several years before its independent discovery by the German philosopher and mathematician Gottfried Leibniz. For Leibriz, based on his crucial insight that the integration of a function is merely the inverse

A Life Worth Knowing: Isaac Newton

1126 words - 5 pages Did you know today more than ever we are conscious of the great work of Sir Isaac Newton, for without Newton's understanding of the laws of gravity and motion we could not have rockets and satellites? (Bevlah, Stillman, epilogue) Newton is worth knowing because he "laid the foundation for differential and integral calculus, his work on optics and gravitation made him one of the greatest scientists the world has ever known." (

Biography of Isaac Newton

2501 words - 11 pages opponent, began publishing papers on calculus in 1684, almost 20 years after Newton's discoveries begun. The result of this progressive difference was a bitter dispute that raged for nearly two decades. The trial began with rumors that Leibniz had borrowed ideas from Newton and rushed them into print. It ended with charges of dishonesty and outright plagiarism. It is now generally agreed that Newton and Leibniz each developed the calculus

Similar Essays

Contributions Of Isaac Newton Essay

1251 words - 5 pages applied mathematician. Thus, Newton was able to discover and develop calculus and also apply it to scientific experiments. However, Newton was not the only one who developed calculus. Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz, a German mathematician, also developed calculus at the same time as Newton. The difference between the two types of calculus is that Leibniz looked at variables as “ranging over sequences of infinitely close values” (“The History of

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Essay

1056 words - 5 pages discovery of the Calculus. Both unwavering in their belief it was themselves who discovered it and should receive full credit; Leibniz was accused of stealing Newton’s ideas. Most mathematicians agree that they developed their ideas completely separate from each other. Newton is seen to have developed the ideas first and Leibniz was the first to officially publish them. When it came to practical use and advancement in other fields of study

Leibniz: The Father Of Modern Calculus

1549 words - 6 pages Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz is an important figure in the history of philosophy and mathematics. Although his work was not fully appreciated during his day, he did much to advance the "thinking" on a variety of subjects. His fame was scarred by the infamous controversy with Isaac Newton on the subject of the discoverer of calculus. Leibniz's work encompassed a wide scope, ranging from philosopy to politics to mechanics and

Isaac Newton Biography Essay

911 words - 4 pages principle of gravitation. His other notable rival Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz was claimed to have invented the first calculation. As Newton's Principia came after Leibniz's calculus, some began to think that Newton borrowed his method of Leibniz. The truth was that Newton had invented the calculus between 1665 and 1666, but he was reluctant to publish his work for years, while Leibniz presents his work in 1684. Leibniz actually received letters from