This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Can A Person With Average Charisma Or Personality Be A Superior Leader?

633 words - 3 pages

Can a person with average charisma or personality be a superior leader? Support your position and if applicable, provide an example.My answer is No. A personal trait alone is not a factor for superior leadership. Ralph Stogdill argued that, "traits of an effective leader can only be assessed in conjunction with other factors, such as the nature of followers and the characteristics of the situation" (Wren, J.T. 1995, p. 125). Furthermore, Kirkpatrick and Locke in their writing of Do Traits Matter (1991) underscore that charisma is on the three traits with less clear-cut evidence of importance to leadership (Wren, J.T (1995). A person even with all of the things involved in being a charismatic leader (not with average charisma) is still not enough to be a superior leader. On the contrary there can limitations and even risk to the organization. Nadler and Trushman observed that "there are inherent limitations to the effectiveness of charismatic leaders, many stemming from risk associated with leadership which involves around a single individual". A leader with charisma or personality may create unrealistic and unattainable expectations. This exactly what happened at my local Engineering Association in the year 2004; the charismatic president of the association during his key note address of the annual association conference stated that the revision and publication of the association's charter in accordance with the new government regulation will be completed prior to the next year annual conference. Apparently his goal was important to renew the association's license to continue to operate legally, allows the enrolment of many new members, and he can get re-elected if he succeeded. The entire board of directors and more than 200 members worked so hard for the entire year and the goal was not even 50% achieved. Even though, the government regulators extended the deadline for submission extended by one more year the unrealistic goal was not attainable. Many senior and key members left the association and the...

Find Another Essay On Can a person with average charisma or personality be a superior leader?

Can a Robot be a Person? Bicentennial Man

1797 words - 7 pages Can a robot be a person? Or should it be said, can Andrew be a person? Andrew is simply NDR-114: an androgynous robot designed to handle household chores, child education, servant work, and anything else as ordered by humans, the Martin family. It only got its name when Little Miss stumbled over the word "android", and mistaken it as something else and said "Andrew" instead. As Andrew begins to experience emotions and creative thought, the

Lessons on Being a Good Leader Described in John Maxwell's Book, Be a People Person

520 words - 2 pages to treat you” (13). This includes, but is not limited to encouraging, appreciating, forgiving, listening, and fully understanding people (30). For anyone truly to be a great leader, you must attain a specific unique quality that causes people to be drawn to you as well. Maxwell notes that you must be charismatic in how you interact with people. “If your desire is to become a people person, then you need to develop an appealing personality that

Be A Leader

792 words - 4 pages the need of the group with the greatest number always. In contribute to the information thus far giving. Being a leader can have it pros and cons as well. Often leadership can be just like management a business. We have to lose some things to gain a profit. When looking deeply in the word of God, one greatest leader would have been Job. Through the testing of some difficulties in life he still manages to keep faithful to his works

To Be a Good Leader

1568 words - 6 pages they can use to improve some of their techniques. To become a good leader, the person must be responsible, because no one wants an unreliable leader. The way a leader is responsible is by always being prepared and organized with all of the information needed on a moments notice for what is supposed to happen and also what might happen (Rich). The leader should be able to take notes on the directions that their boss told them and do the task

manager should be a leader

2191 words - 9 pages coordinator for non-compliance but I can visualize that the leader could "counsel" the visitation coordinator in strong terms and express "extreme disappointment" in his or her performance. These could be considered milder forms of coercion. There are a couple of important limitations to reward and coercion, the most important being that they're both highly dependent on the influencing agent. Also, surveillance is absolutely

Napoleon: A Leader Or Dictator

611 words - 2 pages Napoleon: A Leader or Dictator. There are never ending inquiries on the nature of Napoleonic power. But reason can prove to one that the Age of Napoleon was infact a time of democratic rule. Through Political, Social, and Economical reforms, Napoleon Bonaparte did not only transcend France, but he changed the course of history for Europe and the World today. To begin, Napoleon proved himself a democratic leader thorough many Political

Napoleon: A Leader Or Dictator

651 words - 3 pages Napoleon: A Leader or Dictator. There are never ending inquiries on the nature of Napoleonic power. But reason can prove to one that the Age of Napoleon was infact a time of democratic rule. Through Political, Social, and Economical reforms, Napoleon Bonaparte did not only transcend France, but he changed the course of history for Europe and the World today. To begin, Napoleon proved himself a democratic leader thorough many

can be a place?

532 words - 2 pages CAN BE PLACE?The place that I want to tell you has been neglected for almost of your entire life. Can it be a place? You may think no but I tentatively say yes. It is everywhere. It is at the end border of the world, surrounded by human and his consciousness. Its territories are perfectly rounded, huge or even stagnant like a thousand years immutable wall well. Despite the high thin-hole barrier, the territories are somehow are unbreakable and

Sammy: A Follower or a Leader

1160 words - 5 pages Sammy, a Follower or a Leader John Updike, an excellent author of a short story presents us in A & P, a part of teenager’s life, easy to relate with everyone’s life. The picture, in which John Updike introduce his character, Sammy, as a responsible and mature young man which is working at A & P at the age of nineteen, conflicts with his rebellious actions and a behavior of typical American adolescent who is trying to overcome the growing pain

One Person Can Make a Difference

852 words - 3 pages power of the written or spoken word allows one person to change the lives of thousands as in the case of Rachel Carson and Martin Luther King Jr. But the act of one individual can have a more personal impact. I have a personal story about how one person changed my family’s life. My son was diagnosed with kidney disease when he was 16 years old. Over a short period of time he became very ill. The doctors said he would need a kidney transplant. My

Interview conducted with a person with disablity

1031 words - 5 pages This interview was conducted with Mrs. Isola Cumberbatch, Mrs. Cumberbatch is 83 years old. She was a very vibrant out going individual, she did her own cooking, shopping and she walked to church every Sunday. Mrs. Cumberbatch who is a diabetic lost her left leg to gangrene. “Gangrene is a condition that occurs when body tissue dies. It is caused by a loss of blood supply due to an underlying illness, injury, and/or infection.” (webmd.com) Mrs

Similar Essays

How Can He Be A Leader?

893 words - 4 pages "I want to apologize and it will never be allowed to happen again." Kim Jong Il said these words once, and he should be a man that has to say these words over and over again. He is a horrible dictator, and the worst leader in the world. He is the worst political figure in the world because of how he lives in luxury, his nuclear weapons program, and the restriction of rights on all the people of North Korea.Kim Jong Il is a political tyrant

Can A Person Be Fit And Fat?

938 words - 4 pages An average physician, or any other type of medical professional, would insist that until an individual loses weight, they cannot be considered fit. As seen on “The Dr. Oz Show”, experts disagree that someone can be both overweight and healthy at the same time. My stance on the subject is that it is possible for a person to be fat and fit with certain parameters set in place. I have gone over the readings and videos provided in class, as well

A Hero Vs An Average Person

1237 words - 5 pages and got the last of his men killed. An example about this from todays time would be if you were demanded by your boss to go and do your work, but you just sat down and didn’t do it you would face the consequences of getting fired, which in Odysseus’ case his mens consequences were death. Overall, his weaknesses cause him to be an average person, and not a hero. In conclusion, a hero can be both someone we admire or someone who inspires us

A Middle Class Person Can Be A Tragic Hero

659 words - 3 pages A middle class person can be a tragic hero. A tragic hero typically is defined as a great man, who falls from prominence to worthlessness, and eventually dies. The tragic hero's death is supposed to affect the entire population, and the audience members are supposed to feel sympathy for the tragic hero since they believe a similar fate could happen to them. Early playwrights said that a middle class person could not be a tragic hero. They