Can Brown Save Platonism This Time?

1678 words - 7 pages

From the book "Philosophy of Mathematics", the author James Brown addresses many problems involving Platonism's view in mathematics; such as how other mathematicians and philosophers debunk Platonism's view. Brown, however, saves Platonism by attacking the intruders first. Before reaching the stage where Brown fights the intruders, it is necessary to understand the following: (1) the Platonism's claim in mathematics, which is described in the second paragraph; (2) its two main fundamentals problems, which appears in paragraph three; (3) how Conventionalism, Empiricism, and Nominalism rejects Platonism, as described in the fourth paragraph. In the fifth paragraph, Brown will defend Platonism by attacking the intruders. Finally in the sixth paragraph, I will give my opinion on how well Brown defends Platonism and whether he's objective.First, Platonists claim that "mathematical objects are perfectly real and exist independently of us" (Brown, p11). They are perfectly real in the sense that they do have a unique form like any ordinary object. Since they have a unique form, we should be able to describe them. Thus, Platonists came up with the idea that using standard semantics, which is the theory of how truth is assigned to sentences, we are able to describe these mathematical entities. For instance, if the statement 'Jerry has one hat' is assumed to be true, then a person named Jerry must exist. Similarly, '1 x 2 = 2' and '1 > 0' are true statements if and only if the number 1 exists. By showing that objects exist in these true statements, Platonists claim that mathematical objects exist as well. Second, they claim that all mathematical objects are abstract. Abstract doesn't mean universal, but it means "outside of space and time, and they are neither concrete nor physical" (Brown, p12). For example, when we describe a red apple, the redness of the apple is universal, but the 'red-apple' itself is a particular because the apple has an instance color of red. Consequently, a mathematical object such as 7 is a particular, but also abstract-it exists outside of space and time. Third, they claim that men are born with limited mathematical perceptions, which is similar to the fact that men have limited perceptual access to the physical realm. In the mathematical realm, all men are intuited of simple addition such as '1 + 1 = 2', but not the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus. Similarly, within in the physical realm, men can only see ordinary objects like trees, but not the exotic entities of science-electrons. Fourth, they claim that "mathematic is a priori, not empirical" (Brown, p13). Unlike in empirical knowledge, which is dependent upon the five physical senses, priori is independent from them. Priori, according to Platonist, is a physical-sense-independent mechanism that allows a person to experience mathematical objects through the "mind's eye" (Brown, p13). Fifth, they claim that although mathematics is a priori, it's not necessary certain. The...

Find Another Essay On Can Brown save Platonism this time?

A Retrospective on Rebirth Essay

1274 words - 5 pages between it and the Christian faith." (qtd. in Cassirer, Kristeller and Herman 186). This fusion of Platonism and Christian belief as stated above was a method to rationalizing and justifying the retrospective thought of Platonism at the time. Celenza explains that another principle of Ficino is that God is supreme to all; however, this God is not as negative and portrayed during early Christianity but one that is benevolent and imbues in humans the

asafas Essay

988 words - 4 pages mother. The tenth book explains the goal of this autobiography, which is to offer the way by which men can find God. He also explores the way of true prayer and finally analyses the necessity of a Mediator (Christ). In the eleventh book St. Augustine tries to comprehend the mysteries of creation. He studies Genesis 1:1, which talks about the creation of the world. He also makes an exquisite analysis of the subjectivity of time. In the twelfth book

Extra-Causalism and the Unity of Being

2281 words - 9 pages understandable, I want to argue that a genuinely scientific or naturalist or empiricist point of view, or set of commitments, does not require, or even significantly lean to, causalism. This large aim can only of course be intimated and sketched in the time available to me here, with, I hope, the beginnings of plausible argument in the direction of its realization. Notes (1) Daniel C. Dennett, Consciousness Explained. Boston: Little, Brown, 1991, p. 460.

The Influence of Neo-Platonism on Michelangelo throughout his carrer.

1861 words - 7 pages larger than they should be.Michelangelo disliked this trend in art, since this was an area where he felt no one can make fixed rules to where figures are looking the same every time. DÅrer relied on precise proportions in representing the human figure, and Michelangelo found his work uninteresting. For Michelangelo, the function of art was to represent ideal beauty. Michelangelo portrayed figures that are not engaged in any particular activity

Empiricism and Rationalism: Searching for God and Truth

890 words - 4 pages We live in a time where everyone is searching for a reason to believe in something, there have posters and advertisement stating that “Only Prayer Can Save America”. Well if prayer can save us then there is only one question left to be answered. Who are we praying to? What are we praying for? God is the almighty, the creator of everything and without him there would be no world and no us. But many people seem to question if He really exist. In

The Art of Rhetoric

664 words - 3 pages is necessarily relational and socially persuasive, imbued with ethical assumptions, and embodied in knowledge and beliefs. At times this awareness is either lost or left implicit, but by bringing this critical perspective to the historical trajectory, I situate distinct rhetorics of happiness. Content and Scope Aristotle’s assumption that language can be expressed with “clarity, correctness, and appropriateness” (Crowley) overlooks the

The Hero's Journey in Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown

1241 words - 5 pages the Hero's Journey and showing how he discovers that humans are truly evil by nature; therefore, altering his views of other humans and life itself. In the beginning of the story, Goodman Brown is faced with a decision to stay home with his wife another night or to take off on his journey. This parallels his psychological decision to leave behind all that he knew to be true up until that point and discover the truth no matter how harsh it may be

Baudelaire and Nietzsche.

805 words - 3 pages its boldness. He had some influence of the Romanticism, he is in the end of this period but his ideas of love, death were influence by it. He decides to become a poet which his mother rejects. The childhood marked by the loss of the father, the mother's love and his rejection of the stepfather, source of a depressive tendency he called "Spleen", anguish, emptiness that can only be overcome through poetic creation. "What I feel is a huge

Plato and The Renaissance

1843 words - 7 pages than Aristotle's, and promoted Platonism as Christianity's predecessor in right belief.8 It should not be assumed that Plato's philosophy was used only to augment other fields, however. The Renaissance essayist Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592 B.C.E) conceded that his era ultimately limited itself to a superficial knowledge of learning, and so turned to the classics for depth.9 The classics were already very popular at this time, so it can be

Aristotle on Substance, Matter, and Form

1583 words - 6 pages suggests that the primary substances of the Categories, the individual plants and animals, are, when analyzed, actually compounds of form and matter. And in the Metaphysics, Aristotle suggests that a compound cannot be a substance (Z3, 1029a30).3. This may seem a strange move for Aristotle to be making. But the idea may be this: a compound cannot be a basic ontological ingredient. Cf. these compounds:a brown horsea scholarEach of these is a compound


1414 words - 6 pages “Let me tell you why the Creator made this world. He was good, and the good can never have any jealousy of anything. And because he was free from jealousy, he desired all things to be as much like himself as they could possibly be” (Pittenger 101). Plato was a famous philosopher. His affect the world was great. Many things that people have been wondering about for years, such as life’s questions, were first written by Plato in his

Similar Essays

This Essay Has A Table Of How Many Watts Certain Electrical Appliances Use Up And How We Can Save Money And Enerygy In The Kitchen And So On.

602 words - 2 pages . This can save us up to 80 % in lighting running costs PLUS fluorescent lights last up to 8 times longer than regular (incandescent) bulbs,Ways of Saving Energy in the KitchenThere are a lot of different ways of saving energy in the kitchen. Some ways of doing this are;·Defrosting the your freezer when the ice is thick·Examining the fridge's magnetic door seal for any air leaks·Always filling jugs and kettles from the cold tap

A Film Can Be Entertaining And Deal With Serious Issues At The Same Time. How Is This Revealed In The Film 'whale Rider' Directed By Niki Caro?

1366 words - 5 pages leader to help save her Maori community. However, her position as a female means she can not be granted this opportunity and her potential is ignored. Women in this community were marginalised because of the strong existence of a patriarchal society however Pai marks a change in the traditional role of women in the Maori society. She possesses strong leadership qualities of strength, courage and intelligence, and one important scene in which these

The Debate Is Whether One Society Can Truly Have One Structure Of Power That Lasts Over Time And This Essay Will Agree With The Pluralists, That Power

2343 words - 10 pages Absract: The debate is whether one society can truly have one structure of power that lasts over time and this essay will agree with the pluralists, that power is ever-changing and elite domination can at best only be fleeting and temporary. However, this essay will also argue that this is not just down to the issue of power, but elite domination is also a flawed theory, in that history shows it fails in practice. It should be made clear that

Athanasius On God As Creator And Recreator

1567 words - 6 pages theology of Athanasius is essential to understanding who he was as a person. Athanasius was Greek; He was born in Alexandria to Christian parents. His theology is linked to Irenaeus and Bartholomew; we can see this in his use of Logos as Christ. Athanasius was the Athanasius dealt with the Arian Controversy, where he was able to develop his theology of the Trinity. His theology was developed with Athanasius' fourty-five years as bishop of Alexandria