Can Excellence Be Attained? Essay

1574 words - 6 pages

In Plato’s Meno, Socrates uses ignorance to prove excellence cannot be taught or even attained by human actions. The process involves Socrates purposefully contradicting himself to entice Meno’s focus. Through Socrates, Plato argues particular criteria cannot determine excellence within a collective. Instead, Socrates asserts excellence must be a universal quality and applicable to all individuals, by comparing the human collective to a bee colony. Socrates purposefully fails to use a universally applicable proof for shapes to define a square. All shapHis ignorance is used to inspire Meno’s review of the argument and develop a correct definition for excellence. For Meno’s benefit, Socrates contradicts his methods of deduction and proves excellence is divine. Plato employs Socratic irony to inspire a resolution to a problem by facilitating individual thought and input. As a result, Socrates’ ignorance is based on contradiction because contradiction entices review and the development of a correct resolution. Ultimately, Socrates’ methods entice Meno to assert that both knowledge and excellence are divine gifts or that both are attainable by humans.
Socrates argues excellence must be applicable to the collective because individual excellence is not universal. According to Meno, excellence is based “on our walk of life and our age” (Meno, pg 100, ln 71e-72a). Meno’s resolution that distinct excellences define different individuals reflects a folly in his logic because his inquiry was into a single definition of excellence. Meno’s failure to answer his own question correctly inspires Socrates to guide Meno by ignorance and inquiry to resolve the definition of excellence. Socrates states that “bees [are] all no different from one another, but the same” (Meno, pg 100, ln 72b). Socrates argues a bee colony is defined by a universal definition of excellence, despite the many characteristics and aspects of excellence. Therefore, excellence in human beings must be defined by a single universal definition. As a result, Meno should abandon his distinct definitions of excellence and consider a universal definition. Socratic irony forces Meno to develop his own ideas about the nature of excellence. In the argument, Meno agrees with all of Socrates postulations. This process illustrates how Socrates as a teacher guides Meno’s thoughts and argument without producing an answer. The ability to understand that excellence must be a single universally applicable quality is difficult to grasp without guidance. Socrates is aware of the many characteristics and aspects that shroud the definition of excellence. Like a good teacher, Socrates and his irony force Meno to deal with the complications surrounding a universally accepted definition of excellence. Socratic irony serves to entice Meno to do the work necessary to understand and define excellence. Socrates furthers his Meno’s teaching by contradicting his proof for a square.
Socrates proof for a square does not...

Find Another Essay On Can Excellence Be Attained?

Starting at State University Essay

538 words - 2 pages excellence and I accept nothing less. I hope to transfer to the University of Pittsburgh because I want to complete a bachelor’s degree in biology and unfortunately, the Community College is only a two-year institution. The University of Pittsburgh is an idyllic school for me because the prestige of the school is something to admire and the commute is minimal. I believe that at the University of Pittsburgh I can truly flourish as a student

Magnet Status in Hospitals Essay

1699 words - 7 pages list of requirements (Flores, 2007). Magnet status along with everything has its benefits along with its problems. This credential has been researched in depth, and some research feels that certain thing should be changed in order for magnet hospitals to be the best they can possible be. Lastly, there is no doubt that magnet status is of great value because of how it transforms hospitals from great to greater. What is Magnet Status? Magnet Status

An Application of Malcolm Baldridge Quality Principles

1207 words - 5 pages the Baldridge Performance Excellence Program, and summarizes how the program can help enhance the organization’s performance. The Baldridge Performance Excellence Program The Baldridge Performance Excellence Program originated with the passage of The Malcolm Baldridge National Quality Improvement Act of 1987 (“The Malcolm Baldridge,” 2010). The act, established in response to growing concerns over global competition in industries vital to the

Creating a Culture of Excellence Withing an Organization

2248 words - 9 pages the room, to effective communication, pain control, and much more. Creating a culture of excellences requires hospitals to be more attentive to the patients overall experience during their stay (Cliff, 2012). . With specific standards set for hospitals to ensure reimbursement and cliental it is of great value to create this type of culture. Creating this culture of excellence also requires a healthy work environment for staff which includes

My personal Goals

889 words - 4 pages later in the universities curriculum, but if I stick to my current academic plan I should be done with all of those courses in that time. My goal of attaining a Bachelor of Science in Information Technology can be attained in about two years if I stick with my current academic plan. Once I have attained my degree, I should then be able to accomplish my career goal of advancing in my current field or changing to the Information Technology career

Definition Essay - What is Wisdom?

619 words - 2 pages . This view, also known as "Philosophical Wisdom," is thought to be one of the highest attainable virtues. The Stoics, Greek and Roman philosophers, also had their own ideas about wisdom. To them, not only is wisdom a way of attaining human excellence, it also serves as a way to act according to one's personal ideals. Because attaining wisdom places the philosopher in an enlightened Nirvana-like state, however, it occasionally creates conflict

Three Styles of Learning

948 words - 4 pages ) Problem based learning allows you to break it down into segments and analyze each part individually. It allows you to take it step by step until you come to a possible solution. In the end learning can be attained in many different ways it is up to the individual to decide what is best for them. Conclusion In conclusion the fact that everyone learns differently is apparent. Although to optimize you learning ability or level you must

Popular Companies to Work for in California

594 words - 3 pages . Further information about the company can be obtained from their official website. Amgen AmgenAmgen is a committed health service provider that comprises advance tools and innovative therapeutics in an exclusive manner. Medicines introduced by Amgen has been effectively used for treating serious illness such as bone diseases, cancer, rheumatic arthritis, kidney failure and many other sickness. The company has its warehouses situated across USA

Nicomachean Ethics

1127 words - 5 pages types of courage are dismissed: political courage (where the dangers are in politics); experience (or what Socrates called knowledge), exemplifying that experience on the battlefield appears to be courage; next there is passion, which can be the driving force of courage; the sanguine, or those who think they are invincible; and finally, the ignorant. Thus, to be courageous is to “possess excellence to its entirety and the happier he is, the more

Philosophy of Education

1278 words - 5 pages Philosophy As Abigail Adams once said, “Learning is not attained by chance, it must be sought for with ardor and attained to with diligence.” Just as students learn with ardor and diligence, teaching is also a profession learned with ardor and diligence to achieve excellence as a teacher in today’s classroom. As I have grown up in a family thriving with teachers, I have seen both lessons taught and lessons learned. Children can offer

Special Populations Paper

1281 words - 5 pages Melena GillihanUniversity of PhoenixSpecial PopulationsSpecial populations refers to a group of individuals who can be described as people, who have disabilities, come from economically challenged families, single parents, displaced homemakers, and have educational barriers including limited English proficiencies (Texas Collaborative for Teaching Excellence, 2002-2003). In the human service field, special populations can mean a number of things

Similar Essays

The Title Is Empathy, And It Talks About How Different Characters And Alleviate Empathy From The Readers. The Conclusion Sums Up How Empathy Can Be Attained, And How It Can Ideally Be Doled Out.

2073 words - 8 pages . Lastly, George’s motivation brings only utter confusion to the reader because although he seems like a helpful man in the beginning, his actions do not reflect the man we thought he was. Steinbeck attempts to show us that people do not give out empathy equally, but they dole it out based on people’s actions and whether they are deserving of that empathy. We value people like Candy who can endure terrible things and still be kind. However

Hrm Case Essay

1159 words - 5 pages www.successnwellness.com Enrich your Mind, Unleash your potentials These are changing times. Yet in the middle of all the changes there is one thing that constantly determines success. Some call it leadership. But to my mind, it is the single-minded pursuit of excellence. Excellence endures and sustains. It goes beyond motivation into the realms of inspiration. Excellence can be as strong a uniting force as solid vision. Excellence does not

The Fine Arts Are Essential For The Attainment Of Human Excellence

1643 words - 7 pages the achievement of human excellence. The conclusion to draw, therefore, is that human excellence can be attained through the practice of philosophy. This deduction is to be drawn upon in the following text, and need be kept in mind from this time on. Earlier, however, it has been shown that art is helpful in doing philosophy. This is true, since it has been referred to numerous times as a focal practice. According to Strong and Higgs

Quality Management Organizations Essay

541 words - 2 pages Excellence, 2012). PiPEX does this with one goal in mind, to enhance the growth of jobs and economic prosperity in our region (Partners in Performance Excellence, 2012).The effect that these particular organizations can have on the quality performance of an organization can be substantial. Both the NIST and PiPEX can provide an organization with the knowledge and tools to exceed in their quality performance. Both the NIST and PiPEX use the Baldrige