Can Religion Justify Murder? Essay

974 words - 4 pages

If you take a minute to think about it, can you find anything that will justify murder? Some people can, and that is exactly what two brothers from Northern California did, they took the lives of two innocent men and justified it by hiding behind their religious beliefs. On July 1, 1999 Gary Matson and Winfield Mowder were killed by Matthew and Tyler Williams. The Williams brothers broke into the home of Matson and Mowder with the sole purpose of killing these two men because they were homosexual.While incarcerated, Matthew Williams reportedly told his mother, Sally Williams, "I had to obey God's law rather than man's law. I didn't want to do this. I felt I was supposed to...I have followed a higher law...I see a lot of parallels between this and a lot of other incidents in the Old Testament...They threw our Savior in jail...Our forefathers have been in prison a lot. Prophets...Christ...My brother and I are incarcerated for our work in cleansing a sick society...I just plan to defend myself from the Scriptures." ("Religion Gone Bad: Preface")These young men took it upon themselves to justify their actions by saying that what they had done was okay because the Bible told them so. Throughout history there have been many religious leaders who have used their own personal interpretations of various verses from the Bible to justify their personal agenda, but these two young men took that a step further than most people are comfortable with. Some examples of scriptures or sacred texts they were using can be found in both the Old and New Testaments.In the New Testament, Acts 5:17-29, you'll find a story about when the Apostles went to prison. In the middle of the night they were released by an angel of God and went to the temple and taught the people. When Peter and the apostles were found and brought before the council they responded "We must obey God rather than any human authority." (The New Oxford Annotated Bible)In the Old Testament, Genesis 19:1-13, you'll find a story about angels visiting the city of Sodom. Lot, being a man of God, invited them to stay with him. Late into the middle of the night, the men of the town came to Lot's house and wanted to "know" the angels, but Lot refused. The angels then told Lot to leave the city with his family "...For we are about to destroy this place, because the outcry against its people has become great before the Lord, and the Lord has sent us to destroy it." (The New Oxford Annotated Bible)In the Old Testament, Leviticus 20:13, it states "If a man lies with a male as with a woman, both of them have committed an abomination; they shall be put to death; their blood is upon them." (The New Oxford Annotated Bible)Matthew and his brother Tyler used these scriptures to symbolize their actions, saying that it was their personal...

Find Another Essay On Can Religion Justify Murder?

Against Capital Punishment Essay

1900 words - 8 pages carried out is the same. There are, even, many qualities of the death penalty that surpass the moral obscenity of a criminal act of murder. Where then is the difference between a murder and an execution? How can one form of murder be right and another be wrong? How can the same deed, carried out by two different people, be one time evil and another time divine? How, furthermore, can a morally adverse action promote the morality, let alone the

Chronicle of a Death Foretold, by Gabriel Garcia-Marquez

974 words - 4 pages in jail, but Pedro Vicario refused, and convinced his brother that they had nothing to repent" (95). That scene gives the reader a picture of how the twins viewed the killing as being above their religion, as if it is an even higher power. Marquez tries to explain that honor can be used as a way to justify an unjust or rash action. He satirizes the brothers' beliefs when he says they "stood by the thesis of homicide in legitimate defense

Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Gabriel Garcia Marquez

756 words - 3 pages . In his Chronicle, two brothers, Pablo and Pedro Vicario, arbitrarily murder a young man named Santiago Nasar. Marquez' presented conflict, however, is the reason that the brothers give to justify their crime: honor. Marquez' point is that societal values, such as honor, have become more important than the inherent good of human life. Marquez, though, does not openly portray this message; instead, he uses satirical literary devices. In this

Evaluate the view that religion acts as a conservative force on modern society

1243 words - 5 pages society.Marxism believes that religion acts as a conservative force on society, religion is one of the institutions which maintains the capitalist rule within society. Religion distorts reality by encouraging the belief that people are dependent upon supernatural beings or sacred powers. For example the belief that events are controlled by supernatural powers, this means that there is little people can do to change their situation, apart from

The Main Function of Religion According to Sociological Arguments

961 words - 4 pages is based on conflict and exploitation. Religion makes this society justify inequality and maintains ruling class domination. Karl Marx believed religion is a form of social “opium” which dulls oppressive pain and provides hope to the working class people who are being exploited. In Marx’s view religion is used by the ruling class to control the working class. This is done in many ways. One way is to make the working

knowledge and evidence

1624 words - 6 pages One definition of knowledge is true belief based on strong evidence. What makes evidence “strong” enough and how can this limit be established?      The making of knowledge is the process in which personal opinion is fortified by pragmatic evidence. It is to my belief that, evidence is a keystone in the justification of truth, because it is something solid and concrete. Significance of evidence is also magnified by

Comparing Christopher Marlow’s Doctor Faustus and William Shakespeare’s Macbeth

2490 words - 10 pages inner struggle as he contemplates murdering Duncan.  He imagines a bloody dagger, and uses this vision to justify his decision to murder the King, stating that the dagger “[marshals him] the way that [he] was going, and such an instrument I was to use” (2.1.43-44).  In addition, Macbeth’s hallucination of Banquo’s ghost is a representation of the guilt he feels after killing Banquo, but the image does not prevent Macbeth from continuing down his

Steppenwolf's Decision to Live

1266 words - 5 pages philosophically justify suicide by ending their existence. Consequently, only the soul of the man can decide the need for suicide.   The ultimate goal of the Steppenwolf is pure individuality. "Solitude is independence. It has been my wish and with the years I had attained it. It was cold. . . . wonderfully still and vast like the cold stillness of space in which the stars revolve" (The Steppenwolf. 37 ). The Steppenwolf yearns for the total

How Much Wood Could a Woodchuck Chuck

1261 words - 5 pages can clearly see the changing method of murder as you read further into the poem. The farmer began to slaughter individual woodchucks one at a time with a gun, instead of resorting to gassing many unknown victims with no sentimental value to him. Shooting an individual face-to-face is incredibly more personal and harder to do than gassing a crowd of people who you will not see being killed. The farmer is now able to justify why he is killing the

Socrates irrelgious or impious

1153 words - 5 pages . Euthyphro is prosecuting his own blood, his father to a murder; he justifies his indictment as a paradigm of piety/holiness (moral consideration). Euthyphro states that the violence between Zeus and Cronus is justifiable to the indictment upon his father. Socrates critiques his argument, the punishment will be distinct between gods because what was pleasing for Zeus was displeasing for Cronus; what is pious to one god can be impious to another

my cat

579 words - 2 pages Without religion human life would be meaninglessBy Marte DahlA life without religion is for someone very meaningless, but for some other it is not. Why should everyone one the earth has a religion they has to follow? Do we just need the belief for something that is better than us, and can "forgive" us when things not are right? and would not the earth look better without any religion? And why is it so bad to be gay? Think about the world history

Similar Essays

Is Religion A Justification For Fighting?

751 words - 3 pages looting is all justified and legal, as long as they are doing it for their religion, but in all other cases it's a crime against humanity. Religious beliefs and principles do not justify war, just because one-person states that God had told them to fight and fight they shall is conspicuously unintelligent. Warfare destroys lives, using religion, as an excuse to murder countless victims is a mind-boggling question because violence should not be

A Chronicle Of A Death Foretold By Gabriel Garcia Marquez.

1244 words - 5 pages A Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Gabriel-Garcia Marquez. The book "A Chronicle of a Death Foretold" by Gabriel-Garcia Marquez is about a murder in a small South American Village. It is based on an actual murder that took place in 1951 in the town of Sucre, Colombia. This novel provides a detailed insight to the culture of Latin America as it pertains to many aspects of an individuals life. Instances such as religion, marriage, death

Explore Two Characters' Different Responses To The Consequences Of Revenge: "Sleepers" By Lorenzo Carcaterra

720 words - 3 pages killed Nokes and gotten off the murder charge is remorseless about his actions. However it can be viewed that this could be very well related to his stay at the Wilkinson reformatory home. The reformatory home was aimed a doing just that: reforming people but for John this did not occur because of the continual abuse that he was subjected to: “it was a place of innocence ruled by corruption”. John, having been let down by the justice

The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished In America

1227 words - 5 pages . When governments execute criminals through the death penalty they demonstrate vengeance; hence leaving some in society to justify killing another through vengeance. This brutalization theory is evident in Joanna Shepherd’s analysis of the correlation between execution rates and the proceeding murder rates. Shepherd’s analysis concludes that “capital punishment increases murder in thirteen states […]” (Hood and Hoyle 342). Therefore, it can be