Can The European Court Of Human Rights Continue To Play A Meaningful Role In The Protection And Development Of Human Rights Across The Full Range

2414 words - 10 pages

2. Other developments and steps to overcome the crisis
Reforms aside, the Committee of Ministers continuously acknowledged the need to improve the protection of human rights by the help of the ECtHR. Shortly after Protocol 14 the Committee of Ministers of the CoE recalled „its mission to take measures in order to guarantee the long-term effectiveness of the control system instituted by the Convention (Council of Europe 2004)“. In this section some of the steps taken as well as issues that remain problematic will be highlighted.
Let us start with a more general debate about both nature and purpose of the European human rights system: As the overload of applications still poses one of the ...view middle of the document...

“ On the contrary proponents of the ‚individual justice‘ position argue that the right of individual petition is at the core of the Convention, its whole raison d’être allowing everyone of the 820 million inhabitants to bring before Court violations of human rights. A selective approach, critiques fear will thus call into question the Court’s legitimacy and will have political consequences due to the selective approach.
One important element which needs to be considered when referring to the Court’s effectiveness and impact is its influence on national legal systems, which is beyond any doubt quite impressive. Stone Sweet & Keller note that „the ECHR can be said to be effective, domestically, to the extent that national officials recognize, enforce, and give full effect to Convention rights and the interpretive authority of the Court, in their decisions (2008: 6).“ According to them no state can insulate itself from scope and influence the Convention undoubtedly inherits, as its rights possess supra-legislative status and thus bind national officials.
More specific critics however claim that the positive feedback loop or so called culture of compliance which so far induced states to implement ECtHR judgments would be in danger of stalling as „the Court has become more skilled at identifying systematic human rights violations, however, the delays in compliance by states responsible for those violations have lengthened and are becoming endemic in some countries (Helfer 2014).“ This bears the risk of creating a vicious circle in which „government officials point to public criticisms of the Court and compliance delays in other states to justify noncompliance in their own jurisdictions and to legitimize criticism of those who advocate for adherence to ECtHR rulings.“
While a number of core doctrines have so far guided the Court in its jurisprudence - objectivity, effectiveness, autonomy and evolutive interpretation - the interpretative tool has been found to be problematic in regards to the ECtHR and national legal orders. Relying on a passage in Tyrer v. United Kingdom, which inaugurated the Court's extensive use of this evolutive interpretation up to today, the ECtHR is supposed to be treated as living instrument, encompassing three elements: firstly present-day standards are guiding the Court, secondly an acceptance of these standards by the member states, and thirdly that the Court assigns decisive importance to what the member state at hands finds acceptable. This notion did not only have an influence on how the ECtHR itself, but also how member states and their supreme courts interpret the Convention, especially as they are required to respect its evolving standards (Letsas, 2012). Helfer (2014) however, stresses the need for caution „when expansively interpreting the Convention and fashioning remedies. This is not to suggest that the Court will abandon or significantly narrow the jurisprudential principles that it has so carefully developed....

Find Another Essay On Can the European Court of Human Rights continue to play a meaningful role in the protection and development of human rights across the full range

Corruption and its impact on the full enjoyment of human rights, in particular economic, social and cultural rights

4308 words - 17 pages IntroductionIn decision 2002/106 contained in document E/CN.4/2003/2, the Sub-Commission on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights, guided by the Charter of the United Nations and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime as well as other relevant human rights instruments, decided to entrust me with the task of preparing, without financial implications, a working paper on

The Origin, Development and Significance of Human Rights

9689 words - 39 pages announced elections approached, the government conducted a referendum on Nov. 30, 1980, on a new constitution that would have institutionalized the role of the armed forces in a "restricted democracy." The voters rejected this constitution.v USSRThe Helsinki Accords recognized as inviolable the post-war frontiers in Europe. In return the Soviet Union and its socialist allies had to concede that human rights in each European state were the legitimate

The Notion of Human Rights

1166 words - 5 pages , religious freedom and freedom from arbitrary arrest and imprisonment. These documents shifted the changed from "natural rights" to the notion of human rights (“Human Rights”). The popular idea of human rights led to drastic changes in the 19th century which can seen in the United States (“Human Rights”). There were many advances to a person's rights (“Human Rights”). These include the “abolishment of slavery, universal voting rights, the rise of trade

“The impact of Human Rights “

875 words - 4 pages countries multi-layered and intricately designed system of mass incarceration, which has proven to be highly successful. It is the goal of this paper to assert the idea that as a society we have the power to influence the cultural shift of shame and self-hatred with in persons who have been incarcerated. By acknowledging the human rights of African American men as it relates to the role they play in the development and stabilization of their

The Violation of Human Rights in Cuba

3442 words - 14 pages propaganda. Local city officials inhibit freedom of speech by monitoring and reporting dissent or criticism. (US State Dept.) Police and state security officials regularly harassed, threatened, and otherwise abused human rights advocates in public and private as a means of intimidation. (US State Dept.) A court in Holguin sentenced independent journalist Mario Gonzalez Castellanos, Cuba Press correspondent in Holguin, to 2 1/2 years in the Holguin

Human Rights in the Age of Discovery

784 words - 3 pages principles: all human beings have a fundamental right to be treated as free people, to defend their own status of independence, and to enjoy the right to work toward and to make peace and international unity. These principles instigated a dispute between Juan Gines de Sepulveda, the official defender of the monarch, and Vitoria based on the concept of a just war, or, in general, the concept of "justice" altogether when it comes to human rights

The Denial of Human Rights in Cuba

1633 words - 7 pages does not back its citizens civic rights. A fully functioning society provides its citizens with the right to free expression and a voice in their government. As stated by the Swedish president Olof Palme, “for us democracy is a question of human dignity. And human dignity is political freedom.” (Olof Palme). Olof Palme is implying that the freedom of opinion is a question of basic human rights and that it is not something the government can choose

Violation of Human Rights in "The Crucible"

689 words - 3 pages , and maybe the clearest, example to prove the point of violated human rights. This article says 'all are equal before the law and entitled without any discrimination to equal protection before the law. All are entitled to protection against any discrimination in violation this Declaration and against any incitement to such discrimination'. In the witch trials of Salem, it was perfectly clear that the twenty people that lost their lives were not

How Does English Law Give Effect to the Right to Marry and Found a Family as Guaranteed by Article 12 of the European Convention on Human Rights?


The Evolution of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Human Rights in Canada

2009 words - 8 pages Canadian Bill of Rights, the wording of the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, as well as several Supreme Court Cases concerning constitutional questions. Although a "mathematical" approach to equality may prove successful in a homogeneous society, in a heterogeneous society such as Canada, such an idea can restrict, if not violate, equality.ReferencesCanadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. (2009). In Wikipedia. Retrieved January 17

The Role of Immaturity in Human Development

581 words - 3 pages the human species possesses. The slow development of cognitive skills has led young children “to imitate a broad range of behaviors without the knowledge that their attempts are inadequate”(Bjorklund & Pellegrini, 2002, p.203). Unbeknownst to them, children continuously observe and experiment with new behaviors and practice old behaviors, which, in turn, improve their overall skills (motor or social). As the motor skills and cognitive abilities

Similar Essays

European Court Of Human Rights Essay

2357 words - 9 pages European Union as a possible consequence of the enlargement of the Council of Europe. The review of cases decided during the last three years belies that fear. Yet there is a risk in the longer term, a risk that can be avoided if the Court adheres to the role more "constitutional".3. CONCLUSIONEuropean political dualism explains why, during a certain period of European integration, the protection of fundamental rights was not explicit and

The International Criminal Court (Icc) And The Protection Of Human Rights In Africa

1589 words - 6 pages 2 Introduction This essay will discuss the successes and challenges faced by the International Criminal Court (ICC) in prosecuting human rights violations cases in Africa. The ICC has been recently put under the spotlight by the African Union when it called for non-cooperation by its member states not to comply with the warrant of arrests that had been issued by the ICC against some of the leaders in Africa. This has created difficulties when

Have The Courts Struck A Balance Between The Protection Of Individual Rights Under The Human Rights Act And Parliamentary Sovereignty?

2052 words - 8 pages legislation.My conclusion would be that the judges have played a mixed role in relation to the protection of human rights. Although they are given the power to interpret legislation under s.3, and to pass declarations of incompatibility under s.4, these powers have little legal consequence, as the main consequences are political. Also, any decision made by the courts will not invalidate legislation, and the court may still be forced to apply the

Can The Notion Of Human Rights Be Justified And In What Are Such Rights Grounded?

2709 words - 11 pages Can the notion of Human Rights be justified and in what are such rights grounded?"Human rights are a set of universal claims to safeguard human dignity from illegitimate coercion, typically enacted by state agents" (Brysk, 2002 p. 3). The notion of human rights is an important ideal in society and a cause of great debate these days. Rights limit the extent to which other humans can intrude on other individuals and groups and are a necessary