Is There A Moral Obligation To Obey The Law?

2788 words - 11 pages

'Must we only obey a just law; should we obey a law because it is just to do so; or else can we not obey at all?'The questions that shall be answered in this essay are 'Must we only obey a just law?', 'Should we obey a law because it is just to do so?' and 'Or else, can we not obey at all?'Before we can answer these questions it is important to establish what is meant by the term 'just'. 'Just' in this case means 'morally just', I think, but differences of opinion exist as to its meaning. For the purpose of this essay, I shall take 'just' to mean 'fair' in the way Rawls indicates when he writes about the veil of justice in 1971: the every-day-sense of the term the average person would agree about.Should we obey a law because it is just to do so?The first question I shall address is whether one should obey a law 'because it is just to do so'. Woozley in 1979 states: If political leaders and police chiefs had their way, all of us would believe that a powerful reason (possibly the principle, if not the only, reason) that we should obey a law is that it is a law. In fact, with the exception of a special class of laws, it is no reason at all.This is the core of discussion whether there is a general moral obligation to obey the law.This discussion started in the 1970's in the United States. The background to it was the civil rights movement in the United States, and the Vietnam War with its political scandals. People who disagreed with the governments' policies started arguing that sometimes, a citizen is justified in acting illegally.The question is: does a citizen have a moral duty to obey the law and if so, why?In the writings of Honoré, Raz, Smith, Finnis and Bix there are many arguments for and against a general moral obligation to obey. Often, they take each other's ideas as a basis and develop or counter argue them.I shall give a synopsis of five arguments in favour of a general moral obligation to obey, and give my own and theorists' counterarguments. More arguments in favour and against a general moral obligation to obey the law exist than these five, but I shall take those that are clearest and mentioned most often.BENEFIT OR GRATITUDEThe first argument in favour of a general moral obligation to obey the law is provided by ... the Greek philosopher Plato and is known as the benefit or gratitude argument.It is the idea that for those who receive substantial benefits from the state it is immoral not to respond with the small obligation government asks in return namely to obey the law.Indeed, almost all citizens of a country, even when undemocratic, receive benefits from the state. These can be police protection, free education or social benefits, but also simpler things as the provision of roads, electricity, or water.If the benefits are considered 'substantial', they imply a moral obligation to obey the government's laws as an expression of gratitude.Although there are many ways to counter argue this argument, it is perhaps natural the...

Find Another Essay On Is there a moral obligation to obey the law?

Is There a Moral Case for Socialism?

2570 words - 10 pages is a crop or a technological invention? The government is merely a collection of individuals, not unlike the producer, placed in a position of mediation. Under what moral obligation can a collection of individuals own that which they did not produce? There is no divinity in any person in an equal and moral state.The majority of people work to pay for food, water, and shelter in addition to extra comforts. It has been illustrated by the attempted

Our Moral Obligation to Protect Animals

879 words - 4 pages There is mistaken belief that animals used for experimental research are protected through the presence of ethics committees, the Prevention of cruelty to animals act and the code of practice. There is also individual understanding that it is "only" rats and mice that are being used. Of course we know that neither of these is true. What the general public are completely unaware of is that all sorts of animals not limited to rats and mice are

Obligation to the Poor

988 words - 4 pages the steps to improve our society. Improving moral judgments strengthens bonds between close relatives and friends, a love for careers, and passion for our pastimes. At the end of ones life, the ability to look back on their virtuous life shows they have achieved eudemonia. In addition to this, care is an essential principle to living. Betterment of an individual allows them to distinguish right from wrong. Their ability to live in

The Ethics of Belief by William Clifford: The Moral Obligation to Justify Your Beliefs

794 words - 4 pages important because even the smallest beliefs affect others in the community, add to the global belief system, and alter the believer moral compass in future decisions. Clifford believes that it is a moral requirement that beliefs are justified in order to minimize the chance that an incorrect belief will affect other people. In the case of the ship-owner, who sent out his old emigrant ship based solely on the fact that he was able to suppress

According to Socrates, Should you Obey an Unjust Law?

685 words - 3 pages Q: “According to Socrates, should you obey an unjust law?” Convicted For Living? Do we have an obligation to obey any law, no matter how unjust or evil, provided only that it is in fact a valid rule of the legal system in which we happen to be physically located? In the following composition, I am going to examine the answer to this question in accordance to what Socrates believes. The best way to understand this almost “WWSD” (What Would

It is our moral responsibility to Question God's existence and if there is a God, would he want us to use our reason

771 words - 3 pages stable belief. Although some may claim that it is wrong to question or doubt the existence of God, we are morally responsible to seek evidence for our beliefs.To question whether or not there is a god means being open to the possibilities of a god or gods, but also to the possibility that there may not be any gods at all. If you assume ahead of time that there must be a god and set out to find evidence, you are not questioning, but skipping over

Is there a Solution to Date Rape?

1491 words - 6 pages to obtain sexual pleasure without being raped. There are several arguments against this myth found on page 457 of Pineau’s essay. The sexual provocative behavior of a woman does not provide a contract of consent. Both women and men are not sexually pleased with a lack of communication. Another argument is that men can actually display moral behavior in these situations. The last is that women are not entitled to be sexually provocative, therefore

Is it the government's obligation to ensure and protect every citizen's pursuit of happiness?

733 words - 3 pages government does not do enough to ensure their personal happiness. The government is only responsible for happiness in our lives to a certain extent. Pursuit of happiness is sought by an individual, it is merely protected by the government. The government doesn't have the obligation to help criminals and terrorists pursue happiness, but law-abiding citizens should be entitled to this protection.Our Founding Fathers strongly believed that the government

How plausible is the claim that there is no moral justification for warfare?

1149 words - 5 pages other governments had foreseen what the Nazis would do, they would probably have been right to invade Germany to remove Hitler in the early 1930's. This would have avoided far worse calamities that actually took place.Another subject to be considered, once a war is underway, is are there any moral restrictions on the numbers or kinds of deaths that may be brought about in pursuit of victory?"Killing must be necessary for a military objective

Moral Law According To Kant

553 words - 2 pages . Most significantly, Kant renounces happiness as the principle of morality because it obliterates the specific difference between virtue and vices.      Universality is the form of a moral law whereby all rational beings are subject to the same condition as the basis of morality. Kant argues that there can be principles for action that do not admit of exceptions, and that this occurs through practical reason. In other words, the possibility for

Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God

1058 words - 4 pages Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God Rational: To be rational is to think logically and within reason. To base your thoughts on evidence, and then use that evidence to come to a "rational" conclusion. Motivation: To be motivated to do or think something, normally the motivation will be because it will benefit you in the long run. Many philosophers use theses types of words when

Similar Essays

Our Duty To Obey The Law

1038 words - 5 pages view can be substantiated by a simple logic explained in Law as a moral Judgement that explains the idea of an essential moral requirement being a prerequisite for a law to be called such under the natural law system. This however is contrasted by H.A Hart (minimum content of natural law) that accepts the role morals play, but does not admit that morals are an essential requirement of law. WHY DO WE OBEY THE LAW? Although there may be various

The United States Has A Moral Obligation To Mitigate International Conflicts

688 words - 3 pages chemical gasses more than 20 times. It is estimated that between 500,000 and 1,000,000 men, women, and children died in the attacks.Our Contentions are...1) The United States has a moral obligation to reduce human suffering in countries outside the U.S.2) Because the U.S. remains the strongest country in the world, we therefore have the right and moral obligation to help nations that aren't as fortunate.3) The U.S. enforces international peace by

Wealthy Nations Have A Moral Obligation To Educate Poor Nations

3669 words - 15 pages do think it is helpful to give such an argument for two reasons. First, simply recognizing that there is a moral obligation to fulfill leaves many crucial issues untouched. The majority of the relevant work consists of designing and implementing programs of assistance that fulfill the moral obligations which are recognized. Making clear the nature and motivation of obligations informs the choices made in designing and implementing meaningful

Can A Free Person Ever Obey The Law? Jurisprudence Essay

1182 words - 5 pages impeding the primacy of reason and autonomy.[footnoteRef:4] Thus, he comes to the conclusion that authority is incompatible with autonomy, meaning all authority is illegitimate and there exists no obligation to obey it. According to Wolff, one can come to the same conclusion to that of the law, however one has a moral obligation to come to that conclusion autonomously.[footnoteRef:5] [1: Robert Paul Wolff ‘In Defense of Anarchism’ (1970).] [2