Can Virtue Be Taught? Essay

555 words - 2 pages

lthough today's society includes much technology and new things are supposedly being discovered every day, many age old questions still remain unanswered; questions such as: "Can virtue be taught?" This question is examined in detail throughout Plato's Meno, and although the play leaves the question as to what virtue is unanswered, Socrates attempts an answer to Meno's question. Although he is not particularly keen on answering whether virtue can be taught without first having a complete understanding of what virtue is, he attempts to please Meno by solving this in the way that geometers conduct their investigations, through a hypothesis. Socrates states that if indeed virtue can be taught then one thing will happen, and if it cannot a different thing will happen. In the end of the play, the conclusion is reached that virtue is a gift from the gods. Now the question must be asked: how was this conclusion reached in relationship to Socrates' previous hypothesis?

It is thought by Meno that men cannot be taught anything but knowledge, therefore, virtue must be a kind of knowledge in order to be taught. This corresponds with the hypothesis because the conclusion can be reached that, if virtue is knowledge then it can be taught, but if it is not knowledge then it is impossible to teach. However, this leads to a new question that must be answered before a conclusion can be reached: is virtue knowledge? It is later stated that, if knowledge includes all aspects of reality, virtue would then be knowledge. On the other hand, if virtue is good, and there is anything good...

Find Another Essay On Can virtue be taught?

'Eighteenth century literature is united in its common concern with the meaning of virtue in a changing world.' Statements relevance to Pope's 'The Rape of the Lock' and Richardson's 'Pamela'

2408 words - 10 pages Pope's The Rape of the Lock and Richardson's Pamela are apt for comparison in that they both deal with exposing the upper class for having a lack of virtue. Pope's parody is to show up his social peers by bringing to light their vanity and lack of concern for morals. Pamela, on the other hand was originally written to educate the lower classes, which obviously impacts on its handling of virtue.On a more subtle level, Pamela can be compared to

Plato’s Theory of “Recollection” Essay

1678 words - 7 pages , in Meno, the discussion between Socrates and Meno about virtue is the most representative example of Socrates’s pursuit of true knowledge. In Meno, it begins a discussion with the question “can virtue be taught?” Socrates has a different way thinking about questions. He believes that before discussing “can virtue be taught?” The first question is “what virtue is?” Because if people do not know what virtue is, it is impossible to discuss “how

A Scrutiny of Subservient Collapse

955 words - 4 pages knowledge that enhances her virtue and become a freewill independent individual. It did not mean women have to gain the same power as men do. However, women should be taught equally and counted as a virtue as men do and also valued equally. Under certain circumstances, women may face financial problems that equal learning opportunity can strengthen women’s financial independence. If Franco and Pizon were learned under Wollstonecraft’s ideal

Comparing Virtue and Vice in Utopia, The Bible, and Othello

881 words - 4 pages narratives of Genesis, "Utopia," and Othello" all exemplify the achievements and victories of virtuous characters or traits. The failures and miseries inherently connected with vices are also presented. These literary works corroborate Sir Philip’s claim that poetry presents virtue in a light so "that one must needs be enamored of her." It can be assumed, therefore, that the study of literary works such as these can only improve morals and virtues, and for the good of American society, all students should major in Literature.

Primary Goal Of Government

892 words - 4 pages historical precedences showing how they support his inturpretation of human nature. This makes his argeuments even stronger and lends considerable creadence to his ideas. However, his seemingly casual dismissal of morality, justice and virtue make his ideas repugnent to anyone who believes mankind can ever be more than an opportunistic, materialistic, creature interested only in the satisfaction of individual desires.One of the most contimplated themes


900 words - 4 pages capacity to become wise and ethically virtuous, and therefore, practice is required. In order to develop virtue in character and understand the mean of it, reason is the main key since reason is connected to virtue. To achieve ethical virtues one must develop proper habitats during childhood, and then wisdom must be acquired when reason is finally developed. This does not mean that one can do whatever it was told to be ethically virtuous; it still

Aristotle's Argument for People's Actions

654 words - 3 pages . He argues that happiness is an activity of the soul in accordance with perfect virtue. This cannot be true, because if one, at anytime, acts outside of perfect virtue than he has undermined the whole "activity." Aristotle argues that happiness is not found in amusement for it is too incongruous to end in amusement, and that our efforts and sufferings would be aimed at amusing ourselves. I argue that happiness can be found in amusement. When

The Alternative View To Virtue Ethics

1093 words - 4 pages the formation of character. As another example, consider that virtue theories often suggest that long lists of rules are impractical and that there is great simplicity or moral economy in offering a virtue-imperative. We might be told that "Love your wife!" requires much more of us than "Don't commit adultery, and spend time talking with your wife, and take your wife out on dates from time to time", etc., suggesting that

Positve Psychology and Aristotle's Virtue Ethics Converge

1627 words - 7 pages ideas presented by Aristotle in Nichomachean Ethics. The basic premise of each theory is the attainment of “true happiness” described as eudemonia, which can be accomplished through the exercise of virtue. Aristotle’s theory, as well as, the ideas presented by positive psychology primarily relies on the employment of virtue in order to obtain eudemonia though Aristotle does not denote specific character strengths associated with the virtues

Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle

1510 words - 6 pages , he believed that we are taught the values and beliefs of society as a whole, and it is necessary to maintain a balance of the positive as well as the negative, for too much positive is unnecessary excess, it is necessary to learn from both the good and the bad in life. Only once a person can find the balance, it will be then that they achieve virtue, and only then will they be free. The Greek philosopher was assured that though the chase for

Virtue of Aristotelian Ethics

3683 words - 15 pages ;mer was certainly not considered a good German at the time of his execution. Does that mean he was not virtuous?[11: Robinson, Timothy. Aristotle in Outline, Hackett, 1995, p. 64]The subjective nature of virtue can also be problematic on a personal level. If someone individually decides that spending two hours a day looking in the mirror is the mean between excessive humility and vanity, have they really achieved a proper balance relative to them

Similar Essays

Can Ethics Be Taught? Essay

1594 words - 6 pages Guide to professional ethics’ was published which contains a number of different principles in order to govern the behaviour of accountants and also to identify and reduce the greatest areas of risk with respect to unethical behaviour. How does a person form their set of morals? Ethical programming had been left out of the Professional Accounting syllabus due to the argument of whether or not ethics can be taught. Each individual creates

Platos Meno Essay

803 words - 3 pages The dialogue opens up with Meno asking what virtue is and whether it could be taught. Socrates asks Meno for a general definition of virtue, since as Socrates points out, we cannot figure out if virtue can be taught if we do not have a clear idea what it is. Socrates is looking for a general, or formal definition of virtue, not just examples or instances of it. Socrates wants to know what all the examples of virtue have in common. He wants to

Meno: Plato Essay

825 words - 3 pages "Socrates, can virtue be taught?"1 The dialogue begins with Meno asking Socrates whether virtue can be taught. At the end of the Meno (86d-100b), Socrates attempts to answer the question. This question is prior to the division between opinion and knowledge and provides to unsettle both. Anytus participated in Socrates and Meno conversation about virtue. Socrates claims that if virtue is a kind of knowledge, then it can be learned. If it is

How Dose Socrates Prove “Virtue Is Knowledge”

1030 words - 4 pages In this paper, I will investigate the logical progress of Socrates’s proof “virtue is knowledge”. The reason why Socrates shows Meno how to prove “virtue is knowledge”, is because it can answer Meno’s question “can virtue be taught”, if virtue is knowledge, thus it can be taught. In brief, first Socrates proves someone who has virtue, knows what is good, then he proves someone who knows what is good, has virtue. Therefore, virtue is knowledge. I