Can We Say That The Selection Of The Best And Able And Then Educating Them To Become True Leaders Is Better Than Popular Vote To Choose Leaders?

1580 words - 7 pages

Before trying to answer this question, let me first talk about Plato’s principle of specialization and why he was against popular vote.
This paper will show that popular vote is better than the selection of the best and ablest for a position of a leader
In Plato’s just society, people should be selected for a particular work or duty in their early childhood and be trained to perform that work or duty. According to the principle of specialization, people of the state are divided into three categories: these are producers, guardians, and rulers. Everybody does their work and it is not allowed to them to interfere in works of others. As Plato says,” we should select for governing position people who showed themselves as courageous and curious in their childhood, as these are the main characteristics that leaders are required to possess” (укажи источник высказывания).So, they are educated to become the governors of the state since their childhood. He explains why people are to be selected in their childhood by saying, “That is the time when they are easily molded and when any impression we choose to make leaves a permanent mark.” (Republic. Book2. Part 3, Passage 377b). Plato claims that people in that young age are most sensitive and susceptible to the environment around them, and we can make from them whoever we want. But when a person has grown up and got more experience in life, it is extremely hard, even impossible, to change his or her personality. Plato claims that it is the reason why people must be selected when they are young .
We can find here the main weaknesses of his argumentation. As we know, all people develop differently, their abilities and characteristics develop differently, and evolve in various ways. The characteristics that were not seen in the childhood can become noticeable when a person is a little bit older. There is likelihood of underestimating or overestimating a person’s abilities in their childhood. It does not help to establish a good state. What is more, I think it seems unjust, because it deprives most people of rights to build their own lives, because everything is predetermined for them. Plato neglects people’s ability of self-growth and self-development.
Plato strongly opposes the popular vote in choosing leaders. He is against people’s participation in making and changing laws. Laws must be made and changed by selected few people who were educated to lead the state. Plato mistrusts people’s ability to reason and think unless they are taught so. He does not approve the opinion of the majority, because their decisions are not based on reasons and knowledge, but on a whim. The reason why Plato comes to strongly oppose the popular vote is that his teacher Socrates was put to death in the result of the popular vote. Plato was deeply convinced that Socrates was accused unjustly. Socrates, in Plato’s opinion, was promoting the enlightenment, but the Athenians did not like it and wrongly condemned him. It...

Find Another Essay On Can we say that the selection of the best and able and then educating them to become true leaders is better than popular vote to choose leaders?

How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from its foundation?

1361 words - 5 pages How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from its foundation ?In November 1918, the first republic is declared in Germany. It is however unable to survive, and only 25 years later replaced by the dictatorship of Hitler. Indeed, the democrats lacked legitimacy right from the start. Directly after the war, army generals blamed the SPD as "November Criminals", accusing them of having betrayed the German people by signing the

"How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from it's foundation?"

2034 words - 8 pages entity would have had to sign the treaty that was asked for. Indeed there also seemed to have been important actions taken against the Weimar by this group but only one can be severly highlighted, this being the "Kapp Putch" of 1920. The Freikorps backed the operation and since the military had almost become a self-governing organization there was nobody to stop it from occurring and ending in short-lived success. It was only the SPD

What Causes the Algae called Pseudo-nitzschialgal to Blooms and How We Can Prevent Them?

864 words - 4 pages Algal Blooms and Their Effects Over the past years, due to warming waters, a toxic kind of algae called Pseudo-nitzschia has been blooming. This toxic algae affects sea life, especially marine mammals such as sea lions, which die of brain disease after feeding on this algae. This research paper will provide the reader with a conclusion in respect to what causes algal blooms and how we can prevent them. Pseudo-nitzschia is a type of algae that

How far it is true to say that World War II was the result of Hitler's aggressive policies?

1360 words - 5 pages , but mainly- their declaration of war.The origins of the Second World War however lay in a rather complex mix of causes rather then something as straightforward as the appeasement policy or the hostility caused by competition of empires. To find the true causes we must combine most of the views outlined by Overy, Taylor and Churchill.It was mostly the nature of the German nation that enabled other issues such as imperialism to come into effect

Secrets. We Have Them, We Hide Them, but Can We Live With Them? Refers to "The scarlet letter" by Hawthorne

951 words - 4 pages Secrets. We Have Them, We Hide Them, but Can We Live With Them?Deception is defined by Webster's Dictionary as the art of misrepresentation. Throughout the history of mankind, the use of deception to promote oneself to a higher level, or to hide one's past, has been a common occurrence. In the novel The Scarlet Letter, by Nathaniel Hawthorne , Chillingworth and Dimmesdale both use deception to hide secrets from each other, and from the rest of

Organizational Culture How Do We As Leaders Change An Environment That Appears To Be Detrimental To Allowing Our Soldiers To "Be All They Can Be"?

1031 words - 5 pages Organizational CultureHow do we as leaders change an environment that appears to be detrimental to allowing our soldiers to "be all they can be"? Making policies, issuing directives and establishing doctrine attempt to attack the issue, but what we really want to do is change the way the Army thinks. We want to change the Amy's culture. Organizational researcher Edgar Schein points out that an organization's culture is a pattern of assumptions

To what extent were Stalin’s methods in removing opposition more effective than the Tsarist and other Communist leaders between the years 1855 t

895 words - 4 pages the institution more than Lenin because Lenin stepped away from the institutions of terror and Stalin was more involved in it indicating that it was more effective in Stalin’s regime. This is evident because in Lenin’s regime the cheka had executed 844 people from December to July, which compares nothing to Stalin as he had killed 1 million to 1.5 million over four months. As well as that, Service argues that there were 12,733 prisoners killed by

Team Dynamics. Good leaders are made not born. If you have the desire and will power, you can become an effective leader

898 words - 4 pages Team Dynamics.Good leaders are made not born. If you have the desire and will power, you can become an effective leader. Good leaders develop through an ever-constant process of self study, education, training, and experience. This comes in very handy when dealing with teams due to the fact that the leadership hat is going to change according to each member's region of proficiency. The leader isn't necessarily going to issue instructions

Can We Say "NO" To Recycling

2448 words - 10 pages -efficient, not time consuming, and a better quality of products, this would be like a dream come true. Recycling should be cost-efficient because what all nations are facing are massive economical problems. Financing these programs is one hell of a job and if it has to be done anyway, then we should at least look for ways to make it cost efficient. People should learn to use and reuse, rather than use and dispose. If we can use things more than

Can We Say NO To Recycling

2418 words - 10 pages Can We Say "NO" To Recycling Lately the earth’s capacity to tolerate exploitation and absorb solid wastes disposal has diminished, due to excess trashing. People dispose lots of stuff, and simply do not care. Therefore scientists found out a way to reuse things and that process was called "recycling". This new approach seemed quite successful at the beginning, until its true identity appeared. Recycling first started as man’s best friend

Essay on Machiavelli's, The Prince: How it is better to be a leader that is feared and not hated, rather than loved

1851 words - 7 pages of how things ought to be, and to use reality to form a dream of something different that we believe would be better than the current state of affairs. Dreams though can not be actualized without action, and all the discussion in the world will accomplish nothing if everyone sits idly by. We all want peace, and in order to have peace there must be structure and in order to have structure you must have an effective leader that you trust to design

Similar Essays

Is It True To Say That The Soldiers In The Trenches Of Wwi Experienced Boredom, Brutality And Comradeship?

2584 words - 10 pages actions and feelings that propelled them above and beyond the call of duty, and far beyond what they ever would have thought themselves capable of.From the accounts of the war that survive it seems impossible to describe or even imagine what the experience must have been like without having been there. Indeed, veterans of the First World War have said it is not possible to properly tell of the true horror that the war was, and certainly not to imagine what it must have been like. The fact that they say this alone magnifies the dark visions that one thinks up tenfold, and still they are probably not quite gruesome enough.

"Afghanistan" This Essay Is About The History Of Events That Has Happened In Afghanistan, And About The Past To Present Leaders

1200 words - 5 pages -American slogans in front of the United States embassy. President Daoud ordered the arrest of seven top PDPA leaders. The PDPA Central committee member Hafizullah Amin was placed under house arrest shortly. He planed a coup d'etat. PDPA leaders were liberated from a government prison. The plan for the April coup, according to Amin in a press conference that it had occurred two years ahead of the PDPA's schedule for revolution.Taraki, Amin, and

Images Of Women In Advertising; Its Impact On Social Perceptions Of Beauty And Body Image Idealisms, And The Extents To Which We Go To Become Them

2482 words - 10 pages amount of power over the everyday woman who spends her life chasing an ideal, which does not exist, often leading to psychological and physical effects which can last a lifetime. In a world of social media, the influence of advertising is much stronger than it once was, as it is a form of social communication that influences and often manipulates us. Advertising is everywhere from the photo on the front of a magazine, to the online ads that appear

Creative In Leadership And The Importance That Leaders Have Creativity

1937 words - 8 pages gifts and not by what we earn." If Keillor is accurate, then it is true that notable leaders have come full circle with their gifts and have been able to share their gifts with others. Moreover, these leaders should give us openings to recognize, acknowledge, and share memories of the gifts that we so contentedly received in our own lives. In doing so, we can find out new things about ourselves. In the end we can share our gifts and shed a quantity