Canada And Quebec's Conflict Essay

2581 words - 10 pages

Canada and Quebec's Conflict

Canada and Quebec have always been in conflict from the confederation of 1867 to the Supreme court judgement on the secession of Quebec in 1998. Quebec faces several challenges in terms of constitutional relations with the rest of Canada. Quebec is seeking a special status to preserve and protect its culture and language, while the rest of English-speaking Canada accepts the view of provincial equality. There have been attempts to recognize Quebec's concerns through constitutional amendments, but these attempts have not lived up to Quebec's expectations and for the most parts have failed. Quebec has threatened Canada throughout history with separation from Canada. These threats have not been ignored, the rest of Canada realizes the devastating impact economically and politically if Quebec did separate but they cannot reach a compromise. Canada has as tried to encourage Quebec not to separate from Canada. In 1995 Quebec held its second referendum on sovereignly and the separatists narrowly lost the province wide. The province brought the case to the Supreme court of Canada to rule on the legal guidelines of unilateral secession under Canadian and international law, in the end some say the federalists (those not wanting to separate) came out on top. In this essay I will discuss the various historical attempts made by government to keep Quebec a part of Canada. I will also attempt to explain the impact of the Supreme Court Ruling on the Quebec secession. Many argue that the federalist won in the decision but that statement is debatable. Both Quebec and the rest of Canada won in the ruling. I believe that English Canadians should spend some time getting to know their French neighbors and vice versa. Lets get started with the never ending tale of Quebec quest for sovereignty. Quebec is Canada only French speaking province. The conflict Canada and Quebec's search for sovereignty started in the early days of American settlement. In the 1800s the united colonies of Canada, Canada east (French speaking) and Canada west ( English speaking) was in constitutional deadlock. The only way out of this deadlock was to separate or to bring more colonies into confederation.
There was much immigration into both Canada east and Canada west, these new immigrants were primarily English which added to the problem of linguistics groups. As Canada east grew in population "it remained tied to Canada east by a constitution that shared power equally between the two." The arrangement was becoming ever more difficult because of the difference in sizes and political power between the two Canada. English speakers called for "representation by population, in other words, each group of people deserved political power that was equivalent to its proportion to the population." While the French language survived, it had gone from majority to minority of the population due to immigration.
The confederation agreement of 1867, which included...

Find Another Essay On Canada and Quebec's Conflict

Must Every Nation Have Their Own State if They Want One?

982 words - 4 pages disbanded after Quebec’s release from Canada’s sovereignty. That never happened. Now Canada is trapped with a political party who is full with ideology of Québec protectionism and to advance its own sovereignty. Quebec’s stance on its sovereignty is its unique culture and francophone speaking majority. They feel that Quebec's economically, politically and socially the development of Quebec would be halted by the interest of English Speaking Canadians

Negative affects on Terrorism Essay

1279 words - 5 pages in 1995. This referendum consisted partially because of Quebec's demands for distinct society status. On October 30th the citizens of Quebec decided to stay with Canada by a mere 1.4 percent. The Quebec referendum is factual evidence that Canada is not a multicultural society that maintains specific social order. Problems are growing and mistakes are being made for many minority groups (Tepperman 1997). In 2000, over 11 million (37 percent) of

Quebec Nationalism The question of whether Quebec will secede from Canada to become an independent nation has been a hot topic in the country for several years now.

1646 words - 7 pages inequalities in personal incomes. Despite all of this, many feel that this is not the reason for Quebec secession.Quebec has 24 percent of the total population of Canada, and 25 percent of its Gross National Product. The majority of Quebec's population is of French descent and language. It reaches approximately 83 percent of the entire province. About 60 percent of the French voted for secession in the 1995 referendum, at a remarkably high turn out, 94


2114 words - 8 pages Quebec's sovereignty regarding economic factors, political structure, and constitutional issues will be of great importance. Whether emotional issues will play a major role in decision making is subjective; however, it is fair to say that it will be an emotionally charged event and it could either tear apart the ROC or fuse it together. Placing emphasis on investigating what keeps Canada together is perhaps the key to Canada's future, and salvaging a

A Comparison of Quebec to the Rest of Canada

1652 words - 7 pages Quebec’s social identity and defining characteristics contradict and conflict with those of rest of Canada. Since the genesis of our country, the political, social disagreements, and tensions between Quebec and the rest of Canada have been unavoidable. Utilizing Hiller’s key contradictions in the analysis of a Canadian society, we will compare and contrast the nature of the societal identity in Quebec compared to that of rest of Canada

A Critical Review of Peter H. Russell's Essay "Can the Canadians be a Sovereign People?"

1075 words - 4 pages public pressure. This rejection sent Canada into "the first of five rounds of what I refer to as macro-constitutional politics". The first round, according to Russell, starts with the rejection of the Fulton-Favreau formula and ends with Quebec Premier Robert Bourassa's rejection of Pierre Trudeau's Victoria Charter. The second round began in 1976 with Quebec's desired independence from Canada. Constitutional change seemed imminent at this point

Quiet Revolution

1045 words - 4 pages Yes or No, What Will it Be?Coined by an anonymous writer in the Globe and Mail, the "Quiet Revolution" was a period spanning throughout 1960 into 1966 in which Quebec spearheaded a movement throughout Canada of radical social, political and cultural change. Quebec's outlook plummeted from one of a religious viewpoint right into one of a secular perspective. All the traditionalism of before was replaced by an increasingly liberal attitude towards

The History of the Quebec Francophones and the Attempts Made to Accommodate Their Concerns

2150 words - 9 pages The History of the Quebec Francophones and the Attempts Made to Accommodate Their Concerns The merging of two separate and distinct groups is what has given Canada its unique cultural identity. While some early politicians believed assimilation was the best approach to building a strong Canada, it became increasing difficult to convince the Quebec francophones that a national identity should take precedence over retaining their unique

The Sponsorship Scandal

2386 words - 10 pages on sovereignty, and soon after Mr. Parizeau's win, he delivered on his party's promise. The 1995 Quebec referendum took place on October 30th, and the motion to pursue Quebec's independence was defeated by an extremely small margin; 50.58% voting "No" to 49.42% voting "Yes". Though the people of Québec voted, by the narrowest of margins, to remain Canadians, the referendum provoked questions about Canadian identity and Quebec's place in

Pierre Elliot Trudeau: Great Canadian Prime Minister?

1435 words - 6 pages , his vision for a 'Just Society' reshaped our Nation. Trudeau became a great Canadian Prime Minister through the ways he dealt with Canada's bilingualism, Quebec's thoughts of separatism, the renewal of Canada's sovereignty, the rights of individuals in our nation, and his never-ending love for Canada.What language do we speak? What language would a person who was born in Quebec speak? Obviously we all know that Canada is a bilingual country. Yet

French language in Quebec: still under threat

2116 words - 9 pages language, and the debate between the French and English language in Quebec. • Conrick, M. (2006). The challenges of linguistic duality for francophone Canada: contact, conflict and continuity. International Journal Of Francophone Studies, 9(3), 311-328. doi:10.1386/ijfs.9.3.311_1 This source is from an article which talks about the challenges of dual languages of Canada and Quebec, which will be useful for the identification of threats to

Similar Essays

Geopolitical Conflict In French Canada Essay

954 words - 4 pages Quebec's seven million people speak English. This cause many businesses to move elsewhere, but more importantly, Quebec's liberties caused other provinces to question the use of French in their territory. They also engendered confusion and conflict between Canada and Quebec and the various indigenous societies in Canada. These peoples expected the same treatment as Quebec, as a distinct society. The conflict however went unsolved because the

Thoughout The 20th Century, Relations Between French Canadians, And English Canadian's Had An Negative Impact On Canada

1514 words - 6 pages again disrupt the nation's unity.Indeed, the arrival of the next conflict that split the French and the English in Canada did arrive suddenly between 1950-66 and was marked as Quebec's Quite Revolution, which was disastrous for the nation's unity. When Maurice Duplessis of the Union Nationale Party died in 1959, Jean Lesage became Quebec's new Liberal Premier, winning fifty-one and a half percent9 of the popular vote. This ended Quebec's

Quebec Nationalism Essay

3224 words - 13 pages classic and binational concept of federalism. The French Canadian population was not consulted by plebiscite prior to the ratification of the project. Within this expanded Canada, Quebec's population was to shrink even further into minority status. From that time onward, the federal government would appoint judges to the superior courts and courts of appeal. The taxation basis was structured to provide the federal government with the largest sources

Should Quebec Become A "Distinct Society" In Canada?

891 words - 4 pages I do not believe in distinct society for Quebec. The term "distinct society" in Quebec allows Quebec to have more control over many aspects of Quebec's affairs and policy. Meaning they are more independent from Canada and it is the first step of separation of Quebec. In our past history Britain may have disrespected the French Canadians by sending the protesters to Louisiana's wilderness and ignore their basic needs and concerns in the mid 1700