Canadas Brain Drain Issue Essay

1797 words - 7 pages

Canadas Brain Drain Issue

What is a brain drain? It is the emigration of highly educated and skilled Canadians to the United States. Does Canada suffer from a Brain Drain? This is a question that economists have been trying to answer for a decade now and have conducted different studies resulting to different conclusions about this issue. There are some economists that believe that yes Canada is suffering from a brain drain if not now it will be soon, amongst those economists are Don DeVortez and Samuel Laryea who prepared a study of C.D howe Institute. They claimed that Brain Drain is real and is costing Canada Tax Payers millions of dollars. Then on the other side of the debate we have economists like John Helliwell, who compares the current perceptions to past movements of educated Canadians to the United States, and the past and current immigration to Canada from other countries, concluding that the 90’s movement of educated Canadians to the United States, is relatively small. He strongly believes that the existing data and analysis provides no evidence of a current crisis or any great changes in the tax system.

So why is it that the media are convinced that there is a brain drain? This “brain drain” leads to the conclusions that there must be something wrong with Canada and that if nothing is done the nation is doomed. A brain drain means that Canadian productivity will slip even further behind American, that will cause even more of Canadians to leave, and the cycle will continue. Although brain drain believers don’t have much data to back them up, they have two strong arguments 1. The apparently small numbers of emigrants are a catastrophic loss for Canada, cause the issue is not how many we are losing, but who we are losing.

2. A definite crisis will come unless governments do something -cut taxes- for example.

The main concern economists have is the future outcome of this brain drain. They understand and even some might agree that Canada is not currently suffering from a brain drain but there definitely is a problem and if it is not addressed by the government fast then there will be a major threat to the economy of Canada and then there will definitely be a BRAIN DRAIN. McKinsey & Company describes the Brain Drain as “WAR FOR TALEN”, it is a battle of quality rather than quantity so even though the statistical evidence might show that we are better off than many years ago, the truth is that we are not. The fact of the matter is that American firms are out there targeting Canadian workers, they understand the value of star players and they welcome them, nurture them, celebrate them and in return the outflow from Canada to the United States increases.
“I believes in the queen bee theory, that one real talented leader, can create all kinds of enterprise and wealth” said the CEO of a major corporation in Western Canada. “ If you lose that one person or that small group of people to places that they would...

Find Another Essay On Canadas Brain Drain Issue

Fixing the Canadian Productivity Lag Essay

2453 words - 10 pages as well as technological investment all go hand in hand. On the other hand, it may also point to a need for proper compensation for such talent as “Brain Drain” has often been touted as a Canadian disorder. Further to human capital and capital asset investment, the report also points to an underlying lack of investment in information and communications technologies (ICT) across various sectors as the reason for the drag in labour productivity

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Skilled Migrants Increased Rate of Movement

1822 words - 7 pages The topic of this essay was inspired by Peter Stalker’s writing ‘Emigrants as heroes’. Furthermore, the issue brain drain resulting from sending skilled immigrants to developed nations as a result of benefit to themselves and their country. Hence the question, ‘Do they benefit the host country or their own country. This article by Stalker shows both sides of the argument referring the advantage and disadvantage of immigrants migrating to

Migration from the Nation-State of Singapore

573 words - 2 pages citizenship and national identity. This has also raised an old issue of why Singaporeans are leaving Singapore for ‘greener pastures’ overseas (Straits Times, 21 August 2002). Most often, the ones who left are deemed as talents who could have contributed to Singapore if they had not ‘quitted’ Singapore (National Day Rally, 2002). This is widely known as a ‘brain drain’, a problem that most migrant-sending countries in Asia currently face. In Singapore

youth uhemployment

973 words - 4 pages ways to tackle this problem is changing market structure by taking into account certain features of the job market affecting rates of unemployment. Youth unemployment problem may cause brain drain. It can take place because of challenge to find permanent job for young people, as employers do not have incentive to hire youngsters on full-time job places. Young people have less rights and high likelihood to be dismissed rather than aging workers

The opinions and perceptions of Sri Lankan physicians

1279 words - 5 pages address the ‘brain drain’ phenomenon in Sri Lanka, providing physician level care where necessary to support practicing physicians 8. From 1940s to the late 1900s, Sri Lankan health outcomes have shown marked improvement. Average life expectancy increased by 30 years between 1946 and 1996, while the introduction of healthcare to rural populations and an outreach of antenatal care to mothers has contributed to a decreased both infant and

The effects of software piracy on society and the economy

721 words - 3 pages brain drain. If we examine except of the economic impact community awareness and negatively affected and such results occurs. Software is an esential tool of production in every esctor of the modern economy. Enterprises of all sorts rely on design products, provide services, communicate with others. Software contributes more value to economy considerably. But it is increase steadly, computer engineer, and individual developers are affected to

The Game of Fate and The Pain It Has In Store

892 words - 4 pages a friend but Robin actule said she was taken him to the hospital. We told the people at the window what happened and they discovered that he had bleading in the brain. The said he was lucky to be alive. The said he should have died in his sleep. They called a helicopter but the only spot they could land was in the ball park. An ambulance drove him to the helicopter then to SE Gape Garudo. The doctors put tubs in Dad’s head to drain the

Purpose of Education Is to Help Students Learn on Their Own

655 words - 3 pages pretend they can. Employment in New Zealand can be difficult, especially with the brain drain. Where educated New Zealanders continue to leave the country after completing university.But when looking at the intake of people coming to New Zealand there are more with degrees and bachelor's than those that are leaving. Many believe the purpose of education is to create well rounded citizens who will one day bring world peace. Probably not anytime in

The Risk Factors of Glacucoma

1628 words - 7 pages (Glaucoma Research Foundation). According to the American Optometric Association, “Glaucoma is a group of eye diseases causing optic nerve damage. The optic nerve carries images from the retina, which is the specialized light sensing tissue, to the brain so we can see.” They go on to say that when dealing with glaucoma, one’s eye pressure plays a vital role in damaging the delicate nerve fibers of the optic nerve. “When a significant number of nerve

Understanding Epilepsy

2231 words - 9 pages patient who is having a seizure. Epilepsy was not always known to be a medical issue. Epilepsy was thought to be caused by spirits, demons or divine experiences, like many cultures such as the Hmong believed (they still do). The first occurrence of epilepsy being considered a medical issue dates back to around 400 BC with the Greek physician Hippocrates. Although Hippocrates believed epilepsy to be a condition caused by “an imbalance of the

Unemployment and Migration in the Philippines

2027 words - 8 pages & Alburo, 2002, p. 4). Brain drain is a huge issue along the health sector as proven by the surge in the number of doctors and nurses who migrate from the Philippines. There was a very notable period in time when the demand for nurses in the United States drove both students and professionals to nursing schools. This then gave a boost to the establishment of nursing schools in the country a greater percentage of which provide low quality nursing

Similar Essays

Brain Drain Essay

2337 words - 10 pages .” Brain drain is therefore more of a moral issue in which we need to view every aspect of the phenomena in order to reach fairly solution. Literature review One of the leading movement for fighting brain drain is The African Renaissance Ambassador (A-RA), which helps Africa development by cutting down brain drain and helps to keeps Africa’s most valuable resource, her human potential. It collects and publishes astonishing facts about how much

The Legend Of The Avro Arrow

1609 words - 6 pages Arrow Project." CBCnews. CBC/Radio Canada, 06 Dec. 2013. Web. 01 May 2014. . "CBC Digital Archives - The Avro Arrow: Canada's Broken Dream - Brain Drain: Avro Engineers Head to the U.S." CBCnews. CBC/Radio Canada, 06 Dec. 2013. Web. 04 May 2014.

Canada And Brain Drain Essay

2773 words - 11 pages have of the 'brain drain'. Persistent media and political hype have blown the issue out of proportion. This is not to say however that the brain drain is merely an illusion, but that it is a relatively minor problem that can be effectively dealt with by welcoming talent from other countries to replace the talent that is lost. The Canadian Government can do much to tackle the issue by simply accelerating the present immigration policy and making it

Brain Drain Essay

1275 words - 6 pages highly skilled. Borjas and Bradsberg (1996) demonstrated that, in general, return migration is characterized by negative self-selection and is rare among the highly skilled unless sustained growth in the home country precedes their return. Works Cited AGENCE Française de Développement (AFD), (2007): Migration and Development: Mutual Benefits? Research Department. BEINE, M. et al. (2008): Brain drain and its determinants: a major issue for