Canadian Nationalism Essay

1874 words - 7 pages

Canadian Nationalism
Many people across the globe argue that nationalism within Canada is simply not feasible. It is said that we as a people, differ so greatly with our diverse cultures, religions, and backgrounds that we cannot come together and exist together as a strong, united nation. In his book, Lament for a Nation, George Grant tells the reader that “…as Canadians we attempted a ridiculous task in trying to build a conservative nation in the age of progress, on a continent we share with the most dynamic nation on earth. The current history is against us.” (1965) Originally directed towards the Bomarc Missile Crisis, the book argues that whatever nationalism Canada had was destroyed by globalization as well as the powerful American sphere of influence. Although it is true that the book was initially written as a response to the events that took place in the late 1950s, many of the points are still valid today.
Though diversity can be, and often is an asset, in the context of nationalism, so many variations among a nation in conjunction with globalization can cause an observer to believe that in a sense, there is no true Canadian nationalism. Prime Minister Trudeau may have indeed attributed nationalism and the foundation of a nation to will, but a desire to build a nation is insufficient for one to be formed. For a nation to truly be stable and unified, nationalism is key. In turn, then, this nationalism will result in citizens desiring to improve and further their nation. Despite the fact that will has indeed played a critical role in preserving Canada by helping to create nationalism during watershed moments in history such as the Patriote movement, key battles in World war I, and even Québécois movement today, it is important to remember that the will was first a byproduct of nationalism as opposed to will being the creator of nationalistic beliefs among people.
Francophone Nationalism
During the 19th Century
As most Canadians may know, the land we know now as Canada was once the property of Britain and France- the countries that originally colonized Canada. After Canada was officially formed in 1867 and even prior to that event, there was much division among the Anglophone and Francophone populations, though a strong desire for freedom from the British Empire ran on both sides.

Due to the bitter rivalries of their mother countries, the two sides also had a strong feels of animosity against one another. This animosity was furthered when the French surrendered New France. This cession of French territory to the British occurred after the French and Indian Wars of the mid 18th century; specifically after the treaty of Paris in February 20th of 1763. The essential annexation brought about much anger within the French. This was illustrated during the highlights of the Patriote movement (the rebellions of 1837 and 1838) and the secession of New France to become British. These events, along with prior rivalry with Britain and its...

Find Another Essay On Canadian Nationalism

Examining Literature in Grade 12 Essay

890 words - 4 pages overlook the accomplishments of American and British authors as of right now. We can come back to contemplating them once our students have a solid feeling of our own journalists, culturally. Endnotes 1 Letters in Canada p. 426 Robertson Davies 2 Robertson Davies, “Canadian Nationalism in Arts and Science”, Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada (Series IV, Volume XlII, 1975), p. 35 3 Margaret Atwood, Survival, 18, 1972. Works Cited

Nationalism In Canada Essay

1624 words - 6 pages Canadian flag, and the National Anthem. Quebec is not the only culture to have their own way of life, however, Quebec does take protect their own culture very strongly.         Canada has always said that this country would be a multicultural country. Most Canadians agreed with this idea from the beginning, however now this idea is becoming more and more controversial. Most Canadians want to have a sense of nationalism, and they are finding this

Imagined Communities

1461 words - 6 pages became one of the most recognizable catchphrases in recent Canadian history. The slogan reflects a cultural shift towards a more consumer-oriented brand of nationalism similar to Roots’ clothing company. The commercial’s “was ‘insidious’ because it defined nationalism as ‘benign, entertaining, innocent, and seamless” (Cormack and Cosgrove 64). Like Molson, Roots has made it possible for Canadians to purchase a particular Canadian identity. Roots was

Biography on Pierre Elliott Trudeau

953 words - 4 pages , style or intellect, then surely none but Macdonald would surpass Trudeau. He would be considered truly the second father of his country.There is a powerful irony in the nationalistic outpouring that followed Trudeau's death. He hated nationalism of all kinds and French-Canadian nationalism in particular. The whole idea of the nation state, he once wrote, "managed to cripple the advance of civilization." He argued throughout his life that

Canada's struggle for autonomy in the 20th century

672 words - 3 pages During the twentieth century, Canada began to take steps towards full autonomy (complete control over its own affairs) and becoming an independent nation During the twentieth century, Canada began to take steps towards full autonomy (complete control over its own affairs) and becoming an independent nation. Canadian Autonomy was the product of the evolution of Canadian Nationalism and the development of a desire to become

American Influence Promotes Canadian Identity

1399 words - 6 pages From the start of the 1920's, Canadians have faced a considerable amount of threat towards the Canadian culture from it's American neighbours. For Canada, living so close causes a concern on Canadian identity from American implementation, however, being in a close relationship with the States, it has also promoted Canadian culture. An examination of the nation's success with CBC from America's involvement in the airwaves, Canadian nationalism is

Alaskan Boundary Dispute

1116 words - 4 pages ; , to rule in favor of the U.S. The British member had also been coerced in order to keep strong allies with America. This caused controversy in the final decision, which outraged Canadians. This sense of anger and betrayal is what changed the governments views of its ties with the British and what started self-governance and Canadian nationalism. Although the tribunal ruled in favor of America in the Alaskan Boundary Dispute, and Canadians lost

Canadian History

1973 words - 8 pages ). The biggest factor in continuing to develop regulations to protect Canada’s cultural industries is globalization (Pg.289) and the cultural nationalism in Canada that wants protection for Canadian content (Hiller 305). Continentalism is a major contributing factor because it can be very threatening for the less powerful country. Continentalism refers to “the presence of a global power (e.g., United States) at one’s border must be

Lester B. Pearson's Impact on Canada

804 words - 4 pages Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson was a prominent figure in Canada in the 1960s. Pearson was Canada's most significant post WWII prime minister because of his government's many innovations that still benefit Canadians today. He fostered Canadian nationalism, which continues to the present day, promoted equality throughout Canada – equality that now thrives as part of Canada's identity – and he introduced many social services that are still

The AFL Canadian: Labor, National Identity, and Transnational Discourse 1936-1955

1868 words - 7 pages -war period. How do Canadians with a rising sense of nationalism understand themselves and their roles within a decidedly American institution? The relationship of the Canadian and the American is often more conflicted than Americans believe. The discourse surrounding the “foreigner” was often conflated with communist in America, must have been contradictorily felt by Canadian labor. Often they were not Communist, nor American, yet this conclusion

Were the needs of Quebecois Effectively Met?

1338 words - 6 pages about the needs of French Canadians still exists. Through an extremely thorough analysis of several key sources, it is evident that the needs of French Canadians were, undoubtedly, not met, which shall be plainly and exhaustively proven through an in depth analysis of French Canadian Nationalism, Heritage Problems in Quebec, as well as impending acts of terrorism in Quebec. French Canadian Nationalism has always been an impending issue within

Similar Essays

Billy Bishop And Canadian Nationalism Essay

666 words - 3 pages qualities that our national love is based upon throughout the play. Being willing to do anything to protect our country and its freedom is nationalism. Mr. Billy Bishop was an ace World War One pilot who was extremely devoted to being a pilot. Billy was a man who was loyal and courageous. The young, gentle, Canadian man was devoted to what he did, Bishop would practice flying and shooting all the time. “You’ve got to be good enough to get him in the

Nationalism In Quebec And Canadian Politics

2341 words - 9 pages During the twentieth century, Canada as a nation witnessed and endured several historical events that have had a deep and profound influence on Canadian politics. The most influential and constant force in twentieth century Canadian politics has been the increasing power and command of Quebec nationalism and the influence it has had on Canadian politics today. Quebec nationalism has shaped the structure and dynamics of Canadian federalism from

Vimy Ridge True Origin Of Canada

1037 words - 5 pages with nationalism, recognized and earned Canada a place in World affairs as well as moved Canada towards its autonomy from British sovereignty creating and developing a new power in the world by the name of Canada. Firstly, Vimy Ridge was a Canadian battle that was fought by all Canadian troops together. Vimy Ridge was designed to be conquered through uniting all Canadian soldiers and creating nationalism among Canadians. General Arthur Currie

A Vote For Canadian Content Regulations

1614 words - 6 pages leisure activities.”(Acheson, 1992) This accounts for the Canadians that decide to not watch or listen Canadian media and are not contributing to the well being of the Canadian economy. The Canadian economy not only benefits from Canadian citizens but also tourists and citizens from other countries. With regulations in place on Canadian content, a sense of Canadian nationalism is brought forth. An example of this is used by the Canadian co-operation