Capital Punishment Essay: It's Fair And Effective

992 words - 4 pages

Capital Punishment - It's Fair and Effective

    Confronting head-on two of the most prominent objections to the death penalty is the object of this paper: Is the death penalty a miscarriage of justice? And Does it Deter Crime?

 

It's a miscarraige of justice. In a survey Professors Hugo Adam Bedau and Michael Radelet found that 7000 persons were executed in the United States between 1900 and 1985 and that 35 were innocent of capital crimes (1). Among the innocents they list Sacco and Vanzetti as well as Ethel and Julius Rosenberg. Although their data may be questionable, I do not doubt that, over a long enough period, miscarriages of justice will occur even in capital cases.

Despite precautions, nearly all human activities, such as trucking, lighting, or construction, cost the lives of some innocent bystanders. We do not give up these activities, because the advantages, moral or material, outweigh the unintended losses (2). Analogously, for those who think the death penalty just, miscarriages of justice are offset by the moral benefits and the usefulness of doing justice. For those who think death penalty unjust even when it does not miscarry, miscarriages can hardly be decisive.

 

Is it a deterrent? Despite much recent work, there has been no conclusive statistical demonstration that the death penalty is a better deterrent than are alternative punishments (3). However, deterrence is less than decisive for either side. Most abolitionists acknowledge that they would continue to favor abolition even if the death penalty were shown to deter more murders than alternatives could deter (4). Abolitionists appear to value the life of a convicted murderer or, at least, his non-execution, more highly than they value the lives of the innocent victims who might be spared by deterring prospective murderers.

 

Deterrence is not altogether decisive for me either. I would favor retention of the death penalty as retribution even if it were shown that the threat of execution could not deter prospective murderers not already deterred by the threat of imprisonment (5). Still, I believe the death penalty, because of its finality, is more feared than imprisonment, and deters some prospective murderers not deterred by the thought of imprisonment. Sparing the lives of even a few prospective victims by deterring their murderers is more important than preserving the lives of convicted murderers because o the possibility, or even the probability, tht executing them would not deter others. Whereas the live of the victims who might be saved are valuable, that of the murderer has only negative value, because of his crime. Surely the criminal law is meant to protect the lives of potential victims in preference to those of actual murderers.

 

Murder rates are determined by many factors; neither the severity nor the probability of the threatened sanction is always decisive. However, for the long run, I share the view of Sir James...

Find Another Essay On Capital Punishment Essay: It's Fair and Effective

Capital Punishment Essay: Retardation and Capital Punishment

793 words - 3 pages Retardation and Capital Punishment       One can agree (or not) with the recent ruling by the Supreme Court that the death penalty should not apply to retarded citizens because it violates the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against "cruel and unusual punishment," and still be troubled by the twisted road the court took to reach its destination. Reading the history of the Eighth Amendment shows that it proceeded from concerns over the

Capital Punishment Essay: Retain Capital Punishment?

706 words - 3 pages Capital Punishment - Retain or Not?         This essay tangles with the question of whether or not we should retain the death penalty within the American code of penal law.   There is a feeling of frustration and horror that we experience at the senseless and brutal crimes that too frequently disrupt the harmony of society. There is pain which accompanies the heartfelt sympathy that we extend to the victims' families who, in their

Capital Punishment Essay

560 words - 2 pages Law 12 - LG #5Capital Punishment EssayI believe that capital punishment (the death penalty) should not be reinstated in Canada. Four main reasons for this argument are on the basis of deterrence, retribution, wrongful sentencing, and prejudice towards the accused person.Those people who think that deterrence justifies sending certain criminals to their death bear the burden of proving that the death penalty is a deterrent. The conclusion from

Capital Punishment and Politics

3922 words - 16 pages parties support the use of the death penalty, feeling that it is effective in deterring crime. Neither party morally argues their support for capital punishment. Many religious organizations, on the other hand, have strongly argued for the abolishment of the death penalty. The Presbyterian, Lutheran (ELCA), Episcopal, United Methodist, American Baptist, and Catholic Churches are all opposed to its use (“Religious Calls for Abolition”). In

Legal Studies Essay– Capital Punishment

1873 words - 7 pages right to life. Whilst many of these arguments are very strong there are also very strong arguments made by the supporters of capital punishment and some of these are: that the death penalty is justified for murderers by the principle of retribution; that life imprisonment is not an equally effective deterrent; that the death penalty affirms the right to life by punishing those who violate it in the most strict form; that the death penalty sets a good

Persuasive Essay Against Capital Punishment

900 words - 4 pages Persuasive Essay Against Capital Punishment “Kill. (Verb) To make someone or something die.” Does anyone really think they have the right to take another person’s life? Apparently yes. Perhaps we should give the judge a knife and tell her that if she has decided that the accused is guilty, she should stab him herself. Perhaps then she would hesitate. But if many people (hundreds or thousands who operate the

Capital Punishment Essay: Christian Opposition

1105 words - 4 pages Christian Opposition to Capital Punishment The matter of the death penalty is one which we, as Christians, should address at this time since victims continue to be killed by the state. We should give the religious teaching concerning it, in order to assist those who are making efforts to clarify their thoughts about this very complex and difficult question. Such is the subject of this paper.   There are two sources from which we

Capital punishment. this essay is opposed to capital punishment

808 words - 3 pages Capital PunishmentCapital punishment is a disgusting example of how stupid, ignorant and lazy our American society is. Society punishes victims (yes, "victims," of our corrupt system) for its own mistakes. It is a punishment that does not fit the crime because in most circumstances the "crime" was destined to happen, considering everything (and I would like to emphasize on the word "everything") that an individual has been through. If people are

Fair Punishment and the Death Penalty

908 words - 4 pages Fair Punishment and the Death Penalty 94 federal attorneys have the power to submit a case to Janet Reno (Willing 3A). These attorneys seek the death penalty for these cases, and why should they not? Whys should one who has taken a life, or even several, deserve the air that they breathe? Capital punishment is a harsh punishment created for people who have committed harsh crimes. The death penalty should be used to punish violent

Capital Punishment And The Innocent

1238 words - 5 pages of love, and a host of destructive social conditions. These extenuating circumstances may have damaged their humanity to the point that it is unfair to hold them fully accountable for their wrong doing." Explains www.frontiernet.com, "Corporate responsibility somehow has to be factored into some degree," In an essay titled "Capital Punishment" under www.monmouth.com, there is an interesting point the author makes. He is speaking to God at

Capital Punishment: Pros and Cons

1655 words - 7 pages rate when capital punishment is implemented in a country. Ironically, the study actually showed that some countries that have abolished the death penalty have succeeded in lowering crime rates. Bibliography Amnesty International, "List of Abolitionist and Retentionist Countries," Report ACT 50/01/99, Updated June 2004 "Argumentative Essay In Favor of Capital Punishment." Web log post. Capital Punishment Essays. Blogger, 16 Aug. 2012. Web. 2 Feb

Similar Essays

Could Capital Punishment Be Effective In Albania?!

1203 words - 5 pages were 41% lower than they are now (Ministry of Justice, 2013). The government may reflect on how to minimize this phenomenon by using a really shocking measure, but which may result effective. A possible start could be a consolidation of the laws in general and to the Penal Code in specific. The citizens need some strict laws to follow and a strict attitude regarding their execution. More specifically a strict law can be capital punishment, but

The Use Of Capital Punishment On Convicted Murderers Is An Effective Method Of Deterrance

1545 words - 6 pages The Use of Capital Punishment on Convicted Murderers is an Effective Method of Deterrance Capital punishment is the legal infliction of death as a penalty for violating criminal law. The capital punishment debate, in the United States, has been ongoing for almost four hundred years. Opponents of capital punishment cite that it’s arbitrariness and the execution of the “innocent” as reasons why they oppose it. Supporters of capital

Capital Punishment, Proven To Be An Effective Deterrent Of Major Crime

964 words - 4 pages Throughout history, statistics have proven that CapitalPunishment or otherwise known as the death penalty, has beenan effective deterrent of major crime. Capital Punishment is thelawful infliction of death among criminals and has been used topunish a wide variety of offenses for many years all over theworld (Bedau 16). When the death penalty is enforced, it showssociety that committing a capital crime has deadly consequences.In early times, many

Capital Punishment Essay: Christians And Capital Punishment

601 words - 2 pages Christians and the Capital Punishment   The restoration of the death penalty by the Supreme Court prompted statements of opposition by some Christians around the country. This essay reflects on these statements and draws the conclusion of their suitability and correctness in light of our Christian heritage and other secular, practical reasons.   These statements acknowledge that Christians of equally serious moral concern